Vital Signs: Albanese to come clean on emissions targets, but a carbon price is still hush-hush

The Australian Labor Party is set to announce its target for cutting greenhouse gas emissions today.

At the 2016 and 2019 elections, Labor promised net zero emissions by 2050 and a cut of 45% on 2005 levels by 2030. Among the promises it adopted to get it there in 2019 was a target of 50% renewable energy by 2030.

But it lost those elections. So up to now Labor has refused to say what policies it will take to the 2022 election. We should know by the end of the day.

The Coalition’s position is clear – sort of.

Formally the government is sticking with its long-settled position of delivering a cut of 26-28% on 2005 levels by 2030 (as well as net zero by 2050).

But Prime Minister Scott Morrison is having a bet each way, by also saying the government will do better. As he said on November 15:

We are going to achieve a 35% reduction in emissions by 2030. That is what we’re going to achieve. That is what actually matters. What matters is what you actually achieve. We are well above our target.

This leaves Labor, which has consistently taken a stronger stance than the Coalition, with three broad options.

Targets, predictions, safeguards

Option 1 is to match the 35% reduction but make it a formal target, not a prediction.

Option 2 is to go a little higher with a prediction – say 40% – and claim this is achievable given announced Labor policies such as electric vehicles and upgrading the electricity grid (“rewiring the nation”).

Option 3 is set a more ambitious target – perhaps 45%, as Labor did at the last election, along with a change to the so-called “safeguard mechanism” introduced by the Coalition in 2016 as part of its alternative to a price on carbon.

The safeguard mechanism requires Australia’s largest greenhouse gas emitters to keep their net emissions below a certain cap.

At the 2019 election Labor proposed to cut the eligibility threshold for the cap from 100,000 to 25,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide a year, and extend it to more emitters.

The difference between now and 2019 is that this time the business community is behind the approach.

In fact, the Business Council of Australia’s climate plan, published in October 2021, is to do exactly this.

November 15, introduced by the Coalition, climate plan, Business Council of Australia, Peter Martin, government document, as if, an even higher carbon price

Business Council of Australia

Pitfalls abound

Each one of these options have pitfalls. Option 1 looks weak, and gives the government a free pass on climate. It’s hard for Labor politicians to campaign on the government not doing enough if they aren’t willing to do more themselves.

Option 2 (perhaps the most likely) is a hedge: Labor will do more because it cares about the planet, but not too much more because, you know, politics.

Option 3 is the bravest of the likely targets. It’s a bigger number that would make for more meaningful change. It also now has air cover from the Business Council of Australia.

But it’s also the option taken to the last election, which Labor lost. Maybe that was due to other reasons, such as the retiree tax, but it still seems politically risky.

No talk about a carbon price

One option you can bet Labor will not adopt is a price on carbon.

That’s the best way to balance what’s good about emissions (economic growth and development) with what’s bad about emissions (climate change).

This has been off the table with Labor since it lost government in 2013 – in no small part due to Tony Abbott exploiting the issue with his “great big tax” campaigning.

But a funny thing has happened on the way to the 2022 election. A few months ago the Coalition inserted a price on carbon into its own plan.

As The Conversation’s Peter Martin put it, the plan assumed emissions reductions “the same as what would be expected if Australians faced a carbon price (or tax) that climbed to A$24 per tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent by 2050”.

If Energy Minister Angus Taylor is trying to hide this, he is not being particularly stealthy about it.

Page 6 of the government document outlining the modelling and analysis behind the plan acknowledges it models voluntary emissions reductions “as an abatement incentive which is taken up across the economy and rises to $24/t CO2-e in 2050”.

It says behaving “as if” there was a carbon price of A$24 per tonne in place would get emissions down by 85%.

To get them down further to net zero would require an even higher carbon price: about A$80 per tonne on the model’s logic.

Labor could take its cue from the Coalition

So why doesn’t Labor do what it knows to be right – announce a price on carbon? It could say it will start at the government’s own figure of $24/tonne, and take any needed subsequent increases to future elections.

That won’t happen on Friday. Or any time soon. We should reflect on why.

November 15, introduced by the Coalition, climate plan, Business Council of Australia, Peter Martin, government document, as if, an even higher carbon price

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Denunciation of tax convention with Switzerland not expected — official

In 2020, the Russian president ordered to impose the 15% tax on income in the form of dividends and interest transferred to accounts overseas Read more »

Nord Stream 2 AG endeavors to comply with EU rules

The company made no comment on potential consequences of possible new sanction efforts of the US Read more »

Uniper expects completion of Nord Stream 2 certification in summer 2022

Construction of the gas pipeline ended in last September Read more »

Gas price in Europe hovering around $900 per 1,000 cubic meters

The total increase in the gas price since the trading opening has reached around 3% Read more »

Burger King Japan announces discounted price for popular Whopper burgers

Photo by: Burger King Japan Burger King Japan has launched a new promotion, and it will be running for a limited time only. Customers can get two Whopper burgers for ... Read more »

(LEAD) Lotte acquires Ministop's S. Korean operations

(ATTN: UPDATES with details in 4th para) SEOUL, Jan. 21 (Yonhap) — Lotte Corp., the holding company of South Korean retail giant Lotte Group, said Friday it has acquired an ... Read more »

Novosibirsk scientists plan to install seismic stations on Arctic ice

A new long-term expedition on a unique vessel - the North Pole ice-resistant platform - is due to begin in 2022 Read more »

Yakutia's authorities: Arctic development strategy will improve Northern supplies system

The national plan includes the construction and reconstruction of regional, inter-regional automobile roads Read more »

Lotte acquires Ministop's S. Korean operations

SEOUL, Jan. 21 (Yonhap) — Lotte Corp., the holding company of South Korean retail giant Lotte Group, said Friday it has acquired an entire stake of Ministop Korea Co. for ... Read more »

S. Korea to raise supply of beef, pork ahead of holiday to tame inflation

SEOUL, Jan. 21 (Yonhap) — South Korea plans to increase the supply of beef and pork by around 50 percent on-year ahead of the Lunar New Year holiday in an ... Read more »

Dollar climbs to 76.72 rubles on the Moscow Exchange

The euro rose by 17 kopecks to 86.88 rubles Read more »

MOEX index down 3.38% at trade start

By 07:05 it decreased to 3,397.13 points Read more »

Hanjin chief borrowed money from man at center of corruption scandal, but no illegality found: sources

SEOUL, Jan. 21 (Yonhap) — Prosecutors have found Cho Won-tae, chairman of Hanjin Group and Korean Air, borrowed and repaid 3 billion won (US$2.5 million) from a man at the ... Read more »

Cabinet approves 14-tln won extra budget for small merchants

SEOUL, Jan. 21 (Yonhap) — The Cabinet on Friday approved a 14 trillion won (US$11.8 billion) extra budget plan aimed at supporting small merchants hit by the pandemic. The proposal ... Read more »

Animoca Brands raises $358 million to fund open metaverse project

The company seeks to provide digital ownership of assets and data to be used across the metaverse without impediment. Animoca Brands has raised an additional US$358 million to push its ... Read more »

Thrill One inks 8-figure, multi-year A Shoc sponsorship deal

The deal covers Thrill One’s various properties, including Street League Skateboarding (SLS), Nitro Rallycross, and Nitro Circus. Action sports entertainment company Thrill One Sports & Entertainment closed an eight-figure, multi-year ... Read more »

S. Korea's KT collaborates with Russia's Yandex on developing delivery robots

KT and Yandex Self-Driving Group, an affiliate of Russian tech giant Yandex inked an agreement in Moscow to roll out the autonomous delivery robot within this year . Major South ... Read more »

Gas prices in Europe above $900 per 1,000 cubic meters

Prices moved by 2.3% over the day Read more »

Trading volume at SPIMEX up 39.8% in 2021 to over $17 bln

Petroleum products trading gained 16.6% in physical terms to 27.03 mln tonnes Read more »

Two thirds of last year's gas already withdrawn from EU gas storage facilities — Gazprom

Total gas content of underground gas storages in Europe dropped to 45.45% as of January 18 Read more »

Moscow ready to host Expo 2030, says Mayor

The future Expo venue will be situated near the Vnukovo airport Read more »

Copper demand to be above supply in the long run — USM founder

Growing demand from clean energy technologies will also cause increasing demand from construction and manufacturing Read more »

Moldovagaz announces paying off Gazprom debt for current supplies

Gazprom and Moldovagaz extended the gas supply contract for five years last October Read more »

Moldovagaz receives funds to pay off debt to Russia's Gazprom — government

According to the Moldovan government, the gas distributor Moldovagaz lacks about $25 million in order to pay off its debts to the Russian company Read more »

Russia's Sukhoi Superjet 100 fleet to be increased to 192 jets by yearend

The Sukhoi Superjet 100 is a Russian short-range passenger jet, having a maximum capacity of 103 seats Read more »

Rosatom to develop micro reactor — First Deputy CEO

The capacity of the reactor is planned at the level of 60 MW Read more »

Ban on holding cryptocurrencies not suggested, says Russian Central Bank

Director of the regulator’s Financial Stability Department Elizaveta Danilova noted that there were fraud risks, as well as difficulties in asserting rights when acquiring cryptocurrency on foreign crypto exchanges Read more »

Ministry: More than 300 companies become Arctic business residents

The most popular business direction is tourism Read more »

Russia exports more than 19 million tonnes of LNG, gas condensate via Sabetta seaport

The cargo left the Sabetta port in 257 LNG carriers and 20 condensate carriers Read more »

Cabinet to allocate $26.1 mln for regional, long-range aircraft projects — PM

One of the projects is Russian regional Il-114-300, what is to replace obsolete An-24 aircraft on local airline routes Read more »

Cryptocurrency investments of Russian legal entities are small, Central Bank says

Payment transactions with cryptocurrencies are not widespread in Russia, the regulator informed Read more »

Central Bank seeks ban on issuance, mining, circulation of cryptocurrencies in Russia

It is also proposed to establish liability for violating the legal ban on the use of cryptocurrencies as a means of payment for goods, works and services sold and bought by legal entities and individuals, that are residents of the Russian Federation Read more »

Continued use of cryptocurrencies can pose serious threats to economy, says Central Bank

The regulator pointed out that further use of cryptocurrencies as a means of payment for goods and service would carry the risk of undermining the circulation of money and the sovereignty of the nation’s currency Read more »

Moldovagaz to transfer $8.5 mln to Gazprom on Thursday to repay debt — Deputy PM

Deputy Prime Minister Andrei Spinu noted that the government is doing its best to prevent the interruption of gas supply to the consumers Read more »

Reverse gas supplies via Yamal-Europe continue for one month

Gazprom noted that it supplied gas to Europe in accordance with consumers’ requests under current contracts Read more »

Europe needs long-term contracts with gas suppliers, says Hungarian Foreign Minister

Russia has proved to be a reliable partner in this area, Peter Szijjarto stressed Read more »

MOEX index up by 0.72% to 3461.73 points at trade start

By 7:00 Moscow time, the index was at 3451.5 Read more »

Dollar rises to 76.22 rubles

Euro remains at 86.45 rubles Read more »

Jobs in public sector grow by largest number in 2020

SEOUL, Jan. 20 (Yonhap) — Jobs provided by the government and state-run companies grew by the largest-ever amount in 2020, as the number of public servants rose and state-arranged jobs ... Read more »

Number of layer chickens rebounds in Q4

SEOUL, Jan. 20 (Yonhap) — The number of layer chickens raised in South Korea rebounded in the fourth quarter from a year earlier as it gradually recovered from the impact ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic