What is Israel's word worth?

What is Israel’s word worth?
© Provided by Al Jazeera A man works inside the Palestinian civil society group Addameer, which was designated by Israel as a terrorist organization along with other five groups, in Ramallah, in the Israel-occupied West Bank October 24, 2021. [Mohamad Torokman/Reuters]

On October 22, Israel issued a military order designating six prominent Palestinian human rights groups – Addameer, Al-Haq, Defense for Children International-Palestine, the Union of Agricultural Work Committees, the Bisan Center for Research and Development, and the Union of Palestinian Women Committees – as “terrorist organisations”.

The Israeli Ministry of Defence said the decision was taken on the basis of “links” they established between these groups and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) – a left-wing movement with a political party, as well as an armed wing that has carried out deadly attacks against Israel.

The Palestinian Authority, many international rights groups and the United Nations swiftly condemned the move. In interviews, comment pieces and statements, officials, analysts and experts expressed their belief that Israel “has gone too far this time”. The most prominent line of argument against the designation was that these six groups are clearly human rights organisations and they cannot be placed in the same “terror” category as groups like the PFLP that consider violence a legitimate means to achieve political ends. “The misuse of counter-terrorism measures in this way by the government of Israel undermines the security of all,” UN human rights experts said in a statement.

For its part, Israel defended its decision by claiming that these groups are “controlled by senior leaders” of the PFLP and that they employ its members, including some who had “participated in terror activity”. The Israeli Ministry of Defence also accused the groups of serving as a “central source” of financing for the PFLP.

In response to these claims, Michael Sfard, a prominent Israeli lawyer who often represents Palestinians, said that Israel’s argument “amounts to absolutely nothing” and that its whole case against these organisations is built on “guilt by association”. “Even if it is true that people who work in certain organisations are PFLP operatives, it does not follow that the organisation itself is part of the PFLP,” he told the AP news agency.

Sfard’s point of view, shared by many others, helped raise some important questions: So what if people working in these organisations are also members of the PFLP? Does it mean anything that Israel considers the PFLP a “terrorist organisation”? What is, after all, “Palestinian terror”?

Why the PFLP cannot be reduced to a mindless terror group

The PFLP lost its prominence in Palestinian politics some time ago, but it still has significant support among Palestinian leftists, and especially among Marxists and socialists.

It is a well-established political organisation that provides Palestinians with social services, communal support and a world view that helps them make sense of their reality and find ways to change it.

The PFLP holds the position that armed resistance is a valid path towards liberation from Israeli settler colonialism, but not every member of the group participates, supports or agrees with armed resistance.

The overwhelming majority of the group’s actions are, in fact, unarmed: it organises strikes, demonstrations and educational activities, provides social services, collects donations, gives economic support to those in need, and so on.

Thus, the PFLP’s complex history and contemporary dynamics, its ever-evolving status and positions, and the role it plays in Palestinian life cannot be reduced to “terror”. Israel’s designation of the group as a “terrorist organisation” and labelling of all its members, supporters and associates as mindless terrorists are nothing but political moves that aim to maintain Israeli power and dominance over Palestinian life.

What is ‘Palestinian terror’?

The PFLP carried out violent operations against the Israeli state and society. And some of its attacks harmed and killed Israeli civilians.

Palestinians are not denying this. In fact, many Palestinian activists, journalists, politicians, academics and artists, myself included, have critiqued the group’s path of armed resistance. I find the targeting of civilians in the name of resistance horrifying and I am categorically opposed to it. And I am not alone. There have always been, and continue to be, vibrant debates within the Palestinian society in Palestine and beyond about the use of violence as a means to achieve liberation.

But does the fact the PFLP engages in armed resistance give Israel – and its allies – the right to label the group as a “terrorist organisation”? Who is Israel to determine the nature and the label of Palestinian violence?

Israel and its Euro-American backers have unleashed levels of violence and destruction on the globe that no Palestinian armed group can hold a candle to. How can states that established themselves on stolen land, states that engage in ethnic cleansing and states that bombed millions of civilians claim to have the moral authority to label the violence of the colonised and the oppressed against them as “terrorism”?

Why is Israeli, American or European violence not considered “terror”, but Palestinian violence is?

Are drone attacks that eradicate entire families in the blink of an eye not terror? Are Israel’s military attacks on Palestine, that have left thousands of civilians, including many children maimed or dead, not terror? Is the brutal siege of Gaza, that left two million people living in an open-air prison, not a blatant act of terror? Do ethnic cleansing, arbitrary arrests, unlawful evictions not terrorise people?

For any objective observer, it should be clear that Israeli state violence is far more destructive in scale and scope and thus more “terrorising” than Palestinian violence.

In this context, it is easy to see “terrorism” is merely a political concept for Israel. It arbitrarily designates Palestinian groups as terrorist organisations to add weight to the false narrative that Palestinian violence is somehow more terrifying, more destructive and objectionable than Israeli violence. Israel labels Palestinians as terrorists to conceal its own violence. It uses the legal designation of terror to continue inflicting violence on oppressed and colonised masses with impunity.

The power of Israel

So, what is Israel’s word worth? The short answer is: everything and nothing.

It is worth everything because, by officially designating six prominent Palestinian rights groups as “terrorist organisations”, Israel made it easier for itself to control and destroy Palestinian lives. Now, these six groups that have long been providing important services to the Palestinian population will struggle to carry out their work. Simply put, by labelling these groups as “terrorist”, the Israeli state increased its already substantial ability to violate Palestinian rights without hindrance and accountability, and with little to no political, juridical, economic, or diplomatic consequence.

But, at the same time, Israel’s word is worth nothing. It is worth nothing in the sense that a designation of “terror” made by Israel reveals nothing about the complex reality of violence.

Israel’s word on violence, as it is the case for Euro-American imperial hegemony writ large, is completely shallow and empty, divorced from the reality on the ground. It is a word that is solely guided by the political impetus to conceal Israeli violence – the unspeakable brutality of their own violence.

This, and nothing else, is what the designation of “Palestinian terror” does for Israel. It teaches us nothing about reality, and instead actively conceals it. And therefore, I repeat the critical question that is being buried underneath this latest story from Palestine: So what if members of the PFLP are also members of these six organisations? The reason why Palestinians join any group is simple: They are doing everything that they can in their desperate yet steadfast efforts to resist the Israeli state’s settler-colonial project which kills, maims, dispossesses, and expels them.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

News Related


Kad TnG generasi baharu yang boleh ditambah nilai guna telefon akan hadir beberapa minggu lagi

TNG Digital Sdn. Bhd. mengumumkan yang dalam beberapa minggu lagi, mereka akan melancarkan kad Touch ‘n Go generasi baharu. Kad ini membolehkan penggunannya menambah nilai kad terus daripada telefon yang ... Read more »

Afcon 2021: Zimbabwe's Musona thinking about future after early exit

Zimbabwe captain Knowledge Musona is considering his international future after they suffered an early exit from the Africa Cup of Nations in Cameroon. The 31-year-old forward, who currently turns out ... Read more »

Terbuka Australia: Keys kejutkan Krejcikova di Melbourne Park

© Provided by Sinar Harian BINTANG tenis Amerika Syarikat (AS), Madison Keys meneruskan momentum positif di Terbuka Australia apabila melangkah ke peringkat separuh akhir selepas mengatasi juara Terbuka Perancis, Barbora ... Read more »

Will you buy this Rs 7k pair of sandwich sneakers? Internet is divided

The internet can never fail to surprise, don’t you think? There is a plethora of mindboggling content online that can create a stir within seconds. Well, you must be thinking ... Read more »

The Latest: Nadal moves into Australian Open semifinals

MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) — The Latest at the Australian Open on Tuesday (all times local): © Provided by The Canadian Press 6:35 p,m. Rafael Nadal has stayed on track for ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas set to welcome their baby girl in renovated LA home and it costs a BOMB!

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com When a couple opts for surrogacy, people start thinking that one of them might have some health issue. However, the report in the portal states that ... Read more »

86% Indians want voting to be made compulsory: Survey

An overwhelming 86 per cent people want voting to be made mandatory in the country, according to a survey released on Tuesday on the occasion of the 12th National Voters’ ... Read more »

'Kyu Hit Hui Mai Nahi Jaanta' When Aamir Called Govinda's Aankhen 'Too Crude' & 'Vulgar'

© Provided by MensXP David Dhawan’s Aankhen, featuring Govinda, Chunky Panday, Ritu Shivpuri, and Raageshwari Loomba in the lead roles, was released in 1993 and turned out to be a ... Read more »

MP home minister directs DGP to file FIR against Amazon officials, owner

Amid a row, the Madhya Pradesh government has directed the police to register an FIR against officials of e-commerce giant Amazon and its owner for allegedly selling products, including shoes, ... Read more »

Bengal govt disburses Rs 74 cr to settle around 15,000 Covid-19 death claim

The West Bengal government has spent Rs 74 crore from its State Disaster Response Fund to settle around 15,000 claims of COVID-19 deaths out of the over 18,500 applications it ... Read more »

Australian Open 2022: Rafael Nadal outlasts Denis Shapovalov in 5 sets marathon to reach 1st semi-final since 2019

Rafael Nadal Rafael Nadal punched the air in delight at the Rod Laver Arena with the very little energy that he had left in his tank after taking 4 hours ... Read more »

Morocco vs Malawi: Kick-off, TV channel, squad news and preview

© Getty Sofiane Boufal, Morocco vs Ghana, 2021 Afcon Morocco will battle it out with Malawi in the 2021 Africa Cup of Nations Round of 16 encounter at Ahmadou Ahidjo ... Read more »

Australian Open director says supporters are ‘welcome' to wear Peng Shuai T-shirts

© PA Peng Shuai file photo. SPECTATORS AT THE Australian Open are welcome to wear T-shirts supporting Peng Shuai, tournament director Craig Tiley has said. Organisers have been heavily criticised ... Read more »

UK scraps Covid border testing for fully vaccinated travellers

© Leon Neal/Getty International arrivals at Heathrow airport The Prime Minister said the move would signal that Britain is “open for business” as it emerges from the latest wave of ... Read more »

Further details over transfer involving Stoke City and Sheffield United revealed

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Sheffield United v Stoke City Stoke City keeper Adam Davies is said to have chosen to leave the club because he felt ... Read more »

Rafael Nadal ‘walked up with authority' during Denis Shapovalov Australian Open win

Rafael Nadal has been praised for the way he handled Denis Shapovalov’s Australian Open outburst on Tuesday morning. The Spaniard had to dig deep and go the full five sets ... Read more »

Ukraine: Russia warned of ‘unprecedented sanctions' by world leaders after crisis talks

Russia was warned it faces an “unprecedented package of sanctions” if it invades Ukraine after world leaders held talks over the crisis. Joe Biden has said there is “total unanimity” ... Read more »

Ananya Panday says 'thanks' as Mira Rajput writes she's obsessed with AP. Fans point out it's AP Dhillon

Mira Rajputs makes AP Dhillon reference on her post, Ananya Panday replies. AP Dhillon is the new buzzword among the millennial lot. It was in December when we saw many ... Read more »

Covid live news: Johnson faces outrage over lockdown birthday; Netherlands expected to drop Omicron measures

LIVE – Updated at 08:07 News UK prime minister spent birthday indoors with 30 guests in breach of Covid restrictions prompts new fury; 7pm announcement in Netherlands expected to ease ... Read more »

Kartik Aaryan is a thorough professional: Shehzada team backs actor amid Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo release row

© Provided by Pinkvilla The release of the Hindi dubbed version of Allu Arjun’s Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo has been the talk of the town for a while now. And recently, Ala ... Read more »

Arsenal loanees Matteo Guendouzi and William Saliba flourishing in France at Marseille

Both Matteo Guendouzi and William Saliba are quickly emerging as two of the finest talents in the top-tier of French football as they continue their shared spell at Marseille on ... Read more »

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai SPOILERS: Abhimanyu reveals Aarohi's lies; Latter blames everyone for her actions

© Provided by Pinkvilla In the upcoming episode of Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai, it will be seen that Birlas and Goenkas will finally get to know the truth about ... Read more »

UN data reveals ‘nearly insurmountable' scale of lost schooling due to Covid

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Hemis/Alamy The scale of the number of children who have lost out on their schooling during the pandemic is “nearly insurmountable”, according to UN ... Read more »

COVID-19 vaccination for 5 to 11 years old to start Feb. 1 —NTF adviser

© National Task Force Against COVID-19 NTF vs COVID-19 medical adviser Ted Herbosa The vaccination against COVID-19 of children aged 5 to 11 years old is set to start on ... Read more »

Anti-abortion group sees surge in donations ahead of US Supreme Court ruling

In the nearly two months since a conservative majority of justices on the US Supreme Court indicated openness to dramatic new restrictions on abortion, money has poured into the political ... Read more »

Higher quality masks vs. Omicron not yet recommended for public, only for health workers —NTF adviser

Photo: Tina Panganiban-Perez National Task Force Against COVID-19 medical adviser Dr. Ted Herbosa on Tuesday said it is not recommended yet for the public to use higher quality masks to ... Read more »

One player per Premier League club with less than a week to move

Record signings, bit-part players, promising youngsters… here are 20 players with only six days to get themselves away from their current clubs…   Arsenal – Bernd Leno With Leno having ... Read more »

Harsher discipline of boys at school linked to high dropout rate in male pupils

– Nearly 80 000 more girls than boys enrolled for the 2021 matric exams, continuing a trend seen over the past decade – Research suggested boys repeat grades at a ... Read more »

Indonesia: 19 killed after gangs fight with Molotov cocktails and machetes - sparking fire in karaoke bar

Police are still investigating what happened - and whether the fire was set or if it was accidental. Read more »

Palace: Covid-19 vaccination for kids aged 5 to 11 starts on Feb. 4

THE government will administer Covid-19 (coronavirus disease 2019) vaccine to children aged 5 to 11 years old starting on February 4, Malacañang announced on Tuesday. In his virtual press briefing, ... Read more »

Danish Sait's Kannada film One Cut Two Cut teaser looks intriguing; Trailer out on January 28

© Provided by Pinkvilla The official teaser of Danish Sait starring Kannada film One Cut Two Cut is out and it looks intriguing. In the video, Danish’s character is busy ... Read more »

VIRAL VIDEO: Matrix Wali Dulhan! THIS bride bends during jaimala ceremony, groom looks amazed - Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Netizens love to throng social media for surfing entertaining wedding videos and that’s why we see many trending ones on Instagram and Twitter ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif shares gorgeous pictures of herself from Maldives, calls it her happy place

© Provided by Radio City Katrina Kaif has shared some beautiful pictures of herself from Maldives, the go-to vacation spot of Bollywood over the last two years. The actress stunned ... Read more »

Genocide survivors urge compassion for migrants ahead of Holocaust Memorial Day

Holocaust and genocide survivors who fled their homelands to escape persecution have urged Britons to show the same compassion afforded to them to the thousands of people crossing the English ... Read more »

If elected president, Bongbong Marcos says he won't make his SALN public

© Philippines Daily Inquirer MANILA, Philippines — Should he win in the May 2022 polls, presidential aspirant and former senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr. said on Monday he will not make ... Read more »

AirAsia announces Chinese New Year, 2.2 promo fares

© AirAsia Philippines AirAsia A320. AirAsia Philippines AirAsia Philippines on Tuesday announced promotional deals in celebration of the Chinese New Year, along with its “Save Now, Fly Later” sale. The ... Read more »

PRN Johor: Pertimbang kerjasama dengan PAS, Bersatu, ahli Amanah beritahu PH

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Mazlan Aliman berkata, PH dan parti pembangkang mesti berjiwa besar dan melupakan persengketaan demi kepentingan rakyat dikhianati dengan mandat diberikan mereka. PETALING JAYA: Kerjasama ... Read more »

Rundingan agih kerusi PRN dijangka selesai esok, kata pemimpin Amanah Johor

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Formula PH Johor adalah mudah saja, iaitu mengekalkan parti yang menang pada PRU14, menurut Dzulkefly Ahmad. PETALING JAYA: Rundingan Pakatan Harapan (PH) Johor mengenai ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: You Wouldn't Believe What Pratik Sahejpal Called Rakhi Sawant!

Age-shaming has been one of the most controversial topics inside the house of Bigg Boss for many years now. From the beginning of the reality show, there have been instances ... Read more »

Kartik Aaryan, Kiara Advani's 'Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2' sticks to same release date

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Amid several speculations, makers of one of the much-awaited movies of the year ‘Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2’ have clarified that the film’s release date ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic