US lawmakers target big tech 'amplification' but what does that really mean?

US lawmakers target big tech 'amplification' but what does that really mean?

Lawmakers argue that when social media sites boost the performance of hateful or violent posts, the sites become accomplices.

NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – United States lawmakers have spent years investigating how hate speech, misinformation and bullying on social media sites can lead to real-world harm. Increasingly, they have pointed a finger at the algorithms powering sites like Facebook and Twitter, the software that decides what content users will see and when they see it.

Some lawmakers from both parties argue that when social media sites boost the performance of hateful or violent posts, the sites become accomplices. And they have proposed bills to strip the companies of a legal shield that allows them to fend off lawsuits over most content posted by their users, in cases when the platform amplified a harmful post’s reach.

The House Energy and Commerce Committee discussed several of the proposals at a hearing last Wednesday (Dec 1). The hearing also included testimony from Ms Frances Haugen, the former Facebook employee who recently leaked a trove of revealing internal documents from the company.

Removing the legal shield, known as Section 230, would mean a sea change for the Internet, because it has long enabled the vast scale of social media websites.

Ms Haugen has said that she supports changing Section 230, which is a part of the Communications Decency Act, so that it no longer covers certain decisions made by algorithms at tech platforms.

But what, exactly, counts as algorithmic amplification?

And what, exactly, is the definition of harmful?

The proposals offer far different answers to these crucial questions. And how they answer them may determine whether the courts find the bills constitutional.

Here is how the bills address these thorny issues.

1. What is algorithmic amplification?

Algorithms are everywhere. At its most basic, an algorithm is a set of instructions telling a computer how to do something. If a platform could be sued any time an algorithm did anything to a post, products that lawmakers are not trying to regulate might be ensnared.

Some of the proposed laws define the behaviour they want to regulate in general terms. A Bill sponsored by Minnesota Democrat Senator Amy Klobuchar would expose a platform to lawsuits if it “promotes” the reach of public health misinformation.

Ms Klobuchar’s Bill on health misinformation would give platforms a pass if their algorithm promoted content in a “neutral” way. That could mean, for example, that a platform that ranked posts in chronological order would not have to worry about the law.

Other legislation is more specific. A Bill from Democrat representatives Anna Eshoo (California) and Tom Malinowski (New Jersey) defines dangerous amplification as doing anything to “rank, order, promote, recommend, amplify or similarly alter the delivery or display of information”.

Another Bill written by House Democrats specifies that platforms could be sued only when the amplification in question was driven by a user’s personal data.

“These platforms are not passive bystanders – they are knowingly choosing profits over people, and our country is paying the price,” said Representative Frank Pallone Jr, chair of the Energy and Commerce Committee, in a statement when he announced the legislation.

Mr Pallone’s new Bill includes an exemption for any business with five million or fewer monthly users. It also excludes posts that show up when a user searches for something, even if an algorithm ranks them, and Web hosting and other companies that make up the backbone of the Internet.

2. What content is harmful?

Lawmakers and others have pointed to a wide array of content they consider to be linked to real-world harm.

There are conspiracy theories, which could lead some adherents to turn violent. Posts from terrorist groups could push someone to commit an attack, as one man’s relatives argued when they sued Facebook after a member of Hamas fatally stabbed him.

Other policymakers have expressed concerns about targeted advertisements that lead to housing discrimination.

Most of the bills now in Congress address specific types of content.

Ms Klobuchar’s Bill covers “health misinformation”. But the proposal leaves it up to the Department of Health and Human Services to determine what, exactly, that means.

“The coronavirus pandemic has shown us how lethal misinformation can be, and it is our responsibility to take action,” Ms Klobuchar said when she announced the proposal, which was co-written by New Mexico Democrat Senator Ben Ray Lujan.

US lawmakers target big tech 'amplification' but what does that really mean?

A bill co-written by Senator Amy Klobuchar (centre) would remove the legal shield of Section 230 if a social media platform “promotes” the reach of health misinformation. PHOTO: NYTIMES

The legislation proposed by Ms Eshoo and Mr Malinowski takes a different approach. It applies only to the amplification of posts that violate three laws – two that prohibit civil rights violations and a third that prosecutes international terrorism. Mr Pallone’s Bill is the newest of the bunch and applies to any post that “materially contributed to a physical or severe emotional injury to any person”.

This is a high legal standard: Emotional distress would have to be accompanied by physical symptoms. But it could cover, say, a teenager who views posts on Instagram that diminish her self-worth so much that she tries to hurt herself.

Some Republicans expressed concerns about that proposal last Wednesday, arguing that it would encourage platforms to take down content that should stay up.

Representative Cathy McMorris Rodgers of Washington, the top Republican on the committee, said it was a “thinly veiled attempt to pressure companies to censor more speech”.

3. What do the courts think?

Judges have been sceptical of the idea that platforms should lose their legal immunity when they amplify the reach of content.

In the case involving an attack for which Hamas claimed responsibility, most of the judges who heard the case agreed with Facebook that its algorithms did not cost it the protection of the legal shield for user-generated content. If Congress creates an exemption to the legal shield – and it stands up to legal scrutiny – courts may have to follow its lead. But if the bills become law, they are likely to attract significant questions about whether they violate the First Amendment’s free-speech protections.

Courts have ruled that the government cannot make benefits to an individual or a company contingent on the restriction of speech that the Constitution would otherwise protect.

“The issue becomes: Can the government directly ban algorithmic amplification?” said Jeff Kosseff, an associate professor of cyber security law at the US Naval Academy. “It’s going to be hard, especially if you’re trying to say you can’t amplify certain types of speech.”

News Related


Dominic Cummings refuses to meet Sue Gray so PM can't ‘spin his way out'

Dominic Cummings refuses to meet Sue Gray (PA Archive) Dominic Cummings said he won’t meet with Sue Gray so Boris Johnson can’t “invent nonsense and spin it in the media”. ... Read more »

Peter Dinklage blasts Disney for remaking ‘f***ing backwards' Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Peter Dinklage has criticised the forthcoming revival of the 1937 children’s film Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, calling the story “f***ing backwards”. The actor, who has dwarfism, was discussing ... Read more »

Chimpanzee culture ‘more similar' to humans' than previously realised, researchers say

The nut cracker. A chimpanzee in Guinea uses a hammer and anvil arrangement of stones to crack open a nut (Kathelijne Koops, UZH) Human culture is not only complex, but ... Read more »

Dark Souls 3 bug could let hackers seize control of your PC

As if Dark Souls 3 wasn’t already difficult enough, playing it online could open up your computer for malicious actors to swoop in, steal sensitive data, and brick it completely, ... Read more »

Best single-player games 2022: the top games for playing solo on console and PC

Dive into the best single player games available right now for a gaming experience you’ll never forget. These are titles big and small that have managed to not only capture ... Read more »

How to watch The Responder online for free and from anywhere

Night after night, Chris Carson navigates the dark streets of Liverpool responding to emergency calls, but worn down by the stresses of the job and issues at home, he decides ... Read more »

IIT-Guwahati team develops 3D printing tech to cut concrete use by 75%

A team of researchers at the Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati (IIT-G) has developed a 3D printed urban furniture using construction material made from local industrial wastes.Concrete 3D printing is ... Read more »

Astonishment as SNP claims ‘clear signs of Covid recovery' pave way for second independence vote

John Swinney insisted that some sectors are ‘in a stronger position today’ than before the pandemic – Fraser Bremner/Daily Mail/PA Wire Hospitality leaders have expressed astonishment after Nicola Sturgeon's deputy ... Read more »

Meat Loaf's home with wife Deborah didn't pay tribute to music career

After Meat Loaf, whose real name is Michael Lee Aday, sadly passed away at the age of 74, tributes have been pouring in from his followers remembering his incredible music ... Read more »

Meghan King Goes on 'Empowering' Solo Ski Trip to Utah After Cuffe Owens Split: 'Here's to Me'

Meghan King Goes on ‘Empowering’ Solo Ski trip to Utah After Cuffe Biden Owens Split Meghan King/Instagram Meghan King is traveling solo! Last week, the Real Housewives of Orange County ... Read more »

Sarah Palin tests positive for Covid, delaying New York Times defamation trial

Photograph: Steve Nesius/Reuters ‘She is, of course, unvaccinated’, judge says after positive test Former Alaska governor suing newspaper over 2017 editorial Sarah Palin has tested positive for the coronavirus – ... Read more »

Water seen below polar ice cap on Mars may be optical illusion, scientists say

The extreme conditions on the red planet make the existence of water on its surface unlikely. Scientists now say they have a more plausible explanation, with the sighting in 2018 being put down as a mirage. Read more »

A Minecraft competition inadvertently took a whole country offline - here's how

A multi-day DDoS attack coinciding with a highly-anticipated Minecraft tournament left the entire country of Andorra without access to the internet last week. The DDoS campaign targeted Andorra Telecom, the ... Read more »

Google faces lawsuits over location-tracking practices from U.S. states

Google spokesperson Jose Castaneda said the “attorneys general are bringing a case based on inaccurate claims and outdated assertions about our settings.” Read more »

With Crash Bandicoot and Spyro heading to Microsoft, PlayStation should revive Jak and Daxter

Microsoft’s agreed acquisition of Activision Blizzard for close to $70 billion is a monumental deal that’s thrown up all manner of talking points about the way we play video games, ... Read more »

Ford Unveils The Bronco Raptor, Starting At $70,000

Ford Motor Company (NYSE:F) has announced a new Bronco SUV member, the Raptor, to be released later this year and starting at $70,000. The automotive giant is also aiming at ... Read more »

Best free DVD burner 2021: burn videos and data to disc

The best free DVD burners make it easy to burn videos and data to disc. Best free DVD burner 1. Ashampoo Burning Studio Free 2. WinX DVD Author 3. BurnAware ... Read more »

These Amplifiers Upgrade Your Home Wi-Fi

The business world has adapted to a new normal over the past couple of years as businesses have shifted to fully remote or hybrid models. If your company expects you ... Read more »

GT7 could be the PS5 game that forces your SSD expansion

Gran Turismo 7’s file size has been revealed, confirming that the upcoming racing game will eat your console’s storage space much like the cars it features would eat your wallet. ... Read more »

When will the Motorola Edge 30 be released in the UK? Here's everything you need to know

The handset is expected to arrive in the summer (iStock/The Independent) Motorola might not be the dominant force it once was – we still remember our Razr flip phone fondly ... Read more »

Bose SoundLink Flex review

One-minute review For a small, relatively affordable product, the portable Bluetooth speaker has an awful lot of boxes to tick before it can be deemed ‘competitive’. Happily, the Bose SoundLink ... Read more »

Why Implementing IT Service Management Is More Crucial Than Ever

After suffering from the catastrophic pandemic in 2020 and 2021, this is an important year for organizations operating in major industries worldwide. The Covid-19 situation resulted in a sharp drop in the demand ... Read more »

This Outlook email update will give your calendar a splash of color

Microsoft Outlook users will soon be able to liven up their work calendars with a bit of color thanks to a new update coming to the service. An upcoming upgrade ... Read more »

Best registry cleaners of 2022: Free and paid programs for Windows 10

Best registry cleaners 1. Restoro 2. CCleaner 3. Iolo System Mechanic 4. Wise Registry Cleaner 5. AVG TuneUp Read on for our detailed analysis of each program In the modern ... Read more »

Twelve new Xiaomi phones could be coming soon

Xiaomi tends to release a lot of handsets, and this year looks set to be no exception, as a leaker has found evidence of no fewer than twelve possibly on ... Read more »

Porsche Taycan gets Spotify support and more new features as major update rolls out

Technology and software are such a huge part of the modern vehicle ownership experience that it’s big news when an automaker makes a change. Porsche, a company far better known ... Read more »

Shop Macy's bras starting at just $9.60 during this huge one-day sale

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re looking for a few new wardrobe essentials, Macy’s has ... Read more »

Xbox Game Pass vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

For many, Xbox Game Pass has been a huge reason to buy an Xbox Series X or Xbox Series S console. The subscription service offers a vast library of games ... Read more »

The best free drawing software for 2022

Free drawing software has come a long way from its humble beginnings. While older drawing applications were severely limited, their modern counterparts are extremely powerful, offering lots of capabilities as ... Read more »

Lee Enterprises asks investors to help fight off hedge fund

OMAHA, Neb. — Newspaper publisher Lee Enterprises is asking its shareholders to help it fight off a hostile takeover offer from “vulture hedge fund” Alden Global Capital. The publisher of ... Read more »

This Slovakian startup claims we will own flying cars within 2 years

Most electric vertical take-off and landing (EVTOL) aircraft owe their design to futuristic flying robots and insects. But there’s a more humble kind of flying innovation — the flying aircar. ... Read more »

An 11-year-old with abdominal pain 3 months after getting COVID-19 still had the coronavirus in her gut

A slide from the girl’s biopsy reveals the coronavirus in her gut, seen here as brown shading.Dalia Arostegui et al./JPGN Reports/Insider Scientists found signs of the coronavirus in a girl's ... Read more »

Google Drive update will stop even the most gullible users falling victim to scams

Google is rolling out an update for its cloud storage service designed to shield even the least security-savvy users from malicious content. As explained in a blog post, Google Drive ... Read more »

Google is reportedly working on Chromecast with Google TV successor

Google launched its first Chromecast with Google TV in 2020. Two years later, Google is reportedly working on a new Chromecast with Google TV device, according to the documentation spotted ... Read more »

Partygate: Two Things That Everyone Is Pointing Out About Sue Gray's Report

Sue Gray is set to reveal the findings of her investigation into Partygate this week (Photo: Getty/PA) Sue Gray’s report into the parties which allegedly took place throughout the pandemic ... Read more »

12 things that will keep you warm outdoors this winter

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Over the past few weeks, many parts of the country have ... Read more »

Maida Vale: Woman stabbed to death before knifeman run over and killed as driver ‘tries to save her'

Police have launched an investigation into the deaths of a woman and the man who reportedly killed her in west London. Officers were called at 9am on Monday 24 January ... Read more »

Met apologises to woman for ‘sexist, derogatory' language in strip-search

Force pays compensation to Dr Konstancja Duff for language used after CCTV captures officers’ comments The Metropolitan police has apologised and paid compensation to an academic for “sexist, derogatory and ... Read more »

ITV Revamps Pre-9pm Schedule: Extends Evening News, Moves Soaps Back-to-Back

U.K. broadcaster ITV is making key changes to its pre-9pm schedule, including extending the evening news and putting its two biggest soaps, “Coronation Street” and “Emmerdale,” back to back. Presented ... Read more »

Reliance Jio 5G coverage update: Trials in top 1000 cities and more

Reuters file photo Reliance Jio has completed 5G network coverage planning for top 1,000 cities in the country and is augmenting its fibre capacity as well as running pilot across ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic