Voices: After a good week for Labour, Keir Starmer still needs to tell people why they should vote for him

Voices: After a good week for Labour, Keir Starmer still needs to tell people why they should vote for him
© UK Parliament/PA

Labour leader Keir Starmer during Prime Minister’s Questions in the House of Commons

– UK Parliament/PA

All in all, it’s been a pretty good week for Keir Starmer. He forced through his front bench reshuffle, ruffling some feathers in the process, but ultimately managing to stamp his authority on the party.

He got in some good jabs as the government’s continuing problems with sleaze, laissez faire Covid rule breaking (that Downing Street party), and its chronic incompetence created yet more negative headlines.

If the Bexley & Sidcup by-election didn’t produce an earthquake, Labour at least put a dent in the Tory majority with a 10 per cent swing. Most voters, however, stayed home. Which perhaps ought to give Starmer pause.

Sure, Bexley & Sidcup is bluer than a desert sky. Even a tanker full of magic Heineken probably wasn’t going to allow Starmer to find common ground with enough voters for Labour to win the seat. But more could surely have been done to make that dent deeper, by persuading some of the waverers to at least stop off at the polling booth on their way back from Sainsbury’s.

Nationally, the polls say it’s neck and neck. Starmer faces a government of historic incompetence, mired in sleaze, with a joke of a prime minister who burbles on about Peppa Pig when speaking to business leaders. It’s a godawful mess, one of historic proportions. A steaming pile of horse manure. But Starmer can’t get a lead.

The Labour leader looks… well, he at least looks competent. Like someone who’d do a better job, although that isn’t exactly hard to accomplish. But he’s not (yet) moving the needle to anything like the extent that he needs to. It’s going to take more to tempt an electorate that views Labour with a mixture of suspicion and puzzlement.

I’m not sure Starmer necessarily needs to spell out too many policies, at least not yet. A friend pointed out a big problem with the party’s approach to social care, which has also been picked up by my esteemed colleague John Rentoul. It amounts to beating up the government’s admittedly dismal policy, which would protect rich home owners in the south sitting on fat piles of equity at the expense of those in the north. People who, say, bought their council houses. Most of the value of their homes would be gobbled up under the Tory plan.

Boris Johnson’s response to Starmer’s complaints is: “At least we have a plan.” The thing is, Starmer knows that anything he proposes will leave someone – whose vote he might need – losing out. His plan will get picked apart, gutted and hung as a millstone around his neck.

Theresa May torpedoed her majority, in part by putting forward a social care plan, which was given this treatment. So it’s best for Starmer to duck that one, even if he doesn’t look good by doing so.

But there are things Labour could do. Set out some principles. Make it known how life would be better under Prime Minister Starmer. Perhaps try a little radicalism on for size.

Building links with business is a good idea, but business shouldn’t dictate the agenda. So, yes, talk more about dignity at work, fair pay and employment rights. Be pragmatic about public ownership. Recognise that the left has some good ideas so if, for example, fully nationalising the railways (a popular policy) makes things work better for Britain, say you’ll do it.

Sorry. I know that sentence contains something that looks dangerously like one of those vomit-inducing slogans. But then, vomit-inducing slogans can work quite well. “Get Brexit Done” – even though it hasn’t been – explains why we are where we are.

To keep up to speed with all the latest opinions and comment sign up to our free weekly Voices Dispatches newsletter by clicking here

The fact that an away day with Germany’s Social Democratic Party (SPD) was recently held is a good sign. The SPD was faced with a much better, more competent, sensible and serious opponent than Labour is. And yet the party pulled up its socks and won.

It didn’t do that by hoping the Christian Democrats would just drop the ball after the departure of Angela Merkel. Olaf Scholz had a message that resonated, which he repeated ad infinitum. He had themes. It also didn’t hurt that the SPD abandoned the infighting which had plagued the party.

This helped lure enough former CDU voters to make the SPD the leading partner in German’s coalition, which is something Labour is also probably going to get its head around even if Starmer does decide to can the caution and be bolder. Which he needs to do.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Parakram Diwas 2022: PM Narendra Modi Pays Tributes to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on his 125th Birth Anniversary

Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Birth Anniversary: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday led the nation in paying tributes to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose on his 125th birth anniversary. Taking to ... Read more »

62% Maharashtra parents don't want to send kids to school from 24 Jan, says LocalCircles survey

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: Nearly two-thirds of parents of Maharashtra’s school children are unwilling to send them for classes, after the state government Thursday announced their reopening ... Read more »

Two outfits move SC for probe into hate speech against Hindus

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Ten days after the Supreme Court entertained a plea for probe into Dharam Sansad hate speech and stringent action against hate ... Read more »

Is Omicron ‘subvariant' more virulent? Concerns over BA.2 as India reports 530 samples to GISAID

© Provided by Hindustan Times The UK Health Security Agency has designated the Omicron variant sub-lineage as a variant under investigation. (HT Photo/Representative Image) British health authorities have identified hundreds ... Read more »

Bill Maher pushes back against blindly following advice of Dr. Fauci

HBO talk show host Bill Maher took aim at Anthony Fauci and other medical experts over their ever-changing COVID guidance during the pandemic. ‘Don’t sit there in your white coat ... Read more »

ICC Under 19 World Cup 2022: Angkrish Raghuvanshi, Raj Bawa Centuries Set up Big Win for India; Pakistan Thrash PNG

© Provided by News18 ICC Under 19 World Cup 2022: Angkrish Raghuvanshi, Raj Bawa Centuries Set up Big Win for India; Pakistan Thrash PNG Raj Bawa and opener Angkrish Raghuvanshi ... Read more »

Vivek Oberoi - The good guy show

© Provided by Mid-Day Proceeds from Vivek Anand Oberoi’s first production venture, Verses of War will be donated to charity, says the actor who announced it on Indian Army Day ... Read more »

Shehnaaz Gill, Nia Sharma, Nakuul Mehta — These 5 TV stars set Instagram on fire this week

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com It is that time of the week when we bring to you the best of Instagram posts from your fave TV stars. Shehnaaz Gill is back ... Read more »

The aurora hunters who chase the Northern Lights

Some people are prepared to stand for hours in the freezing cold on a winter’s night to watch and capture the Northern Lights. Meet the aurora hunters. Michelle Cumming has ... Read more »

Officials relocate hoping never to commute again

Civil servants have bought houses in Cornwall and the Cotswolds ‘gambling’ that they will never have to return to the office. Government sources last night said a number of Whitehall ... Read more »

Female inmates piling on so much weight they are breaking toilet seats

Prisoners are piling on so much weight inside they are constantly breaking toilet seats. Inspectors at HMP Downview in South London said that a ‘large proportion’ of the 210 female inmates ... Read more »

New York shootings an early test for former cop-turned-mayor

© Ed JONES The taped-off area marking the scene of a shooting in Harlem, New York is seen on January 22, 2022 Gun violence has rocked the first three weeks ... Read more »

NWSL Board of Governors approves structural changes of Washington Soccer Properties; Y. Michele Yang's shares

© Provided by CBS Sports The National Women’s Soccer League Board of Governors announced their unanimous approval of changes to the structure and makeup of Washington Soccer Properties ownership group ... Read more »

The Bengals' rookie kicker called his shot before nailing a 52-yard field goal and a trip to the AFC Championship

© Wesley Hitt/Getty Images Bengals kicker Evan McPherson. Wesley Hitt/Getty Images Bengals kicker Evan McPherson hit a 52-yard field goal to send Cincinnati to the AFC Championship. The rookie called ... Read more »

Buccaneers activate Leonard Fournette ahead of divisional matchup with Rams

“Playoff Lenny” is back. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers officially activated running back Leonard Fournette off injured reserve on Saturday, which made him available for Sunday’s divisional matchup with the Los ... Read more »

The Masked Singer fans all say the same thing about Doughnut after spotting clue

THE Masked Singer fans have all come to the same conclusion about Dougnut’s hidden identity after spotting a major clue.  Viewers of the beloved ITV singing show have been frantically ... Read more »

Christian Eriksen expected to sign for Brentford in the next 72 hours

Christian Eriksen is expected to complete a sensational return to the Premier League and sign for Brentford in the next three days, according to reports. The former Tottenham midfielder has ... Read more »

The night Lesley Manville tackled a gaggle of rowdy teens at theatre

She is well known for her presence on stage but Lesley Manville can also make her mark as a member of an audience – as a group of rowdy teenagers ... Read more »

Dune's Denis Villeneuve Provides An Update On The Sequel

© Provided by CinemaBlend Timothee Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson in Dune No one would blame Denis Villeneuve if he wanted to take a step back and relish in Dune’s momentous ... Read more »

MI6 uncovered plot to install a pro-Moscow puppet leader in Ukraine

British intelligence has discovered a plan by Russian President Vladimir Putin to install a pro-Moscow puppet leader in Ukraine, Foreign Secretary Liz Truss revealed yesterday. As Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky ... Read more »

Light rainfall lashes parts of Delhi-NCR on Sunday morning, IMD predicts more showers

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Delhi continued to receive light rainfall on Sunday (January 23, 2022) as the Met department expected that the minimum temperature is likely to ... Read more »

Full dress rehearsal for Republic Day 2022: Traffic advisory issued by Delhi Police, check blocked routes here

© Provided by DNA According to the traffic advisory, the full-dress rehearsal for R-Day parade will start from Vijay Chowk and will proceed to National Stadium According to a traffic advisory ... Read more »

Former Trump campaign adviser acknowledges being part of 2020 'alternate electors' plot

Boris Epshteyn, an adviser for former President Donald Trump’s 2020 presidential campaign, acknowledged Friday that he was part of the effort to prop up so-called “alternate electors” to support Trump ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel prices today: Rates unchanged on 23 January, check here what you need to pay in your city

© Provided by Firstpost Petrol, diesel prices today: Rates unchanged on 23 January, check here what you need to pay in your city Petrol and diesel prices remained unchanged in ... Read more »

'Public spirited' persons outraged selectively over Tripura violence: State to SC

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: The BJP-ruled Tripura government on Saturday told the Supreme Court that the so-called public spirited persons are setting a dangerous precedent ... Read more »

Edu gifted perfect chance to sign Portugal star in cut-price Arsenal deal amid contract standoff

Arsenal are on red alert after it has emerged that their transfer target Renato Sanches has reportedly confirmed he is ready to leave Lille. According to SportItalia, the French champions ... Read more »

Bakers seek increase in bread prices amid spike in flour cost

Bakers seek increase in bread prices amid spike in flour cost If flour prices continue to spike, bakers may have no other choice but to likewise increase bread prices. According ... Read more »

A new law lets Illinois homeowners remove racist language from deeds, including clauses saying a house can never be sold to Black or Jewish people

© JHU Sheridan Libraries/Gado/Getty Images A 1910 image of the Roland Park/Guilford neighborhood of Baltimore. The neighborhood was segregated, and is considered an early example of the enforcement of racial ... Read more »

Quezon City warns vs counterfeit vax cards

© The STAR/Michael Varcas, file Quezon City warns vs counterfeit vax cards MANILA, Philippines — The Quezon City government has issued a warning against people who sell and use fake ... Read more »

New Zealand adds new COVID restrictions as omicron spreads

The Associated PressNew Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern speaks about the COVID-19 situation while visiting New Plymouth on Thursday, Jan. 20, 2022. New Zealand is among the few remaining countries ... Read more »

Queensland reports 10 COVID deaths, 11,947 new cases on Sunday

Queensland has recorded 10 more deaths from COVID-19 and 11,947 new infections, Health Minister Yvette D’Ath says. There were 863 people in hospital with COVID across the state as of ... Read more »

Everything We Know About HBO’s The Last Of Us TV Show

Movies based on video games don’t have the best track record, but TV shows based on video games still have a relatively clean slate. There’s an endless number of video ... Read more »

Uttarakhand Elections 2022: Cong releases first list of 53 candidate; name of Harish Rawat missing

© Provided by Jagran English Dehradun | Jagran Politics Desk: A month before the polling, the Congress on Saturday night released its first list of 53 candidates for the crucial ... Read more »

Covid jabs to be commercially available by 2023

VACCINE czar Carlito Galvez Jr. said that coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) vaccines might become commercially available in the Philippines by 2023, noting the government would continue providing it for free ... Read more »

German navy chief resigns over 'Putin deserves respect' remark

The head of Germany’s navy has resigned following controversial remarks on the crisis in Ukraine, a defence ministry spokesman said on Saturday. Kay-Achim Schoenbach said the idea that Russia wanted ... Read more »

ICICI Bank Q3 profit rises 25%

Private-sector lender ICICI Bank on Saturday reported a 25.4% year-on-year (y-o-y) rise in standalone net profit to Rs 6,193.81 crore in the December quarter of FY22 on the back of ... Read more »

PAN Card Update: Here's how you can change your last name online on your PAN Card

© Provided by DNA PAN card or Permanent Account Number is the most essential document for all types of financial transactions. It comes with a 10 digit alphanumeric PAN number. ... Read more »

Nets' James Harden says he's ‘definitely back' to the player he was

MINNEAPOLIS — Is the Beard back? Maybe James Harden was sparked by the defense Friday night, or perhaps he was just unusually springy at San Antonio. But he says it’s ... Read more »

Tory MP says fines for minor lockdown breaches should be REFUNDED

Fines dished out for minor breaches of lockdown laws should be refunded because they were a ‘huge imposition on personal freedoms,’ a Tory MP has suggested. Andrew Percy is calling ... Read more »

Donald Trump slams Jan. 6 panel after Ivanka Trump interview request: 'They'll go after children'

© Associated Press/Ross D. Franklin Former President Donald Trump speaks at a rally, Saturday, Jan. 15, 2022, in Florence, Ariz. Former President Donald Trump slammed the Jan. 6 committee investigating ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic