Voices: At the first hissing of the taxpaying goose, Rishi Sunak has turned and fled

Voices: At the first hissing of the taxpaying goose, Rishi Sunak has turned and fled
© PA Wire

Rishi Sunak, pretending a public spending rise is a tax cut (Victoria Jones/PA)

– PA Wire

Rishi Sunak has a slick press operation. The front-page lead headline in The Daily Express on Wednesday read: “Rishi: my actions prove I’m a low-tax Tory.” And a similar message led The Times today: “Sunak plan to slash taxes.”

It’s so slick, it looks desperate. The one thing the chancellor’s actions do not “prove” is that he believes in lower taxes. “Actions speak louder than words,” he told the Express, claiming that spending more public money on universal credit amounted to “cutting taxes for millions of the lowest paid people”.

This is redefining the meaning of words so blatantly it would make the prime minister blush. He is paying more universal credit to claimants in work, so that they keep more of their benefit as their earnings rise. The rate at which benefit is withdrawn works like a tax rate, meaning that claimants now keep 45p of each extra pound they earn, instead of 37p, but it is not a tax cut. It is a welfare spending increase.

It may be a welcome policy change – although it is no substitute for the temporary rise in the basic rate of universal credit, which applied to people both in and out of work and which has now ended – but it is not a tax cut.

Unabashed, Sunak has launched another assault on the intelligence of the electorate today. According to The Times, he has “told officials to draw up detailed plans to reduce the tax burden”, which he wants to do before the next election.

Again, this involves Johnsonian levels of chutzpah. This is a chancellor who has announced huge tax rises over the next two years, but before they have even come into effect he now says he wants to cut taxes.

What is worse is that he wants to cut taxes that bear more heavily on the better-off – income tax, the higher rate of income tax and inheritance tax – while the tax that is actually going up next year, national insurance, is less progressive.

If he really thinks he could cut taxes significantly in 2024, the likely election year, he shouldn’t be putting up taxes so much in 2022 and 2023. It not only looks like cheap election bribery, it looks like poor fiscal planning too.

It might be different if Sunak said he had to put up taxes to regain control of the public finances after the coronavirus emergency, but if the economy bounced back faster than expected, he would ease the burden slightly. That is what was implied in the Budget, and it would be the fiscally responsible position. Politically, however, it would mean that he is a tax-raiser first and a tax-cutter only if and when prudent.

That is not the message the Conservative Party – or indeed the country – wants to hear. Sunak got away with his first big tax rise because it was remote. In his first Budget in March this year, he announced a rise in the corporation tax rate from 19 per cent to 25 per cent, to take effect in April 2023. Because it seemed a long way off and no one thinks of taxes on “corporations” as affecting them, there was hardly any hissing from the taxpaying goose – although it is a huge amount of money that will mainly come from customers and employees.

Sunak must have thought he was the new Jean Baptiste Colbert, Louis XIV’s finance minister, who said: “The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing.”

Thus he was emboldened to take the next step, agreeing with Boris Johnson and Sajid Javid, the health secretary, that national insurance contributions should go up to pay for clearing the NHS backlog (with a bit of ill-advised window-dressing on social care tacked on). This time, the goose hissed violently. The rise doesn’t come in until April next year but the chancellor has already taken fright.

To keep up to speed with all the latest opinions and comment sign up to our free weekly Voices Dispatches newsletter by clicking here

Liz Truss, the foreign secretary and Sunak’s rival for the post-Johnson succession, criticised the tax rise in the cabinet meeting that approved it (along with Jacob Rees-Mogg and Lord Frost). Just as Sunak responded to Truss posing in a tank in Estonia on Tuesday by being photographed with Gurkhas yesterday, he is now trying to outdo her as a “low-tax Tory”.

This is a foolish and panicky response. Sunak’s high standing is the product of his calm and responsible handling of the coronavirus crisis. He did the right thing by borrowing vast sums of money to keep people in jobs, but the British people knew that there would be a price to pay later. They may not like the big tax rise when it cuts their pay in April, but they know it is a choice that cannot be dodged.

Sunak is making a mistake in such a transparent pitch to the low-tax dreamers of the Conservative leadership selectorate. Both groups – the MPs who draw up the shortlist of two candidates and the party members who choose between them – would be more impressed by a chancellor who took tough decisions and defended them. Instead, Sunak has tried to disown his own policy and pretend to be something he self-evidently is not. It is time for him to say boo to a goose.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

News Related


Go First Airlines announces Republic Day 2022 offers, flight tickets at only Rs 926

© Provided by Zee News Go First Airlines Republic Day Offer: Good news for those travelling by air. Like the festive season, Republic Day has also become a sale event ... Read more »

BBC The Responder viewers completely divided after first episode with some moaning they can't understand the accents or spot a storyline

The BBC’s eagerly awaited new drama starring Martin Freeman as a morally compromised Scouse police officer in Liverpool began on Monday (January 24) night. Martin Freeman, who is best known ... Read more »

INTERVIEW: Aanand L Rai on Atrangi Re, gauging OTT success & more: ‘I was selling my most complicated story'

On December 24, Aanand L Rai’s directorial, Atrangi Re, with Sara Ali Khan, Dhanush and Akshay Kumar premiered on the digital world and the content sparked multiple conversations on social ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel's tactical tweaks give air to Chelsea's wings

It is customary for any great trilogy to feature some sort of redemption, revenge, or at least a fitting finale. In truth, the clinical nature of Chelsea’s three victories over ... Read more »

Andhra employees association submit indefinite strike notice beginning February 6

Andhra employees association submit indefinite strike notice beginning February 6 Union leaders under Pay Revision Commission (PRC) Sadhana Samithi served an indefinite strike notice to the Andhra Pradesh government announcing ... Read more »

'Pick up the phone, talk to each other. Put country before yourself': Kapil Dev wants Kohli and BCCI to bury the hatchet

© Provided by Hindustan Times Kapil Dev wants BCCI and Virat Kohli to put the recent captaincy controversy behind them and move forward.  (Getty Images) Former India captain Kapil Dev ... Read more »

England's Eddie Jones tips Steven Gerrard for coaching stardom - 'He's very impressive'

It’s nothing new for England rugby coach Eddie Jones to glean wisdom from his peers between competitions, and Aston Villa ‘s Steven Gerrard is the latest to catch the Australian’s ... Read more »

7 Effective Astrological Tips for Bliss And Success in Your Love Life

© Astroyogi.com 7 Effective Astrological Tips for Bliss And Success in Your Love Life Ah, how beautiful is love! You have to agree that love can make life so much ... Read more »

'Set to undergo surgery' - Hay shares more LUFC injury news; ‘outstanding' talent's season over

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Mateusz Bogusz in action for Leeds Leeds United youngster Mateusz Bogusz has suffered a cruciate ligament injury during his loan spell at Ibiza, as The ... Read more »

UPSC ESE 2022: Prelims exam schedule out at upsc.gov.in; check details here

© Provided by Firstpost UPSC ESE 2022: Prelims exam schedule out at upsc.gov.in; check details here The timetable for the Engineering Services Examination (ESE) prelims 2022 has been released by ... Read more »

Eight people reportedly dead after crush at Africa Cup of Nations match

A minimum of eight people have died as a result of a crush prior to Cameroon vs Comoros at the African Cup of Nations, according to reports. Cameroon had been ... Read more »

Mounting concern as Russia to hold ‘war games' off southwest coast of Ireland

The Minister for Foreign Affairs has accused the Russian Ambassador to Ireland of ‘downplaying the significance’ of a planned military exercise by the Russians off Ireland’s southwest coast. It comes ... Read more »

'Work of Art': Rare Pristine Coral Reef Discovered in Tahiti

© Provided by News18 ‘Work of Art’: Rare Pristine Coral Reef Discovered in Tahiti In a rare find, a research team supported by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural ... Read more »

Shilpa Shetty-Richard Gere Kissing Case: Court Calls Actress 'Victim' In Obscenity Case, Grants Her Relief

© Provided by News18 Almost 15 years after Shilpa Shetty landed in an obscenity case Richard Gere kissed her in a public event, the actress was discharged from the case ... Read more »

Priti Patel's immigration bill will ‘all but destroy' main safe and legal route for refugees, charity warns

© Getty Images The Nationality and Borders Bill seeks to penalise asylum seekers who arrive in the UK via unauthorised routes by limiting their family reunion rights – Getty Thousands ... Read more »

LPGA Q-Series 'like walking on a tight rope'

© Getty Meghan MacLaren narrowly missed out on securing her LPGA Tour card last month The first full-field event of the LPGA Tour season takes place this week at the ... Read more »

IPL 2022: South Africa sends proposal to BCCI to host T20 League, says report

© Provided by Zee News The 15th edition of the Indian Premier League (IPL) in 2022 is just a couple of months away and Cricket South Africa (CSA) have thrown ... Read more »

German firms fear supply chain pain from China's battle with Omicron

FILE PHOTO: Workers stand at a residential area under lockdown following COVID-19 outbreak in Xian By Christian Kraemer BERLIN (Reuters) – German companies doing business in China are worried the ... Read more »

Australian Open: 'Where is Peng Shuai?' T-shirts now allowed after backlash

Tennis stars joined in the criticism after footage emerged on Sunday of a woman being intercepted at Melbourne Park wearing a shirt with an image of Peng on the front and the message "Where is Peng Shuai?" on the back. Read more »

Selin Kiazim's recipe for butter beans, paprika and piquillo peppers

Simple, quick and bursting with flavour, you’ll find most of this dish’s ingredients in your store cupboard I love this recipe and others of its kind because it’s simple, quick ... Read more »

Prem Bandini: Ekta Kapoor approaches Anchal Sahu to play the lead role in the new show?

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com TV czarina Ekta Kapoor is all set to entertain viewers with her upcoming new shows. Well, a few days ago there were reports that Ekta is ... Read more »

For the love of craft: Dibyendu recalls bleaching his hair for 'Looop Lapeta'

© IANS Dibyendu Bhattacharya. Mumbai, Jan 25 (IANS) Actor Dibyendu Bhattacharya, who will be soon seen in the upcoming comedy thriller ‘Looop Lapeta’, bleached his hair for his part in ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra Jonas Having A Daughter Via Surrogacy Is None Of Your Business

A few days ago, Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Nick Jonas broke the internet with the arrival of their baby via surrogacy. They took it to their Instagram handles and wrote ... Read more »

North Korea Conducts Cruise Missile Test, Its Fifth This Year: Report

© Provided by News18 North Korea Conducts Cruise Missile Test, Its Fifth This Year: Report South Korea on Tuesday said that it detected two cruise missiles into the sea off ... Read more »

Soha Ali Khan wishes Kunal Kemmu on 7th anniversary, reveals what makes them the perfect match

Soha Ali Khan and Kunal Kemmu are celebrating 7 years of marriage. Soha Ali Khan and Kunal Kemmu make an adorable couple. The two are clocked in seven years of ... Read more »

Pokémon Masters EX update teases upcoming events and new Sync Pairs

© Provided by Dot Esports Game producers Yu Sasaki and Tetsuya Iguchi today shared their latest dev blog for Pokémon Masters EX and it has provided players a glimpse of ... Read more »

Adivi Sesh-starrer 'Major' postponed due to Covid

© IANS Major. Mumbai, Jan 25 (IANS) Makers of ‘Major’ starring Adivi Sesh have announced the postponement of their film, after the new regulations about curfews and restrictions have been ... Read more »

Le Mans Virtual Series von Motorsport Games wird von mehr als 81 Millionen Fans verfolgt

© Motor1.com Deutschland Motorsport Games’ Le Mans Virtual Series followed by more than 81 million fans Die fünf Runden der Le Mans Virtual Series 2021/2022, die am vergangenen Wochenende mit ... Read more »

Alfa-SUV erwischt - erste Daten und Debüt bekannt - Alfa Romeo Tonale (2022)

Präsentiert wurde der Alfa Romeo Tonale als Studie in Genf 2019. Zu den Händlern rollt der kleine Alfa-SUV nach vielen Verzögerungen ab Mitte 2022. Sein Debüt als Serienmodell gibt der ... Read more »

Coin Master free spins and coins links (January 25, 2022)

© Provided by GamePur The main objective of Coin Master is building your village by spinning a slot machine and collecting coins to buy upgrades. Additionally, you can raid and ... Read more »

From Aparna Yadav to Imran Masood to Harak Singh Rawat: Curious Case of Party Hoppers Awaiting Tickets

© Provided by News18 From Aparna Yadav to Imran Masood to Harak Singh Rawat: Curious Case of Party Hoppers Awaiting Tickets Jumping parties just before elections is an old phenomenon ... Read more »

Weltraumteleskop «James Webb» erreicht Zielorbit

© keystone James Webb © keystone James Webb Rund einen Monat nach dem Start ins All hat das Weltraumteleskop «James Webb» nach Angaben der US-Raumfahrtbehörde Nasa seinen Zielorbit erreicht. «Webb, ... Read more »

Diese 6 Schnitte sind jetzt Trend - Männerfrisuren 2022

© James Barr / Unsplash.com Die besten Männerfrisuren 2022 Nicht zu verachten, wenn es um deinen individuellen Look geht, ist die Frage: Was hast du auf dem Kopf? Nein, keinen ... Read more »

Supreme Court notices to Centre, Election Commission on PIL against poll freebies

© Provided by The Financial Express A bench comprising Chief Justice N V Ramana and Justices A S Bopanna and Hima Kohli sought the response in four weeks on the ... Read more »

ANC MP Dirks wants court to declare his suspension unlawful and unconstitutional

© parliament.gov.za FILE: Mervyn Dirks. CAPE TOWN – African National Congress (ANC) member of Parliament (MP) Mervyn Dirks wants the Western Cape High Court to declare his suspension unlawful and ... Read more »

TOWIE's Cara is pregnant with third child following ectopic pregnancy

Photo credit: Instagram/carakilbey The Only Way is Essex star Cara Kilbey has announced that she is expecting her third child. The reality TV personality is already a mum to a ... Read more »

Asian shares decline amid omicron, Fed, Ukraine jitters

The Associated PressA currency trader watches monitors at the foreign exchange dealing room of the KEB Hana Bank headquarters in Seoul, South Korea, Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2022. Asian shares skidded ... Read more »

77 years after Auschwitz, Jews honor those who rescued them

The Associated PressThe 93-year-old Polish citizen Andrzej Sitkowski, who was named “Righteous Among the Nations” by Yad Vashem in 1995 talks to the Associated Press during an interview in Durach, ... Read more »

Emmerdale's Dawn left alarmed as character returns amid doomed wedding fears

Emmerdale spoilers tease a big return next week on the ITV soap, that leaves Dawn Taylor panicked. Dawn is looking forward to her upcoming wedding to Billy Fletcher but it’s ... Read more »

‘We will regret this', ‘Nightmare' – These Derby County fans react as transfer update shared

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Peterborough United v Derby County Festy Ebosele is set to leave Derby County before the transfer deadline with plenty of interest in ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic