Waste not, want not Environmental groups are urging the Thai government to stop importing other countries' toxic garbage

Waste not, want not  Environmental groups are urging the Thai government to stop importing other countries' toxic garbage

Thailand has enough of its own e-waste to handle that it doesn’t need to import waste from other countries, environmental groups say. Photo: Ecological Alert and Recovery Thailand

To generate extra income, farmers in Tambon Khok Sa-at in Kalasin have been collecting and separating discarded electronic products, or e-waste, in between harvests since 1996.

The practice has often brought them more income than farming. But along with the extra cash came illnesses attributed to prolonged exposure to toxic substances. Most farmers do not take protective measures, like wearing gloves or other protective clothing. Also, parts of e-waste that could not be sold was burnt, causing atmospheric pollution.

“E-waste contains heavy metals and plastic, which contain toxic components. If waste management is not controlled properly, hazardous components, which contain carcinogens, can be released into the environment,” said Penchom Saetang, director of Ecological Alert and Recovery Thailand (Earth).

Earth, along with the environmental NGO Arnika, recently made a statement urging the government to terminate hazardous waste imports and dirty recycling industries as well as to ratify the Basel Convention Ban Amendment, an agreement that prohibits the export of plastic and electronic waste to developing countries.

The lack of efficient waste management in Thailand — especially electronic waste — makes the situation worse. According to statistics from Earth, 400,000 tonnes of electronic appliances and devices are discarded each year in Thailand which should be enough for the local recycling business. However, Industrial Works reported that imported e-waste increased from almost 2,000 tonnes in 2016 to over 54,000 in tonnes 2017. Following such a huge surge, the Commerce Ministry last year announced a ban on the import of 428 types of e-waste with an aim of helping Thailand reduce the amount of e-waste. However, many loopholes remain.

The ministry’s move banned hazardous waste defined by the Basel Convention — an international treaty aimed at controlling the transboundary movement of hazardous waste as well as its disposal.

However, other used materials, such as cell phones, batteries, accumulators, laptops, keyboards and desktop computers are still allowed to be imported into the country.

“These used products are electronic waste. Why do we need to import these used products? This is how other countries find ways to dump their waste. We found that from last September to April, 28.85 million kilogrammes of used electronic waste was imported into Thailand as foreign countries exploited a loophole in Thailand’s regulations,” said Akarapon Teebthaisong, research and technical officer for Earth.

In addition to the ministerial regulation’s loophole, only 10% of trash containers that arrive in Thailand are inspected by the Customs Department, which possibly allows the entry of banned e-wastes into the country.

Discarded electronics require an efficient and highly regulated waste management system to handle hazardous components like lead, mercury and cadmium. Akarapon said improper recycling processes in Thailand have a negative effect on air, soil, and water.

“Thailand lacks efficient e-waste management. After electronic products are dumped, they are separated to sell parts. Parts that cannot be sold are burnt, buried or thrown away. Burning e-waste releases a residue of carcinogens into the environment causing severe air pollution because the air will consist of a mixture of cancer-causing chemicals,” Penchom said.

Tara Buakamsri, country director of Greenpeace Southeast Asia, said most e-waste goes to “dirty recycling industries” or improper recycling factories.

“We are not against efficient recycling factories but dirty recycling industries have a negative impact on our environment and communities and we gain a very small benefit from this industry. E-waste in Thailand is more than enough for recycling businesses; we do not need imported e-waste,” said Tara.

European Union countries have Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment regulations (WEEE) that aim to contribute to sustainable production and consumption.

Tara notes that WEEE’s regulations require electronic manufacturers to be responsible for the “entire lifecycle of their products from designing to final disposal”.

“In 2016, Greenpeace urged Apple to use more recycled materials to produce their products and Apple changed its materials after our urge,” he said.

Penchom explained that the concept of Extended Producer Responsibility was developed so that manufacturers take back their devices to be disposed of properly and safely.

Representatives from both environmental groups said Thailand lacks strong laws that regulate and control e-waste. A proposed EPR bill for e-waste management has been under consideration by the Office of the Council of State for several years.

“During this process, we cannot request information concerning how the bill has changed and developed,” Penchom said.

In response, environmental groups have been busy drafting another bill on waste management that promotes recycling through the circular economy concept.

“The idea of the circular economy is to promote waste sorting at its source. Plastic, glass and e-waste or hazardous waste are separated at households or companies so less garbage goes to landfills. Then, recyclable materials will go through a recycling or reuse process. This is a long-term solution that can reduce the amount of waste sent to landfills or is burned,” said Penchom.

Penchom said another issue in Thailand is that the country has lax enforcement on quality assurance policies of recycling factories. Tara added that the Kingdom lacks an environmental restoration programme.

“In the US, the federal superfund programme collects money from companies that pollute in order to restore contaminated lands. However, people who live in polluted areas in Thailand do not have any support for restoration. Environmental restoration does not cost much but we lack the funds,” said Tara.

Earth and Greenpeace have said Thailand should ban all types of imported e-waste and endorse the Basel Convention. Once Thailand ratifies the Basel agreement, the legal loopholes allowing some e-waste imports will be closed.

“Authorities are still reviewing details of the amendment. If Thailand ratifies this agreement, amendments to local laws must be made in order to comply with the Basel Convention Ban Amendment,” Akarapon said.

In the meantime, Tara said that Thai people can help reduce e-waste by using their electronic devices for as long as possible. Penchom says people should sort waste and separate hazardous waste from other kinds of waste. The private sector should support the EPR law and the government should take the e-waste issue seriously.

“Members of the government may live far away from polluted areas but toxic substances can spread and stay in the environment for a long time, even to the next generations. Sooner or later, the negative impact on the environment will affect everyone and the government will not be able to avoid the issue,” Penchom said.

News Related


Some birds learn to recognize calls while still in their eggs

Over a decade ago, behavioral ecologist Diane Colombelli-Négrel was wiring superb fairy wrens’ nests to record the birds’ sounds when she noticed something odd. Mother fairy wrens sang while incubating ... Read more »

A beautiful oak leaf portrait won the 2021 Nikon Small World photography contest

A closeup view of even the most common objects can make the mundane look spectacular. A glimpse of the underside of a southern live oak tree leaf, which won first ... Read more »

How metal-infused jaws give some ants an exceptionally sharp bite

If you’ve ever felt the wrath of a biting or stinging insect, it may seem incredible that something so small can so easily slice or puncture human skin. Scientists already ... Read more »

A newfound boa sports big eyes and a square nose

A wide-eyed snake has made scientists do a double take. The Hispaniolan vineboa, with its large protruding eyes and square snout, is the first boa species to be discovered in ... Read more »

Fossil tracks may reveal an ancient elephant nursery

Fossilized footprints found on a beach in southern Spain betray what may have been a nursery for an extinct species of elephant. The track-rich coastal site, which scientists have dubbed ... Read more »

Netflix finally eyes TV's top prize with 'The Crown' at in-person Emmys

Leading streamer Netflix has never won best drama at the Emmys — nor best comedy, nor best limited series LOS ANGELES: Netflix is tipped to finally win television's biggest prize ... Read more »

14,555 new Covid cases, 171 more deaths

A food rider and other motorists wait for a train to pass through a crossing in Bangkok on Wednesday. Food delivery booms in Thailand after the Covid-19 outbreak forces people ... Read more »

Villagers slam EIA report on Yuam water project

A group of ethnic villagers who oppose a plan to divert water from the Yuam River to Bhumibol dam is planning to submit a protest letter to Prime Minister Prayut ... Read more »

AQ hotels see occupancy rates plummet

Food service during quarantine at Rattanakosin Hotel, an alternative quarantine hotel. (Photo: Apichart Jinakul) Alternative quarantine (AQ) hotels are enduring their lowest occupancy rates, amid signs that infection levels have peaked ... Read more »

Corporate takeover Loxley's popular in-house food service goes local

I first learnt about Tamrub Guru, this week's subject of Eating In, via online ads. The brand’s title is a bilingual word play betweeen tamrub, Thai for recipe, and English ... Read more »

Robinhood Is Going on a College Tour to Recruit New Customers The app criticized for gamifying trading is kicking off a nationwide push to court students, including a shot at a $20,000 prize

Robinhood Markets Inc., the go-to trading app for young investors, wants its user base to get even younger. The digital brokerage is kicking off a nationwide marketing campaign Wednesday that ... Read more »

Making amends Netflix's Afterlife Of The Party is a formulaic rom-com about a woman given a second chance to right her wrongs on Earth

Midori Francis and Timothy Renouf in Afterlife Of The Party. Netflix Thailand Whether you believe in life after death or not, we can all agree that it would be nice ... Read more »

Time flies The Oris Okavango Air Rescue Limited Edition supports doctors in Southern Africa

Okavango Air Rescue’s service now covers the whole of the Southern African continent. Justin de Reuck2016www.aviati Through its “Change For The Better” initiative, Oris has supported projects across the world, ... Read more »

Protests immortalised in art

Artist Jirapatt Aungsumalee. photos courtesy of VS Gallery When a writer replaces his pen for a paintbrush, the outcome takes on a new dimension as seen in the artworks of ... Read more »

TPCH eyes options as wood chip prices rise Company considers other renewable fuels

TPCH’s wood chip-fired power plant, with a capacity of 9.9MW, in the southern province of Satun. Higher prices for wood chips are causing TPC Power Holding Plc (TPCH), a renewable ... Read more »

Ananda slashes transfer, presales targets

Sermsak Khwanpuang, chief finance officer, Ananda Development Plc. SET-listed developer Ananda Development has cut its transfer and presales targets for 2021 by 37% and 24%, respectively, after the most recent ... Read more »

Hotels pin hopes on Bangkok revival

Travel resumes at Suvarnabhumi airport following the end of a ban on domestic flights on Sept 1. Wichan Charoenkiatpakul Hotels hope the reopening of Bangkok in October and domestic stimulus campaigns ... Read more »

SMEs offer timid support of restart Plan must include Covid safeguards

The atmosphere at Chatuchak weekend market in Bangkok, which reopened following the easing of Covid-19 restrictions. Only about 10% of vendors resumed trade. Apichart Jinakul The Federation of Thai SME has ... Read more »

New programme hones in on cybersecurity skills

The National Cyber Security Agency (NCSA) is gearing up to develop the cybersecurity skills of personnel working in seven sectors of critical information infrastructure (CII) through an intensive capacity-building programme, ... Read more »

SCB Abacus growth lures tech investors Lender raises US$12 million in funding

SCB Abacus, an alternative digital lending platform under Siam Commercial Bank, has raised US$12 million (396 million baht) in a Series A funding round and targets digital loan growth of ... Read more »

Methods sought to ease airlines' liquidity crunch

Finance Minister Arkhom Termpittayapaisith has instructed the Fiscal Policy Office and the Bank of Thailand to jointly seek ways to relax some of the criteria for state banks to lend ... Read more »

Direct sales sector forecast to slip just 1-2% this year

Thailand's direct sales industry is expected to contract by 1-2% this year as consumer purchasing power remains weak due to the spread of Covid-19. Kittawat Ritteerawee, president of the Thai ... Read more »

Agency urges reworking

The government is being advised to speed up developing infrastructure for science, technology and digital as well as promote private investment in R&D next year to spur the economy and ... Read more »

Oct 1 reopening up in air Experts say target may be premature

The Public Health Ministry yesterday addressed concerns raised by academics over the government's plan to reopen the country to vaccinated foreign tourists starting next month. The plan is in line ... Read more »

Chiang Mai mountain reserve-listed Doi Chiang Dao gets Unesco approval

Chiang Dao Cave is located at the foot of Doi Chiang Dao Mountain. The cave, full of stunning stalactites and stalagmites, is a tourist magnet in Chiang Mai. photos by apichit ... Read more »

Moderna jab nod for 12-17 year-olds

Thailand's Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has given approval for the Moderna Covid-19 vaccine to be administered to adolescents aged from 12 to 17, ZP Therapeutics, a division of Zuellig ... Read more »

Hua Lamphong to get a makeover

The Transport Ministry is conducting a study to develop Hua Lamphong railway station and its adjoining areas for commercial purposes, Transport Minister Saksayam Chidchob said. He said the ministry has ... Read more »

Torture, disappearance bills pass MPs of all banners praise legislation

Four long-awaited bills on torture and forced disappearances sailed through the House of Representatives yesterday. A total of 368 MPs voted in favour of the bills with one abstention. The ... Read more »

NACC told to release watch scandal details

Prawit: ‘No need to declare watches’ The National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC) will study the details of the Central Administrative Court's order that the agency disclose a probe into a luxury ... Read more »

Phuket faces clinic bed shortage crisis

Phuket is facing a critical bed shortage as Covid-19 spreads throughout the island, said Wachira Phuket Hospital yesterday. Chalermpong Sukhonthaphol, director of the hospital, said the bed occupancy by patients ... Read more »

Govt plans out booster shots

The government will provide a booster shot against Covid-19 for those who received alternative vaccines, according to Public Health Minister Anutin Charnvirakul. The minister was responding to questions concerning recipients ... Read more »

Samuel Adams set to release its 2021 Utopias beer. At 28% ABV, it's illegal in 15 states

Samuel Adams beer maker Boston Beer Co. is ready to release its potent Utopias beer, which weighs in at 28% alcohol by volume – a strength that makes it illegal ... Read more »

Lawmakers vote on law against torture, disappearances

Activists hold up pictures of abducted activist Wanchalearm Satsaksit as people gather in support of him during a protest calling for an investigation, in front of Government House on June ... Read more »

Bed shortage looms in Phuket as caseload surges Occupation rate reaches critical point, says hospital chief

A field hospital is set up at Phuket Rajabhat University on Sept 8 this year. (Photo: Achadtaya Chuenniran) PHUKET: The resort island has added more beds for Covid-19 patients as ... Read more »

Man arrested for murder of wife, stepson 10 years ago

Sawai Khanpakwaen, 60, seated right, former chairman of tambon Pho Klang administration organisation in Muang district of Nakhon Ratchasima, is questioned after his arrest in Surat Thani for shooting dead ... Read more »

HK had world's second largest billionaire population in urban centres

A general view showing the Central Business District, in Hong Kong on Sept 15, 2021. (Reuters photo) HONG KONG: Hong Kong had 111 billionaire residents, the second-largest such population among ... Read more »

The lowdown on tax box 1, 2 and 3 – plus other common tax terms

When you land in the Netherlands, you aren’t just dealing with a different language, employer and queuing etiquette – ­you also have to deal with the Belastingdienst. The Dutch tax ... Read more »

PostToday, Super Trader Republic and Chulalongkorn University unveil PostToday Republic New club catalyses business dynamism with holistic courses and services

From left: Prapat Phungboonpisan, Co-Chief Operating Officer, PTR; Isaraporn Bunnag, First Vice President – Marketing, Bangkok Post Group; Krasuang Jarusira, Co-Chief Executive Officer, PTR; Dr. Ronnachit Mahattanapreut, Chief Executive Officer, ... Read more »

Grand Seiko increases its warranty to five years

Since its global launch in 2010, Grand Seiko has expanded its after-sales service operations in line with its ever-increasing international acceptance. Today, Grand Seiko is proud to announce that it ... Read more »