United States: Supreme Court set to take up all-or-nothing abortion fight

United States: Supreme Court set to take up all-or-nothing abortion fight

Both sides are telling the United States Supreme Court there’s no middle ground in Wednesday’s showdown over abortion. The justices can either reaffirm the constitutional right to an abortion or wipe it away altogether.

Roe v. Wade, the landmark 1973 ruling that declared a nationwide right to abortion, is facing its most serious challenge in 30 years in front of a court with a 6-3 conservative majority that has been remade by three appointees of President Donald Trump.

“There are no half measures here,” said Sherif Girgis, a Notre Dame law professor who once served as a law clerk for Justice Samuel Alito.

A ruling that overturned Roe and the 1992 case of Planned Parenthood v. Casey would lead to outright bans or severe restrictions on abortion in 26 states, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a research organisation that supports abortion rights.

The case being argued Wednesday comes from Mississippi, where a 2018 law would ban abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy, well before viability. The Supreme Court has never allowed states to ban abortion before the point at roughly 24 weeks when a foetus can survive outside the womb.

The justices are separately weighing disputes over Texas’ much earlier abortion ban, at roughly six weeks, though those cases turn on the unique structure of the law and how it can be challenged in court, not the abortion right. Still, abortion rights advocates were troubled by the court’s 5-4 vote in September to allow the Texas law, which relies on citizen lawsuits to enforce it, to take effect in the first place.

“This is the most worried I’ve ever been,” said Shannon Brewer, who runs the only abortion clinic in Mississippi, the Jackson Women’s Health Organization.

The clinic offers abortions up to 16 weeks of pregnancy and about 10 per cent of abortions it performs take place after the 15th week, Brewer said.

She also noted that since the Texas law took effect, the clinic has seen a substantial increase in patients, operating five days or six days a week instead of two or three.

Lower courts blocked the Mississippi law, as they have other abortion bans that employ traditional enforcement methods by state and local officials.

The Supreme Court had never before even agreed to hear a case over a pre-viability abortion ban. But after Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death last year and her replacement by Justice Amy Coney Barrett, the third of Trump’s appointees, the court said it would take up the case.

Trump had pledged to appoint “pro-life justices” and predicted they would lead the way in overturning the abortion rulings. Only one justice, Clarence Thomas, has publicly called for Roe to be overruled.

The court could uphold the Mississippi law without explicitly overruling Roe and Casey, an outcome that would satisfy neither side.

Abortion-rights advocates say that result would amount to the same thing as an outright ruling overturning the earlier cases because it would erase the rationale undergirding nearly a half-century of Supreme Court law.

“A decision upholding this ban is tantamount to overruling Roe. The ban prohibits abortion around two months before viability,” said Julie Rikelman, who will argue the case for the clinic.

On the other side, abortion opponents argue that the court essentially invented abortion law in Roe and Casey, and shouldn’t repeat that mistake in this case.

If the justices uphold Mississippi’s law, they’ll have to explain why, said Thomas Jipping, a Heritage Foundation legal fellow. They can either overrule the two big cases, Jipping said, “or they’re going to have to come up with another made-up rule.”

Conservative commentator Ed Whelan said such an outcome would be a “massive defeat” on par with the Casey decision in 1992, in which a court with eight justices appointed by Republican presidents unexpectedly reaffirmed Roe.

This court appears far more conservative than the one that decided Casey, and legal historian Mary Ziegler at Florida State University’s law school, said the court probably would “overrule Roe or set us on a path to doing so”.

Chief Justice John Roberts might find the more incremental approach appealing if he can persuade a majority of the court to go along. Since Roberts became chief justice in 2005, the court has moved in smaller steps on some issues, even when it appeared there was only a binary choice.

It took two cases for the court to rip out the heart of the federal Voting Rights Act that curbed potentially discriminatory voting laws in states with a history of discrimination.

In the area of organised labour, the court moved through a series of cases that chipped away at public sector unions’ power.

The high court also heard two rounds of arguments over restrictions on independent spending in the political arena before removing limits on how much money corporations and unions can pour into election advocacy.

If the court looks to public sentiment, it would find poll after poll that shows support for preserving Roe, though some surveys also find backing for greater restrictions on abortion.

Mississippi is one of 12 states ready to act almost immediately if Roe is overturned. Those states have enacted so-called abortion trigger laws that would take effect and ban all or nearly all abortions.

Women in those states wanting abortions could face drives of hundreds of kilometres to reach the nearest clinic or they might obtain abortion pills by mail. Medication abortions now account for 40 per cent of abortions.

Some legal briefs in the case make clear that the end of Roe is not the ultimate goal of abortion opponents.

The court should recognise that “unborn children are persons” under the Constitution’s 14th Amendment, a conclusion that would compel an end to almost all legal abortions, Princeton professor Robert George and scholar John Finnis wrote. Finnis was Justice Neil Gorsuch’s adviser on his Oxford dissertation, an argument against assisted suicide.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Covid 19 Omicron: Residents and staff at Auckland retirement home linked to Omicron case return negative results

More than 300 residents and staff at an Auckland retirement village where a kitchen hand tested positive for Omicron have all returned negative test results. And if a further round ... Read more »

RFK Jr. apologises after condemnation for Anne Frank comment

Anti-vaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. apologised for suggesting things are worse for people today than they were for Anne Frank, the teenager who died in a Nazi concentration camp ... Read more »

Jamie Oliver hires cultural appropriation advisors for recipes

The Naked Chef says he has hired “cultural appropriation specialists” to avoid further offence and embarrassment caused by his recipes. The celebrity chef-turned-restaurateur Jamie Oliver described his ongoing battle with ... Read more »

How a swimming pool reportedly led to Adele's Las Vegas residency drama

A new detail has emerged in Adele’s Las Vegas residency saga. According to a source who spoke to the Sun, the reason for the cancellation of her shows goes beyond ... Read more »

Italy wants their famous espresso coffee to have UNESCO status

Few things feel more quintessentially Italian than ordering ‘un caffè’ at an espresso bar. Around the world Italy is known for its coffee culture; something the nation now want to ... Read more »

Ukraine crisis: What are US options for sanctions against Putin?

The financial options being considered to punish President Vladimir Putin if Russia invades Ukraine range from the sweeping to the acutely personal — from cutting Russia off from U.S. dollars ... Read more »

Zakharova: Times ran fake news on ordinary Ukrainians taking up arms

Russian Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman said the Times misrepresented a member of Ukraine’s territorial defense forces as an ordinary citizen Read more »

Portugal's snap election: Why now? Who leads the polls? Why does it matter?

Portugal is holding parliamentary elections on Sunday, 30 January. Here’s our special guide to understanding the vote. Why has the election been called? Portugal is holding snap elections after the ... Read more »

Palmerston North writer Miriam Sharland working on an eco-biography

What does an Englishwoman living in Palmerston North do when Covid-19 grounds her writing plans? In Miriam Sharland’s case, she makes like a Kiwi and turns to her neighbourhood and ... Read more »

Benedict Cumberbatch's lockdown antics in Hawke's Bay - the legitimate and the dubious

A-lister Benedict Cumberbatch might’ve been in lockdown in Hawke’s Bay, but it didn’t stop him seeing some of the region. Ever since a Sherlock Holmes-inspired Hawke’s Bay Today reporter looked ... Read more »

Kanye West's bombshell Kim Kardashian 'second sex tape' claim

In the latest Kimye news, Kayne West is claiming he prevented his ex-wife’s second sex tape from seeing the light of day. Kim Kardashian rose to fame shortly after her ... Read more »

Covid-19 Australia: Anti-vaxxers caught out selling 'legal letters' to parents ahead of schools' return

Anti-vaxxers are selling ‘legal’ letters which experts say carry no more weight than a note scrawled on a piece of paper to parents concerned about their children being vaccinated. It ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Government 'commandeering' rapid antigen tests secured by private sector, National Party says

The National Party is accusing the Government of taking rapid antigen tests away from the private sector to hide its own incompetence. There are 4.6 million of the Covid-19 tests ... Read more »

'You were a tireless warrior': Family of slain Christchurch woman Juliana Herrera speak

The family of Colombian woman Juliana Herrera have paid tribute to her days after she was allegedly murdered in her Christchurch home. The 37-year-old was found dead in her flat ... Read more »

Border reopening plan: Stranded New Zealanders to learn about self-isolation scheme soon

Overseas New Zealanders desperate to return home will soon learn when they can travel here without booking a stay in a managed isolation (MIQ) facility. They have been waiting for ... Read more »

Rangiora signwriter accused of making fake vaccine passes

Police have swooped on a Canterbury signwriter who has allegedly been making fake vaccine passes. Officers this morning raided the printing and graphics business which operates out of a shed ... Read more »

Harakeke: Tamariki create putiputi at Hollard Gardens

Harakeke (flax) was transformed into putiputi (flowers) at a school holiday activity. Last week, tamariki and their whānau made their way to Hollard Gardens for a putiputi weaving workshop, organised ... Read more »

Thousands become New Zealand residents under new government scheme

By Gill Bonnett for RNZ About 5000 people have become residents under a fast-track government scheme launched last month, with migrants from India, South Africa, and the Philippines topping the ... Read more »

Biden called the conditions for imposing sanctions against Putin

It is possible in case of Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, US President said Read more »

18 policemen, 3 protesters hurt during clashes near parliament building in Kiev

According to the police, media reports that one of the protesters was killed are not true Read more »

White House says papers like US response to Russian proposals aren't typically made public

"It’s a part of the diplomatic process", White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said Read more »

Macron says plans to hold phone talks with Putin on January 28

According to French President, they will discuss "the situation in general" Read more »

Opinion: Goal is to create 'path forward to resolve the issues'

Weekly column by Kāpiti’s Greater Wellington Regional Council representative Penny Gaylor. Welcome to 2022, happy new year, and I hope it has been a safe summer for you all. Like ... Read more »

Nicola Alpe: Five ways to make 2022 your most productive year yet

Summer is coming to a swift close and it’s time for us to turn up the productivity. It can be an ugly word, but if you look at productivity as ... Read more »

Greerton Aquatic Centre to close for nine weeks

The Greerton Aquatic and Leisure Centre will close for nine weeks to undertake scheduled maintenance and improvements to this much-loved community facility. Improvements will be made to enhance the visitor ... Read more »

How takeaway delivery services are killing the art of cooking - Jamie Oliver

Jamie Oliver says online takeaways are killing off the art of cooking. The 46-year-old TV chef has insisted the habit of ordering meals to be delivered is “driving our kids ... Read more »

Racing: Opawa Superstar dominant in NZ Breeders

Opawa Superstar lived up to his name at Addington on Thursday night, when he broke through for his maiden Group One victory in the Suck It Up Ltd New Zealand ... Read more »

Rising cost of living in Aotearoa may trigger civil disobedience, social service says

By Hamish Cardwell of RNZ A “perfect storm” of the rising costs of basic necessities, inflation and Covid-19 have a social service warning of possible “civil disobedience” – with people ... Read more »

Crystal Hefner confirms Hugh Hefner had 'thousands' of explicit photos taken without consent

Crystal Hefner has confirmed one of several alarming claims about life in the Playboy Mansion, tweeting her support of former Playmate Holly Madison. Madison, who dated millionaire Hugh Hefner from ... Read more »

Woman reveals 'genius' trick to getting expensive tourist experience for free

Want to take an iconic gondola ride around Venice, without paying €80? One UK woman has shared how to do exactly that in a popular TikTok. Katie, from the UK, ... Read more »

Ordering takeaways are killing the art of cooking - Jamie Oliver

Jamie Oliver says online takeaways are killing off the art of cooking. The 46-year-old TV chef has insisted the habit of ordering meals to be delivered is “driving our kids ... Read more »

Facebook gently mocks the New Zilund accent in its first Metaverse ad

It’s time to enter the Matrix … of dad jokes. The Kiwi accent gets a gentle ribbing in Facebook’s first global ad for its much-hyped “metaverse”. The tech giant- which ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Auckland locations of interest list grows, Hamilton and Kaitaia shops added

More Auckland high-risk locations are being added to the growing list which now includes six flights, three bus routes, a liquor store, a bakery and a wedding that had up ... Read more »

Neil Young demands Spotify removes his music, citing Joe Rogan's podcast as a reason

Neil Young has demanded his music be removed from Spotify because it is “spreading” Covid-19 vaccine misinformation. The legendary musician has requested – via an online letter to his record ... Read more »

Covid 19 Omicron outbreak: Grant Robertson clashes with Heather du Plessis-Allan over RAT 'ban'

Newstalk ZB host Heather Du Plessis-Allan has clashed with Deputy Prime Minister Grant Robertson over the Government’s plan for the supply of rapid antigen tests (RATs). New Zealand’s supply of ... Read more »

Across NZ on an EV road trip: Where to stop, stay and charge

Motor Industry Association statistics show a record 3290 Teslas registered in Aotearoa last year, up from 592 in 2020. That accounts only for new Teslas – add other brands, used ... Read more »

Ski resorts invest millions to fight drought and climate change

The sight can be jarring during extreme drought: snowmaking guns lined up on a mountainside, blasting precious crystal flakes on a ski run while the rest of the land goes ... Read more »

White House says Biden has no intention, desire to send troops to Ukraine

"The United States are working through NATO to plus up support in our eastern flank countries," White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said Read more »

Hunt on for Magpies' charity partner

The Hawke’s Bay Rugby Union has started the hunt for the Magpies’ charity partner as it looks forward to another big season of Ranfurly Shield and national provincial championship rugby. ... Read more »

Focus Morning Bulletin: 26 Jan, 2022

New mask mandates, schools prepare for teaching under red and Russia massing troops on the Ukraine border in the latest New Zealand Herald headlines. Video / NZ Herald Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic