Voices: If we are serious about tackling the migrant crisis, we must follow Germany's example

Asia's Tech News Daily

Compassion for desperate refugees. Panic over porous borders. These conflicting emotions have both been on display in the last week. Most reasonable people will admit to feeling an element of both.

Voices: If we are serious about tackling the migrant crisis, we must follow Germany’s example
© PA Wire

A group of people thought to be migrants adrift in a dinghy in the Channel

– PA Wire

The tension between these competing instincts is far from unique to Britain and far from new. At the turn of the 20th century, there was a flow of Jewish refugees from the Russian pogroms which brought around 150,000 people to our shores. They didn’t arrive in rubber dinghies but had an equally hazardous journey across Europe. There was a political backlash. The Conservative – Balfour – government of the time brought in the Aliens’ Act (1905) to curb immigration and assert border control.

There was, in turn, a liberal backlash against the backlash. An up-and-coming Tory MP denounced the legislation and was sufficiently incensed to cross the floor to join the Liberal Party. He said that the legislation would “appeal to insular prejudice against foreigners and fan racial prejudice” and spoke in favour of “the old, tolerant and generous practices of free entry and asylum to which this country has long adhered and from which it has so far greatly gained”. This compassionate Conservative was Winston Churchill.

If Churchill is watching today’s events from above, he will doubtless be surprised to see that curbs prompted by another wave of refugees are being introduced by a Conservative home secretary of East African Asian ancestry. East African Asians prompted a comparable migrant panic when, in 1968, Kenyan Asians (who carried British passports) came to the UK after expulsion from Africa. The door was slammed by the Labour government through emergency legislation despite opposition from the Liberals, led by David Steel, and from a small group of Conservative and Labour MPs.

Shortly after, with the prospect of a fresh exodus from Uganda, the Conservative government of Edward Heath decided to emulate Churchill rather than Balfour and welcomed the refugees. Since my late wife, Olympia, was a Kenyan Asian I was caught up in the politics and the emotions of the time and saw Britain at its best and worst. The best was the genuine warmth and tolerance many British people showed. The worst was the outpouring of visceral racial hatred which drew inspiration from the speeches of Mr Enoch Powell, the Nigel Farage of his day.

Similar episodes, albeit of lower intensity, have followed, concerning refugees from the former Yugoslavia and Hong Kong. In the latter case, the British government has progressed from initial, horrified warnings of millions of destitute Chinese appearing, to a largely uncontroversial welcome following the political clamp-down by the Chinese authorities. Broadly speaking, public opinion has been positive or, at least, accommodating.

The awkward truth however is that the asylum versus migration distinction is largely meaningless in practice. Of the millions fleeing Afghanistan, it hardly matters whether the primary reason for leaving is hunger and unemployment or the attitude of the Taliban to women and criminal justice. For those caught up in the civil wars in Syria and Ethiopia or the lawlessness of Somalia, Northern Nigeria or Congo or being used as political pawns by warlords in Libya and the Belarus dictatorship, the political versus economic motivation is often a pedantic, legalistic distraction from a life – or death – struggle.

It is the sheer vastness of the potential refugee problem which excites the competing emotions of compassion and fear. It would take an exceedingly insensitive bigot to deny that those crossing in small boats are “genuine”. To take such risks is itself a sign of sheer desperation. Yet only the most other-worldly idealist would deny that politicians have a genuine problem trying to balance a limited supply of domestic resources and tolerance against an almost infinite level of need. Britain’s geography has shielded it from the much larger refugee crises being contained in camps in Pakistan and Turkey or in Greece and Italy.

Immigration and asylum is a seriously difficult area of policy for these reasons.  All things considered, Britain’s overall historic record is not too bad, though legislation currently before parliament will now make ours one of the more illiberal systems in the western world. Some countries – Japan and China, for example – have dealt with immigration by keeping the door firmly closed for essentially racist reasons. Others, despite a big capacity to absorb refugees, like Australia, have behaved appallingly with thousands imprisoned in camps on islands far away. Even the US, a country whose idea of freedom is based on its openness, has succumbed to nativist prejudice. And even those famed for their liberal democratic traditions, like the Scandinavians and the Dutch, struggle with the politics of non-European immigration.

If there is a modern success story it is Germany. The decision by Angela Merkel to admit and welcome a million Muslim Syrians was widely condemned by nationalists at the time but appears to have worked well: sufficiently so for the new “traffic light” coalition to embrace the legacy and further liberalise the immigration regime, easing the path to citizenship. If there are lessons to be learnt, they are about the importance of steady political leadership, careful planning and a conscious policy of integration. The Germans have ignored a bogus distinction between “political” and “economic” migrants, treating the Syrian war refugees as an economic resource.

So, what can be done in the UK?  First, we need some calm, public education about numbers. In the year before Covid (2019) there was total immigration of around 650,000 people and net immigration – that is, after deducting emigration – of just under half that number. A third of the arrivals came to work. Another third came to study and are not “immigrants” at all (they intend to return to their home countries) but are counted as such for bizarre statistical reasons. Refugees making asylum claims were 35,700 in 2019 (a mere 6 per cent of immigrants) and the numbers fell to 29,000 last year. More are now arriving by boat and fewer by air, train or lorry.

Second, the policy of closing legal routes to asylum has seriously and shamefully backfired. It is now virtually impossible to apply for asylum at British embassies overseas. And airlines are subject to heavy fines if they allow asylum seekers on board flights to the UK. As a consequence, refugees use more dangerous routes like the cross-Channel boats. Some relaxation of the legal routes would reduce numbers coming by this treacherous route. We should also welcome people who can be useful: Iranian engineers or Kurdish entrepreneurs, such as the family of Mr Nadim Zahawi, the current education secretary.

To keep up to speed with all the latest opinions and comment sign up to our free weekly Voices newsletter by clicking here

Third, trying to control our borders while spurning cooperation with France is simply silly. There are people smugglers on both sides of the Channel. And anyone who has tried to get cooperation from a French official by shouting at them loudly in English knows that there will only be one winner: the French official. It is also doubtful if those voters who are genuinely worried about border control are likely to be convinced by childish chauvinism. Of course, the French are also behaving badly. But we need them at least as much as they need us.

Fourth, there are basic issues of competence. I don’t believe that the German people are more generous than ours or that their politicians are more enlightened. But the Germans expect efficiency. The British Home Office by contrast is a disgrace (a judgement based not just on recent events but 20 years dealing with casework as an MP). We are currently seeing a Phase 2 Windrush disaster in the compensation system; virtually no progress in setting up an Afghan Resettlement programme; regular endless, inhumane, delays in the deportation system; and breakdowns in the electronic gates at Heathrow causing massive delays. Replacing the incumbent home secretary with a competent alternative might help on all fronts.

Meanwhile, since the prime minister idolises Winston Churchill, he would do well to suspend his populist clown act, and instead emulate the great man who fought for “tolerant and generous practices” in the face of a migrant panic over a century ago. 

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Here's everything we know about the Steam Deck's specs

© Provided by Dot Esports Valve unveiled today its new portable gaming console, the Steam Deck, and while it has a similar look to a Switch or PlayStation Portable, it’s ... Read more »

Dancing on Ice's Liberty Poole strips to lace underwear in fake tan demonstration ahead of show debut

DANCING on Ice's Liberty Poole stripped to her lace underwear while preparing for the ITV show. The Love Island star applied her fake tan in a video ahead of her ... Read more »

Man, 24, is arrested over death of five-month-old girl who was found in cardiac arrest at house in Sheffield before Christmas

Man has been arrested following the tragic death of five-month-old baby Avery Officers were called to the Intake area of Sheffield on December 18 at 9.54amAvery was found in cardiac arrest and taken to hospital where she tragically died The 24-year-old was arrested in connection with her death and released on bail  Read more »

Video: It's not a gap, it's a GULF! Manchester City show they are on a different planet to Chelsea in terms of playing, planning and power as runaway Premier League leaders extinguish Thomas Tuchel's title challenge

Read more »

One in five people try dentistry at home including pulling out their own TEETH amid staff crisis at surgeries, report shows

Report reveals millions of Britons are missing out on professional care they need Problem is being fuelled by growing number of practitioners giving up NHS workThe deepening crisis has led to one in five people treating themselves at home  Read more »

Giants GM candidates have mixed histories of identifying franchise quarterbacks

If the Giants knew for certain which of their nine candidates for general manager can identify a franchise quarterback, the search could be called off. Too bad it’s the trickiest ... Read more »

Juvenile sent to hospital after shooting on East 83rd Terrace in Raytown, police say

A juvenile was sent to a hospital Sunday afternoon after being shot in Raytown, according to police. Officers responded to a call of shots fired about 3:45 p.m. at a ... Read more »

Kelly Rizzo Mourns 'Sweet Husband' Bob Saget After His Funeral: 'How Lucky Was I'

© Provided by People Jason LaVeris/FilmMagic Kelly Rizzo is opening up about her late husband Bob Saget after laying him to rest Friday. Rizzo, 42, spoke out about her loss ... Read more »

Jonah Hill Makes It Very Clear He Has No Beef With Baby Yoda: We ‘Text at Least Once a Week'

© Provided by TheWrap Jonah Hill Baby Yoda Jonah Hill may not have cared much about watching “The Mandalorian” but make no mistake — he’s very good friends with Grogu ... Read more »

Australia, New Zealand step up efforts to aid tsunami-hit Tonga

© Reuters/HANDOUT Handout image shows a plume rises over Tonga when the underwater volcano Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai erupted in this satellite image taken by Himawari-8 By Renju Jose and Praveen ... Read more »

NARCL chief Pradip Shah, Egon Zehnder to look for RBL CEO

© Provided by The Times of India TNN Mumbai: The RBL Bank board has appointed Pradip Shah, chairman of National Asset Reconstruction Company (NARCL), as an external expert to work ... Read more »

Most recast loans on track: HDFC Bk

© Provided by The Times of India TNN Mumbai: HDFC Bank, which reported a record net profit of Rs 10,342 crore for the quarter ended December 2021, has said that ... Read more »

Everyone Has Same Message For Jerry Jones On Sunday

AT&T Stadium, home to the Dallas Cowboys, is one of the finest stadiums in all of sports. However, it has one glaring issue – pun intended. © Provided by The ... Read more »

Outlook 2022: Trends in the education landscape

© Provided by The Financial Express Thus, programmes on skilling, reskilling and upskilling are taking centre-stage to minimise the gap and align with industry demands, while promoting the ‘learn and ... Read more »

In UP, politics is second career for many bureaucrats, cops

© Provided by The Times of India LUCKNOW: When ex-IPS officer Asim Arun and former IAS officer Ram Bahadur formally joined BJP on Sunday, the development marked a conspicuous trend ... Read more »

India@2047: Govt's plan with focus on ease of living likely to be ready by May

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Centre is readying an action plan for India@2047, when the country will complete 100 years of independence with 10 sectoral group ... Read more »

78% bankers see frauds rising in 2 years: Survey

© Provided by The Times of India TNN Mumbai: Around 78% of bankers expect frauds to increase over the next two years because of the current business disruption due to ... Read more »

Banks' e-biz ambitions set to face talent crunch

© Provided by The Times of India Mumbai: Banks are set to face a major challenge in finding talent to meet their digital ambitions. While banks have the resources to ... Read more »

Budget must give capex a boost

© Provided by The Financial Express New-project-starts in the December 2021 quarter, stood at Rs 1.9 lakh crore, more or less in line with the amounts seen in the previous ... Read more »

'Cashless treatment' scheme for NH crash victims set for launch

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) has invited bids from insurance companies for the roll-out of “cashless treatment” scheme for ... Read more »

Farrah Abraham involved in altercation at Los Angeles club

© Bang Showbiz Farrah Abraham has been involved in an altercation Farrah Abraham was arrested on Saturday (15.01.22) for allegedly slapping a security guard. The 30-year-old star was at the ... Read more »

Video: Aussies are using this kitchen gadget to perfectly spread butter on bread EVERY time 

Read more »

Video: American expat is shocked over his mate's way of peeling a boiled egg: 'Is this an Australian thing?'

Read more »

Video: Ben Affleck eats croissant and holds hands with son Samuel at the Brentwood Farmers' Market

Read more »

Nick Bosa suffers possible head injury against Cowboys

The San Francisco 49ers got a significant scare Sunday when Nick Bosa suffered an apparent injury against the Dallas Cowboys. © Tim Heitman-USA TODAY Sports Nick Bosa was the Niners? ... Read more »

Four Quarterbacks the Eagles Can Acquire to Replace Jalen Hurts

The Philadelphia Eagles were bounced from the playoffs on Sunday thanks to a 31-15 loss to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. One thing that became clear throughout that game is that ... Read more »

NFL World Reacts To The Nick Bosa Injury News

The Dallas Cowboys lost star pass rusher Micah Parsons for a couple of plays early in the first half against the San Francisco 49ers. Parsons had a rough collision in ... Read more »

Nick Bosa injury update: 49ers star leaves Wild Card game after big collision

49ers star defensive end Nick Bosa was forced to the sidelines with a head/neck injury after a scary collision in the Wild Card game against the Cowboys. © Provided by ... Read more »

Carjacking suspect who escaped cops turns himself in after three days on lam

Akeem Williams found his way out of the handcuffs, fleeing the area. Paul Martinka A suspected carjacker who escaped from a Brooklyn hospital while in NYPD custody surrendered Saturday after ... Read more »

Tonga turned into ‘moonscape' by ash from ‘once-in-millennium' volcanic eruption

Ash from an erupted underwater volcano has made Tonga look “like a moonscape,” according to residents of the Pacific island. Particles emitted by the eruption of the Hunga-Tonga-Hunga-Ha’apai volcano – ... Read more »

NFL World Reacts To Trevon Diggs' Performance Today

Even some of the best in the game get got sometimes. That was certainly the case on Sunday for Cowboys Pro Bowl corner Trevon Diggs. © Provided by The Spun ... Read more »

College Football World Reacts To The Texas Transfer News

The 2021 college football season wasn’t exactly a memorable one for first-year head coach Steve Sarkisian. But 2022 might be a lot better on offense after the big transfer the ... Read more »

Texas attack: Hostage-taker identified as Blackburn man Malik Faisal Akram

UK counter-terrorism officers are working with authorities in the US after a British hostage-taker was shot dead after an hours-long stand-off at a synagogue. The man has been identified as ... Read more »

Walmart is getting serious about the metaverse

© Photo by Yichuan Cao / NurPhoto via Getty Images Walmart’s recent trademark applications suggest that it wants to break into the metaverse. Walmart appears to be getting ready for ... Read more »

Atalanta knüpft Inter Mailand einen Punkt ab

© KEYSTONE/EPA/PAOLO MAGNI Remo Freuler holt mit Atalanta Bergamo einen Punkt gegen Meister Inter Mailand. Milan könnte nun am Montag zum Profiteur werden. Inter Mailand hat in der 22. Runde ... Read more »

IAN LADYMAN: Antonio Conte needs to quit moaning and do his job at Tottenham… plus, Romelu Lukaku will have to earn his confidence back - and Man United players are not impressed with their new coaches

Antonio Conte has been complaining about the standard of his Spurs squad The Italian has asked Chairman Daniel Levy for financial backing in January However, he's likely to face opposition from Levy after Spurs' summer spendingRomelu Lukaku needs love to thrive at Chelsea but has to prove he deserves it  Read more »

Will China's zero-Covid crackdown ruin the Olympics? As Omicron variant tears through the country, a draconian response from the hardline government fuels fears pandemic could hit sporting spectacular

Omicron Covid variant is spreading in China ahead of Beijing Winter Olympics Case recorded on Saturday involving woman who had not left city for two weeksBeijing residents have been urged to stay at home for Chinese New YearFears over ‘green, safe and simple’ Games demanded by President  Xi Jinping Read more »

Robin Goodfellow's Racing Tips: Best bets for Monday, January 17

Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Monday’s meetings at Wolverhampton, Chepstow and Fakenham. Sportsmail’s racing expert Robin Goodfellow dishes out his tips for Monday’s meetings CHEPSTOW ROBIN ... Read more »

Test mit kühleren Heizdecken - Problem Reifen-Luftdruck und Temperatur

© Motorsport Images Die Formel 1 ist die einzige größere Rennserie weltweit, in der Heizdecken noch erlaubt sind. Doch auch in der Königsklasse sind die Tage der Reifenwärmer gezählt. Die ... Read more »

Remote job postings for NYC firms nearly quadruple in seismic shift

Remote work positions from New York City businesses have quadrupled in the past year, according to data. Getty Images New York City firms offered nearly quadruple the number of remote ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic