Weinstein's appeal: a blow to #MeToo

weinstein's appeal: a blow to #metoo

Weinstein’s appeal: a blow to #MeToo

It was a “brutal” defeat for the cause of women’s rights, and for the #MeToo movement, said Moira Donegan in The Guardian. Last Thursday, the 2020 conviction of Harvey Weinstein for rape and sexual assault was overturned by the New York Court of Appeals.

The Hollywood producer’s trial had been a “symbolic milestone”: after accusations were made against him in 2017, more than 100 women came forward to accuse Weinstein of sexual harassment, assault and rape. Their stories sparked the global #MeToo reckoning and led, eventually, to his conviction.

The new ruling doesn’t mean that Weinstein will walk free; he was also convicted of rape in California in 2022 and was sentenced to 16 years in jail. But it does seem like a shocking reversal, an indication that the gains of #MeToo are being lost.

Weinstein ‘entitled to due process’

The truth is that the criminal case against him “has been fragile since the day it was filed”, said Jodi Kantor in The New York Times. New York prosecutors made “a series of gambles”, and ultimately they did not pay off.

While Weinstein’s alleged victims “could fill an entire courtroom”, only two of them could support a New York criminal trial. (Many of the accusations were of sexual harassment, which is a civil violation, not a criminal one; most did not take place in New York; others fell beyond the statute of limitations.) So prosecutors put a number of women on the stand as so-called “prior bad act” witnesses, to “establish a pattern of predation”.

But New York law in this area is complex, and the move risked violating a cardinal rule of criminal trials: “defendants must be judged on the acts they are being charged with”.

The appeal court made the right decision, said Melanie McDonagh in the Evening Standard. Weinstein’s lawyers argued successfully that the trial was flooded with “irrelevant” evidence. People are “entitled to due process”. Even “creeps like Weinstein” are “innocent until proved guilty”.

The ‘he said, she said’ problem

Yet the ruling “highlighted the striking gap between how we’ve come to believe women inside the courtroom and outside it”, said Jessica Bennett in The New York Times.

The difficulty with prosecuting sex crimes is that they generally have few witnesses, and come down to “he said, she said”. #MeToo seemed to offer a way round that: an “army of voices” could be assembled to show a pattern of offending, to support individual women’s testimony. In other states, prosecutors are given more latitude.

The case will “revive debate about whether the rules for such convictions need to be updated”.

OTHER NEWS

14 minutes ago

John Stamos shares rare picture with Olsen twins and ‘Full House' cast for Bob Saget's birthday tribute

14 minutes ago

Death of off-duty CPD officer in West Loop home ruled a suicide

14 minutes ago

USA Hockey names HC for 2025 4 Nations Face-Off and 2026 Olympics

14 minutes ago

‘Dhoni should go to school on RCB bowlers’: Matthew Hayden on what he wants to see in RCB vs CSK

20 minutes ago

Brighton boss Roberto De Zerbi to leave after last game of season

20 minutes ago

62-year-old man buried alive saved after four days as police hear his muffled cries

20 minutes ago

NYC’s last superhero: On patrol with real-life crimefighter — the Brooklyn Devil

22 minutes ago

2024 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix – Qualifying results (Imola)

22 minutes ago

Met Office weather: Yellow warning issued for thunderstorms in England and Wales

22 minutes ago

£115 for parasite crisis water firm’s sick customers – as shareholders get £112m

22 minutes ago

Sweden beats Latvia 7-2, Switzerland routs Denmark 8-0 at men's hockey world championship

22 minutes ago

South Africa signs universal health law

23 minutes ago

Jon Rahm ‘surprised’ to miss cut at US PGA Championship

25 minutes ago

Xavi responds to rumours of Barcelona exit & Joan Laporta rift

25 minutes ago

Putin forces advance as Russia takes control of village in Ukraine's Kharkiv region

25 minutes ago

PM Modi's 'Bheekh ka Katora' Jibe At Pakistan, Reiterates Need For A 'Dhakad' Govt In Haryana Rally

25 minutes ago

High School Senior Accepted into 231 Schools and Awarded More Than $14 Million in Scholarships: It's 'Heartwarming'

25 minutes ago

Thousands arrive from KZN for MK Party’s election manifesto in Soweto

25 minutes ago

Between lacrosse and football, Jordan Faison does it all for Notre Dame

25 minutes ago

Action man Grylls shares sweet moment with his son as they step out for sunrise walk in Costa Rica where he is filming Netflix show Bear Hunt

27 minutes ago

Ground beef cooked medium to well done poses no H5N1 bird flu risk, says US study

27 minutes ago

Leverkusen become first Bundesliga team to go all season without defeat

27 minutes ago

Red Bull’s Max Verstappen beats McLaren duo to pole at Emilia-Romagna Grand Prix

28 minutes ago

Aid from new pier off Gaza should be distributed this weekend, while pressure grows on Netanyahu

30 minutes ago

Kyle Sandilands issues a brutal response when asked if he feels bad about his radio competitors Jason 'Jase' Hawkins and Lauren Phillips getting axed

30 minutes ago

Nahyan bin Zayed inaugurates Burjeel Day Surgery Centre in Al Ain

30 minutes ago

The Traitors’ Mollie Pearce: ‘I was told my colon could erupt at any moment’

30 minutes ago

PGA Championships 2024 tee times: Round 3 pairings at Valhalla

30 minutes ago

North Carolina mom joins daughter to work at notorious Chicken Ranch brothel near Las Vegas

30 minutes ago

NYC shoplifting soars with over 21K complaints lodged so far this year — causing CVS, Walgreens to close up shops

30 minutes ago

Huge fire destroys London bus

32 minutes ago

BBC viewers blast Motherland spin-off announcement: ‘Bring it back!’

37 minutes ago

Brits face summer holiday chaos as Majorcans crank up their anti-tourism campaign by threatening to block the island's airport and protest outside hotels

37 minutes ago

Marks & Spencer website and app go down as retailer apologises to customers saying they 'are working on it'

38 minutes ago

Late ConCourt judge Justice Yvonne Mokgoro hailed for her role in promoting social justice

38 minutes ago

Chelsea close to securing €60m transfer for Palmeiras youngster Estêvão Willian

38 minutes ago

Dublin see off Wexford to move into Leinster MHC final

38 minutes ago

IDF destroys terror infrastructures, kills 50 Hamas terrorists in Rafah

38 minutes ago

The all-time Challenge Cup semi-final record of all this year’s final four

38 minutes ago

John Stamos calls late Bob Saget ‘heart of Full House family’ on star’s birthday

Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch