[Us and Them] Korea's public sector provokes xenophobia

Asia's Tech News Daily

[Us and Them] Korea’s public sector provokes xenophobia
(123rf)Korean authorities’ overzealous approach to the COVID-19 response regarding foreigners has raised concerns of discrimination and fanning xenophobia.

“When a Korean person catches COVID-19, people in the area are notified that someone has been infected. The alert goes right to their phone. When someone who isn‘t Korean catches COVID-19, that same message suddenly is amended to state the nationality of the infected person. Why is it important to know the person’s nationality?” posed Brandon P., an assistant professor at a university outside Jeonju, who wished to use only her last initial.

Noting that someone who is infected with the virus is a foreigner perpetuates the idea that foreigners are the ones spreading COVID-19 recklessly, she said, though the reality is that the proportion of infected foreigners is just a fraction of the total caseload.

“When you’re being turned away from businesses like restaurants, cafes, or hotels, or you‘re being barred from participating in activities like renting picnic baskets or doing tours solely based on the fact that you’re a foreigner, you can see it’s not only frustrating but discriminatory,” she told The Korea Herald.

“Your existence and participation in society can and will be reduced to your answer to the question ‘Are you a foreigner?’”

In September, the city of Pyeongtaek, Gyeonggi Province, wrote in its daily COVID-19 notification text message that 25 of the 38 confirmed cases were foreigners.

The Lawyers for a Democratic Society, also known as Minbyun, and the COVID-19 Human Rights Watch Network condemned the local government, saying the text message separating city residents from foreign residents is an obvious case of discrimination as the city’s ordinance regards foreigners there as citizens.

The group added that other cities, such as Yongin, Icheon and Anseong, also all in Gyeonggi Province, that had many foreign residents did not single out the number of foreigners in their virus notifications.

In March, Seoul and Gyeonggi Province came under fire after they singled out expats and ordered all foreign workers to get tested for the coronavirus. If any foreign worker failed to get tested before the designated date, they could be fined up to 2 million won ($1,700).

“The British Embassy has made clear to the national government and to the Seoul and Gyeonggi administrations that we consider these measures are not fair, they are not proportionate, nor are they likely to be effective,” British Ambassador Simon Smith said in a video posted on his Twitter account.

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea also denounced the local governments’ decision, saying that policies to exclude or separate immigrants can lead to negative perceptions and discrimination against them and shake the foundation of social integration, solidarity and trust, leading to race-based hate crimes.

Seoul and Gyeonggi Province withdrew the administrative orders after facing heavy backlash and changed their scheme to recommendations for expats to get tested for the virus.

Despite the criticism, some local governments in the Chungcheong and Gyeongsang provinces recently ordered all foreign workers in the region to get tested for the virus in early October.

In regards to the disaster relief funds that the government has given out on five occasions since the coronavirus outbreak early last year, foreign residents, whether they pay taxes here or not, were largely excluded from the financial support programs.

With the exception of some local governments, most state-level funds were only provided to foreigners who had permanent residency or were married to a Korean.

“Foreign residents are members of Korean society but they are invisible in situations hit by disasters,” former lawmaker Jasmine Lee, a Philippines-born naturalized Korean, said at a press conference held in front of the NHRCK in April 2020.

“We need universal social policies that do not discriminate based on nationality and race.”

Slip of tongue

Aside from the xenophobia stemming from antivirus measures, public figures have also been at the center of controversy for making comments that belittle other nationalities.

In May 2019, Mayor Jung Heon-yul of Iksan, North Jeolla Province, was criticized for using the term “half-breed” at a sports festival for multicultural families held at Wonkwang University.

“Biologically and scientifically speaking, there is something called half-breed vigor. But if society wrongfully leads these smart and pretty children, there could be a problem like the Paris riot,” Jung said. He later released a formal apology, saying he meant that society should work together in raising interracial children.

In June 2019, Hwang Kyo-ahn, then chairman of the Liberty Korea Party, a precursor to the conservative People Power Party, caused public outcry after he said he thinks it is not fair to arithmetically maintain the same level of wages for foreigners because they have not contributed to the country.

“Koreans contribute to our country by paying taxes, so keeping certain wages and giving tax benefits for them is because they have fulfilled their obligations as citizens and will continue to do so in the future,” Hwang said at a meeting with small and medium-sized enterprises in Busan.

He later claimed he was trying to make a point for correcting side effects from an excessive increase of the minimum wage.

The latest slip of tongue by a public figure came from Yoon Seok-youl, former prosecutor general and now one of the leading presidential contenders for the main opposition People Power Party.

“Companies nowadays make a living off of technology. Nothing can be achieved by hands-and-feet labor. India doesn’t even do that anymore. It’s something only a place like Africa still does,” Yoon said during a sit-down with students at Andong University on Sept. 10.

Public sector’s role

The COVID-19 crisis was not the first time that local health authorities issued administrative orders for foreigners to get tested for a virus, according to a migrant workers’ rights activist.

“When AIDS was spreading in the country, a few regions including Cheonan (in South Chungcheong Province) ordered all foreign workers to get tested for HIV. (The coronavirus situation) is an extension of that,” Yang Hae-woo, former director of the Korea Migrant Human Rights Center, told The Korea Herald.

“People who implement government policies should consider the impact of them, but there is not much of that. In fact, Korea is too less sensitive to migration or multiculturalism.”

Yang said even the progressive left-wingers who should expand the basic human rights for all people by implementing policies in favor of foreigners have too much nationalism, adding that she thinks Korean society’s problem with hatred and discrimination of foreigners will worsen over time if nothing is done to change people’s perception.

As the government and public figures have greater influence in how foreigners are viewed or treated, experts stress the importance of their role in preventing xenophobia.

“What individuals say can be a problem, but especially what the government or public figures say has far-reaching power as it provides a type of barometer. That could set a standard for what can be said, so special caution is needed,” said Hong Sung-soo, associate professor of law at Sookmyung Women’s University.

“It may be justified if foreign workers at certain workplaces were required to get tested (for the virus) under the goal of quarantine. But issuing an administrative order for all foreign workers regardless of their workplaces has no justification of quarantine. Such administrative order does nothing but strengthen prejudices toward foreigners altogether, which is inappropriate.”

Ha Shang-eung, a professor of political science at Sogang University, told The Korea Herald that the government should actively and effectively punish discriminatory acts that cross a certain line, including instances when such acts violate the current law.

He added the government should keep in mind that if it thinks of fundamentally eradicating hate speech and prejudice against foreigners, it can be counterproductive.

“As an individual, public figures should officially deny discrimination against all foreigners at the moral level, not at the legal level, and make efforts to prevent the spread of such discrimination,” Ha said.

For other reasons behind the public sector evoking negative feelings toward foreigners, a study points to the government’s deep-rooted use of the word “multicultural” in drafting policies.

“Multicultural policies are mainly limited to migrants from poor countries, such as ‘foreign workers’ and ‘marriage migrant women’ among foreigners residing in Korea. In particular, by assuming these migrants as problem targets or objects that may cause problems in the future, related policies are also dominantly one-and-done,” Kim Mi-young, a researcher at Kyung Hee University’s Research Institute of Global Ryukyu-Okinawa, wrote in the Journal of Multi-Cultural Contents Studies published in April.

Kim noted that if the government wants foreigners to settle in society and live a harmonious life with Koreans, it should put forward more efforts to change the attitude of Koreans.

“Rather than confining the relevant policies under the name of ‘multicultural’ to limit them to certain migrants, (the government) should embrace ‘multiculturalism’ within the policies to eliminate the distinction between migrants,” Kim wrote.

Kim added that policies on migrants should be carried out in the form of understanding differences between foreigners and Koreans without discrimination, saying that xenophobia will not disappear unless the sense of discrimination that comes from classifying foreigners by nationality through the term “multicultural” goes away.

By Kan Hyeong-woo (hwkan@heraldcorp.com)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Daily infections stay below 3,000, but critical cases hit all-time high

A long line of people forms yet again at an outdoor COVID-19 testing station in Seoul on Monday, as the country’s new cases show no signs of declining since the ... Read more »

COVID-19 situation ‘very dangerous,' says Korea's disease control chief

Jeong Eun-kyeong, the Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency chief, speaks during a televised briefing Monday at the agency headquarters in Osong, North Chungcheong Province. (KDCA)The head of Korea’s disease ... Read more »

1,956 people caught for drug-related charges from Aug.-Oct.: police

This Nov. 1, 2021, file photo, provided by the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency, shows illegal drugs confiscated in a crackdown. (Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency)A total of 1,956 people have been ... Read more »

In-person classes fully resume at schools nationwide amid virus resurgence

Students head to in-person classes at an elementary school in Seoul’s Yongsan district on the first day of the full resumption of in-person school attendance on Monday. (Yonhap)In-person school classes ... Read more »

Daily infections fall below 3,000, country's guard up as in-person classes resume

Students arrive at their junior high school in Incheon, 40 kilometers west of Seoul, on Monday, as in-person school classes at all kindergartens, elementary, middle and high schools across the ... Read more »

Police chief apologizes over bungled response to violent dispute between neighbors

National Police Agency Commissioner-General Kim Chang-yong (Yonhap) Police chief Kim Chang-yong apologized Sunday for the police’s bungled response to a violent dispute between neighbors that left one person unconscious. “I ... Read more »

Rising number of COVID-19 patients waiting for hospital care in Korea

Portable negative pressure wards for housing COVID-19 patients are set up outside a public hospital in Seoul. (Yonhap) More than 800 patients with COVID-19 in Seoul were waiting for hospital ... Read more »

[From the scene] As home isolation becomes default, bed availability remains issue

Health at Hallym University Medical Center give telephone consultations to Yeongdeungpo-gu patients in home isolation on Thursday. (Ministry of Health and Welfare) Health care workers in charge of looking after ... Read more »

[News Focus] Pay gap for regular, nonregular workers widening

A participant in a job fair in Seoul experiences an experimental interview via virtual reality devices earlier this month. (Yonhap)SEJONG — Nonregular workers’ pay has risen quite slowly compared to ... Read more »

Fine dust blankets much of South Korea

A road around Gwanghwamun Square in Seoul, is shrouded in fine dust on Saturday. (Yonhap)A choking pall of fine dust plagued much of South Korea on Saturday, prompting authorities to ... Read more »

US service member detained for refusing sobriety test after car accident

A US service member stationed in South Korea was detained by local police after refusing to take a field sobriety test following a minor car accident, authorities said Saturday. The ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily COVID-19 cases hover over 3,000 for 4th day

People wait in a line to undergo COVID-19 test at a coronavirus testing site at Seoul Station, Friday. (Yonhap) South Korea’s new coronavirus cases stayed above 3,000 for the fourth ... Read more »

Ultrafine dust advisory in effect in Seoul

(Yonhap) An ultrafine dust advisory was issued for all of Seoul on Friday for the first time in about six months, the metropolitan government said. The advisory was issued at ... Read more »

[From the Scene] Korea's top health protection agency chief gets third COVID-19 shot

KDCA Commissioner Jeong Eun-kyeong receives a Moderna booster on Friday morning at a hospital in Cheongju, North Chungcheong Province, near the agency’s headquarters. (Kim Arin/The Korea Herald)The head of South ... Read more »

Return to normal could stop with rise in serious COVID-19 cases: PM

Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum (Yonhap)South Korea could stop its return to normal, Prime Minister Kim Boo-kyum said Friday as the country continued to see a sharp rise in the number ... Read more »

Quintuplets born in South Korea for first time in 34 years

Photos of the quintuplets born at the Seoul National University Hospital on late Thursday night. (Seoul National University Hospital)South Korea saw the first successful birth of quintuplets in 34 years, ... Read more »

In-person school classes to fully resume next week

A high school teacher conducts online classes in the southeastern city of Daegu last Thursday, a week before the country’s nationwide college entrance exam. (Yonhap)In-person school classes will fully resume ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily COVID-19 cases hover over 3,000 for 3rd day

Makeshift wards made of containers are set up at a parking lot of the Seoul Medical Center in Seoul on Thursday. (Yonhap)South Korea’s new coronavirus cases stayed above 3,000 for ... Read more »

17 days of normal push Korea's COVID-19 cases to hit new high

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea saw the highest number of new COVID-19 cases since the start ... Read more »

[News Focus] Nonregular jobs increase faster in 5 major cities

A bulletin board at the regional unit of Employment Welfare Plus Center in Seoul shows job information earlier this month. (Yonhap)SEJONG – Major cities outside the capital have led the ... Read more »

Beaumax donates 30,000 masks to Myanmar upon high school kid's request

A ceremony is held for Beaumax’s donation of 30,000 face masks to children in need in Myanmar through Worldshare. (Beaumax)Cosmetics firm Beaumax donated 30,000 face masks to support disadvantaged children ... Read more »

[Photo News] Rogers family in hanbok

Investor Jim Rogers (left), his wife Paige Parker (right) and their daughter Hilton Augusta pose in contemporary hanbok at their residence in Singapore in this file photo acquired by The ... Read more »

Daily reports of stalking sharply increase after implementation of anti-stalking law: police

View from the outside of a police station (Yonhap)The number of stalking complaints filed with police shot up to about 103 cases a day since the anti-stalking law went into ... Read more »

S. Korea's daily virus cases hit new record high amid relaxed virus curbs

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea’s new coronavirus cases hit an all-time high on Thursday since the ... Read more »

National college entrance exam kicks off amid pandemic

College aspirants at a high school in Seoul’s Yongsan district prepare to take the College Scholastic Ability Test on Thursday. (Yonhap)Nearly 500,000 high school seniors and other exam takers nationwide ... Read more »

Gimhae city apologizes for mandatory virus testing of foreign children amid xenophobia concerns

The headquarters of the National Human Rights Commission of Korea in Seoul. (Yonhap)The government of the southeastern city of Gimhae apologized Thursday for ordering mandatory COVID-19 tests of foreign children ... Read more »

USFK begins COVID-19 inoculation program for affiliated children

A seven-year old child gets a Pfizer vaccine shot at a US Forces Korea base in Pyeongtaek, on Wednesday. (Yonhap)The US Forces Korea on Wednesday started inoculating children in its ... Read more »

Korea reviewing emergency approval for Merck's COVID-19 pills

Minister of Food and Drug Safety Kim Ganglip speaks to reporters during a press conference held Wednesday at the ministry headquarters in Osong, North Chungcheong Province. (Ministry of Food and ... Read more »

[Newsmaker] Ex-lawmaker's home, Hana Bank head office searched in Daejang-dong scandal

Investigators from the Seoul Central District Prosecutors Office carry boxes containing items they seized during the raid on ousted lawmaker Kwak Sang-do on Nov.17.(Yonhap)South Korean prosecutors on Wednesday searched ousted ... Read more »

Korea to shorten wait for COVID-19 boosters as breakthrough hospitalizations rise

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)South Korea will shorten the wait for COVID-19 booster shots as the daily ... Read more »

Seoul reports record daily COVID-19 cases

People stand in line to receive coronavirus tests at a screening clinic in southeastern Seoul on Wednesday. (Yonhap)Daily coronavirus cases in Seoul topped 1,400 for the first time Wednesday, two ... Read more »

'Face-to-face phishing' on rise: police

This illustrated image depicts voice phishing. (Yonhap)Voice phishing scammers are getting increasingly bold lately as many of them prefer to directly meet fraud victims to extort money, the National Police ... Read more »

Gimhae city withdraws virus test program of foreign children amid xenophobia concerns

The headquarters of the National Human Rights Commission of Korea in Seoul. (Yonhap)The government of the southeastern city of Gimhae on Wednesday withdrew a mandatory virus test program of foreign ... Read more »

Metaverse ceremony to virtually celebrate homecoming of late independence hero Kim Gu

This image of a metaverse avatar of independence hero Kim Gu is provided by the Seoul Museum of History. (Seoul Museum of History)A metaverse event on Wednesday will conjure up ... Read more »

New COVID-19 cases spike to second-largest figure of 3,187

A nurse in full protective gear works at a ward for serious COVID-19 cases in Gachon University Gil Medical Center in Incheon, west of Seoul, on Tuesday. (Yonhap)South Korea’s daily ... Read more »

2.9 magnitude earthquake hits off S. Korea's southeastern coast: KMA

This image, provided by the Korea Meteorological Administration, shows the epicenter of a 2.9 magnitude earthquake that hit South Korea’s southeastern coast on Wednesday. (KMA)A 2.9 magnitude earthquake struck off ... Read more »

S. Korea to cut dosage interval for COVID-19 booster shots on senior citizens

A health worker administers a COVID-19 vaccine booster shot to a person at a hospital in Seoul in this photo taken last Monday. (Yonhap)South Korea will cut the dosage interval ... Read more »

[News Focus] Korea to top OECD gender pay gap, again

Flags of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development at its headquarters in Paris (OECD)SEJONG — South Korea looks set to keep its undesirable No. 1 position in the pay ... Read more »

Seoul hospitals overwhelmed, but Korea committed to staying open

  A proctor in full protective gear rehearses to supervise the college entrance test at a classroom for test-takers with COVID-19 symptoms at Areum High School in Sejong, central South ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic