Voices: Six years ago today, I voted Leave – would I do the same again?

Six years ago I made a terrible, terrible mistake. I voted Leave. I thought Brexit would work, or at least could work and create the conditions to build a more competitive economy, and therefore a more prosperous one.

I’d been watching the 2016 Euros and drew inspiration from them. Every team had different tactics. They competed, in different systems, adapting tactics to their own group of players’ unique strengths and weaknesses. Their team managers made their own decisions, and got sacked if they got it wrong.

In other words, the voters, or their representatives in parliament, were able to “sack the manager”, to try and gain a competitive advantage on the economy when we were judged to be losing and falling behind other countries. There wasn’t enough freedom to adjust policies and democratic accountability inside the EU.

Here’s what I wrote at the time, before the vote, and I think many people evidently felt the same. I guess I’m at liberty to quote myself at length, and partly as a matter of a fair defence for an action that proved misguided and wrong: “In Britain, that’s how it used to be, even under the earlier phase of our time in the EU. Since 1945, we’ve had a socialist command economy with rationing, Tory dirigisme, Wilsonian planning, Heathite corporatism, a few spells of social democracy, a long experiment with Thatcherism, and then what came after (which I suppose is managerialism).

“Sooner or later, each of these approaches ran out of steam; and the break in policy was executed by an electorate who wanted fresh leadership and a fresh approach. So they sacked the government in a general election. In other words, the voters, or their representatives in parliament, were able to ‘sack the manager’, to try and gain a competitive advantage on the economy when we were judged to be losing and falling behind other countries.

“As things stand now, the UK is not able to take radical steps to the left or to the right to change economic policy if it wants to. Yes, we have general elections and some freedoms over tax rates and so on; but the general trend in Europe is towards constant harmonisation and limits on national freedom of action.”

I can see where I was coming from, because the EU had, and still has, serious flaws; but it was a poor analogy. That’s because the Euro football championship has to have common rules and standards (eg 11 players on the pitch at any one time, and the troublesome offside rule) and if you don’t wish to play by those rules then that’s fine, but you can’t enter the European football championship. Play with other countries instead. Or yourself, so to speak. You can create the most brilliant football system in the world but if other countries don’t want to allow you into their competition, then it’s not going to be of any use to you.

In other words, people like me understated how difficult life would be outside the EU, and overestimated the degree of freedom we could have in terms of access to crucial European markets as well as fast-growing economies around the world. To borrow a phrase that later became notorious, I thought we could have our cake and eat it – keep most of what we liked about EU membership, and ditch the bits we didn’t want. (After all, every other time an EU state voted No to some new EU treaty there was a quick renegotiation, better terms sorted out.)

voices: six years ago today, i voted leave – would i do the same again?
© Provided by The Independent To embark on a huge and arduous national project such as Brexit requires a bit more popular consent than it got in 2016, and now it is more resented than ever (Getty Images)

Indeed, it became clear during the course of the post-referendum negotiations that it wasn’t in the EU’s interests to offer the UK the deal we dreamed of because we needed the EU more than we needed them – even if German car makers made lots of money here.

To use the football analogy, they liked to play England (apologies to the rest of the UK), but they could run a perfectly fine tournament without them. England can’t play European football without agreeing to certain rules; and couldn’t, in the end, accept them. At that point, in 2018 and 2019, the only sensible, fair and democratic thing would have been to secure whatever terms of Brexit we could and then get the people to have a vote to approve them – the Final Say referendum that The Independent campaigned for.

I underestimated the pain the economy would go through – though not that there would be some hit to GDP. The exchange rate, as I thought, is taking a lot of the strain of adjustment, and with it inflation, but the process will take even longer than I anticipated, if it ever does get done.

The trade deals with other countries we thought were waiting to be signed have proved elusive. Most disappointing has been the failure to agree one with America, under presidents of both parties. The truth is that it doesn’t matter if the US president is Anglophile or not; Congress controls trade policy, and the majority of the political leadership of America reflects the population’s general preference for protectionism and suspicion of free trade. It was summed up in the slogan “America First” and a remark Donald Trump once carefully wrote on a draft of a speech on economics: “TRADE IS BAD”.

Also, for depressing reasons of a different kind, hitching the UK to China, Russia and Brazil doesn’t look like such a great idea any more. Japan and India are about the only major economic powers we can do business with, as well as the Gulf states and Australia, and it’s not enough to compensate for the loss of EU export markets, broken pan-European supply chains, and above all the shortage of labour and cost inflation that followed Brexit. Not to mention the Horizon project and defence and security cooperation.

I think I was right about the general British hostility to Europeans “telling us what to do” and to “free movement” migration, factors that probably made Brexit inevitable. Yet the other misjudgement about Brexit I made was to underestimate how ready the British were (and still are) to take the revolutionary measures needed to transform the economy. This was especially foolish because it was all-too apparent in 2016 that the Brexity mood was one of blind, boosterish enthusiasm, the high-water mark of senseless Johnsonian optimism.

voices: six years ago today, i voted leave – would i do the same again?
© Provided by The Independent The British believed Boris Johnson and thought they could have their cake and eat it (POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

The half of the population who voted Remain were, fair enough, not up for it in 2016 or after; but most of the other half of the population who voted Leave, and with it the corollary of radical change, weren’t prepared for a shake-up either, or even expecting one. Brexit always meant some hardship if the long-term gains were going to be won. The atmosphere was the reverse. It was all about butterflies emerging from chrysalises, Independence Day, and Prometheus unbound. Well, we got a shake-up, as we see.

I also took the lazy view in 2016 that the question of Northern Ireland was soluble with goodwill and, as Boris Johnson thought, it was ridiculous to have the tail wagging the dog, and that if it was in the interests of the whole UK to leave it shouldn’t be stopped by the relatively small population of the province. Big error.

In fact, quite apart from Brexit being incompatible with the Belfast Good Friday Agreement, the new pseudo-federal UK that had emerged by 2016 effectively meant that Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and England should all have had an effective veto, because trying to leave without majority consent in all four parts of the UK was asking for trouble so far as the Union was concerned. So it proved, because Scotland and Northern Ireland both voted No, and of course Wales and England only voted Leave by relatively modest margins, with London and other cities voting Remain.

To embark on a huge and arduous national project such as Brexit requires a bit more popular consent than it got in 2016, and now it is more resented than ever, especially in Scotland and Northern Ireland.

To keep up to speed with all the latest opinions and comment, sign up to our free weekly Voices Dispatches newsletter by clicking here

The overriding thing I did get right is that Britain does have to compete in the world (and so does Europe) and can’t forever evade the emerging competition by hiding behind tariff barriers and avoid inevitable hard choices by throwing subsidies around. Brexit was only ever going to work as a project to secure long-term global economic survival that would be understood and supported by the vast majority of the populace. “Brexit opportunities” aren’t just lying around waiting for Jacob Rees-Mogg to pick them up and pass a law to bring them to life, like allowing the sale of more powerful vacuum cleaners. That’s an infantile version of Brexit.

Brexit opportunities are about sacrifices to make the UK globally competitive and able to overcome tariff and other protectionist barriers. It’s about flattening costs and reducing consumption to foster private sector productive investment. It’s about diverting goods and services consumed at home towards exports. It will mean poorer public services at least in the short term. It means more migration, from everywhere. It isn’t about subsidising petrol prices or “fair pay” or exempting home ownership from capital gains tax.

A radically different economic model is the only way Brexit can work, and it’s not the Brexit the British voted for. The British believed Boris Johnson and thought they could have their cake and eat it. The deal we had in the EU wasn’t perfect, but it was far better than we realised.

I’m sorry to say that, with rare exceptions, no one who voted Leave in 2016 properly understood what it would really entail to make it a success. Me included. I’m sorry.

To mark the six year anniversary of the referendum on Britain’s membership of the EU, Voices brings you Brexit, 6 years on – a series exploring the impact of the vote to leave

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Man who glassed fellow mourner at funeral in 'unprovoked attack' is jailed

© Provided by Metro Max Prior was found guilty of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (Picture: Geograph/Evening Gazette) A mourner who smashed his wine glass into the ... Read more »

Martin Lewis says he was called 'Jew' and anti-Semitic nicknames at school as kids used to throw sweets to see if he would pick them up

Martin Lewis has opened up about the anti-Semitic experiences he faced in school and the prejudiced comparisons people continue to make online today about his Jewishness and his role as ... Read more »

Newcastle 'will make an offer' in the 'coming days' for Brazilian gem with £60.2m release clause

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Pepe Porto Newcastle United will reportedly now ‘make an offer’ to sign FC Porto winger Pepe in the ‘coming days’. The Lowdown: Busy summer Lille ... Read more »

Man arrested on suspicion of murder after ‘pub altercation’ in Cotswolds village

© Google Maps Thames Close.png A man has been arrested on suspicion of murder following an altercation in a pub in a Cotswolds village. Police have launched a probe into ... Read more »

Rita Ora wows in a pink floral bralette and tight black vinyl trousers at Glastonbury - amid claims she's set to wed beau Taika Waititi 'imminently'

Rita Ora caught the eye at Glastonbury Festival in Somerset on Friday. The singer, 31, turned heads in a pink bralette with floral patterns, which she teamed up with a pair ... Read more »

Dad's Army star dead at 90: Frank Williams who played Timothy Farthing in classic BBC sitcom passes away - as fans thank actor for 'all the joy and laughter'

The star's death was announced in a statement on his dedicated Facebook pageFrank, who starred as Reverend Timothy Farthing, died on Sunday morningHe once described time on Dad's Army as the 'happiest' period of his work life Read more »

Trump SHOULD be criminally charged, nearly 50% of US voters say in new poll: Adam Schiff warns DOJ it would be making a 'political decision' if it fails to investigate ex-president over January 6

46% of respondents to a new poll said the January 6 committee should recommend Donald Trump for criminal charges over the Capitol riotHalf US voters think he tried to stay in office using illegal means, survey suggestsHowever 53% also admitted to paying 'not much' attention or 'none at all' to the House January 6 committee's ongoing bombshell hearingsCommittee member Rep. Adam Schiff suggested on NBC's Meet the Press that he's disappointed the Justice Department has yet to go after TrumpIt comes after the DOJ sent subpoenas to multiple Trump allies allegedly involved in a scheme to send fake Electoral College votes in the 2020 race  Read more »

Sadio Mane's PR agent claims his client's £35.1m move to Bayern Munich was NOT down to salary demands as he says rumours over low Liverpool wages are 'false'... and he refuses to reveal the 'other very big clubs' who were trumped by German giants!

Sadio Mane has left Liverpool after six years for Bayern Munich in a £35.1m deal The Senegalese was keen for a new challenge away from the Premier League The 30-year-old signs a three-year contract worth £250,000-a-week in Germany Read more »

'There is no hiding': Wayne Pivac insists Wales are desperate to put their Six Nations embarrassment by Italy behind them in their daunting three-Test series in world champions South Africa's backyard 

Wayne Pivac has admitted Wales' loss to Italy in March was 'embarrassing'The Dragons are currently preparing for a three-Test series against South AfricaPivac is hopeful Wales will bounce back against Springboks, starting next week Read more »

Derby promote coach Liam Rosenior to be Wayne Rooney's successor on an interim basis after England legend resigned... as administrators announce they've accepted Clowes Developments' bid to acquire cash-strapped club

Derby have named Liam Rosenior as their interim boss to replace Wayne RooneyRooney stepped down on Friday following 18 months in charge of the RamsFormer defender Rosenior has been on Derby's coaching staff for three years Quantuma announced they've accepted Clowes Developments' bid for the club  Read more »

Dean Henderson celebrates 'most beautiful day' with Lewis Capaldi wedding performance

© Dean Henderson/Instagram Dean Henderson, Lewis Capaldi and Henderson’s wife at their wedding ceremony Manchester United goalkeeper Dean Henderson has celebrated ‘the most beautiful day’ on Instagram after he married ... Read more »

Justin Bieber is seen for the FIRST time since getting diagnosed with Ramsay Hunt syndrome as he touches down in Los Angeles with wife Hailey

Pop star Justin Bieber was seen for the first time since being diagnosed with the rare neurological disorder Ramsay Hunt syndrome with his wife Hailey earlier this month. On Sunday, the ... Read more »

Manchester United close to £69m Frenkie de Jong deal and first Erik ten Hag signing

© GETTY IMAGES Manchester United close to £69m Frenkie de Jong deal and first Erik ten Hag signing – GETTY IMAGES Manchester United are nearing the first signing of the ... Read more »

Daley Thompson gives emotional reaction to son becoming GB decathlon champion

Olympic legend Daley Thompson has told how he nearly burst with pride watching son Elliot follow in his golden spike marks. Forty six years after Britain’s greatest athlete won the ... Read more »

Player ratings as Huddersfield inflict third straight defeat over Hull KR in 2022

Hull KR slumped to a 38-6 defeat to Huddersfield Giants on Sunday afternoon. Here are the player ratings from the defeat. Lachlan Coote – Wasn’t the fullbacks day, struggled in ... Read more »

Boris Johnson looks to shore up vote with ‘red meat’ policies on Brexit and benefits, again

The Prime Minister’s closest aides have been leading outreach to Eurosceptic MPs in order to keep their support Read more »

Report: Tottenham gifted boost as 'big player' is open to Spurs move; Conte wants him

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Richarlison, Everton, Tottenham, Spurs, Premier League Everton forward Richarlison wants a move to Tottenham Hotspur this summer, according to a report from Football Insider.  The ... Read more »

Brian Laundrie's mother wrote him a letter where she 'offered to assist him' and wrote 'burn after reading this' on the envelope, lawyer for Gabby Petito's family claims

The lawyer for Gabby Petito's parents claims that Brian Laundrie's mother, Roberta Laundrie, offered to bake him a cake with a saw in it if he was arrested Riley said the letter was written after Petito's death, and before Laundrie committed suicide. It was found in the van the pair used while travelingHe also claimed that Roberta Laundrie had written 'burn after reading' on the letter's envelope'It's a pretty interesting, pretty odd letter' Riley said.Petito's family sued Laundrie's parents accusing them of assisting their son to flee after her murder. Riley suggested that the letter could offer proof Read more »

Sydney's public transport network to be thrown into chaos this week as rail workers plan four days of industrial action over Korean-built trains

Industrial action this week will likely cause mass disruptions on public transport The Rail, Tram and Bus Union is striking over new Korean built trains  Train drivers will deliberately drive slower and not operate foreign-built trains  Read more »

NASA launches its first rocket Down Under in 27 years with local Indigenous community playing a key role in the historic mission

First commercial space launch for NASA lifted off on Sunday night in AustraliaThe rocket is number one of three being launched from the Northern Territory  Arnham Space Centre was built with the help of local Aboriginal owners The launch was significantly delayed because of strong winds in the area  Read more »

Brigitte Macron goes Nordic walking with G7 wives in chic pink shirt and platform trainers

© GETTY Brigitte Macron Emmanual Macron’s wife Brigitte Macron has wowed in two very different looks since she touched down in Germany for the G7 summit. The pair emerged hand ... Read more »

Glastonbury: Thousands flock to see George Ezra at his ‘not so secret’ show

This afternoon huge crowds flocked to see George Ezra after the English singer announced that he would be performing a surprise show at Glastonbury. “SURPRISE! glastonbury see you 2pm on ... Read more »

Barcelona sets new restrictions for tourists ahead of summer holidays

© Owen Humphreys/PA Wire People on a beach in Barcelona Hundreds of thousands of Brits head to Spain for the consistently stunning weather and there’s lots to do. As Covid ... Read more »

Neil Parish: Porn scandal ex-MP had guns confiscated by police 'in case I shot myself'

The 66-year-old farmer admits he was "not feeling in the best place" having "blown up" his parliamentary career of 12 years and claims he was left to "drown" by the Tory chief whip Chris-Heaton Harris in the wake of the controversy. Read more »

Olivia Munn pushes son Malcolm in his stroller as she goes for leisurely morning walk... after John Mulaney's latest sold-out show at Madison Square Garden

Olivia Munn went for a morning stroll with her son Malcolm after attending boyfriend John Mulaney’s sold-out show at Madison Square Garden. The actress, 41, was spotted pushing her seven-month-old ... Read more »

Video: Khloe Kardashian shows off toned tummy in crop top and leggings in gym mirror selfies...after sister Kim reveals she widened 'vagina area' of SKIMS bodysuit at Khloe's request

Read more »

Two police officers killed in north Benin attack

COTONOU (Reuters) – Two police officers were killed and one wounded in an attack on a police station in northwest Benin on Sunday, police sources said, the latest in a ... Read more »

Neil Parish: Police took away my guns to stop me shooting myself

© Geoff Pugh/For the Telegraph Neil Parish said he had ‘blown up’ his parliamentary career of 12 years – Geoff Pugh/For the Telegraph Neil Parish, the former Tory MP caught ... Read more »

Video: The mastermind behind Sir Paul McCartney's virtual duet with John: As fans praise the Glastonbury performance, FEMAIL reveals how director Peter Jackson engineered it by using 'custom AI' to 'isolate Lennon's vocals'

Read more »

Video: Size matters! Justin Trudeau and Boris Johnson joke about who has the BIGGER jet... with the British PM admitting his own official plane is 'very modest'

Read more »

Child abusers will be jailed for LIFE under Tony's Law: Legislation inspired by seven-year-old boy who lost his legs due to being tortured by his parents comes into force this week - in wake of tragic deaths of little Arthur and Star

The government is introducing measures so that child abusers face longer in jailKnown as 'Tony's Law', the most serious offenders could face life behind barsTony Hudgell lost his legs due to his cruel parents who were jailed for 10 years Read more »

300 bottles of Cognac recovered from ship sunk in WWI could fetch nearly £8,000 EACH: French shipment on Swedish steamer bound for tsarist Russia ended up at bottom of the Baltic Sea after German U-boat strike

Bottles were salvaged in 2019 by a specialist Swedish team near the Baltic Sea600 bottles of cognac and 300 bottles of Benedictine were brought to shoreSwedish steamer Kyros was sunk by German submarine during First World WarNow bottles have been cleaned, refilled and are on sale for nearly £8,000 each  Read more »

Homes evacuated as huge fire sweeps through playing fields and shrubland: 80 firefighters battle blaze sending huge smoke cloud over south London

Nearly 20 people had to be evacuated due to a blaze in Norbury, south London Large fire swept over seven acres of wasteland, shrubs and school playing fieldsOver 80 firefighters were called into action with 12 engines present at the sceneThe London Fire Brigade and the Metropolitan Police are investigating the cause  Read more »

Comparing Nunez to the best U23 strikers: Haaland, Mbappe, Vlahovic…

Darwin Nunez has completed his big-money move to Liverpool this summer – but how does he compare to the  best young strikers in the world? Kylian Mbappe and Erling Haaland ... Read more »

Hill thinks Mercedes are ‘still some way off’ the pace

© PA Images Mercedes’ George Russell and Lewis Hamilton during the Canadian Grand Prix. Montreal, June 2022. Damon Hill has warned that Mercedes are still “some way off” the pace ... Read more »

Piers Morgan furiously defends Sir Paul McCartney after Glastonbury set complaints

Former Beatles bassist and musical legend Sir Paul McCartney has been slated for ‘not playing enough’ of his old band’s tunes during his appearance at Glastonbury this weekend – but ... Read more »

Antonio Conte's ideal Tottenham bench vs Southampton after Fabio Paratici transfer masterclass

© David Rogers/Getty Images Antonio Conte had little to choose from off the bench at times last season The final few months of the 2021/22 Premier League season highlighted Tottenham’s ... Read more »

Inter Milan 'must seize' Paulo Dybala when his Juventus contract runs out next week, claims ex-Nerazzurri striker Diego Milito - with forward linked to Man United, Arsenal and Spurs

Paulo Dybala scored 115 goals in 293 appearances for Juventus in seven seasonsThe 28-year-old won nine trophies with the Old Lady, including five Serie A titlesHe is set to leave the club next week after an emotional farewell in his final gameFormer Inter Milan striker Diego Milito urged his club to sign Dybala if they can  Read more »

'I couldn't be more proud': Olympic legend Daley Thompson heaps praise on his son Elliot for winning the British decathlon title in Manchester... 46 years after his father first won it!

Daley Thompson said he 'couldn't be more proud' of his son Elliot's title winElliot Thompson won the British decathlon title 46 years after his dad first didDaley heaped praise on his son for managing to step out from under his shadow After winning, Elliot Thompson has chosen to step down from full-time athletics  Read more »

Juventus 'turn down Chelsea's player-plus-cash bid for Matthijs de Ligt despite Timo Werner and Christian Pulisic being offered to them' - with Serie A giants not 'crazy' about either player as they hold firm over defender

Chelsea are eyeing up ambitious move for Juventus centre back Matthijs de LigtAs Sportsmail has revealed, De Ligt is hesitating over signing fresh terms in Italy Thomas Tuchel is set to be backed this summer, with a new defender a priorityReports say a bid including Timo Werner and Christian Pulisic has been rejected  Read more »