‘Voter bribery' case: Gujarat assembly speaker, former BJP MLA, Patidar stir leader get court relief

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Provided by The Indian Express

GUJARAT ASSEMBLY Speaker Nimaben Acharya, former BJP MLA Kantilal Amrutiya and Patidar quota agitation leader Manoj Panara got relief in a case related to alleged bribing of voters at an election meeting in Morbi town during the 2009 Lok Sabha election as the district and sessions court of Morbi on Saturday set aside a trial court verdict that pronounced them guilty.

The court of additional sessions judge MK Upadhyay on Saturday allowed separate appeals filed by Acharya, Amrutiya and Panara against the trial court conviction on February 12, 2018.

“The court concurred with our submission that the prosecution had erred in interpreting the law and therefore, the trial court’s verdict convicting the accused was illegal, perverse and untenable in the eye of law and hence allowed our appeal,” Anil Desai, Acharya’s advocate, told The Indian Express.

Acharya and Amrutiya, then sitting BJP MLAs from Anjar and Morbi Assembly constituencies respectively, and Panara, then a BJP worker, were booked under Indian Penal Code sections 171-B (bribing voters), 188 (disobedience to order duly promulgated by a public servant) and 114 (abettor present when offence is committed) on March 25, 2009. The case was registered on the basis of a complaint filed by Arvind Patel, the assistant returning officer (ARO), Kutch Lok Sabha seat.

In his complaint, the ARO said that at a meeting in Morbi town on March 18, 2009, Acharya had promised BJP workers that if elected, the party MP would allot Rs 5 lakh grant to the polling booth that records the highest voting in favour of the party candidate. Acharya also promised that the MP would allot Rs 2 lakh and Rs1.51 lakh respectively to the booths that comes second and third, the ARO alleged.

As per the complaint, Amrutiya had promised that BJP MLAs in Kutch Parliamentary seat would allot Rs1.51 lakh to the “organisation” of the area in each Assembly

from where the party candidate gets the highest lead in LS poll. The complaint alleged that Panara had applied for permission for the event but it went beyond the officially permitted time.

The trial court in Morbi that pronounced Acharya, Amrutiya and Panara guilty of violating IPC Sections 171-B and 114 in 2018, had sentenced them to one year simple imprisonment and fined Rs 1,000 each while acquitting them of the charge under IPC Section 188. However, the court allowed the convicts’ plea for stayed operation of its judgement for 30 days so that they can approach the sessions court.

Acharya moved the Morbi district and sessions court on February 22, 2018 challenging the trial court verdict. Amrutiya and Panara, too, moved separate appeals. The sessions court subsequently stayed operation of the trial court judgement till pendency of the appeals.

On Saturday, Acharya thanked the sessions court for “doing justice” to her. “I was not even an MLA from Morbi which would have allowed me to allot my (MLA Local Area Development Fund) grant in Morbi. Nor had we promised anyone money or had made any attempt to lure voters. All that we had done is to tell our workers to encourage people to vote in large numbers. But no one is above the law and one has to go through the procedure,” Acharya told The Indian Express, adding, “The judgement has strengthened my faith in the judiciary.”

Acharya was protem speaker of Gujarat Assembly when she was convicted in February, 2018. She was elected Speaker last month after incumbent speaker Rajendra Trivedi resigned.

During the hearing of the appeals, Desai and advocates of Amrutiya and Panara contented that Acharya and Amrutiya had not addressed any “individuals” but “party booth workers of the constituency. “Even those words do not fall within the ambit of Section 171-B of the IPC so as to attract the punishment U/S. 171-E of the IPC for the offence of Bribery,” the sessions court notes the appellants as having argued.

“The prosecution never produced the VCD (video city disc) containing recording of the said event in trial court… In absence of material evidence, the prosecution’s case rested on oral testimonies of seven witnesses. But we contented that all the seven witnesses examined by the prosecution were government servants and that there was no independent witness supporting the case hence the prosecution had failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt,” Desai added.

In his judgement, judge MK Upadhyay underlined that the VCD was a vital piece of evidence but the prosecution failed to produce it. “In such a case the question arises as to why the Court should not draw an adverse inference against the Prosecution that if at all the said electronic evidence would have been produced before the Court, it would have definitely gone against the Prosecution Case… And hence inference can definitely be drawn against the Prosecution U/S. 114 of the Evidence Act,” the judgement noted.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Cake Boss Buddy Valastro is Bringing a Bakery to Toronto (Plus, He Shares His Fave Moments From Buddy vs. Duff Holiday)

“I’ve been literally working 18-hour days for the last month, says Buddy Valastro, AKA the Cake Boss, from the hit baking competition show Buddy vs. Duff.   “I’ve been actually sleeping ... Read more »

What a former CDC director says about Omicron

With at least 16 states now reporting cases of the Omicron variant have been detected, there’s still much more we don’t know about the spread of the latest COVID-19 strain.  ... Read more »

Report: Man dies at Florida golf course while diving for golf balls

© Provided by SMG Ponte Vedra Inn & Club A man died while diving to recover golf balls from a Florida golf course, according to the First Coast News. The ... Read more »

Jewish couple kicked off American Airlines flight for refusing to put prayer shawl on floor

A Jewish couple who were kicked off an American Airlines flight for refusing to store their sacred prayer shawl on the floor have filed a lawsuit against the airline. © ... Read more »

Next season starts now for the Giants and the Jets

Photos: Getty Images (3); AP Getty Images (3); AP Sign up here to get Beyond the Back Page delivered to your inbox each morning. It ended appropriately, with more urgency ... Read more »

I'm remortgaging but might move, should I fix for two years or five?

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo My mortgage fixed term is coming to an end, and I am looking to remortgage.  Given the low rates currently available, fixing ... Read more »

China Evergrande shares hit record low as it edges closer to default

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Aly Song/Reuters Shares in the struggling Chinese property developer Evergrande hit a record low on Monday after strong indications that it is on the ... Read more »

Putin heads to India with eye on military, energy ties

© – Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to India will be only his second trip abroad since the coronavirus pandemic began Russian President Vladimir Putin arrived in India on Monday ... Read more »

Three charged after £500,000 drugs seized in raid

© PA Archive Mock-up picture of cocaine. – PA Archive Police have seized cocaine and heroin with an estimated street value of £500,000. Officers with a warrant raided a property ... Read more »

Billionaire investor Ray Dalio says his comments on China's disappearances were misunderstood – after he said Beijing was being a 'strict parent'

© Eoin Noonan/Web Summit via Getty Images Ray Dalio has raised $1.3 billion for a private fund in China, according to Bloomberg. Eoin Noonan/Web Summit via Getty Images Ray Dalio ... Read more »

EV maker Lucid gets SEC subpoena on $24-billion blank-check deal

© Reuters/ANDREW KELLY Lucid Motors (Nasdaq: LCID) begins trading today on the Nasdaq stock exchange in New York City (Reuters) -The U.S. securities regulator has asked Lucid Group Inc for ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb's Arlene Phillips reveals details of castle evacuation when she had roots done

What happened to the I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! campmates during the ITV show’s three-day cancellation due to the havoc caused by Storm Arwen has mostly remained ... Read more »

EU and Nato ‘believe Russia is preparing to invade Ukraine'

© Sat Img ©2021 Maxar via REUTERS A satellite image of Russian military deployments in Crimea, close to the border with Ukraine – Sat Img ©2021 Maxar via REUTERS Intelligence ... Read more »

Don't look at my teeth! Pregnant Jennifer Lawrence's dental challenge on movie set

© Getty Images Netflix’s “Don’t Look Up” World Premiere 06122021 Jennifer Lawrence says she had to film most of her latest movie toothless after losing a veneer during filming. The ... Read more »

Adam Driver's 'exhausting' Burberry Hero shoot

© Provided by BANG Showbiz Adam Driver’s ‘exhausting’ Burberry hero shoot Adam Driver found it “exhausting” trying to “mirror” a horse’s “physicality” for the Burberry Hero campaign. The ‘House of ... Read more »

A Shake Shack manager who makes over $100,000 a year describes her daily schedule and says supply issues are her biggest challenge

© Provided by Business Insider Angela Campbell/Shake Shack Angela Campbell is a General Manager at a Las Vegas Shake Shack. She is responsible for keeping her store staffed and ready ... Read more »

Omicron: Curve of COVID cases driven by new variant 'much steeper' than previous waves, professor warns

South Africa is preparing its hospitals for more admissions as the Omicron variant pushes the country into its fourth COVID-19 wave, with the strain now accounting for the majority of new infections, President Cyril Ramaphosa said. Read more »

World's oldest giraffe dies aged 31 after having 14 babies at Aussie zoo

THE world's oldest giraffe has died at an Australian zoo aged 31. Taronga Western Plains Zoo in New South Wales announced the devastating news on Friday just weeks after Mutangi ... Read more »

Woman shares simple item she found in her boyfriend's car which has her convinced he's cheating

NOTHING'S as heartbreaking as finding out your loved one, the one you thought would stay loyal, turns out to be something you never thought he would. Unfortunately, some cheaters are ... Read more »

Warning for millions of Apple fans NOT to buy new iPhone model

A TIKTOKER has highlighted why shoppers should think twice before buying the latest iPhone this Christmas. In a recent video, Kevin Hirschberg explained why he thinks splashing out on an ... Read more »

Probe opened into fights at French election campaign rally

The Associated PressFrench far right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour delivers his speech during his first rally, Sunday, Dec. 5, 2021 in Villepinte, north of Paris. Far-right former French TV pundit ... Read more »

Japan has 3rd omicron case as Kishida vows strict response

TOKYO — Japan confirmed on Monday its third case of the new omicron variant — a traveler entering from Italy — as Prime Minister Fumio Kishida vowed to take strict ... Read more »

Nepal starts census of endangered Royal Bengal tigers

© Prakash MATHEMA A Royal Bengal tiger walks in its enclosure at a zoo in Lalitpur, on the outskirts of Kathmandu Nepal started counting endangered Royal Bengal tigers in its ... Read more »

Olympics-Swedish goaltender Lehner to skip Beijing Games due to mental health issues

(Reuters) – Swedish goaltender Robin Lehner will skip next year’s Winter Olympics in Beijing after the 30-year-old said on Monday that his participation would not be ideal for his mental ... Read more »

'Dominant', 'Would be ideal...' - Luke Hatfield drops key Wolves January transfer verdict

Wolves need to bring in both a centre-back and a midfielder in the January transfer window, according to journalist Luke Hatfield. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Bruno Lage Wolves The ... Read more »

Transgender swimmer smashes women's records while competing for University of Pennsylvania

Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas smashed a number of women’s records for the University of Pennsylvania last month. © GiveMeSport Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas smashed a number of women’s records for ... Read more »

Better.com CEO fires 900 employees on Zoom call, accuses them of ‘stealing'

Better.com CEO Vishal Garg reportedly fired the 900 people during a zoom call. The chief executive of New York-based online mortgage lender Better.com laid off some 900 employees during a ... Read more »

Elly Mattiuzzo dead at 18: Tributes paid to figure skating star after dying in horror car crash alongside boyfriend

FIGURE SKATER Elly Mattiuzzo has tragically died aged 18 following a horror car crash with her boyfriend. According to Gazzetta dello Sport the couple were driving a Fiat 500 on ... Read more »

Gender pay gap has barely changed if gains in women's educational attainments are excluded, IFS says

The pay gap between men and women has barely changed in 25 years if the gains in women’s educational attainments are excluded, according to the IFS – PA The gender ... Read more »

MPPSC exam calendar 2021-22: Tentative schedule out for recruitment exams at mppsc.nic.in

© Provided by Firstpost MPPSC exam calendar 2021-22: Tentative schedule out for recruitment exams at mppsc.nic.in The examination calendar for recruitment to various posts for the year 2021-2022 has been ... Read more »

‘It takes great courage to write that way': David Eldridge on Robert Holman

Photograph: Sarah Lee/The Guardian In Robert Holman’s play Jonah and Otto, Otto says: “I think we learn to love, by loving, by listening to another person. Love is paying attention.” ... Read more »

Indian math genius Nikhil Srivastava just solved a 62-year-old problem and won a top US prize

Say you have been facing a maths problem for a very long time and neither you nor your colleagues have been able to solve it so far. Many years after the problem, a computer ... Read more »

'Unang Hirit' hosts share their motivation to wake up early for the past 22 years

Photos: Unang Hirit/IG “Unang Hirit” hosts shared what has been motivating them to wake up early in the morning to serve the people for the past 22 years as they ... Read more »

Rabiya Mateo retraces the biggest lesson from her "emotionally devastating" Miss Universe loss

© Provided by PEP.ph “I used to be a people pleaser talaga. That was my downfall when I was competing for Miss Universe.”  Ito ang pag-amin ni Rabiya Mateo tungkol ... Read more »

Cyclone Jawad-triggered heavy rainfall leads to waterlogged streets in Kolkata

© Provided by Zee News Kolkata: Normal life was partially disrupted in parts of Bengal on Monday as heavy rain triggered by Cyclone ‘Jawad’ left several areas waterlogged in the ... Read more »

Become a PayMaya Verified Seller now and let your customers know you're legit!

Online shopping has definitely become more popular in the Philippines, but online scams – from fake sellers to bogus buyers – are ruining the experience for many Filipinos. © Provided ... Read more »

England braced for return to bushtucker trials as Ashes with a difference loom

© Getty Images Pat Cummins and Joe Root at the launch of the men’s Ashes © Getty Images Until Covid struck, it was a long-standing tradition for British TV executives ... Read more »

PM Modi lauds Jai Ram govt for 100 per cent Covid vaccination

© Provided by The Statesman PM Modi lauds Jai Ram govt for 100 per cent Covid vaccination Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday lauded Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur led ... Read more »

How an incredible bench strength has fuelled India's golden era in cricket

© Provided by The Indian Express The Wankhede Test against New Zealand was only Jayant Yadav’s fifth Test match, and his first in almost five years. The last time he ... Read more »

FMSCI concludes INRSC 2021: Hero MotoSports take wins in stock & modified classes

© Provided by The Financial Express Hero MotoCorp is the world’s largest manufacturer of motorcycles and scooters. The company’s motorsports team – Hero MotoSports Team Rally, has emerged as champions ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic