We have a crisis: South Africa urgently needs leadership to roll out Covid-19 vaccine mandates

Asia's Tech News Daily

South African society is lit up by discussion and debate about the place of vaccine mandates in the fight against Covid-19. Conspicuous by their absence in this crucial issue are those elected and appointed to provide leadership at local, provincial and national level.

We have a crisis: South Africa urgently needs leadership to roll out Covid-19 vaccine mandates
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

About 35% of the nation is vaccinated, woefully short of the desired target of 90% most experts agree we need to avert the disastrous consequences of recurring Covid-19 waves.

While there are aspects of the South African response to Covid-19 to date that are commendable, the deafening silence on vaccine mandates that have proven effective elsewhere around the globe is hard to understand.

In July this year, France introduced a health passport with proof of either vaccination, a negative Covid-19 test or of past infection required to enter public places. This increased vaccine coverage to 75% and reduced hospitalisation and death significantly.

If this pandemic was a war and more than 250,000 South African lives had been lost, one can only begin to imagine the clamour for the state to do whatever was necessary to resist the invasion and end the carnage. And yet, according to the SA Medical Research Council, excess mortality has been a shocking 264,809 over the past 18 months.

Adding insult to this national injury, Stats SA recently reported a drop in life expectancy of 3.8 years in females and 3.1 years in males since 2020. Based on our HIV/AIDS experience, we know that this is likely to take years to regain and will undermine the National Development Plan goal of increasing life expectancy of South Africans to at least 70 by 2030. So, why are our leaders not seizing the opportunity of broad nationwide vaccine mandates for preventing further carnage in the country?

We have a crisis: South Africa urgently needs leadership to roll out Covid-19 vaccine mandates
© Provided by Daily Maverick health passport France introduced a health passport with proof of either vaccination, a negative Covid-19 test or of past infection required to enter public places. This increased vaccine coverage to 75% and reduced hospitalisation and death significantly. South Africa’s Department of Health officially launched a digital vaccine certificate for those who received the Covid-19 jab. (Photo: techcentral.co.za / Wikipedia)

Opponents of vaccine mandates in South Africa include those who understand that vaccines are effective, but are uncomfortable about perceived and/or real infringements of individual liberties, choices and human rights and have a false perception of an absence of a “legal framework” that permits them.

Other commentators, including Professor Pierre de Vos,  a respected constitutional law scholar, have penned very accessible articles explaining the legal framework that allows vaccine mandates for the greater good. History teaches us that, with rare exceptions, when societies are under siege, the key to overcoming adversity is a leadership that makes tough, sometimes unpopular, decisions to benefit society and help stop the suffering — even if they involve measures that restrict rights in the short term.

Is this not what informs the National State of Disaster Act legislation that has allowed the government to deny us the ability to worship, bury our dead and shut down our economy?

Also, among mandate opponents is perhaps a lack of an appreciation of the social solidarity value that requires even “low-risk” individuals to vaccinate so we can achieve community immunity that protects the most vulnerable. Other opponents’ scepticism is borne of the fact that even though vaccines are effective at reducing hospitalisation and death they do not completely stop viral transmissions. Nonetheless, breakthrough infections in those who are vaccinated tend to be mild and people are infectious for much shorter periods, thus reducing the community transmission risk significantly.

Others have said natural immunity after Covid-19 is just as good as a vaccine. The evidence, however, suggests otherwise and shows that those with natural immunity are twice more likely to be infected with Covid-19 than those vaccinated.

Opponents of vaccine mandates contest their overwhelming benefit for the greater good — versus individual and societal risk, for example, potential loss of access to social services, education and employment — especially if vaccine mandates are not implemented responsibly. In fact, the Government Gazette of June 2021 provides a framework for mandatory vaccination policy in the workplace that recognises and upholds constitutional rights. Unfortunately, few if any of the passionate opponents offer effective evidence-based alternatives to vaccine mandates that would ramp up vaccine coverage to the very high levels that we need at speed to reduce hospitalisations and death.

We do not deny that the most effective way to engage peoples’ concerns authentically is to educate, persuade and ultimately convert those that are vaccine hesitant to become vaccine confident. We are, however, concerned that, while the clarity and direction that trusted elected leaders can provide remains lost in a leadership vacuum, Rome will continue to burn. Public confusion, increased anxiety, vaccine apathy and hesitancy will thrive.

It should not be forgotten that the fourth wave is projected for some time in December. And, as with the first three iterations of the battle in this war, society’s healthcare and other resources will get redirected to the Covid effort with often devastating, but little spoken-about “collateral” damage to the most vulnerable members of society. The care of those with chronic disorders such as HIV, TB and diabetes, as well as those awaiting critical cancer and cardiac surgery, will inevitably be sacrificed as clinics and hospitals are repurposed to look after what will be mostly unvaccinated people.

And what of the short- and long-term physical and mental health toll this pandemic has taken and will continue to take on the much-lauded front line sacrificial lambs and their loved ones? Bear in mind that South Africa’s stretched healthcare workforce was barely coping with the country’s high disease burden in the pre-Covid period.

The ongoing epidemic of burnout, anxiety disorders and depression among healthcare workers is yet another form of Covid collateral damage, the long-term consequences of which few have had time to contemplate. Surveys conducted and presented by the University of KZN psychiatrist Dr Saeena Paruk indicate that mental health disorder rates that were already double rates found in the general public have increased by close to 40% during the pandemic.

We have a crisis: South Africa urgently needs leadership to roll out Covid-19 vaccine mandates
© Provided by Daily Maverick vaccine mandate Some have said natural immunity after Covid-19 is just as good as a vaccine. The evidence, however, suggests otherwise and shows that those with natural immunity are twice more likely to be infected with Covid-19 than those vaccinated. (Photo by Gallo Images / Brenton Geach)

Elsewhere, we only need to look at well-documented rising rates of gender-based violence, child abuse, teenage pregnancy, substance abuse and substance dependency disorders in the country at present to get a glimpse of the magnitude of the problem we are experiencing — and that’s just in the short term.

We ask again, is it worthwhile for us to bury our heads in the sand on state vaccine mandates?

With regular reports in the media about record levels of jobs losses and unemployment, and a significantly depleted fiscus, increased poverty and hunger, what might have been under-emphasised is World Bank analyses suggesting that Covid-19 could have wiped out most of the economic and developmental gains made over the past two decades, further exacerbating poverty and inequality.

What additional hurt and harm to society are our leaders waiting for before they take the bull by the horns and lead from the front on the question of broad vaccine mandates? The single most important ingredient in the management of any crisis is effective leadership.

We welcome the Government Gazette on vaccine mandates in the workplace, but there is good reason to suspect that, without government-led, broad-based national mandates that extend beyond academic institutions and a few private companies, the race to effective community immunity may not be winnable.

We therefore propose that national leadership should seriously consider nationwide vaccine mandates now that we have good vaccine access with lower-than-expected demand. National leadership should call on leaders at all levels and from all sectors to rally society towards a common purpose, allaying anxieties and asking individuals and institutions to sacrifice for the greater good — and call on all of us to give practical meaning to the concept of ubuntu so that “you are more likely to remain alive because we are  all vaccinated.”

Phakamani Maqabane and lead us! DM/MC

Mpiko Ntsekhe and Tracey Naledi write in their personal capacity. Ntsekhe is Professor and Chair of Cardiology at the University of Cape Town. Tracey Naledi is Deputy Dean: Health Services Faculty of Health Sciences at the University of Cape Town and Founding Chairperson of Tekano, Atlantic Fellows for Health Equity in South Africa.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Liam Scales stakes his Celtic claim as debut goal has Irish rising star dreaming of regular place

Liam Scales admitted his phone was red hot after opening his Celtic account – but he’s hoping to get the call from Ange Postecoglou for Thursday. The former Shamrock Rovers ... Read more »

Keir Starmer says anti-vaxxers must 'think again' as NHS resources drained by unjabbed

Keir Starmer has urged anti-vaxxers and jab sceptics to “think again” as he prepares to get his booster vaccine. The Labour leader, who is due to have his third dose ... Read more »

Gambit top EMEA Pro League despite Alliance victory

© Provided by Dot Esports The final day of the first split’s regular season took place with concurrently running lobbies, so no teams would be handed an unfair advantage with ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Arlene Phillips becomes first campmate to be eliminated from ITV's 2021 series

I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! has seen its first contestant, Arlene Phillips, eliminated from Gwrych Castle. The 78 year old, whose daughters recently said they weren’t “embarrassed” ... Read more »

How to unlock the Tropical Soda Islands and what it does in Cookie Run Kingdom

© Provided by GamePur In Cookie Run Kingdom, there’s a very helpful mode called Tropical Soda Islands. This mode can earn you a steady stream of items. However, it isn’t ... Read more »

Patrick Vieira outlines Ralf Rangnick impact during Manchester United victory

Patrick Vieira has revealed that the appointment of Ralf Rangnick had a major impact on how Crystal Palace approached their Premier League game with Manchester United. Having finally been granted ... Read more »

Speaker voices ‘deep concern' at reports of drug-taking in Parliament

Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle is to raise reports of drug misuse in Parliament with the police “as a priority”. © House of Commons Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle has ... Read more »

Overwatch fan creates Workshop mode to visualize the range of every ability

© Provided by Dot Esports Every Overwatch player has uttered the words, “there’s no way I was in range of that.” One fan decided enough was enough, so they went ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta to show no mercy on under-fire Rafa Benitez and former club Everton

Mikel Arteta admits he can show no mercy towards under-fire Rafa Benitez – but insists he has the quality and experience to turn things around. Arteta had six years at ... Read more »

A restaurant dedicated to Brussels sprouts is opening next week in London

© Provided by Metro The controversial vegetable is getting a makeover by tastecard this Christmas. (Photo: tastecard) Christmas is a time of celebration and eating, but sometimes we don’t quite ... Read more »

Quebec introduces $52 million in new funding to tackle gun violence and crime

MONTREAL — Quebec announced $52 million in new funding geared towards the province’s youth on Sunday in a bid to stem a rising tide of gun violence and crime.  © ... Read more »

Victoria's Secret model Kelly Gale shows of phenomenal figure in orange bikini

KELLY Gale goes down a storm in a tropical bikini shoot. The Victoria’s Secret model and actress, 26, also put on a showstopping look for her boyfriend’s birthday last week. ... Read more »

Anne Frank memorial: Vandals defaced tunnels near Idaho site with anti-Semitic graffiti

As millions of Jewish people across the country celebrate Hanukkah, police say vandals painted anti-Semitic messages and symbols in tunnels near Idaho’s Anne Frank Human Rights Memorial on Friday. © ... Read more »

Majority of daters feel burnout from seeing incompatible people

© Provided by Metro 78% of daters feel stressed from constant incompatible dates (Picture: Getty) A seldom acknowledged truth: dating is tiring. Sure, it can be fun – but that ... Read more »

Wolff: Saudi was ‘spectacular, but not a good race'

© PA Images Toto Wolff with microphone in Saudi planetF1 Toto Wolff said the inaugural Saudi Arabian Grand Prix won by Lewis Hamilton was “spectacular, but not a good race”. ... Read more »

Sorting the real from the rubbish and challenging those who stir the Omicron pot of fear

This week we provide tips to help you sort the real from the rubbish when looking for more detailed information online. We also take a look at some of the ... Read more »

Shooting on north side leaves one dead, one injured

One person was killed and another injured after a shooting Sunday afternoon on the city's north side. Indianapolis police located the two victims, both after responding to a report of ... Read more »

Hamilton tops podium for third straight race in chaotic Saudi Arabian GP

Lewis Hamilton passed Max Verstappen with six laps remaining Sunday to win the chaotic inaugural Saudi Arabian Grand Prix and pull even on points with his rival as Formula One’s ... Read more »

Yogi slams Akhilesh: Entire UP is my family, you only care for yours

© Provided by The Indian Express Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on Sunday responded to SP chief Akhilesh Yadav’s jibe that those without family do not care for people, ... Read more »

Dying Columbia student cried for help after being stabbed by reputed gangbanger

Vincent Pinkney, who has a lengthy rap sheet, also threatened a couple walking their dog before police nabbed him. DANIEL WILLIAM MCKNIGHT A Columbia University grad student stabbed to death ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity fans slam ‘ageism' as Arlene Phillips, 78, is first out after public vote

I'M A Celeb said goodbye to its first star tonight – as Arlene Phillips was given the boot from the TV castle. Ant McPartlin and Dec Donnelly revealed the former ... Read more »

Kylian Mbappe says he's "going to play for big club" in latest transfer declaration

Kylian Mbappe had declared that he is “going to play for a big club” in his latest statement surrounding his immediate future. The Frenchman is fast approaching the end of ... Read more »

Brit, 18, savaged by crocodile says she ‘went into overdrive' to escape its jaws in first interview from hospital

A BRIT teen left fighting for life after a monster crocodile attacked her in Zambia has revealed how instinct took over and she went into “overdrive” to fight off the ... Read more »

Starmer calls for ‘national effort' to roll out Covid booster jabs

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has called for a “renewed national effort” to step up delivery of the Covid-19 booster jab. Sir Keir, who gets his third dose of the ... Read more »

Trump official Jeffrey Clark postpones deposition with Capitol riot committee due to ‘medical issue'

© AP Jeffrey Clark speaking at a Justice Department press conference in Washington in October 2020 – AP A Donald Trump official accused of trying to overturn the 2020 presidential ... Read more »

Pope condemns Europe's treatment of migrants during visit to Greek refugee camp

© VATICAN MEDIA/AFP via Getty Imag pope francis greece refugees.jpg Pope Francis condemned Europe’s “indifference” towards migrants and refugees on his first visit to Greece. Visiting the Mavrovouni refugee camp ... Read more »

Tipster who led cops to parents of Michigan school shooter could get $20K reward

Detroit Police Chief James White says he’s “happy” to award the anonymous person who helped tipped off the whereabouts of Jennifer and James Crumbley. REUTERS/Seth Herald The anonymous tipster who ... Read more »

Pourchaire "fine" after Jeddah F2 startline crash

© Sam Bloxham / Motorsport Images Theo Pourchaire, ART Grand Prix The ART Grand Prix driver stalled on the grid in Sunday’s race and was then collected by an unsighted ... Read more »

Kerala HC sends notice to Centre over Renjith Maheshwary's Arjuna Award petition

Olympian Renjith Maheshwary’s petition challenging a press release issued by the secretary of the Department of Sports rescinding the Arjuna award conferred to him in 2013 has been admitted in ... Read more »

Steve Nash thinks Eastern Conference is as deep as ever

The two best records in the NBA belong to Western Conference powers Golden State and Phoenix, but Steve Nash believes the East is as deep as it has been in ... Read more »

Ex-Liverpool ace gets himself 'deliberately booked' to serve suspension whilst injured

Former Liverpool striker Iago Aspas went viral after some quick-thinking ensured the Spaniard will serve a suspension whilst he’s sidelined with an injury. Aspas currently plays in Spain for Celta ... Read more »

Mit Sène im richtigen Fahrwasser

Der 20-jährige Stürmer hat mit drei Toren entscheidenden Anteil am 4:0 der Grasshoppers in St. Gallen – der Gegner schwächt sich früh mit einem Platzverweis gleich selbst. © Bereitgestellt von ... Read more »

Hamilton siegt in Saudi-Arabien und schliesst zu Verstappen auf

© KEYSTONE/AP/Hassan Ammar Lewis Hamilton gewinnt den ersten Grand Prix von Saudi-Arabien. Der Titelverteidiger im Mercedes verweist seinen WM-Rivalen Max Verstappen im Red Bull nach einem verrückten Duell auf Platz ... Read more »

Georgia's Kirby Smart has looming QB decision to make for CFP semifinal

Kirby Smart’s quarterback decision is among the storylines for the CFP semifinals. Brett Davis/USA TODAY Sports; Dale Zanine/USA TODAY Sports; Getty Images All eyes will be on Kirby Smart. His ... Read more »

Kate Garraway fans in tears as her ‘proud' children Darcey, 15, and Billy, 12, pay moving tribute to incredible mum

KATE Garraway fans were left in tears after her proud children Darcey and Billy paid a moving tribute to their incredible mum on Piers Morgan Life Stories tonight. During her ... Read more »

Man stabbed at Kewalo Basin

Dec. 5—Emergency Medical Services responded at 6 p.m. to an apparent stabbing at a park in the Kewalo Basin area. EMS personnel found a man, possibly in his 50s, who ... Read more »

Pregnant Sam Faiers stuns in a glittering dress as she throws jaw-dropping early Christmas party

PREGNANT Sam Faiers dazzled in a glittering dress as she hosted a jaw-dropping Christmas party. The 30-year-old looked glamorous in a black net and sequin embellished dress with frilly detail. ... Read more »

Fresh heartache for The Queen as her close friend and confidante the Duchess of Grafton dies months after Prince Philip

THE Queen is in mourning after one of her closest confidantes and friends died on Friday – mere months following Prince Philip's death. Ann Fortune FitzRoy, the Duchess of Grafton, ... Read more »

Covid: figures reveal extent of vaccine disparity in England

Photograph: Ian Forsyth/Getty Images Children in some parts of England are three times more likely to be vaccinated than others, figures from the House of Commons library show, prompting Bridget ... Read more »

Soccer-Juventus ease past Genoa as Allegri celebrates landmark win

© Reuters/MASSIMO PINCA Serie A – Juventus v Genoa TURIN, Italy (Reuters) – Juan Cuadrado scored directly from a corner as Juventus comfortably beat struggling Genoa 2-0 on Sunday to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic