Two Montanas? New maps highlight state's split personality

Asia's Tech News Daily

Ken and Kelly Speidel stand outside the community hall of Cascade, Mont., Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. The Speidels own a horse boarding business in Cascade, a rural community on the banks of the Missouri River. For the first time in 30 years, the Census has awarded Montana a second seat in Congress and a commission is being tasked with determining how to divide the state into two congressional districts. (AP Photo/Iris Samuels)
1 / 2Redistricting MontanaKen and Kelly Speidel stand outside the community hall of Cascade, Mont., Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. The Speidels own a horse boarding business in Cascade, a rural community on the banks of the Missouri River. For the first time in 30 years, the Census has awarded Montana a second seat in Congress and a commission is being tasked with determining how to divide the state into two congressional districts. (AP Photo/Iris Samuels)

CASCADE, Mont. (AP) — For the first time in 30 years, the Census has awarded Montana a second seat in Congress. On paper, that leaves the state's redistricting commission with the easiest task of all its counterparts across the country: Divide the expansive state in half.

If only.

Nothing is ever that simple in redistricting battles, as political parties jostle for control over maps that will give their candidates an advantage and the simple act of drawing a line becomes a fraught battle over the identity of the state.

In Montana, Republicans are pushing to separate the two booming college towns of Bozeman and Missoula in the western half of the state. Putting the two Democratic-leaning communities in different districts would make it hard for Democrats to win either seat. Democrats want to consolidate their strongholds in one district that would give them a fighting chance to win a House seat. They argue the towns — filled with craft brew drinkers, liberal academics, remote workers and California transplants — share more in common with each other than the vast expanse of rural ranches and farms between them.

The bipartisan commission is set to select the district boundaries on Thursday. With little common ground between the commission’s two Republican and two Democratic members, much of the decision may fall on the nonpartisan chairperson, Maylinn Smith, who was appointed to the commission by the state's Supreme Court.

She has a history of giving small donations to Democratic political candidates in the state, but has said her experience working as a judge in several tribal court systems has given her the ability to act impartially.

To Republicans, there's a simple solution — a neat line splitting the state into eastern and western districts that puts Bozeman in the eastern one and Missoula in the western one. They contrast that with the more tortured route Democrats propose to lump the two cities together.

“When you have a shape that isn’t even a shape, it’s looks like the C from the Cookie Monster, that is not a reasonable district,” said Jennifer Carlson, a Republican state lawmaker from a town 20 minutes outside Bozeman.

But Democrats say it's not that simple. Terry Cunningham, deputy mayor of Bozeman, notes that his city along with Missoula and the state capital of Helena are the only three in the state that have voted for carbon reduction goals while much of the rest of the state depends on the fossil fuel industry.

“I believe it is immoral to add new fossil fuel burning resources to the mix,” Cunningham said. “Other communities in Montana would vehemently object (to our goals) because fossil fuel extraction is part of their lifeblood. So those make us incompatible politically with what could be described as the number one issue facing the entire planet.”

Part of the reason Montana gets a second congressional district is the population growth fueled by Bozeman, a city of 50,000 that has become a hotbed for startups and pandemic-era remote workers. Home to Montana State University, Bozeman grew a whopping 33% in the last decade, growth that dwarfs that seen anywhere else in the state.

Its downtown is packed with pedestrians wearing the latest moisture-repelling microfibers, boutique bakeries and upscale restaurants. Housing prices have skyrocketed, as has homelessness. Missoula, home to the University of Montana, has similar headaches.

Democrats in the two cities argue that their common situation cries out for them being in the same district, which would likely lean only slightly Republican and therefore be competitive in a state where the beet-red hue of its rural swathes has tilted it solidly toward the GOP.

“In order for democracy to function well in the United States, you need to have a political system that is responsive to the electorate’s desires,” said Jeremy Johnson, a political scientist at Carroll College in Helena. In safe districts, “there is less incentive for legislators to listen to constituents.”

Republicans argue that the way they slice up the state would still preserve competition. Still, both seats would lean GOP, in part because of the changes since the last time Montana had two congressional seats.

In the 1990 census, Montana's population growth slowed so much that it lost its second seat and began electing a single representative for the entire state. That seat has been held by Republicans for the past 24 years as rural areas that once voted Democratic became more conservative, leaving the blue islands of Bozeman and Missoula surrounded by vast expanses of red.

“You don’t have to go far from city lines when you’re really in ruby red Republican territory across most of the state,” Johnson said.

But not all towns fit neatly into the redistricting arguments laid out by Republicans and Democrats. The town of Cascade 115 miles north of Bozeman falls alternatingly in eastern and western districts proposed by both Democrats and Republicans. Home to around 700 people, Cascade is sandwiched between an interstate highway on one side and the Missouri River on the other and surrounded by farms and ranches.

In contrast to Bozeman, its sparse main street holds only a handful of businesses, including a couple restaurants, a market, a gas station, a fly fishing shop and a bank. Incorporated 110 years ago, Cascade has changed little since then — aside from a recent upgrade of the town’s water and sewage pipes.

The contrast with Bozeman is obvious to the town's residents.

“There are two Montanas — socially, economically, culturally — we are two states,” said Ken Speidel, who owns a horse boarding business with his wife, Kelly, in the rural town and works as a river guide in the summer and a hockey referee in the winter.

Like many in Cascade, Speidel favors the Republican proposals. But he acknowledges the power of counterarguments.

“There is no solution that is going to make everybody happy,” he said.


Iris Samuels is a corps member for the Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Student kills 3, wounds 8 at Oxford High School in Michigan

APTOPIX School Shooting Michigan (Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved) A 15-year-old sophomore opened fire at his Michigan high school, killing three students, including a 16-year-old boy who ... Read more »

Worldwide health alert after cardiologist says he caught Covid variant during London conference trip

Worldwide health alert after cardiologist says he caught omicron Covid variant at UK conference – Shannon Fagan A London medical conference attended by hundreds of the UK’s leading cardiologists has ... Read more »

Mariners moved quickly to wrap up Cy Young winner Robbie Ray

SEATTLE (AP) — The Seattle Mariners were still in the middle of finishing their first big deal of the offseason when they started making an aggressive move to land a ... Read more »

Possible government shutdown: what to know

Congress could be barreling toward another government shutdown at midnight on Friday if Republicans and Democrats don’t pass a bill to fund the government by then. © BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images ... Read more »

Zwei Traumtore für ein Halleluja: YB dreht Spiel gegen Lugano spektakulär

© PETER KLAUNZER/ Kanga macht das 2:1 für YB. YB beendet seine Negativserie mit einem 3:1-Heimsieg im Nachtragsspiel der 4. Runde gegen Lugano. Matchwinner sind die Einwechselspieler Sulejmani und Kanga. ... Read more »

How scientists found the first case of the omicron COVID-19 variant in the United States

SAN FRANCISCO — The first case of the coronavirus omicron variant in the United States was confirmed at 4 a.m. Wednesday after an all-night session by scientists here. The city’s ... Read more »

Autonomous ‘flying taxi' debuts test flight in Bali (Video)

EHang 216, a Chinese-made autonomous aerial vehicle (AAV) with a capacity of two passengers, debuted its first test flight in Bali last week. Photo: EHang Do we need autonomous flying ... Read more »

Is Aaron Carter now a single dad, a week after the birth of his son?

© The Independent Singapore © The Independent Singapore Hollywood — It’s hardly worth a yawn when two personalities in the entertainment industry split up. But when singer/rapper Aaron Carter announced ... Read more »

Weather snow forecast UK – Met Office issues ice warnings as Brits told to prepare for MORE extreme weather

ANOTHER wintry blast is set to hit again within a matter of hours after the UK was hit by freezing temperatures and flurries of snow. Temperatures of -10C are on ... Read more »

Paddy and Christine McGuinness viewers in tears as he breaks down three times over his love for his 3 autistic children

PADDY and Christine McGuinness left viewers in tears as he broke down over his love for his three autistic children. BBC viewers saw a different side to the popular comedian ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity viewers in hysterics as Danny Miller fantasises over sharing a bed with crush David Ginola

I'M A Celebrity viewers were in hysteric tonight as Danny Miller fantasised about sharing a bed with footballing hero David Ginola. The Emmerdale star was voted the new camp deputy ... Read more »

Carry on with Christmas parties but take a Covid test before, Sajid Javid urges

CHRISTMAS revellers were yesterday told to carry on with their parties — but get tested first. Sajid Javid insisted there is no need to change festive plans — while the ... Read more »

Richard Petty Motorsports sells majority stake in NASCAR Cup team

© Matthew T. Thacker / NKP / Motorsport Images Erik Jones, Richard Petty Motorsports, Chevrolet Camaro Petty’s Garage Airline entrepreneur Maury Gallagher, the owner of the GMS squad that claimed ... Read more »

Michael J. Fox is ‘happy' despite not curing Parkinson's: ‘I don't fear death'

Michael J. Fox has battled Parkinson’s disease for 30 years. Charles Sykes/Invision/AP The eternal optimist. Michael J. Fox has looked on the bright side for the better part of his ... Read more »

Pressure on Hancock over pub landlord's Covid deal

Former health secretary Matt Hancock was under pressure on Wednesday to set the record straight over £40m of government Covid-related work won by his former pub landlord after he accused ... Read more »

Man tells court Jussie Smollett recruited him and brother to fake racist attack

A man who worked with Jussie Smollett has told a court the actor recruited him and his brother to fake a homophobic and racist attack on him in Chicago nearly ... Read more »

Are the Final Fantasy XIV servers down? How to check the server status

© Provided by GamePur With so many players consistently jumping onto the Final Fantasy XIV servers, you can expect to find a few issues trying to jump online every once ... Read more »

Final Fantasy XIV Endwalker, 6.0 update release and maintenance times

© Provided by GamePur The maintenance for Final Fantasy XIV Endwalker expansion will begin a full 24 hours before early access becomes available for everyone who preordered it. All servers ... Read more »

Teen who killed four in US school 'absolutely cold-hearted': police

© Matthew Hatcher Students, parents, teachers, and community members gather for a vigil at the Lake Point Community Church following a shooting at Oxford High School in Oxford, Michigan that ... Read more »

Warzone Pacific Sniper Rifle Early Tier List December 2021

Our Warzone Pacific sniper rifle early tier list for December 2021 is here to project which guns will be the best to use as players begin to truly countdown the final ... Read more »

Where to find the Life Orb in Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl

© Provided by GamePur The Life Orb is a held item that drains the life of the Pokémon holding it. This may sound bad, but it gives the benefit of ... Read more »

Bad Bunny Says He Hasn't 'Gotten Used' to His Fame: 'And Maybe This Is Good'

© HIGHSNOBIETY/Awol Erizku Bad Bunny may be one of the biggest artists in the world, but he’s not bothered by his fame. The 27-year-old singer, whose real name is Benito ... Read more »

'Home Alone' house will be on Airbnb for one night only this month

The home, located in the Chicago area, will be available to book on Airbnb on Dec. 7. Read more »

Shopify sued by publishers accusing company of profiting from textbook piracy

OTTAWA — Several textbook publishers are accusing Shopify Inc. of profiting from content sold through Shopify’s software that’s pirated or infringes on their trademarks. © Provided by The Canadian Press ... Read more »

Ex-White House official says Trump showed 'flagrant lack of regard for public health' in keeping positive Covid test secret

Former President Donald Trump showed “a flagrant lack of regard for public health” and endangered White House staff by not disclosing a positive Covid-19 test he received last year, his ... Read more »

Soldier charged with careless handling of weapons after a shooting accident in Færder Municipality

A soldier was charged with careless handling of weapons after a shooting accident at Mågerøy in Færder Municipality on Tuesday. The Southeastern Police District states that a young female conscript ... Read more »

Military says Adm. Art McDonald already faced ‘significant' action as police report released

The Canadian military says actions taken so far against Adm. Art McDonald are “significant” and there are no plans to pursue measures like stripping or lowering his rank. © Provided ... Read more »

Man testifies Smollett recruited him, brother to fake attack

CHICAGO (AP) — A man who worked with Jussie Smollett testified Wednesday that the former “Empire” actor recruited him and his brother to fake a homophobic and racist attack on ... Read more »

Indigenous leaders concerned over B.C. government's old-growth deferral process

Indigenous leaders and experts in British Columbia outlined their concerns Wednesday over the provincial government’s process to save old-growth forests, while underscoring the urgency to preserve at-risk ecosystems. © Provided ... Read more »

Cargill, union reach tentative deal that could avert strike at High River meat plant

CALGARY — Cargill Inc. says it has reached a tentative deal with the union representing workers at its meat-packing plant in High River, Alta. © Provided by The Canadian Press ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell looking well despite conditions of detention, brother says

Ghislaine Maxwell’s brother has said she is “looking pretty well, notwithstanding the conditions of detention”, after day three of her sex trafficking trial. Kevin Maxwell spoke to reporters after the ... Read more »

Liberals thank Conservatives who championed conversion therapy ban as it passes House

OTTAWA — Canada’s House of Commons erupted into a scene of cheers and cross-party hugs Wednesday as MPs adopted a motion presented by a Conservative MP to fast-track the passage ... Read more »

Impress Your Guests With These Irresistible S'Mores Cookie Bars

Holiday baking is one of our favourite things to do during this time of year. Although we love a classic cookie exchange, sometimes you want to make a cookie treat that ... Read more »

Madagascar food crisis caused more by poverty, natural weather than climate change - study

1 / 2Madagascar food crisis caused more by poverty, natural weather than climate change – studyFILE PHOTO: Madagascar faces ‘climate change famine’, warns U.N. By Andrea Januta (Reuters) – Poverty, ... Read more »

Review: A Neapolitan rhapsody in 'The Hand of God'

The Associated PressThis image released by Netflix shows Filippo Scotti, from left, Teresa Saponangelo, Marlon Joubert and Toni Servillo in a scene from “The Hand of God.” (Gianni Fiorito/Netflix via ... Read more »

Deutsche Forscher haben Antworten gefunden: Darum müssen Corona-Patienten so lange beatmet werden

Schwer an Corona erkrankte Personen erleidet häufig ein Lungenversagen und müssen lange Zeit beatmet werden. Deutsche Wissenschaftler haben nun herausgefunden, warum. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Darum müssen Corona-Patienten so lange ... Read more »

'Zoey's Extraordinary Christmas': Is This It? EP and Star on Movie's Ending and Franchise's Future (Exclusive)

© Roku Channel Spoiler alert! Do not proceed if you have not watched Zoey’s Extraordinary Christmas on Roku. Zoey’s Extraordinary Christmas was the holiday gift we were all waiting for.  The holiday ... Read more »

Marvel's Secret Invasion Is Bringing Back This Fan-Favorite SHIELD Agent

Marvel Studios/Disney+ One of the most highly anticipated projects in the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s current lineup is the upcoming Disney+ series “Secret Invasion.” The six-episode series, which was first announced ... Read more »

Chuck Pagano thought he blew Colts coaching job getting drunk on wine

Chuck Pagano is everyone who has ever woken up after too much wine with a string of missed calls and sense of panic. Pagano appeared on “The Pat McAfee Show” ... Read more »

Facebook staffer secretly advised Andrew Cuomo's team to ‘victim shame' accuser

Dani Lever (right) left then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo administration’s for Facebook in August 2020 — but quietly kept working with his aides. Office of Governor Andrew M. Cuo A Facebook manager ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic