We must keep the scourge of obstetric violence in the spotlight – but it's the state's duty to tackle it

As we reach the end of this year’s 16 Days of Activism for No Violence against Women and Children Campaign, it is notable that for the first time in our country’s history the spotlight has fallen on obstetric violence.

We must keep the scourge of obstetric violence in the spotlight – but it’s the state’s duty to tackle it
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

Obstetric violence is one of the most hidden forms of gender violence and includes physical abuse (including the deliberate withholding of pain relief), verbal abuse, neglect, lack of consent, and coercive use (or withholding) of interventions during labour and/or birth. Thanks to the efforts of organisations such as Embrace (the movement for mothers), the Centre for Applied Legal Studies and dedicated reproductive justice activists, the widespread mistreatment of pregnant and birthing persons in South African healthcare institutions has been foregrounded as unacceptable gender violence that requires urgent intervention and a government response. 

A call for action and accountability in respect of the “war on women’s bodies” alluded to by the President at the launch of this year’s campaign against gender violence, is not complete without acknowledging the violence that mothers, parents and families are subjected to every day in South African labour wards, delivery rooms, clinics and hospitals. As we come to the end of this year’s campaign, it is imperative that we keep the spotlight on obstetric violence and continue to demand redress and action on the issue. 

As we go forward, it is important to understand that obstetric violence is not a new problem in South Africa. More than two decades of research has shown that abuse, neglect and bullying behaviour is normalised and routinely ignored or excused in maternal healthcare settings in the public sector. The problem is also not confined to South Africa. Obstetric violence has been recognised by international bodies such as the World Health Organization and the United Nations as a global healthcare problem affecting both resource-rich and resource-constrained settings. 

While the term “obstetric violence” is contested, activists in Latin American countries such as Venezuela and Argentina have led the way in demanding that the abuse of pregnant and birthing persons be legally recognised as gender-based violence that violates human rights, bodily dignity and reproductive autonomy. 

We must keep the scourge of obstetric violence in the spotlight – but it’s the state’s duty to tackle it
© Provided by Daily Maverick In research conducted with mothers in the Western Cape, some women reported that they avoided public healthcare institutions because they feared being abused and mistreated. (Photo: huffpost.com/Wikipedia)

Researchers have shown that traumatic birth experiences have long-lasting affects on psychological health and can negatively affect parent-infant bonding. In South Africa, we know that impoverished, young, disabled, HIV-positive, migrant, black and gender non-conforming birthers are especially vulnerable to abuse and obstetric violence

Mistreatment in public sector healthcare facilities has been shown to be widespread, with more than 50% of participants reporting abuse in a 2011 study by Human Rights Watch. In research that I conducted with mothers in the Western Cape, some women reported that they avoided public healthcare institutions because they feared being abused and mistreated. As a result, some gave birth at home (with no skilled attendant) or delayed seeking healthcare services. 

The expectation of being subjected to obstetric violence shapes healthcare-seeking behaviours and has life-and-death consequences for mothers and infants. There is less evidence available for obstetric violence in the private sector, but high rates of Caesarean section indicate that all is not well in this sphere either. 

Who must be held accountable for this abuse and mistreatment? 

We know workplace conditions are difficult for healthcare workers in the public sector, with burnout, lack of staff, low remuneration, lack of basic equipment and bullying. Obstetric violence flourishes in such conditions. While individual perpetrators of violence need to be held to account, it must be emphasised that a culture of violence around birth is not the result of individual “bad apples” in the system. It is the system more broadly that is toxic. As a result, addressing obstetric violence requires a multidimensional approach, including targeted reform to medical and midwifery training (towards curriculums that emphasise more humane and respectful maternity care), legal interventions (such as recognising obstetric violence as a legal concept), robust and accountable complaint mechanisms, social campaigns to raise public awareness of birthing and reproductive rights, and the eradication of the patriarchal, racist and discriminatory attitudes that are often embedded in obstetric medicine more broadly. 

Multipronged and imaginative efforts are needed to transform cultures of obstetric and maternal healthcare away from violence, hierarchies, punishment, coercion and discrimination and towards establishing relations of care characterised by respect, dignity, inclusivity and autonomy. 

We must keep the scourge of obstetric violence in the spotlight – but it’s the state’s duty to tackle it
© Provided by Daily Maverick We have known about the widespread mistreatment of birthing persons in South African healthcare facilities since the late 1990s but very little has been done about it. (Photo: humanrightsincontext.be/Wikipedia)

Ultimately, it is the state’s responsibility to ensure that the scourge of obstetric violence is recognised, addressed and eradicated. We have known about the widespread mistreatment of birthing persons in South African healthcare facilities since the late 1990s but very little has been done about it. This lack of action and silence on the issue denotes a wider social disrespect for women and reproductive matters. 

According to the 2019 report on obstetric violence by the UN Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women, states are obliged to ensure that women and birthing people’s rights to humane and respectful obstetric care free of abuse, violence, coercion or intimidation, are protected and enforced. Birthing persons are exceptionally vulnerable during labour/birth and deserve respect, affirming care and dignity. The way we treat women and birthers during pregnancy and birth tells us a great deal about how our society views and values (or devalues) women and reproductive labour. There can be no more excuses and no more tolerance for looking away or pretending not to know. 

Obstetric violence is a serious infringement of human rights. We must commit to keeping the spotlight on this issue and refuse to accept inhumane and violent care. If we are serious as a society about working towards the eradication of violence and gender injustice more broadly, we have to acknowledge and address the violence that often permeates the beginning of life – birth. DM/MC

Rachelle Chadwick is a Senior Lecturer in Sociology at the University of Pretoria and has published extensively in academic articles on obstetric violence.

News Related


Biden approval rating: 8 terrible numbers from the new Pew poll

There’s a tendency when a new poll comes out to look at the so-called “topline” numbers — presidential approval being the main one — and then move on. © Saul ... Read more »

DDMA meet: Delhi govt to suggest reopening of schools as Covid crisis eases

© Provided by Hindustan Times According to a PTI report, Sisodia also spoke about how online education can never replace offline education and that excessive caution is now harming students. ... Read more »

US, allies discussing sending more forces to eastern Europe amid Ukraine tension: Reports

© Provided by WION Following tensions between Russia and the West over Ukraine, the US and many allies are contemplating the idea of sending thousands more troops to NATO’s eastern ... Read more »

Jayant Chaudhary chose 'wrong home', says Amit Shah on joining hands with Akhilesh Yadav's Samajwadi Party

© Provided by Zee News NEW DELHI: Rashtriya Lok Dal chief Jayant Chaudhary has chosen the “wrong home”, Union Minister Amit Shah said on Wednesday as he reached out to ... Read more »

RLD Chief Jayant Choudhary Snubs BJP Offer, Says ‘Send Invitation to 700 Farmer Families'

© Provided by News18 RLD Chief Jayant Choudhary Snubs BJP Offer, Says ‘Send Invitation to 700 Farmer Families’ Rashtriya Lok Dal (RLD) chief Jayant Choudhary on Wednesday rebuffed the BJP’s ... Read more »

US rushes Stingers, Javelin missiles to Ukraine amid threat to sanction Putin's family and girlfriend

© Provided by The Times of India WASHINGTON: In pictures evocative of the American intervention in Afghanistan more than 40 years ago, the United States has rushed to Stinger missiles ... Read more »

Snippets from UK: Positive Signs for India as Omicron-led Covid Wave in Britain Ebbs

© Provided by News18 Snippets from UK: Positive Signs for India as Omicron-led Covid Wave in Britain Ebbs Cases dip: As India looks to the UK for its pattern of ... Read more »

Republic Day: Indian Army unfurls 150 feet high tricolour in J&K

© Provided by Zee News Kashmir: On 73rd Republic Day, the Chinar Corps in collaboration with Punit Balan Group installed a National Flag in the historic town of Shopian. The ... Read more »

Iran foreign minister Abdollahian to visit India next week

© Provided by Hindustan Times Iranian foreign minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian is expected to hold talks with external affairs minister S Jaishankar on January 31. (File/AFP) NEW DELHI: Iranian foreign ... Read more »

Padma Bhushan to Ghulam Nabi Azad: Gandhis mum; colleagues and Change-seekers congratulate senior Congress leader

Even as the All India Congress Committee and Gandhis maintained silence on senior Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad being honoured with a Padma Bhushan by the Narendra Modi regime, many ... Read more »

New Brunswick woman charged with abduction following Amber Alert for missing boy

MIRAMICHI, N.B. — A 33-year-old woman is being charged with abduction following an Amber Alert in New Brunswick on Tuesday in connection with a missing six-year-old boy. © Provided by ... Read more »

Missing youth from Arunachal to be repatriated to India by Chinese army: Kiren Rijiju

Law and justice minister Kiren Rijiju on Wednesday said China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA) has indicated that it will hand over the youth from Arunachal Pradesh who had entered China ... Read more »

Ajit Pawar to government: Extend GST compensation to states

States like Maharashtra will find the going tough if the Centre refuses their request to extend the GST compensation being allotted to them, beyond June 30. Maharashtra, along with several ... Read more »

Here's Who Mortal Kombat's Creator Wants Dwayne Johnson To Play In The Next Movie

Kevin Mazur/Getty Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson has starred in multiple films based on video games throughout his career, including “Doom” and “Rampage.” And it doesn’t seem like he intends to ... Read more »

Grace Kelly's granddaughter Charlotte Casiraghi kicks off Chanel's Fashion Week show on horseback

Chanel’s show during Paris Fashion Week got off to a trotting start as model and professional horsewoman Charlotte Casiraghi entered the runway on horseback in front of guests. Attendees were ... Read more »

DA files court bid to scrap rotational learning at schools

© https://www.123rf.com/stock-photo/classroom_desks.html?sti=ockfu2rxd576vnuzq8|&mediapopup=33268326 © teka77/123rf.com CAPE TOWN – The Democratic Alliance (DA) has filed papers in the Preoria High Court in a bid to scrap rotational learning and get all children ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian deletes bikini picture after fans accuse her of Photoshop

© Getty Images for ABA GettyImages-978281516.jpg Kim Kardashian has deleted an Instagram post after fans accused her of Photoshop. On Tuesday, the Keeping Up With The Kardashians star took to ... Read more »

2023 Kia Niro Pre-Production Test Vehicle Spotted In California

The redesigned SUV will go on sale later in 2022. The redesigned Kia Niro isn’t exactly hiding these days. After all, it was officially revealed to the world in November ... Read more »

Researchers Have Identified 4 Health Factors That May Explain Why Some People Get Long COVID

© Provided by People Getty A sick woman Researchers are finally getting a sense of why some people develop long COVID in one of the first studies to investigate the ... Read more »

Lise Ravary: Identity, language and the Montreal Canadiens

Identity, language and the Montreal Canadiens is a thorny issue, and I will tread softly. Unlike what I did on Twitter, hoping to spark a discussion on the importance of ... Read more »

Crafting YouTuber Melanie Ham Dies At 36 After Battling A Rare Type Of Cancer

© melaniekham Instagram YouTube star Melanie Ham died at age 36 after battling epithelioid angiomyolipoma, a rare type of sarcoma cancer. Her husband shared the news on Instagram. YouTuber Melanie ... Read more »

Collision to return to in-person format this year with Toronto conference

TORONTO — International technology conference Collision says it will return to hosting an in-person event this year in Toronto. © Provided by The Canadian Press Organizers sent out emails today ... Read more »

This is How Imposter Syndrome Affects Women of Colour Differently

© Pexels Black woman wearing a white shirt lays on couch with her hands on her head “Do I belong?” These words circle around some people’s heads continuously. Along with ... Read more »

We come to AFC bio bubble and there is an outbreak: Dennerby

Thomas Dennerby’s time in India has involved working on two key tournaments in the national women’s football setup. Both were hit by Covid-19 and how! The 2020 U-17 FIFA World ... Read more »

US sends 300 Javelin missiles to Ukraine in latest military aid during Russia standoff

The latest American shipment of military assistance for Ukraine weighed in at nearly 80 tons and included 300 Javelin missiles as Western fears of a Russian incursion grow. Tuesday’s shipment ... Read more »

School district denies litter boxes for students identifying as ‘furries'

It’s a load of kitty litter. A Michigan school district has debunked a wild claim that the school provided litter boxes for students who identified as “furries” — people who ... Read more »

Amazon ends program that paid employees to praise company on social media

Amazon nixed a program that paid its warehouse workers to post positive things about the e-commerce giant. Getty Images Amazon has quietly ended a program that paid employees to post ... Read more »

Johnson accuses EU of ‘insane and pettifogging' approach to NI Protocol

© Aaron Chown Prime Minister Boris Johnson (Aaron Chown/PA) Boris Johnson has risked heightening tensions with the EU after accusing Brussels of implementing the Northern Ireland Protocol in an “insane” ... Read more »

600 candles lit to remember victims of the Holocaust and other genocides

Faith leaders have gathered to light candles and remember all the victims of genocide ahead of Holocaust Memorial Day. Six hundred candles were lit during the event at York Minster’s ... Read more »

Oil hits $90 a barrel adding to cost of living headaches

Oil has hit $90 a barrel for the first time since October 2014 on latest worries about tight supply and tensions in Europe in the Middle East. © Reuters US ... Read more »

Legendary investor Jeremy Grantham ramps up market alarms with long-term gloom; 'Nature is beginning to fail'

© Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images Jeremy Grantham is a famed investor and historian of stock markets. Matthew Lloyd/Getty Images In an interview with Bloomberg, Jeremy Grantham added to his earlier warnings ... Read more »

BBC bosses comment on costly new EastEnders set

BBC bosses defended the new EastEnders set project, which ran over budget by more than £20 million, as the corporation faced scrutiny over the future of the licence fee. BBC ... Read more »

The employee value proposition is fundamental to retaining employees. Here's how to build it into a business strategy for the future.

© Insider Insider Experts found a company’s mission and values are more important to workers than compensation and benefits.  Companies need to connect with their workforce to understand what’s important ... Read more »

Mattel wins back rights for Disney Frozen, princess products

Toy company Mattel has won back the licensing rights for Disney’s princess and “Frozen” franchises. The reunion comes after Hasbro bested the rights for the “Frozen” and princess products away ... Read more »

Saleen regresa con un superdeportivo eléctrico

© Motor1.com Copyright 2018 Saleen S1 La empresa promete un “ciclo de crecimiento explosivo” y varios productos nuevos prometedores. Las noticias sobre el fabricante estadounidense de superdeportivos Saleen aparecen con cuentagotas, ... Read more »

YouTube CEO says removing ‘dislike' button prevents harmful ‘attacks'

Susan Wojcicki defended the decision to remove its “dislike” button in a letter to YouTube‘s online community. Getty Images YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki defended the decision to remove its “dislike” ... Read more »

Worst-ever experience as head coach, team devastated, dreams forever killed: Thomas Dennerby

© Provided by The Times of India PANAJI: Thomas Dennerby has coached teams at three World Cups, two Olympics and two European championships, so he was better equipped to handle ... Read more »

2023 BMW 8-Series and M8 Gain Illuminated Grille and Fresh Colors

BMW has given the 8-series and M8 a refresh for 2023, with an updated grille that now comes illuminated as standard. New colors are available across the lineup, and all ... Read more »

«Ich fragte mich: Was würde Djokovic jetzt tun?»

Der Russe kämpft sich gegen den jungen Kanadier Auger-Aliassime im besten Match des Turniers aus dem Nichts zurück und kann Tennisgeschichte schreiben. © Foto: Aaron Francis (Getty Images) Noch zwei ... Read more »

Runaway SpaceX rocket in orbit for 7 years expected to crash into the moon

A SpaceX rocket that has been hurtling through space for the last seven years is expected to crash into the moon. NASA via Getty Images An errant SpaceX rocket that’s ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic