What Is “Phantom Sense” in VR, and Do You Have It?

What Is “Phantom Sense” in VR, and Do You Have It?


You’re standing in a VR world, surrounded by virtual grass. The wind whips up and blows through the field, and as you watch the tall grass blowing in the wind, you can feel it buffet your body; how is this possible?

Episode 1: The Phantom Sense

When you’re in VR and you can “feel” a sensation that’s not actually produced by the hardware, it’s referred to as “phantom sense“, which may sound like the “phantom pain” that amputees experience you’ve probably heard about before. Still, it’s quite different once you consider how phantom sense likely works.

Phantom sense in VR isn’t a new discovery, but now that VR headsets are going mainstream members of the public are discovering this phenomenon for themselves. If you search forums such as Reddit for the term “phantom sense”, you’ll see numerous accounts from VR users who claim to experience it.

For many VR users, this type of ‘bonus” immersion is desirable, so many of those aforementioned forum posts are actually about how to induce phantom sense, with different VR fans offering a variety of advice on how to make it happen. Whether any of those methods work is debatable, but can something like “phantom sense” really happen, and how does it even work?

Perception Is “Top-Down” and “Bottom-Up”

What Is “Phantom Sense” in VR, and Do You Have It?

BNP Design Studio/Shutterstock.com

Humans and other living things “perceive” the world around us with sense organs. In school, you’re taught that there are five senses, but the truth is that you have many different senses that give your brain information about the outside world and the state of your body.

Perception is a complex process that’s both “top-down” and “bottom-up” in nature. The bottom-up part of perception is the raw information that’s going from your eyes, ears, and other sense organs to your brain. In your brain, that information is processed into something that makes sense to your conscious mind. So, what you perceive isn’t actually reality but a processed version of it that makes sense from a human perspective.

Top-down aspects of perception are things like your previous experience and what you’ve learned about the world. Your expectations and prior knowledge let your brain automatically fill in the blanks or predict what it thinks you should be seeing. Magic tricks and optical illusions often take advantage of your expectations and how they influence what we see and hear. It’s most likely between these two types of perceptual processing that phantom sense happens.

Phantom Sense in the Lab

The phantom sense that people report experiencing in VR is most likely a form of “body transference”. Body transference happens when someone takes “ownership” of something as part of their own body when it isn’t. The classic experiment involves a rubber arm attached to the subject so that it’s in the position you expect your real arm to be.

Stroking the arm has been shown to induce that sensation in the subject. Similarly, sticking a needle into the rubber arm can induce pain. Psychologists theorize that this illusion happens when bottom-up processes override top-down processes. In other words, even though you know it’s not your real body part, on a fundamental your brain is fooled into accepting it and your conscious mind is along for the ride whether it wants to be or not.

Adding on to this, VR has been deliberately used to induce body transference. Researchers have determined that a person’s VR body induces the same threat response as it would in real life. In other words, under the right conditions, the brain accepts ownership of the virtual body, and the radical body transference illusion occurs. This might explain why some VR users experience phantom senses.

What Does This Mean for VR?

Much of our media depends on our perceptual systems’ ability to fill in the gaps. That’s why you perceive motion instead of scrolling still images in a movie theater or only need the simplified suggestion of something in a painting to perceive the whole picture.

If VR developers could tease out the factors that reliably induce phantom sense (much like they did for “presence” in VR), it could become another tool for VR authors to use when creating experiences.

Unfortunately, there’s also a dark side to phantom sense since negative perceptions are possible alongside positive ones. The idea that VR could be used for dubious interrogation practices is something that’s given ethicists pause for some time now, and phantom sense could be a sad part of that formula if anyone figures out how to use it deliberately.

Then again, a little like lucid dreaming, if you can teach or train yourself to experience phantom sense in VR, it has the potential to elevate your VR experience beyond mere hardware. Or you can think of it as using the “wetware” in your brain to make VR more immersive than ever.

News Related


Leaky Liverpool may have to learn how to defend differently, says Jurgen Klopp

Liverpool — Liverpool are conceding too many similar goals in their matches this season and the players may need to get “back to basics” to tighten the defence to return ... Read more »

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 2 Preorders: Bonuses, Editions, And More

Modern Warfare 2 launches October 28 on Xbox, PlayStation, and PC. Read more »

AndaSeat Kaiser 3 XL gaming chair review: "A decently dignified chair for work and play"

GamesRadar+ Verdict The AndaSeat Kaiser 3 boasts all the best bells and whistles for comfort, and its perks largely make up for an annoying assembly process. Pros + Lots of ... Read more »

How to Prepare for a Personal Injury Lawsuit

Photo : cottonbro If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s negligence, you may be considering filing a personal injury lawsuit. While nobody wants to go through the litigation process, ... Read more »

Inter Milan vs. Barcelona: Preview, date, time, live stream and how to watch Champions League match in Canada

Inter Milan vs. Barcelona: Preview, date, time, live stream and how to watch Champions League match in Canada Inter Milan are in need of a victory. A poor run of ... Read more »

New Maserati GranTurismo fully unveiled with electric and petrol V6 powertrains

Maserati’s Porsche 911 rival will be available with a 750bhp electric powertrain, as well as V6 engine from MC20 supercar Read more »

Steph Curry Is A Playable Character In PGA Tour 2K23

Basketball star Steph Curry is a playable golfer in this year's PGA Tour entry. Read more »

AirPods Pro 2: How to Block Out Loud Noises With Adaptive Transparency Mode

Unveiled with the debut of AirPods Pro 2, Adaptive Transparency is designed to allow the AirPods to block out loud sounds without blocking out all noise. This article explains how ... Read more »

How to Enable Keyboard Haptic Feedback on iPhone

In iOS 16, Apple has included an option for you to turn on haptic feedback when using the onscreen virtual keyboard. This article explains how to turn it on and ... Read more »

BLUELOCK Offers a Grim View of Sports Anime You’ve Never Seen Before (Episode 1 Preview)

If one were to base their opinion of the new Football anime BLUELOCK on the Sports anime genre’s norms, they wouldn’t be blamed for expecting another show about hot guys ... Read more »

Cyno’s Special Dish Recipe and how to cook it in Genshin Impact

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides Cyno, the General Mahamatra, may seem stern at first glance, but his penchant for throwing the dryest of jokes (and making it a point to ... Read more »

Get Microsoft’s Ultra Thin Surface Pro X For $400 Off This Week

Microsoft Microsoft’s vision of mobile laptop computing has often differed from Apple’s perspective. While the latter prefers to sell two different devices with overlapping qualities (MacBook + iPad), the former’s ... Read more »

Amazon’s Fire TV Sticks Are at Their Lowest Prices Yet

Picturesque Japan/Shutterstock.com Amazon’s Fire TV lineup of streaming sticks is very popular. Any of them can be a great addition to any TV, and they’re also pretty cheap. Right now, ... Read more »

PC Power Consumption Is Getting Out of Control

Kreabobek/Shutterstock.com Innovation in the PC space is fast-paced these days, but that’s coming at a cost. As the hardware in our PCs keeps getting better, power consumption is spiraling out ... Read more »

Lenovo’s Smart Clock With Alexa Is $30, Its Lowest Price Yet

Lenovo Lenovo’s lineup of tiny smart speakers with clock displays has been around for a while, available with either Google Assistant or Alexa. Now you can grab the Lenovo Smart ... Read more »

Studying in UK? ICICI Bank announces bank accounts for Indian students; learn how to activate

Representational image | (Photo by Punit PARANJPE / AFP) One of India’s most prominent banks, ICICI Bank, has announced services for Indian students in the United Kingdom (UK) called ‘‘HomeVantage ... Read more »

How to Make Money with NFTs - 8 Best Methods for 2022

Disclaimer: The Industry Talk section features insights by crypto industry players and is not a part of the editorial content of Cryptonews.com. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) operate in a fast-growing marketplace. ... Read more »

YouTube starts asking users to subscribe to Premium for 4K videos

WTF?! It might sound like a terrible idea, but YouTube could start charging users who want to watch videos on the platform in 4K, making the resolution exclusive to its ... Read more »

Dead Space Remake Gameplay Reveal Coming On October 4

In space, no one can hear you livestream. Read more »

Google Stadia Had Big, Disruptive Ideas That Others Should Steal

A Stadia that resembled Google's original pitch could have had a major impact on the industry. Read more »

Best 12V tyre inflators 2022

We put the pressure on eight rivals to find the top performer Read more »

First Drive: 2023 Chevrolet Corvette Z06

There will never be another Chevrolet Corvette like the C8-generation Z06. I am certain that faster Corvettes will come in the future, but they won’t be like this. Let me ... Read more »

How to install Windows 11 without USB. Use the hard drive immediately to boot Win

You don’t need a UEFI standard USB to boot into the Win 11 installer. So how to install Win 11 without USB? Follow GhienCong’s article below, it will be clear. ... Read more »

Apple Watch Series 8 & Ultra: How to Track Your Nightly Wrist Temperature

Apple Watch Series 8 and Apple Watch Ultra models can log your temperature data while you’re sleeping to give you an “insight into your overall well-being,” according to Apple. This ... Read more »

Champions League 2022-23: Matchday 3 schedule, fixtures, how to watch in Canada

Champions League 2022-23: Matchday 3 schedule, fixtures, how to watch in Canada The first week of October brings the third week of Champions League action as the 2022-23 group stage ... Read more »

Madden 23: How to complete AKA Champion Calvin Johnson and Darrelle Revis Sets

Image via Electronic Arts On October 3, EA Sports continued the AKA program in Madden 23, one that highlights some of the game’s more interesting personalities and nicknames. This time ... Read more »

Kuya Kim Atienza is not just a BMW Motorrad ambassador

But also an outstanding representative of the riding community Read more »

Amazon Adds Halo Rise to Improved Smart Home Lineup

Amazon already has a strong foothold in the smart home space, with several Echo speakers, Fire TVs, Ring doorbells, and more, not to mention the hundreds of devices that incorporate ... Read more »

Fix Error Code 0x00000001419101f1 9926301 0xc0000005 in COD: Warzone and Modern Warfare

Call of Duty Warzone and Modern Warfare are two of the widely played free-to-play battle royale video games for PC. But, like any other game or service, it has its ... Read more »

Hundreds of Grand Canyon hikers struck down by vomiting bug – how to avoid it

null Over 200 hikers and rafters came down with a nasty stomach bug while adventuring at Grand Canyon National Park between April and June this year, according to the Centers ... Read more »

Minecraft Live 2022 Is Bringing Back the Popular Mob Vote

Among the attractions coming at Minecraft Live 2022, players will be able to vote for the new critter that will join the game’s growing ecosystem. The announcement video below hints ... Read more »

How to get Falling Water in Disney Dreamlight Valley

Find out how to obtain Dreamlight Valley Falling Water, along with an Ice Heart, to help Merlin upgrade your magical watering can in the Disney game Read more »

How to get a pumpkin delivered to your doorstep for FREE this fall

HOUSTON – This fall Texans can get pumpkins delivered to their doorstep for free. Oct.1 through Oct. 18, Favor and H-E-B will offer free pumpkin delivery through the Favor app ... Read more »

What is Sudden Cardiac Death (SCD)? How to minimise associated risks?

What is Sudden Cardiac Death (SCD)? How to minimise associated risks? Written by Dr TS Kler Sudden Death, also called Sudden Cardiac Death (SCD), is an unexpected, natural death within ... Read more »

Hori Split Pad Compact Is An Incredible Switch Handheld Controller

Portable Nintendo Switch enthusiasts have an awesome new controller to consider. Read more »

Christian Bale Wanted To Play That Clumsy Stromtrooper In Star Wars Who Hit His Head

Bale also says he would be interested in appearing in a Star Wars project in the future. Read more »

How to get Glabrous Beans in Genshin Impact

Screenshot by Pro Game Guides Glabrous Beans are cooking ingredients used to make plenty of Sumeru delicacies, from the yummy Panipuri to Candace’s Special Dish, Utmost Care. Despite being a ... Read more »

Dragon Age: Dreadwolf Update Teases Amusing Lore Entries

A recent update from BioWare gives fans a taste of the lore of the upcoming Dragon Age game, Dreadwolf. Read more »

One UI feature focus: Multi-Window, how to maximize its potential

One UI 4.1.1 and One UI 5.0 are changing the multitasking and mobile productivity game in a big way. As some of you know, Samsung’s latest One UI versions add ... Read more »

Tesla set a new record with 343,830 electric vehicles delivered in the third quarter

What just happened? With Covid-related restrictions largely in the rearview, Tesla was able to ramp up production and deliveries in the third quarter. For the three-month period ending September 30, ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network