UK flouting UN treaty because legal action to protect environment ‘prohibitively expensive'

Asia's Tech News Daily

The UK is flouting a United Nations convention because people cannot afford to make court challenges to protect the environment, it has been ruled.

UK flouting UN treaty because legal action to protect environment ‘prohibitively expensive’

The Aarhus Convention is an international treaty, signed by the UK, to guarantee the public access to information, participation in decision-making and the ability to contest green controversies in law.

But the UN Economic and Social Council has judged the government has failed to act on previous warnings that it is “prohibitively expensive” for campaigners to bring legal actions.

While progress has been made in some areas, the UK has not “met the requirements” set down as far back as 2017, its ruling said.

Ministers are told to “ensure that the allocation of costs in all court procedures … is fair and equitable and not prohibitively expensive”.

They should also consider “assistance mechanisms to remove or reduce financial barriers to access to justice” – submitting an action plan no later than next July.

The judgment is a further embarrassment for the government ahead of the landmark Cop26 summit in Glasgow, following controversies over delays to passing an Environment Bill.

The group ClientEarth, which has pursued the government over the Convention – drawn up 20 years ago – said it was “not serious about holding itself to a high standard”.

“Amid the current climate and biodiversity crises, it is more important than ever for the public to be able to exercise their environmental rights,” said Gillian Lobo, a senior lawyer.

“Whether that be requesting information from the government or challenging them in court when they make unlawful decisions.

“The UK should be taking all necessary steps to comply with the treaty it has ratified on access to justice, not make its position worse.”

Ms Lobo warned government threats to curb the use of judicial review threatened to “shift the dial further in the wrong direction”.

There are 47 parties to the Aarhus Convention – 46 nations in Europe and Central Asia, plus the European Union – and it is legal binding on those who have signed it.

It is designed to build trust between members of the public and governments by displaying that participation in the decision making process is valued.

Four years ago, the UK was told to submit a detailed progress report in 2017, after the compliance committee said recent policies were moving the UK further away from the Convention’s goals.

That progress report, in 2018 – plus later ones in 2019 and in October last year – have now also been rejected by the committee, but there is no mechanism to compel the UK to comply.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has been asked to respond to the ruling.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Get a Razer Raptor for $200 off with this can't-miss Cyber Monday gaming monitor deal

© Provided by GamesRadar Razer Raptor One of the best Cyber Monday gaming monitor deals we’ve spotted is still up for grabs, giving you the chance to buy Razer’s high-end ... Read more »

Analysis: Biden faces a familiar foe -- uncertainty

President Joe Biden had hoped to return from the Thanksgiving holiday bearing good news about his moves to get the economy back on track, his administration’s effort to fix the ... Read more »

Delhi air quality remains very poor; minimum temperature drops to 9.8 degrees Celsius

Delhi’s air quality remained in the very poor category on Tuesday even as the minimum temperature slipped to 9.8 degrees Celsius. The 24-hour average air quality index (AQI) read 329. ... Read more »

ICMR report on South African traveller's sample in 2-3 days: Karnataka Health Minister

The ICMR (Indian Council for Medical Research) report on the sample of one of the two South Africa returnees, who tested COVID-19 positive with features “different from the Delta variant” ... Read more »

Victoria's controversial pandemic laws to pass after crossbench MP secures amendments

Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAP Rod Barton says changes that give parliament power to disallow pandemic orders make it ‘a much better and fairer bill’ Download the free Guardian app; get our ... Read more »

Two NASA astronauts set for spacewalk to replace faulty space station antenna

By Steve Gorman (Reuters) – Two U.S. astronauts were set on Tuesday to venture out of the International Space Station for a spacewalk to replace a failed antenna, facing what ... Read more »

Petrol increase: Government needs to review the fuel levy - AA

© Provided by 702 With the price of petrol now breaking through R20 a litre from midnight, there are concerns that this will have dire consequences for consumers. This latest ... Read more »

COVID-19 | 2,273 new cases, 25 more deaths

© Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – The National Institute of Communicable Diseases reported 2,273 new COVID-19 cases. It also reported 25 more COVID-19 related deaths, taking the death toll to ... Read more »

Appeals court to weigh Trump arguments to withhold records

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Jan. 6, 2021, photo, insurrections loyal to President Donald Trump riot outside the Capitol in Washington. Trump’s lawyers on Tuesday will ... Read more »

Garena Free Fire November 28 Redeem Codes: Get Free Fire diamond, free pet codes - How to redeem today's free codes

© Provided by DNA Garena Free Fire, which is an action-adventure battle royal game, is rapidly gaining popularity in India. The game is available for free on Google Play Store. ... Read more »

British Gas customers issued warning after some get £46k bill by mistake after they're made to switch supplier

British Gas customers have expressed outrage after their bills were extortionately overestimated by thousands of pounds. Shocked customers were given energy bill estimates of up to £46,000 after being switched ... Read more »

Australia's Westpac to likely pay $81 million for allegedly charging dead people, among other breaches

Westpac said on Tuesday it will likely be fined 113 million Australian dollars ($80.8 million) for alleged compliance failures across its business over many years, including charging financial advice fees ... Read more »

Marilyn Manson's West Hollywood apartment is RAIDED by sheriff's investigators who seized hard drives while probing claims he sexually assaulted multiple women including his actress ex Evan Rachel Wood

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department raided Marilyn Manson's home early Monday morningInvestigators reportedly seized hard drives and media storage units allegedly connected to the ongoing investigations into sex assault allegations against himMore than a dozen women, including his ex-fiancee Evan Rachel Wood, have accused the rocker of physical and sexual abuseSome victims alleged that Manson would lock them in a small, soundproof glass enclosure in the home that he referred to as the Bad Girls' Room The accusers claimed he used the space as a 'solitary confinement cell, used to psychologically torture women'Manson has denied the claims and his attorney has called them 'provably false'  Read more »

Sandra Lee, 55, is snapped with her boyfriend Ben Youcef, 42, in Malibu as her 'sex pest' ex Andrew Cuomo's brother Chris faces CNN probe for secretly helping draft responses to harassment scandal

Sandra Lee, 55, dated Andrew Cuomo, 63, for 14 years until their split in September 2019Lee has since November 2019 lived in Malibu, in a $3.4 million oceanfront mansionOn Monday the Cuomo family was rocked by revelations from the New York Attorney General that Andrew's brother Chris had been involved in strategizing responses to sexual harassment claims Chris, a CNN anchor, has previously said he was a sounding board for his older brother but insisted he was not part of the then-governor's teamCNN have said they are reviewing Chris's future at the network in light of the revelationsLee meanwhile was seen with her new boyfriend, Algerian actor Ben Youcef, returning home from the grocery store  Read more »

Nathan Buckley's cosmetic nurse girlfriend Alex Pike, 44, shows off her ample cleavage and sensational figure in a black dress as she enjoys lunch with friends in Melbourne

Alex Pike recently revealed that one of the secrets to her figure is power walking ten kilometres a day. And on Sunday, the 44-year-old flaunted her sensational physique as she ... Read more »

Video: Now CDC tells ALL Americans ages 18 and up to have their COVID vaccine booster as director Dr Rochelle Walensky says they may be 'best tool' to fight Omicron variant

Read more »

Myanmar court postpones verdict for ousted leader Suu Kyi

BANGKOK (AP) — A court in Myanmar postponed its verdict on Tuesday in the trial of ousted leader Aung San Suu Kyi to allow testimony from an additional witness. © ... Read more »

Brian Kelly's exit from Notre Dame quickly got messy

Brian Kelly’s players and staff at Notre Dame were reportedly blindsided by his decision. AP Brian Kelly’s stunning move ruffled a few feathers. The 12-year Notre Dame head coach bolted ... Read more »

Delhi's LNJP Hospital designated as Covid facility, no patient to be turned back

The Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan Hospital in Delhi has been designated as a Covid Hospital. In the wake of concerns sparked by the new coronavirus variant, Omicron, the Ministry ... Read more »

CBSE Class 10 first term major subjects exam begins on November 30

The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) first term examination of major subjects will commence on Tuesday with social studies paper. Around 2 lakh students in Patna zone, comprising Bihar ... Read more »

Four of family, including 2 children, found dead at house in Delhi's Sirsapur village

Four bodies have been found at a house in Delhi’s Sirsapur village in the outer North district. Delhi Police recovered the bodies of the four members of a family. According ... Read more »

Richarlison dilemma and Demarai Gray decision after Everton substitution hint

Richarlison’s return from suspension will surely see him restored to the Everton starting line-up against Liverpool. The Brazil international was forced to sit out Sunday’s 1-0 defeat at Brentford after ... Read more »

The £36m transfer paving the way for Aston Villa to sign Joe Gomez

Aston Villa have been credited with an interest in Liverpool defender Joe Gomez, ahead of the opening of the January transfer window. Perhaps it was to be expected, that Villa ... Read more »

Ralf Rangnick is the perfect manager for where Roy Keane believes Manchester United are

Manchester United have failed to win the Premier League for eight years and the very fabric of the club is now eroding away. United was built on success and yet ... Read more »

West Brom left with decision to make amid Sam Johnstone's contract stalemate

As we edge ever closer to the January transfer window, the future of West Bromwich Albion number one and England international Sam Johnstone will come further into focus. Save for ... Read more »

Josh Giddey: How has the Thunder rookie performed 20 games into his NBA career?

Oklahoma City Thunder point guard Josh Giddey has established himself as a point guard of the future with an impressive 20-game start to his NBA career.  NBA League Pass:  Sign up ... Read more »

Sixers praise Seth Curry for big performance in close win over Magic

The Philadelphia 76ers were locked in a tight battle with the Orlando Magic that saw them struggle to eventually put them away 101-96. The Sixers led by as many as ... Read more »

Sixers credit Andre Drummond for changing the game in win over Magic

The Philadelphia 76ers needed some type of spark late against the Orlando Magic. They were unexpectedly locked in a tight battle with the young and rebuilding team after they saw ... Read more »

In Houston win, Kevin Porter Jr. records first NBA career triple-double

One week ago, the Houston Rockets had lost 15 straight games. But for over half of that streak, young point guard Kevin Porter Jr. was either limited by a left ... Read more »

In shadow of Texas gas drilling sites, health fears escalate

ARLINGTON, Texas — At a playground outside a North Texas day care center, giggling preschoolers chase each other into a playhouse. Toddlers scoot by on tricycles. A boy cries as ... Read more »

Shocking moment a shameless thief is seen stealing a Christmas wreath off a family's front door in the dead of night

An Adelaide man was caught on video stealing family's Christmas wreathThe thief can be seen removing the wreath off the front doorCommenters shared their tips for avoiding the Grinches of the season  Read more »

Video: BREAKING NEWS: Coalition senators 'BARK and growl' at Jacqui Lambie as she speaks in the Senate - on the SAME DAY report lifted the lid on foul culture at Parliament House 

Read more »

Star Wars Ahsoka spin-off TV series casts Ivanna Sakhno

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The cast of Disney Plus‘ new Star Wars spin-off TV series Ahsoka is growing once again, with Ivanna Sakhno coming aboard. The 24-year-old ... Read more »

Video: Shocking moment a shameless thief is seen stealing a Christmas wreath off a family's front door in the dead of night

Read more »

Disgraced celebrity chef Pete Evans comes out of hiding and reveals his greying mohawk and beard as he heads for a surf at Bondi Beach after spreading his wacky anti-vax conspiracies

Disgraced celebrity chef Pete Evans has been spotted for the first time in months following a string of controversies.   The former My Kitchen Rules star, 48, who is known ... Read more »

Rep. Debbie Dingell says her office was broken into, vandalized

Representative Debbie Dingell said her office was vandalized on Monday. Rod Lamkey / CNP /MediaPunch Vandals broke into Rep. Debbie Dingell’s Michigan office, and trashed some items belonging to her ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell 'preyed on vulnerable young girls', trial prosecutors allege

© JANE ROSENBERG In this courtroom sketch, Ghislaine Maxwell attends at the start of her trial on charges of sex trafficking in New York City. Reuters Ghislaine Maxwell’s lawyer told ... Read more »

WHO warns new virus variant 'omicron' poses 'very high' risk

© The Manila Times People stand holding shopping bags on Regent Street in London, Monday, Nov. 29, 2021. Countries around the world slammed their doors shut again to try to ... Read more »

How to grind XP in Battlefield Portal

© Provided by GamePur With the launch of the Battlefield, Portal players are now able to experience the equipment and maps that made Bad Company 2, Battlefield 3, and Battlefield ... Read more »

Wild Rift patch 2.6 brings two champions, Ultra Rapid Fire mode, new items, and more

© Provided by GamePur After some concern that Wild Rift’s final major update of 2021 might be delayed until 2022, we now have confirmation that patch 2.6 will be arriving ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic