Village heat pump scheme that has cost £250,000 per house

Village heat pump scheme that has cost £250,000 per house
© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo

Can there be any surer way for the Government to waste our money than on green energy schemes?

A new report by the Commons Public Accounts Committee (PAC) is scathing about the Green Homes Grant Scheme, which was supposed to transform 600,000 homes with insulation and greener heating systems, but was abandoned earlier this year after just six months in operation.

Only 47,500 homes received a grant, and it ended up costing taxpayers more than £1,000 per property in administration fees.

The PAC said the scheme didn’t take into account a shortage of tradespeople able to carry out the work it was supposed to fund.

Why does it always end up this way? David Cameron’s Green Deal was much the same.

Introduced in 2013 to slash carbon emissions by offering loans to insulate homes, the National Audit Office found that it had saved ‘negligible amounts of CO2’ by the time it was closed two years later.

Village heat pump scheme that has cost £250,000 per house
© Provided by Daily Mail (

Today I can reveal a green energy project that looks like being an even bigger turkey. 

Near where I live in Cambridgeshire, the county council has thrown £12 million — including a £3.2 million Government grant — at a community heating system powered by a ground-source heat pump (which transfers heat to/from the ground).

It was supposed to be a test bed of how all properties could be heated in future. By the end of December, however, only 47 homes had signed up.

So unless there is a last-minute rush of interest, it will end up costing more than £250,000 per house.

That is as much as some homes in the village of Swaffham Prior are worth.

Yet ministers are intent on forcing us all on to similar schemes. You may have heard that the Government proposes to outlaw the installation of new gas boilers from 2035.

Village heat pump scheme that has cost £250,000 per house
© Provided by Daily Mail (

Rather less well-known is that the end will come sooner for oil-fired boilers and LPG (Liquefied Petroleum Gas) boilers — used by four million homes that lie beyond the gas mains.

Under the Heat and Buildings Strategy, new installations of these boilers will be banned from 2026, as part of a dash to conform with the Government’s legally binding target of eliminating net carbon emissions by 2050.

So, if my oil boiler fails in five years, I won’t be allowed to replace it with another one.

I’ll either have to find room for a bulky biomass boiler — burning wood pellets — or install an electric pump. This pumps heat either from the air outside your home or the earth under your garden.

But heat pumps are very expensive — at an average of £12,000, they cost three times as much as an oil-fired boiler. Moreover, they cost more to run, and, according to some, don’t heat homes sufficiently.

This is why the Government is keen to explore alternatives, such as heating homes via a communal pump, taking advantage of economies of scale.

Village heat pump scheme that has cost £250,000 per house
© Provided by Daily Mail (

The Swaffham Prior Heat Network, therefore, ought to fit the bill. The plan is to lay pipes beneath a field on the edge of the village, extract heat from the soil and use it to pump hot water to residents’ existing radiators.

When the water starts flowing next March, it should come out at 72c on freezing winter days and a little cooler in summer, when it will be used only for baths or showers.

Many homes in Copenhagen, for example, are heated via a communal system that pumps water around the city. Nottingham, too, has a district scheme which pumps hot water to 5,000 homes, using heat produced by a waste incinerator.

But where have the economies of scale gone in the case of Swaffham Prior?

The most absurd thing about the scheme is that even if all 300 homes in the village had signed up, it would still have cost £40,000 per property.

That is nearly four times as much as it would cost each resident to install a heat pump. How on earth did anyone think spending £12 million on a heating scheme for only 300 homes was value for money?

True, pioneering schemes always cost more, before prices tend to fall. But this is nowhere even close to being affordable.

It is so typical of what happens with climate-change policy — all financial sense goes out of the window.

In the Government’s panicked attempt to achieve net zero emissions by 2050, it will throw money after anything.

What has made many residents baulk at signing up for the scheme is a clause in the contract which says it can be discontinued with two year’s notice if it turns out to be unviable. Which would leave them with no heating at all.

We all want clean energy. But the truth is that there is no form of heating yet on the market which can even nearly match oil and gas on price.

Britain already has 2.4 million households living in ‘fuel poverty’, according to government figures. Unless technology changes fast, that will surge once oil and gas central heating have been banned.

If the Swaffham Prior project is anything to go by, you’d need the deep pockets of a millionaire before you could contemplate joining an unsubsidised district heating scheme.

The Denial by Ross Clark is published by Lume Books.

News Related


‘She's an inspiration to every mum': the postnatal depression survivor offering new mothers a lifeline

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Alicia Canter/The Guardian Jo Leach didn’t tell anyone about her postnatal depression. It came on after her second child, Hayden, was born on Christmas ... Read more »

Arsenal prepare double contract offer for key duo as Stan Kroenke makes crucial decision

Arsenal are expected to offer manager Mikel Arteta and star player Bukayo Saka new contracts at the end of the season, understands. Arteta is heading into the last 18 ... Read more »

Jaishankar speaks with Kuwaiti, Qatari counterparts; discusses ties, Afghanistan

External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Saturday spoke with his counterparts from Kuwait and Qatar separately and discussed a host of issues, including Afghanistan. In a tweet, Jaishankar said it ... Read more »

Jack Grealish and Ruben Dias in — Man City fans' line-up vs Southampton

Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola can perhaps afford to experiment a little with his side as they continue to dominate in this season’s Premier League. City have the chance to ... Read more »

Yemen rebels and aid group put death toll from Saudi-led airstrike on prison at over 80

The death toll from a Saudi-led coalition airstrike that hit a prison run by Yemen’s Houthi rebels climbed to at least 82 detainees, the rebels and an aid group said ... Read more »

Parag Agrawal sacks Twitter chief of security: Report

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Micro-blogging site Twitter said its head of security is no longer at the company and its chief information security officer will depart in ... Read more »

Joe Aribo earns rave Rangers review as Nigeria mentor dubs 'adorable' star the silent assassin

Ranges star Joe Aribo is an ‘adorable’ asset for Nigeria and can help lead them to African Cup of Nations glory, according to the man who handed him his international ... Read more »

London Covid: Three 'classic' symptoms becoming less common in Omicron cases

There are three Covid symptoms we have all come to know over the past year which could indicate an infection. But these symptoms, which were first identified at the start ... Read more »

ICICI Bank Q3 results: Net profit up 25% to Rs 6,194 crore

© Provided by Business Today ICICI Bank Q3 results: Net profit up 25% to Rs 6,194 crore Private sector lender ICICI Bank on Saturday reported a 25 per cent year-on-year ... Read more »

Medvedev eases through; Tsitsipas overcomes Paire

© Associated Press Daniil Medvedev has reached the fourth round at the Australian Open for a fourth year in succession Daniil Medvedev eased through to the fourth round of the ... Read more »

Kai Sotto's return spoiled as Adelaide falls to Melbourne

Photo: Adelaide 36ers/Facebook Kai Sotto finally returned to the hardwood but his Adelaide 36ers could not come away with a win, falling to league leader Melbourne United, 97-78, in the ... Read more »

Apple iPhone SE 3 launch may get delayed, here's why

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: This year will see the release of Apple’s next inexpensive iPhone, the iPhone SE 3 or iPhone SE+ 5G (rumoured). According to a ... Read more »

Upcoming trends in direct selling industry in 2022

© Provided by The Financial Express According to a recent report by Indian Direct Selling Association (IDSA), the industry welcomed 53,18,664 new entrants during April-September 2020 period By Samir Modi ... Read more »

EU humiliated by Brexit Britain as Germany's Scholz forced to deny Biden snub

German media outlet Der Spiegel reported that Mr Scholz turned down an invitation last week to fly to Washington to meet the US President amid mounting tensions between Russia and ... Read more »

60% COVID deaths in 'third wave' among partially or completely unvaccinated: Max study

A study by a private hospital has said that 60 per cent of the patients who died during the current wave of COVID-19 pandemic were either partially or fully unvaccinated. ... Read more »

Court bid to bar King kaZwelithini from speaking at commemoration dismissed

© KZN Government. King Misuzulu kaZwelithini Zulu meets with KZN Premier Sihle Zikalala at the kwaKhangelamankengane palace on 13 May, 2021. JOHANNESBURG – The court case preventing King Misuzulu kaZwelithini ... Read more »

TV licence fee to be scrapped by 2027: 'Great news for vulnerable people'

TV licence fees currently sit at £159 and will now remain at this level until 2024. The freeze has been hailed as a saving grace for struggling families with the ... Read more »

Universal Credit rules have changed - three ways to check what you can get

This ended in October 2021. According to the Resolution Foundation think tank, 4.4 million households have seen their incomes fall by £1000 a year as a result of the uplift ... Read more »

Douala academy nurtures Cameroon's next generation of Indomitable Lions

© Pierre René-Worms, France 24 The Brasseries Football School in Cameroon has nurtured some of Africa’s greatest players since it began operating in 1989. The distinguished academy has sent footballers ... Read more »

Gary Neville's rant as Derby County get closer to liquidation is so powerful it's gone viral

Derby County are edging towards liquidation. The club were placed in administration in the middle of September. They have been looking for a buyer ever since but no one has ... Read more »

Government accused of ‘complete abandonment of moral compass' amid claims of whips threatening MPs

© via REUTERS chris-byrant The chairman of the Commons sleaze committee Chris Bryant has claimed he has spoken to “about a dozen” Tory MPs threatened by whips, as hit out ... Read more »

Marc Rochat überrascht im ersten Lauf als Fünfter – Vinatzer führt knapp

© Giovanni Auletta/ Fast alle Schweizer enttäuschten: Marc Rochat sprang in die Bresche. Marc Rochat überrascht im ersten Lauf des Weltcup-Slaloms in Kitzbühel. Der Waadtländer ist als Fünfter der mit ... Read more »

Ein Italiener führt – und ein Schweizer mit hoher Nummer glänzt unverhofft

Aufgrund der Wetterprognosen findet der Slalom bereits am Samstag statt. Von den Schweizern schafft es nur einer in die Top-10 – einer, mit dem kaum einer gerechnet hat. © Foto: ... Read more »

Wolves fans in transfer uproar as Bruno Lage confirms Toti Gomes stance

Fans uproar on Traore Tottenham are closing in on a deal to sign Wolves winger Adama Traore, according to reports. Various media outlets claim Spurs are now favourites to complete ... Read more »

Grmpf! Bei 3 Sternzeichen macht sich Ende Januar Unzufriedenheit breit

© imaxtree Bei drei Sternzeichen macht sich Ende Januar Unzufriedenheit breit imaxtree Wir alle haben Wünsche, Träume und Vorstellungen und gleichen diese von Zeit zu Zeit mit dem Status quo ... Read more »

Liverpool's transfer stance on Denis Zakaria as midfielders set to return

Liverpool have distanced themselves from a move for Denis Zakaria following speculation that they were interested in signing the midfielder. The Switzerland international is out of contract in the summer ... Read more »

About a dozen Tory MPs said to have accused party whips of blackmail

About a dozen Tory MPs have made similar allegations in the last few days to a colleague who claims the party’s whips have engaged in blackmail, the chair of the ... Read more »

Marc Rochat springt in die Bresche

© KEYSTONE/ANTHONY ANEX Marc Rochat überrascht im ersten Lauf des Weltcup-Slaloms in Kitzbühel. Der Waadtländer ist als Fünfter der mit Abstand beste Schweizer. Der mit der Nummer 29 gestartete Rochat ... Read more »

Aldi's new velvet furniture range includes some very stylish storage options

Good news! Aldi’s bold and beautiful velvet furniture collection is back by popular demand – and prices start from just £30. Available to buy online now, the range is perfect ... Read more »

Thomas Tuchel: Chelsea do not have psychological edge over Spurs

Thomas Tuchel has warned Chelsea not to expect a psychological edge over Tottenham after dumping Spurs out of the Carabao Cup. Chelsea will meet Tottenham for the third time this ... Read more »

Harry Maguire reveals injury details ahead of Manchester United return vs West Ham

Harry Maguire is ready for his return to the Manchester United side this afternoon as he prepares for his first start of 2022. The United captain looks set to be ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo told to apologise to Anthony Elanga after 'spoiling' Manchester United teenager's day

Paul Merson has once again slammed Cristiano Ronaldo, telling the Manchester United star he should apologise to Anthony Elanga for his reaction at Brentford. The Portuguese ace hit the headlines ... Read more »

Sheffield Wednesday reportedly closing in on Arsenal striker agreement

Sheffield Wednesday are reportedly closing in on Arsenal striker Tyreece John-Jules according to Yorkshire Live.  The Owls are in advanced talks to sign the young Arsenal attacker on loan, after ... Read more »

Gilbert Crockett drops a new collection with Vans

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Famous skateboarder Gilbert Crockett and sports footwear and apparel brand Vans collaborate on a new colourway for the Crockett Hi and a well-curated apparel ... Read more »

3 Clean eating breakfast recipes to start your day with

Breakfast is an excellent way to begin the day. While some people prefer not to eat breakfast, others require it to get going. Skipping the morning meal can throw off ... Read more »

Saints eyeing ‘special’ forward dubbed ‘similar’ to Hazard as reliable journalist shares news

© Provided by Transfer Tavern keane lewis-potter for hull city As per a report by the reliable Gary Jacob of The Times, Southampton are in the mix to sign bright Hull ... Read more »

Ligue 1 star sends Edu £38m transfer message in response to Thomas Partey's new Arsenal dilemma

Arsenal have been reminded about a potential transfer target who could transform Mikel Arteta’s midfield which is evidently needed after the recent poor performances. Bruno Guimaraes released a compilation of ... Read more »

Comparing Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo’s career-best seasons

It will take some getting used to but it appears that after a decade of dominance, Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo are no longer the two best players in world ... Read more »

Pune schools to remain closed amid high Covid-19 surge, says Maharashtra Deputy CM Ajit Pawar

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: As Maharashtra gears up to reopen schools on January 24, Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar on Saturday (January 22) said the government has ... Read more »

Denise Barrett-Baxendale makes Rafa Benitez admission and gives Everton manager search update

Denise Barrett-Baxendale said the decision to sack Rafa Benitez was “necessary” – as Everton’s chief executive provides the latest on the club’s new manager search. The Blues dismissed Benitez last ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic