What impact does the nuclear option have on Australian submarine contractors and jobs?

© Provided by ABC Business Experts say large amounts of the work on Australia’s proposed nuclear submarines, such as the hull, will likely be done at the Adelaide shipyard that built the Collins class. (ABC News: Angelique Donnellan)

There have been two overwhelming reactions from the local defence industry to this week’s announcement that Australia will tear up its contract with Naval Group and build either US or UK designed nuclear submarines instead. One is relief, the other fear.

Nigel Hennessy from defence consultancy Project Alpha Plus — which had worked for Naval Group — explained that, from a strategic perspective, a nuclear submarine made more sense for Australia.

“Australia shouldn’t have diesel submarines, it should have nuclear, because we need the range to get around the whole of the country as covertly as possible, and the only way to do that is with a good nuclear submarine,” he told ABC News.

Brent Clark is the CEO of the Australian Industry and Defence Network (AIDN), and he shares Mr Hennessy’s point of view.

“It’s a tremendous package from a national security perspective, and that’s what we want governments to do,” he said.

Entering the ‘valley of death’

However, Mr Clark was also aware of the financial pain and fear many of his members will be feeling after Naval Group’s contract was torn up.

“There are a lot of companies that have contracts with Naval Group,” he told ABC News.

“They will have been issued cease work orders. That will be devastating for them.

“We are staring down the barrel of nearly three years from when people get work. How are those companies going to be looked after?

“How are we going to ensure that they survive? Because we need them to survive, because they’re going to be required going forward. How are we going to manage the workforce?”

Those questions resonate with Audra McCarthy, who runs the Defence Teaming Centre, which helps industry get involved in the sector.

“Our initial response was complete shock,” she told The Business.

“We are now thinking about the significant investment many of our members have been making to be involved in the future submarine program, at personal cost in some cases. Where does it leave those businesses now?”

Even though the design phase of the project was yet to get underway, due in part to contractual disputes between the French company and Australian government, some work was already being contracted and hundreds of people employed in Adelaide.

“They were on track to employ about 500 people in Adelaide by the end of this year, including about 50 people who are overseas training in France, and on track to award about a billion dollars worth of work to Australian companies,” noted Greg Ferguson, also from Project Alpha Plus.

“All that work is going to stop and the so-called ‘valley of death’, which has been a source of worry for a lot of companies, is going to continue, because it’s going to be a few years before we see any work begin on the new submarines, whatever they are.”

Ms McCarthy was worried that many businesses burned by missing out on work with Naval Group may throw in the towel.

“We’ve seen an influx of new companies transferring from existing adjacent sectors to enter into the defence sector,” she observed.

“I think we’re likely to see a number of companies will exit from the defence industry sector.”

Mr Hennessy said the decision to abandon a $90 billion contract may also make big multinational defence contractors cautious to bid for future work.

“We’re going to struggle to get another contract out of France for a long time,” he warned.

“I think many of the other countries will start thinking twice about working with Australia, when the government does what they’ve done here.”

This view appears to be confirmed by France’s angry reaction to the announcement.

‘No logical reason’ Australia can’t build most of the subs

However, while the next few years will be tough, Mr Clark was confident there would be plenty of work in Australia once the construction of the submarines eventually gets underway.

“We’re building another submarine — and there’ll be an extra bit, a very sophisticated, very costly, extra bit called a nuclear reactor — but the rest of the submarine, there’s no logical reason why Australia can’t be involved in that,” he said.

“I don’t see the government having the appetite to build any of its submarines except for the nuclear part overseas, and I think the general public will get quite upset if they actually did that.”

Both AIDN and Project Alpha Plus agree that Australia had all the skills, technology and experience necessary to build key components of the submarine, including the steel hull, parts of the combat system, sonar, propellers, the torpedo handling system and much more.

“I think we probably will need to have to build overseas initially, in order to get the timeline reduced,” Mr Hennessy said.

“But I think, longer term, you will probably find it will be of that order of 70 per cent or more local content by the end of the final builds.”

Mr Ferguson noted, from his experience scrutinising the Collins class submarine project, that most of the money spent in Australia was outside South Australia.

“The reality was that 75 cents, at least, in every dollar that went into the submarine project, went straight outside the state again,” he observed.

“So any any big project of this kind is a whole-of-nation project.”

However, while Project Alpha Plus could see the overall benefit of the change in direction to a nuclear submarine design, Mr Hennessy was perplexed why the government tore up the French contract and damaged the relationship with that country.

“The original submarine they purchased was a nuclear submarine, which they then converted to a diesel. Why didn’t they get Naval Group to actually use the original design?” he asked.

“That defies logic, because they’ve cancelled the contract, destroyed the relationship and, in turn, they’ve now got to go back to the drawing board and put the program behind by five years.

“So I don’t understand that logic.”


Video: Nuclear-powered submarines a ‘terrible decision’ which will make Australia ‘less safe’ (Sky News Australia)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Iris, 82, who married Egyptian toyboy, 36, reveals sex positions they love and how he doesn't care about her dentures

PENSIONER Iris Jones raised eyebrows on This Morning when she talked about wedding her Egyptian toyboy – 46 years her junior. Iris, 82, married 36-year-old engineer Mohamed Ibriham, a year ... Read more »

LeBron James-less Lakers nip Spurs in OT, Anthony Davis hurts knee

SAN ANTONIO — Davis had 35 points and 17 rebounds, Russell Westbrook added 33 points and 10 rebounds, and the Los Angeles Lakers rallied without LeBron James to beat the ... Read more »

Youth climate activists stage overnight protest at Science Museum

Young climate activists who slept overnight in London’s Science Museum have said they will be approaching the first visitors of the day to tell them about the establishment’s sponsorship deals ... Read more »

'The needs of those who don't live in towns or cities are ignored': Readers on LTNs and the ULEZ

A road with wooden blockades and road signs – Geoff Pugh /Geoff Pugh Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) are just one part of the Government's drive to cut air pollution caused ... Read more »

Illegal waste dumps near Paris wreak environmental havoc

Near a forest barely 20 kilometres from Paris, an impromptu landfill covering more than 16 hectares is just one of many illegal waste dumps polluting the outskirts of the French ... Read more »

Japan PM's nuclear push faces resistance ahead of election

1 / 2Japan PM’s nuclear push faces resistance ahead of electionFILE PHOTO: An anti-nuclear activist demonstrates in front of the Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings office in Niigata By Sakura ... Read more »

Mamelodi's Boko Haram kingpin shot dead

© Provided by SowetanLive Given Mnguni, popularly known as Nkunzi in the township east of Pretoria, is considered as the leader of the gang. He died when a car they ... Read more »

'I never touched her': Sipho Pityana refutes sexual harassment claims

© Provided by SowetanLive On February 18 2019, leading businessman Sipho Pityana, then chair of mining giant AngloGold Ashanti, went to dinner with a female colleague at a restaurant in ... Read more »

Muay Thai expert puts guy in choke hold after he sexually harasses her in train

© Provided by CapeTalk Have you been wondering what’s been trending on the internet lately? Check out some of the top stories on What’s Gone Viral with Khabazela. RELATED: Daughter ... Read more »

Shirley Ballas says ‘concerned' doctor has booked her a hospital appointment after viewers spot ‘lumps' in her armpit

© Shirley Ballas Instagram Shirley Ballas – Shirley Ballas Instagram Strictly Come Dancing head judge Shirley Ballas has shared a new health update with fans after viewers raised concerns over ... Read more »

Shah Rukh Khan's first brush with NCB officer Sameer Wankhede dates back to 2011, read here

© Provided by DNA On October 3, Sameer Wankhede arrested Shah Rukh Khan’s son Aryan and some others from a cruise party where apparently Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) had conducted a raid ... Read more »

Akshay Kumar, Katrina Kaif build a perfect life together in Sooryavanshi song Mere Yaaraa

Akshay Kumar and Katrina Kaif in a still from Sooryavanshi song Mere Yaaraa. The love song titled Mere Yaaraa from Sooryavanshi has been released. The film features Katrina Kaif and ... Read more »

Sardar Udham star Vicky Kaushal pens appreciation note. Says cherishing all the love pouring in

Vicky Kaushal is currently enjoying the success of his latest film, Sardar Udham. The actor has been receiving love and appreciation from his friends and fans for his power-packed performance ... Read more »

Ranbir Kapoor & Alia Bhatt to have a December wedding?

© Provided by Pinkvilla Wednesday couldn’t have kicked off on a better note for fans of Alia Bhatt and Ranbir Kapoor as a latest report claims that the lovebirds are ... Read more »

VIDEO: Mahesh Babu fans rushing to click pics with him in Spain speaks volumes of his stardom

© Provided by Pinkvilla Mahesh Babu is one the finest actors we have in Tollywood and undoubtedly the biggest superstar not only in India but even internationally. His fans have ... Read more »

Amid wedding rumours with Katrina Kaif, Vicky Kaushal shares a photo of him enjoying laddoo

© Provided by Pinkvilla Vicky Kaushal is constantly making headlines for both personal and professional reasons. Professionally, he is currently basking in the success of his recently released film Sardar ... Read more »

Global Carbon Footprint Management Market to 2026 by Component (Solution v/s Service), Deployment Mode (On-Premise v/s Cloud), & Type (Product Carbon Footprint v/s Corporate Carbon Footprint) - ResearchAndMarkets.com

DUBLIN, October 26, 2021–(BUSINESS WIRE)–The “Global Carbon Footprint Management Market, By Component (Solution v/s Service), By Deployment Mode (On-Premise v/s Cloud), By Type (Product Carbon Footprint v/s Corporate Carbon Footprint), ... Read more »

Indict Bolsonaro for crimes against humanity over Covid response, say Brazilian senators

Jair Bolsonaro‘s handling of the pandemic has triggered widespread protests – Horacio Villalobos/Corbis News A Brazilian Senate investigative committee approved a report on Tuesday that calls for President Jair Bolsonaro ... Read more »

IRB Infra hits 10% lower circuit as pref issue price set at 28% discount

New Delhi: Shares of IRB Infrastructure Developers hit the lower circuit on Wednesday after the company’s board approved the fundraising plans. The board approved raising up to Rs 5,347 crore ... Read more »

Couple held after four brothers abandoned, one killed

A mother accused of abandoning her four sons has been arrested in Texas along with her partner suspected of murdering one of the boys, a local sheriff said Tuesday. © ... Read more »

Maureen Wroblewitz, to join next year's Miss Universe-Philippines?

“I’m definitely open to trying it again,” said Maureen Wroblewitz when asked if she has plans to join Miss Universe Philippines 2022. © Provided by LionhearTV In an exclusive interview ... Read more »

Watch: Shoaib Akhtar walks out after being 'insulted on live television, later issues clarification

Shoaib Akhtar walks out after being ‘insulted on live television, later issues clarification Former Pakistan pacer Shoaib Akhtar walked out of a TV programme and resigned from his job as ... Read more »

IGNOU releases tentative date sheet for December TEE 2021; check notification here

© Provided by Firstpost IGNOU releases tentative date sheet for December TEE 2021; check notification here The tentative date sheet for December Term-End Examination (TEE) 2021 has been released by ... Read more »

SC seeks UP govt report on Lakhimpur Kheri violence; directs protection of witnesses

© Provided by The Statesman SC seeks UP govt report on Lakhimpur Kheri violence; directs protection of witnesses The Supreme Court on Tuesday sought from Uttar Pradesh a separate report ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Celebrating 'moment of unity', England keen to take a stand

© Provided by The Times of India Jos Buttler says the England team will continue to take a stand against racism and discrimination and even if it means not taking ... Read more »

‘Won't announce official retirement but may days of playing for South Africa are over': Chris Morris

Chris Morris said his playing days for South Africa may well be over and he is now only concentrating on domestic cricket and T20 leagues. The all-rounder said he is ... Read more »

‘Spent 52 Yrs in Cong, What Harm Will 10 More Days Do': Capt Amarinder on Aroosa Alam, BJP & Future

© Provided by News18 ‘Spent 52 Yrs in Cong, What Harm Will 10 More Days Do’: Capt Amarinder on Aroosa Alam, BJP & Future Former Punjab chief minister Captain Amarinder ... Read more »

India vs Pakistan T20 World Cup 2021: Venkatesh Prasad slams Waqar Younis for 'jihadi mindset' after his 'namaz in front of Hindus' remark

© Provided by Zee News Former India pacer Venkatesh Prasad slammed former Pakistan cricketer Waqar Younis for his controversial statement that opener Mohammad Rizwan offering namaz “in front of Hindus ... Read more »

Rajasthan man sentenced to death for raping, killing 11-year old girl

© Provided by Hindustan Times A man was given death penalty for raping and killing an 11-year-old girl in June. (AFP/Getty Images) A special court in Rajasthan’s Ajmer has awarded the ... Read more »

WWE NXT 2.0 Halloween Havoc Results: Bron Breakker Faces Tommaso Ciampa; New Champion Crowned

© Provided by News18 World Wrestling Entertainment’s 2021 WWE NXT Halloween Havoc special episode started with horror icon Chunky narrating a video package about Tuesday night’s fights. Interestingly for the ... Read more »

Islamabad sealed to prevent TLP march

© IANS Tahreek labbaik Pak. New Delhi, Oct 27 (IANS) The district administrations of Rawalpindi and Islamabad blocked the Faizabad intersection on Tuesday midnight while the law enforcement agencies began ... Read more »

Inquiry, Extortion & 'Fake' Hindu Certificate: Shifting Focus from Aryan Khan Case to Malik-Wankhede Spat

© Provided by News18 Inquiry, Extortion & ‘Fake’ Hindu Certificate: Shifting Focus from Aryan Khan Case to Malik-Wankhede Spat The new focus of the Aryan Khan drugs case has shifted ... Read more »

Sports Authority clears wrestling contingent for World U23 with a rider

© Provided by The Times of India Six wrestlers, three coaches can go at ‘no cost to govt’ NEW DELHI: The Sports Authority of India (SAI) hasn’t taken kindly to ... Read more »

4th Progressive Punjab Investors Summit 2021: Channi assures zero tolerance for political or bureaucratic corruption

© Provided by The Statesman 4th Progressive Punjab Investors Summit 2021: Channi assures zero tolerance for political or bureaucratic corruption Assuring the Captains of the industry of creating conducive ecosystem ... Read more »

New sunspot triggers intense solar eruptions, hurtles particles into space

The Sun has been the source of energy powering all things on Earth and leading to the evolution of life. However, at times, the Sun also becomes the centre of ... Read more »

West Bengal govt allows sale of green crackers but with restricted timings

Ahead of Diwali, the West Bengal Pollution Control Board has permitted the sale of only green crackers. It has fixed a time slot of 8 pm to 10 pm on ... Read more »

Aryan Khan drug case: Mumbai Police record statement of witness Prabhakar Sail for 8 hrs over extortion bid allegations

Mumbai Police recorded the statement of independent witness Prabhakar Sail for over eight hours in connection with in connection with his allegation of extortion attempt by NCB officials in the ... Read more »

Cultural Foundation launches new exhibitions to celebrate the past and a future on Mars

© Ismail Noor The Al Mujamma exhibition tells the story of Abu Dhabi Cultural Foundation through interactive archival footage and materials. Photo: Abu Dhabi Cultural Foundation Today, the Abu Dhabi ... Read more »

Softline to launch $1.5bn London IPO amid cybersecurity frenzy

© Provided by City AM Cybersecurity firm Softline has launched a lofty $1.5bn initial public offering (IPO) in London today, as technology and security creep higher on the business agenda ... Read more »

Cop26: How to put your money where your mouth is

Global warming is the focus of our collective attention this week as thousands of delegates arrive in Glasgow for the 26th UN Climate Change Conference. © REUTERS FILE PHOTO: Climate ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic