What Is White Savior Complex, and Why Is It Harmful? Here's What Experts Say

© Provided by Health Getty Images / Jo Imperio

What can I do to help? It’s a question you might ask yourself after seeing people—especially people of color—in need during or after a natural disaster, an environmental disaster, a pandemic, or any other humanitarian crisis. Or maybe it’s a question you ask yourself after seeing the day-to-day inequities that Black, Indigenous, people of color (BIPOC, for short) face.

© Getty Images / Jo Imperio White savior complex has historically undermined BIPOC people’s autonomy.

But is what you’re doing to “help” making you feel good about yourself more so than actually combatting the systemic problems that affect BIPOC people? Enter the white savior complex.

While helping out your fellow humans is a noble idea, the white savior complex is something that can stand in the way of addressing the real work that needs to be done. But what exactly is the white savior complex, and why is it bad? Here’s what you need to know about it—and how you can avoid it.

Subscribe to our Telegram News Service
Download our mobile app

What is white savior complex?

The white savior complex is an ideology that is acted upon when a white person, from a position of superiority, attempts to help or rescue a BIPOC person or community. Whether this is done consciously or unconsciously, people with this complex have the underlying belief that they know best or that they have skills that BIPOC people don’t have, according to Savala Nolan, author of Don’t Let It Get You Down: Essays on Race, Gender, and the Body and the director of the Thelton E. Henderson Center for Social Justice at UC Berkeley School of Law.

“[They think] they are somehow in the position that should enable them to have more power in terms of solving the problem than the people who are impacted [by the problem],” Nolan tells Health.

This mindset isn’t anything new. In fact, white saviorism is a centuries’ old concept that can be traced back to the days when many white Westerners believed that they inherently had the knowledge, skills, and ingenuity to solve the problems of other people all around the world, especially people in the developing world, and especially Africans. “I think it’s been a fundamental underpinning of Western imperialism, and it’s been evident in the global empire-building enterprise,” Danielle Taana Smith, PhD, a professor in the Department of African American Studies at Syracuse University, tells Health.

Although its roots may be hundreds of years old, white saviorism is still alive around the world and within the walls of the US. Today, it tends to take the shape of focusing on providing immediate solutions, especially during humanitarian crises, to people at the individual level, Smith explains. While these immediate solutions are important because they meet urgent needs in times of crisis, the white savior approach doesn’t look beyond those immediate needs—in other words, the long-term needs of individuals and communities are not addressed.

“I think that these solutions don’t pay much attention to how complicated the interactions are between social and economic and political factors,” Smith says. “And part of what that means is that white savior mentality encourages individual dependency rather than long-term community building or long-term community self-sufficiency.”

RELATED: What Is Cultural Appropriation? Here’s Why the Practice Is So Harmful—and How You Can Avoid Doing It

What does the white savior complex look like in action?

The white savior complex can be played out in pop culture and in real life. In movies, a white person coming to town to help “save” a group of BIPOC people—whether they are students, athletes, or wrongly accused prisoners—is a common storyline. In real life, white savior complex was most recently on display during the pandemic. COVID-19 disproportionately affected BIPOC people in the US. As the country saw them getting sick and dying, the response was to come up with solutions to meet the needs of individual sick people. And that immediate response was needed to save lives. But someone with a white savior mentality might believe that they’ve already provided the solution and then shift their focus the next disaster rather than think about the structural barriers in place that put BIPOC people at a disadvantage when it came to health access and outcomes during the pandemic, Smith says. And without addressing those barriers, substantial change can’t happen in the long run.

RELATED: 5 Things You Can Do Right Now to Be a Better BIPOC Ally

Is white savior complex harmful?

Yes. “I sort of liken someone who’s engaged in white saviorism to a person who rushes into the emergency room wanting to help, but if they don’t have training as a nurse or a doctor, they may actually end up doing more harm than good,” Nolan says.

But how can someone who wants to help actually wind up doing more harm than good? By only putting a Band-Aid on the problem. That Band-Aid will eventually come off, revealing the deeper barriers that still exist. “It’s essentially a form of blindness,” Smith says. “It’s not going to allow you to perceive what is in front of you accurately. And if you can’t see it accurately, then you can’t be of really profound use in solving the problem.”

The person who is trying to render aid may not mean any harm. But white saviorism “perpetuates white supremacy as the system by which we organize our society,” Nolan believes. And research shows that white supremacy—whether conscious or unconscious—leads to poor health outcomes for BIPOC people. “Physicians typically tend to see the patient as an individual person presenting a specific illness or symptom, and they don’t see the larger issues like living in poverty and living in places with high crime rates,” Smith says. “These social factors impact peoples’ health and well-being, and if health care providers want to treat people holistically for them to be healthy over a long period of time, you cannot only treat the symptom that they are presenting. And that is what the white savior mentality does; it focuses on the individual and their specific symptoms … rather than focus on the larger systemic structural issues that cause these illnesses.”

RELATED: Culturally Competent Care Tackles Bias and Racism in the US Medical System—Here’s What to Know About It

How to avoid white savior complex

White people who want to help people and communities of color first need to take a backseat, Smith advises. “Follow the lead of the people of color in the space that [you] are entering,” she says. “[You] need to be willing to not be at the center of the work of the solution and to follow the advice, expertise, and request of the people who are closest to the pain and the problem.”

It’s also important that the work white people do addresses structural societal issues. Instead of narrowing the focus to the individual level, think broadly and consider what systems are in place that might be influencing their health and well-being.

If you see other people or an organization engaging in white saviorism, call them out. But then call them back in. “If you have an understanding of what white saviorism is, then you are in a position to see it and to think about it,” Nolan says. “And hopefully if you’re working to avoid it, you’re also in a position to articulate what the harm of it is, how it can be avoided, and how much more impactful whatever the work the [person or] organization is trying to do will be if [white saviorism wasn’t at play.]”

To get our top stories delivered to your inbox, sign up for the Healthy Living newsletter

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Icra appoints Ramnath Krishnan as Managing Director and Group CEO

Mumbai: Icra on Saturday announced the appointment of Ramnath Krishnan as the company‘s Managing Director and Group Chief Executive Officer. Krishnan, who will assume the new charge with immediate effect, ... Read more »

Greaves Electric fully acquires leading e-rickshaw brand Bestway Agencies

New Delhi: Greaves Electric Mobility on Saturday said it has fully acquired Bestway Agencies Pvt Ltd (BAPL) which sells e-rickshaws under the ELE brand. The company, which is the e-mobility ... Read more »

Minda Industries to hike stake in Strongsun Renewables to 28.10%

New Delhi: Minda Industries on Saturday said the investment committee of its board has given its go-ahead to second tranche of stake purchase in Strongsun Renewables Pvt Ltd. The committee ... Read more »

Entire world looking up to India in view of its vaccination drive success: PM Modi

The entire world is looking up to India in the backdrop of the success of its COVID-19 vaccination drive, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Saturday as he lauded vaccine ... Read more »

Feds sue Libby Nazi sympathizer to collect $9.9M fine

Oct. 23—The U.S. Department of Justice is suing a Nazi sympathizer living in Libby in an effort to collect a $9.9 million fine from the Federal Communications Commission after he ... Read more »

Tea Association of India asks govt to look into paucity of coal in tea estate

Tea Association of India (TAI) has requested union ministry of Commerce & Industry to look into the paucity of coal in tea estate. The organization in a representation to the ... Read more »

Elton John gives heartbreaking health update as he talks alcoholism

Elton John was forced to postpone his Farewell Yellow Brick Road tour until 2023 after a fall on his hip that requires surgery, and in a new interview the star ... Read more »

Lakhimpur Kheri: Three more arrested in Kheri case

UP police arrested three more in the Lakhimpur Kheri case in which eight people including four protesting farmers were killed in the district’s Tikonia area. With the three arrests on ... Read more »

Black Friday 2021 UK: How to find the best deals

Black Friday is one of the biggest shopping events of the year. This year, it will take place on Friday 26 November and the event will run over the weekend ... Read more »

Angelina Jolie's Airport Trousers Are Even Better Than Joggers or Leggings

Airport style is back, baby, and this celebrity outfit–obsessed editor couldn't be happier about it. It's hard to predict how the pandemic will have changed airport style. It will either ... Read more »

Amit Shah reaches out to youths in Kashmir, reiterates 'roadmap ' for polls and statehood restoration

Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Saturday sought the support of the youth of Kashmir in realising Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ”vision of a peaceful and developed” J-K, while reiterating ... Read more »

Tamil Nadu allows 100 per cent occupancy in theatres; Classes for 1-8 on rotational basis from November 1

Easing curbs, Tamil Nadu on Saturday allowed 100 per cent occupancy in film theatres, schools for Class one to eight on ‘rotational’ basis from November 1, operation of bars, lifting ... Read more »

The perfect weekend: how to spend 48 hours in Fitzrovia

Inside Charlotte Street the décor is a homage to the Bloomsbury Group (Handout) Bohemian and laid-back yet as city central as it gets, Fitzrovia offers London life with an intimate ... Read more »

Chip shortage could hit supplies of critical medtech devices

Supplies of critical life-saving medical devices could soon take a hit due to the continuing global shortage of semiconductor chips, medtech manufacturers have warned. A TOI report said the shortage ... Read more »

Police: Altoona man robs EC convenience store

Oct. 23—EAU CLAIRE — An Altoona man committed an armed robbery at an Eau Claire convenience store after the clerk wouldn't let him pump gas without pre-paying for the fuel, ... Read more »

Lakhimpur Kheri Violence Accused Ashish Misra Hospitalised with Dengue Symptoms, Sample Sent to Lab

Union minister Ajay Kumar Misra’s son Ashish Misra, who is currently in jail in connection with the Lakhimpur Kheri violence, has been shifted to a government hospital on suspicion of ... Read more »

‘We planted a seed': the Afghan artists who painted for freedom

Negina Azimi felt shock and fear like never before when she heard that Taliban fighters had entered Kabul on 15 August. As an outspoken female artist in Afghanistan, she knew ... Read more »

Wall Street Week Ahead: Tech giants' earnings may be another test for markets at new highs

NEW YORK: Investors are homing in on a flood of earnings reports from Wall Street‘s tech and Internet giants, as the high-growth stocks that have led markets higher for years ... Read more »

Amit Shah to inaugurate development projects in J K today, meet Kashmiri Pandits' delegation

Amit Shah to inaugurate development projects, lay foundation stone for others today in J&K Union Home Minister Amit Shah, who arrived in Jammu and Kashmir on Saturday for a three-day ... Read more »

Women in burqa, Men in salwar kameez, and artistes in hiding in 2 months of Taliban 'rule'

Mansoor Haidry, a doctor from Kabul, has been living in India for six years and runs a general store in Bhogal in the national capital. Most members of his joint ... Read more »

Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in UP: CM Yogi Adityanath

© Provided by News18 Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in UP: CM Yogi Adityanath Months ahead of the 2022 Assembly elections, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on ... Read more »

COVID-19: Centre asks states to ensure upcoming festivals celebrated with 'utmost precautions'

The Centre has asked states and union territories to ensure that upcoming festivals are celebrated in a safe and cautious manner with “utmost precautions” in view of the COVID-19 pandemic. ... Read more »

Here's what I've learnt on family holidays with my three children

Georgina Fuller and family in France If you were to believe those picture perfect posts you see on Instagram of Boden-clad, peachy-cheeked cherubs in Breton tops on windswept beaches, you ... Read more »

Delhiites to take part in Kejriwal Government's anti-dengue ‘10 Hafte, 10 Baje, 10 Minute' campaign today

© Provided by The Statesman Delhiites to take part in Kejriwal Government’s anti-dengue ‘10 Hafte, 10 Baje, 10 Minute’ campaign today Once again calling Delhiites for Sunday’s weekly in the ... Read more »

Amazon's best-selling portable heater is small but mighty (and currently on sale)

Stay cosy this winter with this portable heater. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life's editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a share ... Read more »

Stock investors remain unfazed by supply-chain snarls

This was the week when supply-chain angst finally landed on media stocks while inflation sirens blared in commodities even as the pace of economic growth showed signs of cooling. But ... Read more »

The Offing review – soft-pedalled adaptation of Benjamin Myers novel

After Benjamin Myers published The Offing in 2019, one shrewd critic said if the novel were a play it would be “a classic two-hander”. On the one hand, you have ... Read more »

Smartwatches are CM Khattar's Latest Idea to Track Attendance, Movement of Govt Officials in Haryana

© Provided by News18 Smartwatches are CM Khattar’s Latest Idea to Track Attendance, Movement of Govt Officials in Haryana Haryana chief minister Manohar Lal Khattar on Saturday said smartwatches will ... Read more »

Why China and Taiwan relations are in such dire straits as Beijing flexes military muscle

© Provided by Firstpost Why China and Taiwan relations are in such dire straits as Beijing flexes military muscle Taiwan is finding it difficult to keep itself out of international ... Read more »

Dalal Street Week Ahead: PSUs, banks, auto and select financials may put up a resilient show

After testing a fresh lifetime high at 18604, the Indian equity markets slipped into some corrective consolidation within a broad range. The bulk of the previous week was spent in ... Read more »

Dhaka ties deeper than any other strategic partnership: Harsh V Shringla

Foreign secretary Harsh V Shringla said on Saturday that India remains a committed partner in Bangladesh’s socio-economic growth and development, and described the bilateral ties as “deeper than any other ... Read more »

India-Pakistan T20 world cup match against national interest: Ramdev

Yoga guru Ramdev on Saturday said the India-Pakistan T20 World Cup match scheduled for Sunday is against the national interest and “Rashtradharma” as the “game of cricket and the game ... Read more »

Power ministry comes out with rules to ensure sustainability of sector

The Ministry of Power on Saturday announced new rules to sustain economic viability of the sector, ease financial stress of various stakeholders and ensure timely recovery of costs involved in ... Read more »

How to spend 48 hours in Qatar

How to spend 48 hours in Qatar Once a pearl-diving settlement, Qatar is transforming into a country of the future with its state-of-the-art architecture and ambitious new real estate projects. ... Read more »

5 budget-friendly knife sets on Amazon, all for the home chef

Join In The Know Cooking Editor Ellie Conley as she dives into the newest recipes and food trends each week. Read more »

Indigenous Australia, holograms and the Beano – the week in art

Exhibition of the week Songlines: Tracking the Seven SistersAn epic gathering of Indigenous Australian art, on tour from the National Museum of Australia, that gives a platform to the world’s ... Read more »

10 nutritionist-approved foods that can help you feel less stressed

Certain foods can help relieve stress. (Getty Images) Stress is a somewhat inevitable part of life. At one point or another everyone will feel stressed-out, whether it’s due to work, ... Read more »

‘I used to breakdance outside Snappy Snaps in legwarmers' – Stephen Gill's exhausted farewell to photography

At the age of nine, Stephen Gill was already experimenting with double exposures and, by the time he was 12, he had created several photographic collages. In one surrealist-style self-portrait, ... Read more »

Drag racer slams into spectators in Texas; 2 children killed

KERRVILLE, Texas (AP) — A driver lost control during a Texas drag racing event on an airport runway and slammed into a crowd of spectators, killing two children and injuring ... Read more »

When is Black Friday 2021 and where are the best UK deals?

Everything you need to know about Black Friday 2021. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life’s editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic