Up in smoke: Batsa's cigarette pricing strategy has backfired, exposing its greedy, grubby underbelly

After two decades of limited competition and ever-increasing profits, things started unravelling for British American Tobacco SA in 2010 after a number of small, aggressive cigarette manufacturers entered the SA market. Previously, the company had been able to exploit its near-monopoly power to increase cigarette prices and therefore profits.

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved  

Corné van Walbeek is a Professor in the School of Economics at the University of Cape Town and Director of the Research Unit on the Economics of Excisable Products (Reep). Samantha Filby is a Research Officer at Reep.

Recently, Stop Tobacco Organisations and Products (Stop), an industry watchdog, published two reports (here and here) that describe British American Tobacco’s (BAT’s) efforts to undermine its competitors’ activities, mostly through dubious or illicit means.

The content of these reports has been summarised in an article that appeared in Daily Maverick. Among other things, the reports indicate that British American Tobacco South Africa (Batsa) and its UK-based parent company, BAT plc, have spent hundreds of millions of rands to fund a surveillance system that spied on — and disrupted — the activities of its competitors.

The ramifications of this scandal are potentially huge: not only are organisations like Stop placing pressure on authorities to punish BAT’s actions, but the average South African smoker is gaining insight into BAT’s “nefarious”, “colonial-like” practices which may have negative implications for the image of and demand for its brands. We believe that the situation BAT finds itself in is, largely, the result of its own actions.

In 1999, when Batsa was formed after the merger of Rothmans and the BAT-affiliated United Tobacco Company, the merged entity had a nearly 95% share of South Africa’s cigarette market. In 2019, it had a market share of 71.4% of the legal market. Its share of the total market, i.e. including the illicit market, is probably less than 50%. How is it that a company that was so dominant could fall so far?

One possible answer: corporate greed.

The story has a long run-up. During the 1970s and 1980s, Rembrandt, the South African subsidiary of Rothmans, was able to increase its market share by producing cigarettes that the market wanted and selling them at competitive prices. South Africa experienced high inflation during the 1970s and 1980s, but Rembrandt generally increased its prices by less than the inflation rate, which meant that its cigarettes became relatively cheaper.

There was a cosy relationship between Rembrandt and the apartheid government. In many years the excise taxes were not increased, and when they were, they were increased by less than the inflation rate. The combination of below-inflation tax increases and below-inflation net-of-tax price increases meant that the real cigarette retail price in 1990 was 40% lower than in the late 1960s.

Things changed in 1990. The ANC was unbanned, Nelson Mandela was released from prison and negotiations for a democratic dispensation began. The ANC made it clear that it would prioritise primary healthcare and disease prevention, and that it would have a strong tobacco-control policy. It, therefore, seemed unlikely that the cigarette market would continue to expand as it had done in previous decades.

In response to this threat, Rembrandt changed its strategy. Whereas previously it had gradually reduced the real price of cigarettes to attract more customers, it now embarked on a strategy to increase the retail price of its products substantially. While this may have caused it to lose those customers who could not afford the higher prices, this loss in volume was more than compensated for by an increase in the profit per cigarette. This strategy increased Rembrandt’s total revenue and total profit.

Crucially, it was only possible because of Rembrandt’s near-monopoly control of the South African cigarette market: holding about 85% of the total cigarette market at the time meant that it could raise its prices without much fear of being undermined by competitors.

When the ANC came into power in 1994, it substantially increased the excise tax on tobacco products. These increases were publicly castigated by Rembrandt as unfair and discriminatory. However, Rembrandt used these excise tax increases as a smokescreen to increase the retail price of cigarettes by much more than the excise tax increase. The result was that their profit per cigarette increased even more.

Since 1994, National Treasury has followed a clear and transparent principle in setting the excise tax level. It sets the excise tax in such a way that the total tax burden (i.e. the sum of excise tax and VAT, expressed as a percentage of the retail price) of the most popular-priced cigarette is 50%. This percentage was increased to 52% in 2002. What this meant is that if the tobacco industry increased the retail price, National Treasury would increase the excise tax in the subsequent budget cycle in order to keep to the targeted tax burden percentage.

Between 1994 and 2010, this system worked very well for Rembrandt, and, since 1999, Batsa. Twice a year, in March/April and again in August, the company would increase the retail price of cigarettes, by a rate usually well above the inflation rate. The price of cigarettes, in inflation-adjusted (i.e. real) terms, simply went up and up. Consumption dropped by between 2% and 5% each year, but the decrease in consumption was more than compensated for by the increase in the profit per cigarette.

In 2010, the total real net-of-tax turnover of the tobacco industry was more than 30% greater than it was in 1994, despite the fact that the total number of cigarettes smoked had fallen by 37%. The creation of Batsa in 1999, following the merger of Rothmans and United Tobacco, further entrenched the dominance of the company by bringing its market share up to 95%.

In the early 2000s, some competitors — among them, Apollo Tobacco, Mastermind Tobacco, Masters Tobacco, and Philip Morris — entered the South African cigarette market, though these entrants did not pose an existential threat to Batsa. Philip Morris marketed its Marlboro brand as a popular-price brand, rather than a discount brand, and did not undercut Batsa’s prices. Mastermind Tobacco posed a temporary threat to Batsa’s market share by producing significantly cheaper cigarettes, but they were closed down in 2006. The other companies were simply too small to pose a significant threat.

After almost two decades of limited competition and ever-increasing profits, things started unravelling for Batsa in 2010. The very large profits earned by Batsa attracted a number of small, aggressive cigarette manufacturers into the South African market. The new entrants were primarily competing in the low-price segment, selling at prices substantially lower than the economy brands sold by Batsa. Some of these manufacturers were legal, some were not.

The presence of low-price cigarettes dramatically changed the cigarette market. Previously, Batsa had been able to exploit their near-monopoly power to increase cigarette prices and therefore profits, but this was no longer possible after 2010. In effect, Batsa sowed the seeds of its own destruction. Had they been more modest in their pricing strategy, they would not have created the incentive for competitors to enter the market. These competitors mercilessly eroded their market share after 2010.

Batsa’s primary response to these low-price competitors is to argue that they are competitive because they are not paying taxes. There is certainly some truth in that. Evidence collected by our colleagues at the Research Unit on the Economics of Excisable Products (Reep) indicates that a substantial proportion of cigarettes produced by Batsa’s competitors are sold at prices so low that it is impossible that the full tax amount has been paid. It did not help Batsa’s situation that the South African Revenue Services was incapacitated from about 2014 onwards, further enabling non-tax-paid cigarettes to undermine Batsa’s market share.

However, Batsa is no saint. As research compiled in the Tobacco Control Data Initiative website shows, both small national companies and large international firms like BAT contribute to the illicit tobacco trade.

Despite attempts to portray itself as a pillar of virtue in a sea of vice, Batsa’s use of spies, lies and bribes to claw back some of its market share reveals its greedy, grubby underbelly. It will be tough to come back from this. DM

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

MacOS Monterey: Apple releases new operating system for computers and makes it available to download now

© Getty Images macmini.jpg Apple has released Monterey, the latest version of MacOS. The new software comes with a range of features, many of which have already been seen in ... Read more »

Teen Allegedly Killed 3 Other Valets in Crash After Doing Donuts in Client's Vehicle and Fleeing Police

© Provided by Law & Crime Ahmedal Tayeb Elnouman Modawi Ahmedal Tayeb Elnouman Modawi. The teenage boy who allegedly killed three other valets by crashing a client’s car into them ... Read more »

Report: Browns RB Nick Chubb Expected to Return vs. Steelers

© Provided by Sports Illustrated Browns running back Nick Chubb is reportedly expected to return Sunday against the Steelers as long as he does not have any setbacks in practice. ... Read more »

Hawks owner says Atlanta should be top free agent destination

© Provided by NBC Sports Atlanta is not traditionally seen as a top free agent destination, at least one on the level of Los Angeles, New York, or Miami. Yet ... Read more »

Liberty University accused of punishing students who reported rape incidents

Liberty University received criticism following allegations that it punished students who claimed to be victims of rape. The Virginia university is accused of dismissing and discouraging students who alleged they ... Read more »

FBI: Lexington man threatened to kill a sheriff after teen was fatally shot by deputy

A Lexington man is accused of threatening to kill an Arkansas sheriff after one of the sheriff’s former deputies shot and killed a teenager earlier this year, according to federal ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin among those responsible for checking gun, ‘Rust' crew member says

At least four people were responsible for checking the weapon that killed cinematographer Halyna Hutchins. Swen Studios/Handout via REUTERS A location manager for “Rust” says at least four people were ... Read more »

Essex Police release details of eight men held in double murder probe

Police have released the details of eight men being questioned on suspicion of murder after two teenage boys died in Essex. Officers were called to Regency Court in Brentwood at ... Read more »

Skateboarder arrested for vandalizing George Floyd statue in Union Square

A 37-year-old skateboarder who allegedly threw paint on a George Floyd statue in Manhattan’s Union Square Park was arrested Monday, cops said. Micah Beals, of Rutgers Street, was charged with ... Read more »

Strictly's Giovanni Pernice breaks silence on ‘great relationship' with Maura Higgins ending after dating app reveal

STRICTLY star Giovanni Pernice has broken his silence about his “great relationship” with Maura Higgins ending. The Sun today revealed the professional dancer was using a dating app before their ... Read more »

National Lottery draw LIVE: Set For Life jackpot of £10k for 30 YEARS up for grabs tonight ahead of EuroMillions draw

THE National Lottery's Set For Life draw takes place tonight, with Brits gearing up to play for a jackpot of £10k a month for the next 30 YEARS. The draw ... Read more »

How to complete all week 5 missions in CS:GO's Operation Riptide

The fifth set of weekly Operation Riptide missions has arrived in CS:GO, bringing six more operation stars for the operation owners to earn and spend at the store. © Provided ... Read more »

These Are the Best Sleeper Sofas for Any Space

© Amazon Space, more often than not, comes at a premium. Homes and apartments only have so much real estate to fit furniture in, so finding a way to make ... Read more »

Jury selection in Ahmaud Arbery slaying crawls into 2nd week

BRUNSWICK, Ga. (AP) — Jury selection in the trial of three men charged with chasing and killing Ahmaud Arbery crawled into its second week Monday, with the judge and attorneys ... Read more »

Whistleblower Haugen says Facebook makes online hate worse

LONDON (AP) — Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen told British lawmakers Monday that the social media giant stokes online hate and extremism, fails to protect children from harmful content and lacks ... Read more »

Metropolitan police officer accused of rape goes on trial in Essex

A Metropolitan police officer accused of raping a woman told her he thought she was “playing hard to get” when she told him no, a court has been told. She ... Read more »

Walmart is already rolling out Black Friday deals — 16 worth shopping now

Shop TODAY is editorially independent. Our editors selected these deals and items because we think you will enjoy them at these prices. If you purchase something through our links, we ... Read more »

Miramar teen was attacked in apartment stairwell, stabbed and beaten to death

Dwight “D.J.” Grant was ambushed in the stairwell at his family’s apartment community in Miramar and beaten and stabbed to death, records just released by the Miramar police reveal. Police ... Read more »

Manchin says he's open to tax targeting billionaires

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) signaled on Monday that he’s open to a tax targeting billionaires as Democrats scramble to figure out how to pay for their sweeping social spending bill. ... Read more »

FIFA 22 TOTW Upgrade: How to Complete the SBC

FIFA 22 TOTW Upgrade SBC packs were released for the first time on Oct. 25 giving players a chance to pack some of the best items released in the game ... Read more »

Steam PC games are now playable on Xbox thanks to Nvidia GeForce Now

If you have a Steam game library, an Nvidia GeForce Now membership, and an Xbox One or Series X/S, then you can totally play those PC games on your console. ... Read more »

Anna Kendrick Goes Pretty in Pink in a Satin Mini Dress for ‘Love Life' Season 2

© Steven Bergman/AFF-USA.COM/MEGA anna-kendrick-pink-dress-red-carpet Anna Kendrick popped in pink for the Tribecca Fall Preview of her hit series, “Love Life.” Walking the red carpet last night in New York, the ... Read more »

France travel: Britons must follow strict rule for France holidays until next year

France’s health passport requires tourists and residents to prove their vaccination status or provide a negative test to enter tourist attractions and hospitality venues. The French Government has just extended ... Read more »

Army on standby to help save NHS from collapse this winter

The threat of COVID-19 cases rising and the emergence of winter flu means doctors and nurses could be overwhelmed by the demand for their services this winter. Mr Wallace stated ... Read more »

New ULEZ rules come into force today - everything you need to know

The Ultra Low Emission Zone (ULEZ) has been expanded to cut pollution in London – and there’s new rules to consider. The zone forces cars and other vehicles with high ... Read more »

Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin proposes commercial space station

Blue Origin, the rocket and space tourism company founded by Jeff Bezos, is proposing a massive new commercial space station called “Orbital Reef” that could be used to host science ... Read more »

23 Money-Saving Tips You Can Start Trying Today

© Denis Novikov Saving money can feel like a complicated, daunting task, but it can be much easier when broken down into a few simple money-saving tips to get you ... Read more »

‘Friends' Cast Pays Tribute to Late Costar James Michael Tyler, ‘You Will Be So Missed'

© Mike Marsland – Getty Images ’Friends‘ star James Michael Tyler, known as Gunther, lost his battle with stage 4 prostate cancer. Jennifer Aniston and other costars paid tribute to ... Read more »

Palestinian PM Calls on U.S. to Push Back on Israeli Plan for West Bank Housing Units

Mohammad Shtayyeh, the prime minister of the Palestinian Authority, has asked the U.S. to push back on Israel’s settlements, straining the peace between them. © Ariel Schalit/Associated Press Mohammad Shtayyeh, ... Read more »

Jamie Foxx doesn't have a personal trainer or lift weights - he swears by doing pull-ups to stay fit and toned

© Leon Bennett/WireImage Jamie Foxx’s Hollywood career spans over two decades. Leon Bennett/WireImage Jamie Foxx said he, unlike many actors, doesn’t have a personal trainer. Instead, he just has a ... Read more »

7 Face Exercises To Sculpt Muscles and Strengthen Skin From the Neck Up

© Photo: Getty/Marco VDM face exercises Given that all the muscles of the body are designed to move for optimal wellness, it makes sense that your face (which also has ... Read more »

Uncertainties weigh on Turkey's ties with West

© Handout Jailed philanthropist Osman Kavala, pictured, is at the centre of the current row between Turkey and the West Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Monday walked back from ... Read more »

Jordan likens Man Utd boss Solskjaer to a ‘one-legged man'

© PA Images Current-Man-United-boss-Ole-Gunnar-Solskjaer Former Crystal Palace owner Simon Jordan has likened Ole Gunnar Solskajer to a “one-legged man” as he “can’t do” the Manchester United job. After managing Molde ... Read more »

Brundle calls for ‘manners and respect' after US GP gridwalk

© PA Images F1 pundit Martin Brundle under an umbrella. F1 pundit Martin Brundle feels it is time for some “manners and respect” after controversial bodyguard behaviour in Austin. The ... Read more »

ULEZ: ‘Stealth tax' to ‘It's a win win'- Londoners react to Ultra Low Emmision Zone expansion

© Getty Images The Ultra Low Emissions Zone Comes Into Effect Londoners have given their say on the expansion of the ULEZ which came into force on Monday across the ... Read more »

How Brian Kemp used the Atlanta Braves making the World Series to troll Stacey Abrams

It’s been 22 years since the Atlanta Braves last made the World Series. And what better way to celebrate such a monumental accomplishment than to use it as a way ... Read more »

HDFC AMC Q2 FY2022 Results: PAT for September quarter stands at Rs 344.38 crore - Check key highlights here

© Provided by Zee Business HDFC AMC Q2 FY2022 Results: HDFC AMC has released the financial results for the quarter and half yearly ended on September 30, 2021. The income ... Read more »

Cargo exports need wide bodied aircraft

© Provided by The Times of India VISAKHAPATNAM: The air cargo from Vizag would be expected to increase around 35% to 40% per year in the next couple of years ... Read more »

Cyient's ex-date for Rs 10 per share dividend tomorrow - this makes it 23rd dividend offer to shareholders since July 2011

© Provided by Zee Business The board of Cyient Ltd has approved a dividend of Rs 10 per equity share for stakeholders. The ex-date for the dividend has been announced by the company as October 26, 2021, while the ... Read more »

Apple starts macOS Monterey rollout: compatible Macs, how to download and what to expect

Apple has started rolling out the much-awaited macOS update for its Mac lineup. Called macOS Monterey, the latest version of the macOS is now available for download for MacBook and ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic