What does euroscepticism in the EU look like now that Brexit has happened?

Asia's Tech News Daily

What does euroscepticism in the EU look like now that Brexit has happened?

“YOU’RE NOT LAUGHING now” was how Nigel Farage attempted to rub salt into the wounds of MEPs in the European Parliament five days after the 2016 Brexit vote.

Farage was in full gloating mode and then-Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker was baited into replying: “The British people voted for the exit. Why are you here?”

If only it were so easy. As Brexit dragged on, Farage remained in Brussels for almost four more years until the UK officially left the EU and lost all its MEPs.

But whether he meant it or not, there was a deeper meaning to Juncker simply asking Farage why he thought it necessary to be in the chamber.

The question of why Farage was there can also be taken to mean why someone so implacably opposed to the European project would devote so much time and effort to being there in the first place.

Many argue that in Farage’s particular case self-interest played a huge part – but speaking more generally, is the European Parliament the best place for a hardline eurosceptic?

It can be fairly argued that the best place to oppose the EU is at its heart, and that UKIP proved this by ultimately wedging the UK out.

But what if your goal isn’t an exit but rather to oppose greater integration?

Dr Ariadna Ripoll Servent is professor of EU politics at Salzburg Centre of European Union Studies and has written extensively about EU institutions and euroscepticism.

She has spoken about the various shades of eurosceptic MEPs elected to the European Parliament and says you can roughly group them as being either ‘hard eurosceptics’ or ‘soft eurosceptics’.

While the former may be opposed to membership or the very existence of the European Union, the latter are merely opposed to its goals and policies.

What does euroscepticism in the EU look like now that Brexit has happened?
© Alamy Stock Photo The European Parliament building in Strasbourg France.

“Soft eurosceptics could be those that are more critical of specific policies or are critical of the system not being democratic enough,” she tells The Journal.

If you have more of a softer form of euroscepticism, we could compare that to some sort of opposition politics. So it’s not much different than when, in national parliaments, you have opposition parties that maybe criticise what is being done by the government.

She adds: “Some of the criticisms are perfectly fair: issues of transparency or migration policies, which, if you think of the EU becoming a “fortress Europe”, is something that the radical left tends to criticise a lot and many people agree with. So yes, I think it can be good for democracy and offers a broader range of opinions.”

2019

The European Parliament elections in May 2019 were among the most closely-watched such votes in the history of the bloc, a fact that was reflected in EU-wide turnout that reached a 25-year high.

The Brexit vote itself, and to a larger degree the election of Donald Trump in 2016, had many EU politicians nervous that a surge of eurosceptic MEPs would be elected as part of a wider populist wave.

The result saw an increase in the number of eurosceptic MEPs elected but the much-expected revolution failed to materialise.

Instead, the outcome led to a greater fragmentation within the European Parliament and alliances that are less clear.

In an analysis Ripoll Servent carried out in the months after the vote, she determined that about 31% of MEPs elected in 2019 could be considered eurosceptic, an increase on the 27% following the 2014 vote.

This 31% would however drop to 28% within the year when the Brexit Party’s members departed along with the rest of the UK’s cohort.

The nature of Brexit also had an impact on euroscepticism across Europe.

While some sceptics may have been emboldened by the result, the tortuous negotiations that followed did not present an attractive proposition for eurosceptics to sell to voters.

Brussels-based Dutch journalist Caroline de Gruyter has covered European politics for well over a decade and says that Brexit has caused eurosceptics to change tack.

“Many eurosceptics have seen that actually it’s not very smart to go for an exit,” she explains.

They don’t want to follow the example of the UK, I think they’ve seen the mess. So we should thank the UK for not having made any plans, for the messiness of it and for the hardness of their Brexit, because it really opened the eyes of a lot of sceptics on the continent.

“What they do want now is instead to stay in and change the EU from the inside. And this is what many of them are doing. They are forming groupings on a European level, contacting each other ever more frequently.”

De Gruyter argues that in the case of the UK – Northern Ireland issues aside – Brexit should have been “relatively easy” because the country wasn’t part of the Euro or the Schengen travel area, whereas other Member States are more intertwined.

Namechecking Poland and Hungary, she adds that another issue for eurosceptics in some states is that their countries “depend on the money” from the EU.

“UKIP never depended on European money. But the the ruling party in Poland does, Fidesz in Hungary [does]. [Hungarian prime minister] Viktor Orban’s power base is almost is almost exactly based on European subsidies and how they are distributed among partners or friends,” she says.

Ireland

When it comes to euroscepticism, making a precise calculation about how prevalent it is within a parliament or a political system is difficult because parties either reject the label or because the label simply doesn’t fit.

It is also complicated by the fact that euroscepticism exists from both left and right of the traditional ideological divide. It is for this reason that the term ‘Lexit’ became popular during the UK Brexit debate, representing those in favour of Brexit from a left-wing standpoint.

In last year’s book Euroscepticism and the Future of Europe, the book’s three editors outline this phenomenon:

Euroscepticism represents a self-standing cleavage cutting through the left-right divide. With the exception of Austria, Cyprus, Denmark, Estonia, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia, most European countries have experienced right and left-wing Euroscepticism in parallel, with the left focusing their discourse largely on a rejection of the so-called “ultraliberal” Europe.

What does euroscepticism in the EU look like now that Brexit has happened?
© Alamy Stock Photo A pro-EU rally in Warsaw Poland earlier this month.

The book goes on to detail the prevalence of euroscepticism in the politics of each member state, including Ireland.

The specific chapter on Ireland is written by Róisín Smith of the Institute of International and European Affairs (IIEA) and notes that “there are no true Eurosceptic parties influencing the political system”.

This would likely lead to some debate, with political opponents frequently pointing out that Sinn Féin has opposed every Irish referendum that sought greater EU integration.

Sinn Féin representatives have defended this history and have argued that critiquing “the European project” should not equate to the label of eurosceptic.

In any event, Smith’s contention that euroscepticism does not influence Irish politics does not mean it doesn’t exist here, but rather that there is “no evidence” to suggest it is “shaping the political landscape”.

Candidates for the Irish Freedom Party, for example, which directly campaigns for an Irish exit from the EU, received 2% or less in first-preference votes in last year’s general election.

Smith writes:

Levels of euroscepticism exist in every EU Member State. In Ireland, there are varying degrees of anti-European, anti-establishment, anti-immigration and populist sentiments. Protest voting, political discontent and distrust for the governing parties did result in an increase in the vote for self-described ‘Euro-critical’ parties such as Sinn Féin, and gains for new groupings, for instance, the Anti-Austerity Alliance, People Before Profit and Independents in the 2016 general election.Notwithstanding this, it is inaccurate to overestimate and conflate the importance of anti-establishment and anti-elitist sentiment in the Irish context and in shaping the Irish voter towards an anti-European view. Anti-establishment sentiment, however, does not lead to a distinctly eurosceptic force.

Smith goes on to argue that the initial rejection of the Nice and Lisbon treaties in Ireland “had more to do with domestic and anti-establishment stances than hard euroscepticism”.

She adds that the “Brexit factor” has also improved the status of the EU among Irish people, arguing that it has “harnessed support for the EU”.

An annual poll by the European Movement Ireland has tracked sentiment about Ireland and the EU since 2013.

This year’s poll found only 9% of people supported Ireland leaving the EU whereas, in 2015, 23% of people said the country should leave if the UK voted to do so.

2022

What does euroscepticism in the EU look like now that Brexit has happened?
© Alamy Stock Photo French far-right leader Marine Le Pen and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban.

The coming year represents an important juncture for the EU’s stability and for the development of euroscepticism across the bloc, specifically the euroscepticism of the far-right.  

A growing east-west divide was highlighted during last month’s EU summit when Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic stood in opposition to Brussels after Poland’s Supreme Court had ruled that certain EU laws were unconstitutional.

It came on the back of a showdown at an earlier summit when Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban defended his parliament’s anti-LGBTQ law from criticism from various EU leaders.

Orban’s authoritarian regime in Hungary has been an increasing concern for many western nations and earlier this year his Fidesz party was forced out of the EPP European Parliament grouping which includes Fine Gael.

The departure of Fidesz from the group ended the debate between EPP parties over whether to kick Orban’s party out or keep his MEPs inside the tent to prevent them siding with far-right eurosceptics.

This fear was realised a number of months later when Orban, Marine Le Pen’s National Rally party and 14 other parties across the right and far-right said they would work towards a “grand alliance” in the European Parliament.

Efforts at forming a coherent eurosceptic alliance of the right have long provided elusive but the joint declaration by the parties sought to move it a step closer.

Other signatories included Matteo Salvini, leader of Italy’s anti-immigration League, Santiago Abascal of the Spanish populist movement Vox and Jaroslaw Kaczynski, leader of Poland’s governing PiS party.

In the statement, they say that the EU “continues to pursue the federalist path that inexorably distances it from the peoples who are the beating heart of our civilisation”.

They urged “reform” of the bloc, adding that Europe’s “most influential patriotic parties” had “understood the importance” of joining forces.

Crucially, both Le Pen and Orban are facing elections next year that will go a long way to determining how influential the alliance may be.

Le Pen is facing an uphill struggle and, based on current polling, may not even make the run off vote against Emmanuel Macron, as she did in 2017.

Even if she or her similarly far-right rival Eric Zemmour do make the head-to-head vote against Macron, it is not expected that they will win the presidency outright.

Le Pen was in Budapest last month and met with Orban, refusing while there to criticise Hungary’s anti-LGBTQ law that’s at the centre of the row with Brussels.

Orban himself is facing tough parliamentary elections in April 2022 after six opposition parties took the unprecedented step of backing a single candidate as part of their efforts to unseat him.

Marki-Zay became the opposition candidate after a primary, consolidating an anti-Orban coalition in the first-past-the-post electoral system.

Polling is said to be neck-and-neck in the contest but the UN has already warned about the staunchly pro-Orban media attempting to “distort” the race.

Reflecting on the coming year, De Gruyter says that while you “never know” what can happen in elections, there have been various examples in recent years of centrist parties defeating populism in places like Switzerland and Austria, a fact she hopes is repeated:

“If we put our heads down and let them walk all over us, we can get into the kinds of scenarios where the far-right wins. But under normal circumstances we should keep answering these guys, because perhaps while they ask the right questions they never provide answers, so we should keep answering them and when they attack democracy, we should defend it.”

This work is co-funded by Journal Media and a grant programme from the European Parliament. Any opinions or conclusions expressed in this work is the author’s own. The European Parliament has no involvement in nor responsibility for the editorial content published by the project. For more information, see here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

This Plant-Based Diet Still Lets You Have Meat

The flexitarian diet is ahead of its time. The concept became popular after Dawn Jackson Blatner, R.D., published The Flexitarian Diet in 2008, and is essentially an outline of the ... Read more »

Justices Gorsuch and Sotomayor seek to play down mask row – but without addressing accusation

© Getty Images GettyImages-1232480839.jpg Supreme Court Justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonya Sotomayor are pushing back on reports of conflict between the justices over Mr Gorsuch’s refusal to wear a mask ... Read more »

Hilary Duff Didn't Know Cadet Kelly Resonated with LGBTQ Community: 'If It Helped Anybody, I Hope So'

© Provided by People Buena Vista/Kobal/Shutterstock Christy Carlson Romano and Hilary Duff in Cadet Kelly Hilary Duff is looking back at her film Cadet Kelly with new eyes. The How ... Read more »

Plans to tackle NHS waiting lists in Wales ‘will be delayed until spring'

© PA Archive Pioneering gene-silencing drug Plans to reduce NHS waiting lists in Wales will likely be delayed until the spring, health minister Eluned Morgan has warned. Baroness Morgan indicated ... Read more »

Maguire on bench for Man Utd vs Brentford

© PA Harry Maguire will be on the bench for Man United’s game with Brentford Harry Maguire will be named on the bench again for Manchester United’s Premier League clash ... Read more »

GM expands market for hydrogen fuel cells beyond vehicles

The Associated PressThis image provided by General Motors shows the GM Logo. General Motors is finding new markets for its hydrogen fuel cell systems. The automaker announced Wednesday, Jan. 19, ... Read more »

HBO leads GLAAD Media Awards for LGBTQ representation

The Associated PressThis image provided by Jeopardy Productions, Inc. shows game show champion Amy Schneider on the set of “Jeopardy!” Schneider is the first trans person to qualify for the ... Read more »

Djokovic has 80% stake in biotech firm developing Covid drug

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Darko Bandić/AP Tennis star Novak Djokovic is the controlling shareholder in a Danish biotech firm aiming to develop a treatment for Covid-19 that doesn’t ... Read more »

London's 'sickest ever' Covid patient who spent nearly a year in hospital only just able to walk again

A man described as ‘London sickest ever’ Covid patient has only just stopped using oxygen support and learnt to walk again after falling ill on Christmas Day 2020. Andrew Watts, ... Read more »

German Green party leaders face probe over bonus payments

BERLIN — Berlin prosecutors have opened an investigation into the leadership of Germany’s Green party, including the new vice chancellor and foreign minister, over pandemic bonus payments last winter. Prosecutors ... Read more »

Florida man gets 5 years for COVID-19 relief, tax fraud

On Location: January 19, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.ABCNews.com ORLANDO, Fla. — A Florida man convicted of fraudulently collecting more than $1.3 million in COVID-19 relief ... Read more »

Unilever won't top $68B bid for GSK consumer healthcare unit

The Associated PressFILE – The offices of pharmaceutical firm GlaxoSmithKline, in London, April 20, 2009. The pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline said Saturday Jan. 15, 2022, it has rejected an unsolicited 50 ... Read more »

NHS worker given suspended sentence for fatally driving into 'amazing mother, wife and nanny' in South London

An NHS nurse appeared in court after he killed an 85-year-old woman on his driveway after failing to notice she was standing behind him. Asgar Mulla had reversed against oncoming ... Read more »

Boris Johnson determined to fight any no confidence vote and next election

Boris Johnson will fight any no confidence vote launched against him by his own MPs and expects to fight the next general election, No 10 has said, after he was ... Read more »

Cardi B offers to pay funeral costs for Bronx fire victims

© Amy Harris/Invision/AP Cardi B Rapper Cardi B has offered to pay the funeral costs for all 17 people who died from smoke inhalation in a high-rise apartment building fire ... Read more »

Luke Bryan's 150-acre family home in Nashville has an emotional backstory

Luke Bryan has an incredible property portfolio, with his main home located in Music City, aka Nashville, Tennessee. MORE: Luke Bryan’s children star in emotional new video The American Idol ... Read more »

ITV News: Tom Bradby's life off camera from being friends with Prince William and Harry to quiet home life with wife and three children

“They’re laughing at us” were ITV News presenter Tom Bradby’s opening words as the story of a lockdown busting Downing Street Christmas party began to unravel. The Prime Minister’s spokesperson ... Read more »

Tory MP says sorry a second time after 'undermining' apology for bullying staff

A Tory MP has issued a second apology for “undermining” the first apology he gave for bullying Commons staff. Daniel Kawczynski faces being suspended for a day over remarks he ... Read more »

NYPD officer, 47, dies of COVID complications in Staten Island: police

It’s with great sadness we announce the passing of Police Officer Daniel Sanchez. Daniel was a 15-year veteran most recently assigned to @NYPDHighway. We pray that memories of Daniel bring ... Read more »

Stacey Abrams: Voting rights legislation can be passed

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – Then-Georgia gubernatorial Democratic candidate Stacey Abrams speaks during an interview with The Associated Press on Dec. 16, 2021, in Decatur, Ga. Stacey Abrams ... Read more »

9-1-1's Oliver Stark shares behind-the-scenes picture as Jennifer Love Hewittt confirms return

Oliver Stark has confirmed the joyous news that Jennifer Love Hewitt has returned to 9-1-1, sharing a picture of their on-set director’s chairs next to each other. “Siblings reunited,” he ... Read more »

Japan's prime minister laid out an ambitious economic plan that could usher in 'a new form of capitalism' and boost a 'shrinking middle class'

© Provided by Business Insider Japan’s Prime Minister Fumio Kishida at 2021 press conference Getty Images Japanese Prime Minister Kishida Fumio called for a new form of liberal democratic capitalism. ... Read more »

WH Smith hit by shareholder rebellion over bonus

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: May James/Reuters WH Smith has been hit by a massive shareholder rebellion, with more than half its investors failing to back payment of a ... Read more »

Sotomayor, Gorsuch deny report they were at odds over masks

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, left, and Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch, gather with other justices of the U.S. Supreme Court for an official group ... Read more »

Around 30% of the bitcoin in circulation is worth less than what holders paid for it, Glassnode has found

© Yuichiro Chino Blue bitcoin Yuichiro Chino About 5.7 million bitcoins in circulation, or 30%, are underwater, Glassnode said this week. Twice when the demand for bitcoin was this low ... Read more »

How to Find the Cheapest Gas Station Near You

Fuel prices are on the rise across Canada, and unfortunately, there’s no sign of a slowdown ahead. In fact, the price of gas is projected to hit $2 per litre ... Read more »

Center for COVID Control and its lab 'fraudulently reported negative test results,' Minnesota lawsuit says

CHICAGO — The Minnesota Attorney General’s Office filed a consumer-protection lawsuit Wednesday against a nationwide chain of coronavirus testing sites for “deceptive practices.” The suit alleges the Center for COVID ... Read more »

Bank of America profits rise 28% as labor costs surge

Bank of America saw most of its businesses grow profits in the fourth quarter. Getty Images Bank of America said its profits rose 28% last quarter from a year earlier, ... Read more »

Bobby Flay sells delicious Chelsea Mercantile spread for $5.6M

Home cookin’: Chef Bobby Flay just offloaded his Chelsea home. Gabe Ginsberg/Getty Images; Douglas Elliman Bobby Flay has finally sold his Chelsea spread for $5.6 million, according to city property ... Read more »

Hana Horka: Czech singer dies aged 57 after deliberately contracting Covid

Czech folk singer Hana Horka has died after intentionally catching Covid. Horka, 57, had not been vaccinated, and her son, Jan Rek, said she got infected deliberately when he and ... Read more »

Portsmouth plotting transfer swoop for Sunderland player

© Provided by Football League World Denver Hume Portsmouth are interested in signing Denver Hume from Sunderland before the transfer deadline shuts. The future of the left-back was uncertain over ... Read more »

U.K. shares higher at close of trade; Investing.com United Kingdom 100 up 2.75%

© Reuters U.K. shares higher at close of trade; Investing.com United Kingdom 100 up 2.75% Investing.com – U.K. equities were higher at the close on Wednesday, as gains in the ... Read more »

I'm disabled & stuck living on my mum's sofa… but the council say it could be SEVEN YEARS until I get my own place

A DISABLED woman has told how she is stuck living on her mum’s sofa after the council told her it could be SEVEN YEARS before she gets her own place. ... Read more »

Rapper Cardi B to pay funeral expenses for victims of the Bronx fire

Cardi B will pay the funeral expenses for victims of the deadly Bronx fire, the New York City Mayor’s office announced Wednesday. Seventeen people, including eight children, were killed after ... Read more »

Trudeau says Russia looking for ‘excuses' to invade Ukraine

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is accusing Russia of looking for “excuses” to ramp up hostilities against Ukraine as NATO allies make another diplomatic push to avoid armed conflict. Speaking to ... Read more »

Love Island's Jake Cornish now gives aerobics classes in Somerset after swapping fame for dance workouts

LOVE Island star Jake Cornish is giving high-energy dance exercise classes in Somerset, he revealed today. The 24-year-old star was on track to win the series last year but split ... Read more »

Teen killer to be sentenced in stabbing death of Barnard student Tessa Majors

Tessa Majors was murdered on Dec. 11, 2019. The teen who murdered Barnard College student Tessa Majors will be sentenced Wednesday — bringing to a close a case that rattled ... Read more »

'Really unfortunate', 'Two to four weeks' - Expert reacts after Celtic hit with injury woes

Injury expert Ben Dinnery believes Celtic forward Kyogo Furuhashi could be out for four weeks with his current muscle problem, Football Insider report. © Provided by Transfer Tavern 2021-12-19T165247Z_48364283_UP1EHCJ1AVYKT_RTRMADP_3_SOCCER-SCOTLAND-HIB-CEL-REPORT The ... Read more »

First contacts made: 'Special' £50m-rated forward now a 'priority' signing for Newcastle

Darwin Nunez is reportedly now the ‘priority’ signing for Newcastle United in the January transfer window. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Primeira Liga – Belenenses v Benfica The Lowdown: Another ... Read more »

I was fined £400 for leaving my rubbish in a box as the council didn't give me a bin – now a stranger has paid the fine

A SINGLE mum fined for leaving her rubbish in a box after the council didn't give her a bin – now a stranger has paid the fine. Chloe Rhodes, 23, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic