US coronavirus: FDA advisers rejected Pfizer's booster shot application -- but may amend the question for another vote

Advisers to the US Food and Drug Administration on Friday rejected Pfizer’s application to add a third — booster — dose of its Covid-19 vaccine to its original two-dose regimen by a vote of 16 to 2, but the group reserved the right to amend the question being asked in a second round of voting.

© Matt Rourke/AP A syringe is prepared with the Pfizer vaccine at a clinic at the Reading Area Community College in Reading, Pennsylvania.

Here’s the question the panel voted on: Do the safety and effectiveness data from clinical trial C4591001 support approval of a COMIRNATY booster dose administered at least 6 months after completion of the primary series for use in individuals 16 years of age and older?

After the first vote, the group was preparing to vote on a narrower approval — perhaps one that allowed booster shots for people 60 or 65 and older, or people at high risk of exposure at work.

“I don’t think a booster dose is going to significantly contribute to controlling the pandemic,” said Dr. Cody Meissner, a professor of pediatrics at Tufts University School of Medicine.

“It is very important that the main message that we still transmit is that we have got to get everyone two doses. Everyone has got to get the primary series.”

More than 2 million Americans have received a booster dose of a Covid-19 vaccine, according to data published Friday by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Pfizer got strong pushback on its request Friday after saying it has data showing that immunity wanes six months or so after people are fully vaccinated with two doses, and adding that a third dose at six to eight months restores that immunity.

Dr. Phil Krause, deputy director of the FDA’s Office of Vaccines Research and Review noted Pfizer was using data that had not been reviewed by experts. He signed an unusual letter in the Lancet earlier this week saying there wasn’t enough evidence yet to justify boosters.

Three reports published Wednesday supporting the argument that people may need a booster dose of Pfizer’s Covid-19 vaccine over time were part of the data discussed by the FDA’s vaccine advisers.

The meeting, streamed online, began Friday morning.

Four days earlier, a group of international vaccine experts, including some from the FDA and the World Health Organization, wrote in the Lancet that current evidence does not appear to support a need for booster shots in the general public right now.

The proportion of the population that is fully vaccinated — now at around 54.4% of the entire population — is still far below where experts have said it needs to be to slow or stop the spread, and cases have been on the rise.

Disparity in the Covid-19 pandemic

The pandemic has impacted different populations differently, and people of color are bearing a heavy burden, according to new research.

Black people, those over 40 and people with pre-existing conditions were the most likely sufferers of long Covid symptoms, which impacted a third of the Covid-19 patients, according to a study by the Long Beach department of Health and Human Services in California.

The most common extended symptom was fatigue, followed by loss of taste and loss of smell, the team reported in the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s weekly Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report.

“The odds of experiencing symptoms 2 months after a positive SARS-CoV-2 test result were significantly higher among females, persons with at least one preexisting condition, and those aged 40–54 years,” they wrote.

Black people had higher rates of difficulty breathing, joint pain, and muscle pain than other racial and ethnic groups. These results show a need to monitor demographic disparities in extended Covid-19 symptoms, the researchers said.

And an analysis published Thursday by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that the race-based disparities among children mirrored those among adults.

Compared to White children, kids of color have had more cases, deaths, and have had more mental health and academic problems related to the pandemic. While the most vulnerable, they’re also less likely to be vaccinated, according to the analysis.

While Covid-19 hospitalization and death are rare among children compared to adults, those kids who were hospitalized were more likely to be Black and Hispanic. Black and Hispanic kids were also more likely to have a Covid-19-related condition called MIS-C — multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children — and Black children were more likely to be admitted to intensive care for it.

Black, Hispanic, American Indian and Alaska Native children were more likely to die from Covid-19 than White children.

“Because children make up a significant share of the population and are more racially diverse than the rest of the population, equitable vaccination among this group is key for achieving an overall high rate of vaccine coverage among the population and may help to reduce disparities in vaccination rates more broadly,” the report said.

Masks help block airborne transmission, study shows

Meanwhile, new research published this week indicates the Alpha variant of coronavirus spread more easily as people breathed or spoke but showed that even the simplest masks can greatly reduce transmission.

“Our latest study provides further evidence of the importance of airborne transmission,” said Dr. Don Milton, professor of environmental health at the University of Maryland School of Public Health, who worked on the study.

The intensive study, conducted at the University of Maryland, the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research and elsewhere, showed people expel virus in their breath and saliva — findings that support the now widely accepted idea that the virus is spread in droplets of all sizes that fall to surfaces or float in the air. They measured RNA, the genetic material most commonly used to detect virus.

Loose-fitting masks stopped about 50% of virus-laden particles from getting out, the team found.

Milton said they’re now testing to see what happens with the Delta or B.1.617.2 variant, which is far more transmissible than Alpha and which now accounts for virtually all infections in the US currently.

But the implications of the findings about Alpha are clear.

“SARS-CoV-2 is evolving toward more efficient aerosol generation and loose-fitting masks provide significant but only modest source control. Therefore, until vaccination rates are very high, continued layered controls and tight-fitting masks and respirators will be necessary,” the team wrote.

“We know that the Delta variant circulating now is even more contagious than the Alpha variant. Our research indicates that the variants just keep getting better at travelling through the air, so we must provide better ventilation and wear tight-fitting masks, in addition to vaccination, to help stop spread of the virus,” Milton said in a statement.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Winston-Salem: Mixxer fundraising for 'Community Play Box,' Boston-Thurmond neighborhood

Local artists are fundraising to help bring more toys and equipment to the Boston-Thurmond neighborhood near Downtown Winston-Salem. © Hearst mixxer community play box The plan is to create a ... Read more »

Take a bite out of fall: 5 Brevard food festivals will keep you full through Thanksgiving

Support local journalism: Find offers for new subscribers at After a year’s hiatus, some of the Space Coast’s favorite fall food fests are back, and organizers are ready to ... Read more »

Lori Harvey Is the Latest Celebrity to Delve Into Skin Care

© Illustration by Clara Hendler At this point, it should come as little surprise that any celebrity would launch a beauty brand. Beauty products tend to be relatively affordable, and ... Read more »

African players in Europe: In-form Salah equals Drogba record

Liverpool star Mohamed Salah equalled the Premier League goals record for an African when he scored in a 5-0 rout of Watford at the weekend.  © Paul ELLIS Liverpool star ... Read more »

Virals: Liverpool 'battling' to sign Lazio star Sergej Milinkovic-Savic

© Paolo Bruno/Getty Images Sport SS Lazio v Lokomotiv Moskva: Group E – UEFA Europa League Liverpool are reportedly ‘battling for the capture of Lazio midfielder Sergej Milinkovic-Savic.  The 26-year-old is ... Read more »

Long road to the top: Sheriff coach Vernydub

Up until last month, Yuriy Vernydub had never stepped onto the biggest stage of European football, let alone succeeded on it. © Sergei GAPON FC Sheriff head coach Yuriy Vernydub ... Read more »

For iconic Missouri band Ozark Mountain Daredevils, upcoming 50th anniversary show is a 'Time Warp' back to 'Celebration'

Thursday, April 20, 1972 was a pretty fine time at the Landers Theatre in downtown Springfield. The Ozark Mountain Daredevils play at Nick Sibley’s recording studio on South Campbell Avenue ... Read more »

How to get your team to work like a Formula One pit crew

If you’ve ever watched motor racing, you’ve likely been in awe of the pit crew. A team of two dozen individuals changes tires, fills the fuel, and checks the aerodynamics ... Read more »

'Dota 2' team takes home biggest esports prize ever -- $18 million

Team Spirit has landed the Aegis trophy after being crowned champions of Dota 2’s The International 2021. The win sees the team take home a cash prize of $18.2 million ... Read more »

DBR Podcast #348 - Countdown To Craziness Was Great!

This weekend marked the formal introduction of the 2021-22 Duke Blue Devils via Countdown to Craziness. The DBR Podcast crew was watching with eagle eyes as the team played two ... Read more »

Health workers to receive additional COVID-19 booster vaccine jabs

© Provided by The South African Health Minister Joe Phaahla has said the department is working on availing COVID-19 booster jabs for the country’s health workers, Phaala revealed on Friday ... Read more »

New ‘wonder drug' injection for severe asthma approved on NHS

A NEW injection to treat patients who don’t respond to conventional asthma medication has been approved on the NHS. The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) has recommended ... Read more »

Covid booster jab uptake ‘too slow to stop NHS being overwhelmed this winter' reigniting lockdown fears

THE Covid booster programme – the key part of the Government’s plan to prevent a new wave this winter – is moving too slow, experts fear.  It could spell trouble ... Read more »

Mom diagnosed with breast cancer while pregnant

Christine Kump, of Channahon, Illinois, was newly pregnant with her second child late last year when she felt a lump in her breast. She said it was in the same ... Read more »

French Covid vaccine that UK ditched has 'stronger immune response' than AstraZeneca

© GETTY French Valneva vaccine The Government was due to purchase some 100 million doses of the vaccine earlier this year, but the deal was terminated citing an alleged breach ... Read more »

Where you can get free check-ups breast cancer awareness month in the UAE

© Motivate Publishing Breast Cancer Early breast cancer detection can save countless lives and the UAE’s taking all the steps to help with this. As October is dedicated to raising ... Read more »

Walk-in jab clinics for children open as Covid cases soar

Health chiefs plan to launch the scheme for youngsters aged 12 to 15 to speed up the rollout. This comes amid fears the Government has been far too slow in ... Read more »

NBA's 75th season: 5 storylines to follow as games begin Tuesday

The NBA will celebrate its 75th season shrouded by the saga that is Kyrie Irving and his COVID-19 vaccination status as well as the drama between Ben Simmons and the ... Read more »

NBA Power Rankings 2021: The biggest unanswered question for the Nets, Lakers and every other team

A new season is nearly here, and that means a new edition of The Sporting News’ NBA Power Rankings has arrived. Some of the top title contenders can be found at ... Read more »

Bucs Arghticles: October 18, 2021

© Photo by George Gojkovich/Getty Images Pittsburgh Pirates News Potential hitting coach candidates for the Pirates’ vacancy (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette) Steve Blass on retirement, hope for current Pirates, goofy minor league ... Read more »

Bluesound boldly breaks back into What Hi-Fi? Awards music streamer category

Hi-fi and streaming are increasingly seeing eye to eye as music services get into lossless audio and manufacturers release better-sounding streamers. The proof of the latter is in two new ... Read more »

Rich Bisaccia: Consistency will be the challenge for Raiders going forward

© Provided by NBC Sports Rich Bisaccia coached in a lot of NFL games over the last 20 years, but none of them was like Sunday’s game in Denver. Bisaccia ... Read more »

Country singer Ashley Campbell to perform at South Shore Conservatory fundraiser

DUXBURY – South Shore Conservatory’s Creative Arts Therapies Department will present the fundraiser “Breakfast with Ashley Campbell”  from 8:30 to 10 a.m. Oct. 22 at the conservatory’s Ellison Center for the ... Read more »

The rise of Cameron Norrie: From feeling tennis was ‘too much' to being Britain's new leading man

Cameron Norrie’s journey to Indian Wells champion and the British No 1 ranking is an international story of improvement, endurance and competitive desire. © PA Images Cameron Norrie fist pump ... Read more »

Valneva Soars as Covid Vaccine Candidate Shows Promise

By Dhirendra Tripathi © Provided by – ADRs of Valneva (NASDAQ:VALN) climbed more than 31% in Monday’s premarket as the company said the phase-3 trials of a prospective ... Read more »

Phaahla confirms govt in talks over COVID booster jab for healthcare workers

© Siya Duda. FILE: Nurse Zoliswa Gidi-Dyosi was the first person in South Africa to receive the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine on Wednesday, 17 February 2021. JOHANNESBURG – Health ... Read more »

NBA power rankings for 2021-22 season

The Times’ NBA crew ranked the teams by a vote from top to bottom, with reporter Dan Woike providing the comments. © Provided by The LA Times Brooklyn Nets guard ... Read more »

WHO to consider emergency use listing of Covaxin on 26 October

© Provided by The Print United Nations/Geneva: The WHO’s technical advisory group will meet on October 26 to consider the emergency use listing of India’s Covaxin which is being used in ... Read more »

Staff profile: Meet the Beacon Journal's Kerry Clawson

© Clawson family Kerry Clawson Local journalism requires local journalists. Each week in the coming months, we will be spotlighting the Beacon staffers who serve our community, including Kerry Clawson. Here’s how you ... Read more »

Harrison grad Robert Fleitz makes Carnegie Hall debut on Monday

LAKELAND – Robert Fleitz said he’s looking forward to representing his hometown on the big stage. © Provided to The Ledger Robert Fleitz, a 2011 graduate of the Harrison School for ... Read more »

Paper Talk: Man Utd consider three Barcelona stars as Koeman asks for Man Utd man

Manchester United are ready to ask for one of three Barcelona stars in return for an unwanted squad man, a top Arsenal target has asked to leave his current club, ... Read more »

Listen to the Superstar Power Hour with Miranda Lambert

Audacy’s Katie Neal welcomes Miranda Lambert to our airwaves as this week’s co-host for the Superstar Power Hour on all your favorite Audacy Country stations nationwide. © Provided by Audacy Miranda Lambert Listen every weekday from ... Read more »

50 best songs by Rock & Roll Hall of Fame's Class of 2021

CLEVELAND, Ohio — The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s Class 2021 is an embarrassment of riches. There are 13 inductees this year, including 12 artists with a collection of ... Read more »

Cheap Trick to treat fans to Greensburg show; guitarist invites Pittsburgh mayor

© Martin Thompson Cheap Trick shall rock the Palace Theater in Greensburg. GREENSBURG — Rick Neilsen never strays far from a guitar. In fact, the Cheap Trick six-stringer picked up ... Read more »

Community invited to Homecoming Musical Gala Oct. 22 on Bison Hill

OBU will host the annual Musical Gala featuring numerous ensembles from the Warren M. Angell School of Visual and Performing Arts Oct. 22 at 8 p.m. in Raley Chapel’s Potter ... Read more »

BC Interruption Player of the Week: Men's Hockey Captain Marc McLaughlin

The Boston College men’s hockey team came away from this weekend with 1 great win and 1 really rough loss. Captain Marc McLaughlin is our Player of the Week thanks ... Read more »

12 pianists in final stage of prestigious Chopin competition

WARSAW, Poland (AP) — Twelve pianists from around the world have been admitted to play in the final stage of the 18th edition of the prestigious Frederic Chopin piano competition, ... Read more »

Geno Smith: I can't keep coming up short

© Provided by NBC Sports Seahawks quarterback Geno Smith blamed himself after his team’s overtime loss to the Steelers on Sunday Night Football. Smith, who lost a fumble in overtime ... Read more »

Delivery driver accidentally traps customer in his own home with a coffee in hilarious TikTok

© TikTok / @slopshaw Delivery driver accidentally traps customer in his own home with a coffee A TikToker found himself in a sticky situation when his DoorDash delivery driver accidentally ... Read more »

Here's How You Can Rate Your Favourite Food's Health Quotient on Food Compass

© KS Swati | Lifestyle Staff Picture Credits: ANI According to a study published in Nature Food, a journal, a new tool has been developed by the scientists at ... Read more »