Western Sydney disproportionately fined for Covid lockdown breaches

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photograph: Joel Carrett/EPA

Police disproportionately fined residents of western Sydney for Covid-19 breaches during the most recent outbreak, new data shows, despite surveys suggesting its residents were among the most compliant in the state.

The state’s premier crime statistics agency has warned the high volume of fines issued to residents in Sydney’s areas of concern will pose a “significant burden for some sections of the community who are already vulnerable” and urged the government to monitor the longer-term impact of the police response.

In a report released on Wednesday, the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Bocsar) examined the enforcement of Covid-19 restrictions in July and August, as Sydney battled a worsening outbreak.

Related: ‘Extraordinary’: Police fine dozens after church service in western Sydney Covid hotspot

It found that while the vast majority of Sydney residents “strictly complied” with public health orders, police acted on 36,597 breaches of public health orders in the two-month period.

Bocsar described the figure as “extraordinary”. It accounts for 90% of all police activity for the duration of the pandemic.

Most of the breaches were dealt with by a fine, typically of $1,000, and usually involved unnecessary movement outside of a local government area (LGA) and visits to other households.

People in LGAs of concern, younger men, and those with recent involvement with police were most likely to be targeted. Roughly half the breaches – about 18,200 – involved a person who police had charged with another offence in the preceding five years.

About 13,292, or more than one-third of all breaches, occurred in the LGAs of concern.

Despite this, a Bocsar survey showed lower rates of non-compliance among people residing in LGAs of concern compared with the rest of the city.

Related: ‘Ridiculous’: NSW police accused of handing out unfair Covid fines and targeting young people

“There is no evidence that people in areas of concern or young people are engaging in more non-compliant activities,” the report said. “Overall, our results suggest that breaches are largely enforcement-driven rather than reflecting underlying patterns of non-compliance.”

Bocsar said its evidence suggested “increased enforcement activity at certain times and locations” was the major factor behind the higher number of breaches for young men with a recent criminal history in the LGAs of concern.

A high proportion of the breaches occurred because police were searching people for other reasons, including suspected drug offences.

    “Close to half of all individuals proceeded against by police for a breach of the Covid-19 public health orders had previously been proceeded against by police for other offences and breaches most often occurred in outdoor public places or at public transport hubs,” the report said.

    “Qualitative data from the narratives analysis also suggests that a high proportion of detected breaches involved police searches, occurring through road patrols and suspected drug activity.”

    The report relied on crime data, Covid case data, a survey of self-reported compliance, and a collection of “police narratives” concerning a random sample of 570 breaches.

    “It is possible that self-reported rates of compliance were greater in LGAs of concern because of the increased enforcement activity prior to the surveying period, but it is also possible that residents were motivated to adhere to the restrictions because the risk of infection was substantially higher in these localities,” the report said.

    Email: sign up for our daily morning briefing newsletter

    App: download the free app and never miss the biggest stories, or get our weekend edition for a curated selection of the week's best stories

    Social: follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter or TikTok

    Podcast: listen to our daily episodes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or search “Full Story” in your favourite app

    “Regardless, the high volume of breaches and the heavy penalties that these offences attract will present a significant burden for some sections of the community who are already vulnerable.

    “The longer-term impact of this enforcement activity should therefore be the subject of continued monitoring and public scrutiny.”

    NSW police said in a statement that the rapid spread of the virus had caused health orders to “continually evolve, resulting in LGAs of concern nominated by NSW Health”.

    “The NSW Government and NSW Health both sought an urgent police response to ensure the highest level of compliance with the health orders in those areas,” a spokesperson said.

    “The public health orders have been in place for a reason, to ensure as many people as possible are protected from serious illness or even death.”

    Internet Explorer Channel Network
    Asia's Tech News Daily
    News Related

    OTHER NEWS

    Patients with Omicron variant have 'very mild' symptoms, says South African doctor

    Patients with Omicron variant have ‘very mild’ symptoms, says South African doctor A South African doctor who was one of the first to suspect a different coronavirus strain among patients ... Read more »

    Paytm Q2: What Macquarie said post maiden quarterly results

    NEW DELHI: Foreign brokerage Macquarie has maintained its underperform rating on newly-listed Paytm , keeping its price target constant at Rs 1,200, following the company’s maiden quarterly results. The brokerage ... Read more »

    Watch: Lamar Jackson and Mark Andrews connect for incredible touchdown

    The Baltimore Ravens are facing off against the Cleveland Browns in a heated AFC North divisional matchup. The first half of the contest was extremely sloppy on both sides, with ... Read more »

    Davante Adams throws shade at Odell Beckham Jr. for choosing Rams over Packers

    Green Bay Packers wide receiver Davante Adams threw some friendly shade towards Odell Beckham Jr. for signing with the Los Angeles Rams. © Provided by Fansided Odell Beckham Jr. played ... Read more »

    NFL Twitter can't believe how sloppy, bad Browns-Ravens is on SNF

    NFL Twitter users tried to process the first half of Sunday’s sloppy Baltimore Ravens-Cleveland Browns game. © Provided by Fansided The Week 12 slate of NFL games on Sunday concluded ... Read more »

    DE Jonathan Greenard says Texans weren't consistent enough to stop the Jets' run game

    Normally when a team is leading 14-3 in the second quarter, the run game starts to shut downs. Instead, the New York Jets remained undeterred and kept feeding their stable ... Read more »

    College Football World Reacts To Kirk Herbstreit's Big Question

    ESPN college football analyst Kirk Herbstreit has a big question for the college football world regarding the playoff situation. © Provided by The Spun Kirk Herbstreit walks on the field ... Read more »

    Kirk Cousins Explains What Happened With Embarrassing Play

    Minnesota Vikings starting quarterback Kirk Cousins made a pretty embarrassing mistake against the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday. © Provided by The Spun Minnesota Vikings QB Kirk Cousins throwing a ... Read more »

    Vikings RB Dalvin Cook to have MRI tomorrow

    Vikings RB Dalvin Cook was carted off the field on Sunday. Cook suffered a shoulder dislocation during the game, according to Ian Rapoport of NFL Network. © Provided by Vikings Wire ... Read more »

    Abbie Chatfield goes braless in a low-cut top as she cuddles up to boyfriend Konrad Bien-Stephens... after Brooke Blurton said their romance 'spoiled' her season of The Bachelorette

    Abbie Chatfield and Konrad Bien-Stephens are clearly still in the honeymoon phase. The reality TV lovebirds couldn’t keep their hands off each other while strolling around Sydney’s Bondi Beach on ... Read more »

    Going back on promises has risks: Annastacia Palaszczuk should think twice about closing the borders and ruining Christmas for millions, writes MICHAEL PICKERING

    Queensland has not ruled out changing re-opening plan over new variant fears Annastacia Palaszczuk was re-elected last year on Fortress Qld approach Re-opening the state on Dec 17 was sold as 'reuniting families' for ChristmasQueenslanders frequently warned that 'Delta is coming' after border rules easedBased on what we know so far, Omicron is no reason to ditch the plan now  Read more »

    49ers awaiting MRIs for Deebo Samuel, Fred Warner

    The 49ers beat the Vikings on Sunday, but saw two key players leave the game because of injury. Wide receiver Deebo Samuel and linebacker Fred Warner both exited Sunday’s game ... Read more »

    Everyone's Saying The Same Thing About Baker Mayfield Tonight

    The 2021 NFL regular season was seen by many as a make-or-break year for Cleveland Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield. © Provided by The Spun Cleveland Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield on ... Read more »

    Myles Garrett shook hands with Lamar Jackson after the Ravens' QB made an impossible TD throw

    When you’re playing against Lamar Jackson, there’s always a possibility he’ll make you look like a fool on defense. © Provided by For The Win Myles Garrett found this out ... Read more »

    Springboks – Tests highlight challenges for defending world champs in 2023

    © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved The Springboks finished the 2021 season as the top-ranked team in the world. Since then, fans and pundits based outside South ... Read more »

    Lincoln Riley will find immediate success with USC football

    USC football has struggled in recent years, but make no mistake, new head coach Lincoln Riley can turn things around immediately for the Trojans. © Provided by Fansided All new ... Read more »

    Kaizer Chiefs' increased squad depth gives Stuart Baxter 'a good problem'

    © Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Durban — Kaizer Chiefs coach Stuart Baxter was delighted after his side followed up their frustrating 1-1 draw with AmaZulu by recording a hard-fought ... Read more »

    Lyon 0-3 Rangers hailed as club's 'greatest ever result' - but do you agree?

    Lyon 0 Rangers 3, October 2, 2007 It all seemed a bit surreal. Nobody went to Lyon and won 0-3. Not least a team from Scotland. But on Tuesday 2 ... Read more »

    Ballon d'Or 2021 favourite Robert Lewandowski faces stiff competition

    © Provided by Daily Maverick Overall individual awards in sports have always been a sticking point. Just recently, there was a furore as no Springbok or New Zealand players were ... Read more »

    On-form English teams fire warning shots in Uefa Champions League

    © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved Two of the last three Uefa Champions League finals have been all-English affairs. Based on current form it looks likely that ... Read more »

    Sweden gets second chance to appoint Andersson as PM

    © Pontus LUNDAHL Last Wednesday, lawmakers elected Andersson as prime minister but she resigned just hours later Swedish Social Democratic Party leader Magdalena Andersson gets a second chance at becoming ... Read more »

    Is Kamo Mphela Still Jealous Of Uncle Waffles?

    Our celebrities find great delight in doing what they love, and with the help of the internet, they may earn fame, popularity, and build a fan base. Kamo Mphela is ... Read more »

    It's very difficult to ‘be different' when you play the gentlemen's game

    The recent exposure of systemic racism in Yorkshire cricket, as well as harrowing stories of discrimination during South Africa’s own inquest into racism in cricket, underlines the sport’s problem with ... Read more »

    MacBook Pro Cyber Monday Deals (2021): Best 14 & 16 Inch M1 Chip MacBook Pro & More Savings Summarized by Spending Lab

    Black Friday & Cyber Monday MacBook Pro deals are live, check out all the latest Black Friday & Cyber Monday 2021 MacBook Pro discounts listed below BOSTON, November 29, 2021–(BUSINESS ... Read more »

    Doctor pushes for quarantine for Hong Kong travelers even after negative RT-PCR

    © REUTERS/Eloisa Lopez A health worker conducts coronavirus disease (COVID-19) swab testing at a gymnasium in Navotas City in Metro Manila on Friday, August 7, 2020. The country’s COVID-19 cases ... Read more »

    Opposition leads after ‘massive' turnout in Honduras election

    © Provided by Al Jazeera Both sides are claiming victory in the Honduras election [Luis Acosta/AFP] Initial results from the presidential election in Honduras showed opposition candidate Xiomara Castro with ... Read more »

    Shanghai canceled over 500 flights, closed schools, and suspended hospital services because of 3 COVID-19 infections

    © Yin Liqin/China News Service via Getty Images Volunteers wearing personal protective equipment (PPE) arrange food supplies at the entrance of a residential block where is under restrictions to halt ... Read more »

    Should defendants be paying for court costs?

    Whether or not defendants should be ordered to pay court costs is coming before the Michigan Supreme Court, however local officials argue it doesn't affect judges' impartiality. A state law ... Read more »

    Covid news live: WHO racing to understand whether Omicron variant causes more severe disease

    LIVE – Updated at 04:17 © Getty Face masks in schools.jpg The WHO says it is not yet clear whether Omicron is more transmissible than other Covid variants, including Delta, ... Read more »

    New Zealand permanently legalises PILL TESTING at events such as concerts - becoming the first country in the world to do so

    Bill passes parliament by 87 votes to 33, after being used on trial basis for a yearOpposition National party says only message that stops fatalities is no pill is safeDrug Foundation hails law as most significant advance since needle exchangesPill testing has been trialled twice in Australia - in the ACT in 2018 and 2019  Read more »

    5P yang diperlukan bagi mendidik kanak-kanak pendidikan khas

    Tugas mendidik kanak-kanak bukan perkara yang mudah lebih-lebih lagi apabila ia melibatkan pendidikan khas. Cikgu Nur Azura Bt Mohamad Yusop dari Sekolah Kebangsaan Lepar, Pekan Pahang merupakan salah seorang tenaga ... Read more »

    Peru shook with a 7.5-magnitude earthquake

    © Provided by The South African A 7.5-magnitude earthquake struck northern Peru on Sunday, destroying buildings including a church tower, injuring at least 10 people and sending shock waves across ... Read more »

    Omicron variant: Here are the ‘early symptoms' to look out for

    © Provided by The South African With COVID-19 cases on the march in South Africa, those who get infected in the next few weeks will be wondering if they’ve been ... Read more »

    Venezuela: Maduro says EU observers of elections are 'enemies' and 'spies'

    © Provided by dw.com Maduro said the EU mission tried to stain the electoral process Venezuelan strongman Nicolas Maduro said on Sunday that European Union observers of his country’s elections ... Read more »

    Sanef criticises Mbalula for blaming SABC for ANC's poor elections

    © @MbalulaFikile/Twitter FILE: African National Congress (ANC) head of elections, Fikile Mbalula, briefs the media on 16 September 2021 on the party’s plans for 2021 local government elections. JOHANNESBURG – ... Read more »

    SA Lockdown: South Africa remains on Alert Level 1

    © Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – South Africa remains on lockdown Alert Level 1. President Cyril Ramaphosa made the announcement on Sunday evening. The president assured South Africans, “we will ... Read more »

    Fresh prince of oversharing? More ‘intimate' details from Will & Jada

    © Provided by The South African American actor Will Smith and his wife Jada Pinkett Smith have been making shocking revelations about their marriage since she had an “entanglement” with ... Read more »

    Spread of Omicron variant forces nations to rethink plans for global travel

    © Reuters/EVA PLEVIER Dutch health authorities find 61 passengers who arrived from South Africa as COVID-19 positive, in Amsterdam SYDNEY (Reuters) – The global spread of the Omicron variant of ... Read more »

    Baltic lawmakers meet Taiwan's Tsai, stepping up cooperation

    TAIPEI, Taiwan — Lawmakers from all three Baltic states met with Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen on Monday in a sign of further cooperation between European Union nations and Taiwan. It ... Read more »

    Japan says it is suspending entry of foreign visitors from around the world as new coronavirus variant spreads

    TOKYO — Japan says it is suspending entry of foreign visitors from around the world as new coronavirus variant spreads. Read more »
    On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic