Two Facebook whistleblowers have publicly attacked the company this year. Here's how their claims overlap.

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Provided by Business Insider Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Drew Angerer/Getty Images

  • Two Facebook whistleblowers, Sophie Zhang and Frances Haugen, have publicly criticised the company in 2021.
  • Zhang told Insider she sees a common link between their criticisms of the company – profit.
  • Both whistleblowers say Facebook under-resources countries it doesn’t consider important.

Facebook has been rocked by a public relations nightmare after whistleblower Frances Haugen leaked internal documents to The Wall Street Journal before appearing in front of Congress to publicly denounce the company.

Haugen isn’t the only Facebook whistleblower to emerge this year. Former data scientist Sophie Zhang went public with her criticism of the company in April 2021. This came after she posted an internal memo in September 2020 after she was fired for “poor performance,” saying she felt like she had blood on her hands.

Haugen worked inside Facebook’s civic integrity team, focusing on elections. Zhang was part of its authenticity team, where she identified networks of fake accounts being created by authoritarian regimes around the world posing as their own citizens.

Speaking to Insider, Zhang said although she and Haugen saw completely different sides of the company, Haugen’s testimony felt familiar.

“There is basically no overlap between any of our details. What overlaps is our overall message,” she said.

Haugen told Congress Facebook routinely places “profit before people” – a claim the company denies.

“I think it’s important to remember that ultimately Facebook is a company whose goal is to make money. We don’t expect Philip Morris Tobacco to have a division that reimburses people and agencies for lung cancer treatment,” Zhang told Insider.

“We have absolutely no commercial incentive, no moral incentive, no company-wide incentive to do anything other than to try to give the maximum number of people as much of a positive experience as possible on Facebook,” a Facebook spokesperson told Insider.

© Drew Angerer/Pool via AP Former Facebook employee and whistleblower Frances Haugen arrives to testify before a Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation hearing on Capitol Hill on Tuesday, Oct. 5, 2021. Drew Angerer/Pool via AP

A linking detail between Haugen and Zhang’s criticisms of Facebook was the allegation that Facebook under-resources its work in countries it doesn’t think will get much attention.

Zhang told The Guardian in April she repeatedly tried to get the company to act against authoritarian governments, which were engineering fake engagement on the platform.

She was successful in some cases, but an interaction with the company’s VP of Integrity Guy Rosen showed Zhang was fighting an uphill battle trying to get the company to act in countries that were either not Western or not the focus of Western media attention. These countries included Russia and Iran, for example.

“I get that the US/Western Europe/etc is important, but for a company with effectively unlimited resources, I don’t understand why this cannot get on the roadmap for anyone,” Zhang told Rosen in private conversation, per The Guardian’s report.

“I wish resources were unlimited,” replied Rosen.

Haugen said during her testimony that Facebook’s moderation of hate speech in non-English speaking countries was severely underresourced, partly because the company does not employ enough native-speakers for the countries in which it operates.

“In the case of Ethiopia, there are 100 million people and six languages. Facebook only supports two of those languages for integrity systems,” Haugen told Congress, adding that Facebook’s lack of action in countries like it is: “literally fanning ethnic violence.”

Insider asked Zhang whether she thinks Facebook ignoring countries is an overarching problem at the company.

“I think there are many overarching problems at the company, this is one of them … What I would call the overarching problem fundamentally is the fact that Facebook is a company whose goal is to make money and therefore has no incentive to fix things and not lose sleep about it unless it affects the company’s ability to make money,” she said.

Facebook’s spokesperson said: “We have invested $13 billion and have 40,000 people working on the safety and security on our platform, including 15,000 people who review content in more than 50 languages working in more than 20 locations all across the world to support our community… Our track record shows that we crack down on abuse outside the US with the same intensity that we apply in the US.”

They added that Ethiopia is a “company priority” and that Facebook has “partnered extensively with international and local experts to better understand and mitigate the biggest risks on the platform.”

Haugen told Congress she wasn’t in favour of breaking up Facebook, and Zhang told Insider she was “neutral” on the issue – but emphasized that she thinks it would negatively impact integrity efforts on Facebook and its subsidiaries Instagram and WhatsApp.

“I am suggesting some regulation to require companies to work with each other and work on issues that transcend the problems between the companies because they have no incentive to,” said Zhang.

Zhang is due to give testimony to the UK parliament on Monday and said that she gave evidence to a European committee earlier this year. Although she told CNN she is willing to testify before Congress, Zhang told Insider she has not been contacted by US lawmakers.

Haugen is due to appear before Facebook’s independent Oversight Board, and to give evidence to the UK parliament on October 25.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Voices: Tony Blair can't resist being confrontational – Keir Starmer will be furious over his wokeism comments

Tony Blair, trying to be helpful (ASSOCIATED PRESS) Even his enemies concede Tony Blair knows how to do two things. One is to win elections; the other is to generate ... Read more »

OPINION - The only way to stem the tragic tide... co-operation and not confrontation

As you read this more Iraqis, Syrians, Eritreans, Afghans, Sudanese and Somalians will be climbing into dinghies criminally ill-equipped to cross the Channel, hoping the wake of a passing ship ... Read more »

Arsenal's Aaron Ramsdale throws down gauntlet to Cristiano Ronaldo amid Man Utd chaos

Arsenal goalkeeper Aaron Ramsdale says he is relishing facing Cristiano Ronaldo for the first time in his career, and has urged the Manchester United star to find his best form ... Read more »

Chloe Ferry issues warning after Storm Arwen blows apart her garden

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Chloe Ferry has admitted she’s ‘devastated’ after her garden furniture was knocked over and ‘smashed’ by Storm Arwen on Friday night. The Geordie ... Read more »

Russia produces deadly 'unstoppable' 6,670mph Zircon hypersonic war missile

© east2west news The frigate Admiral Gorshkov Russia has produced a deadly “unstoppable” 6,670mph Zircon hypersonic missile amid acute tensions with the West. The weapon is being rushed into manufacture ... Read more »

Beijing Keeps Trying to Rewrite History

© Miguel Candela / Anadolu Agency / Getty The Pillar of Shame statue at the University of Hong Kong. Under the relentless crush of Beijing, the courtrooms of Hong Kong ... Read more »

Sanya Lopez at Ashley Ortega, inihayag ang Korean actors na kanilang jojowain o totropahin

Sanya Lopez at Ashley Ortega, inihayag ang Korean actors na kanilang jojowain o totropahin Sa isang online exclusive, inilahad nina Sanya Lopez at Ashley Ortega ang mga Korean drama actor ... Read more »

Comedian John Wing says debut novel has Sarnia connection

© Provided by cbc.ca Canadian comedian John Wing appears in a file photo. John Wing is best known for his career in comedy, which stretches back decades, but he’s also a poet ... Read more »

Storm Arwen: 2 dead as storms lash UK

At least two people are reported to have died as Britain was battered by severe weather with winds reaching speeds of over 90 mph (144 km/h) in some areas. © ... Read more »

Omicron variant unlikely to reboot Covid in UK, expert says

The Omicron Covid variant is unlikely to “reboot” the pandemic in a population that has been widely vaccinated, according to a UK expert who voiced cautious optimism that existing vaccines ... Read more »

This TruGolf mini golf simulator is a hole-in-one for Black Friday

New York Post Store Ah golf … it’s the sport we love to hate. It can be frustrating, difficult, and seemingly inconsistent — not to mention, it’s expensive. Perhaps you’ve ... Read more »

Global Warming Began Way Earlier Than Previously Thought, Finds Study

© Provided by News18 Global Warming Began Way Earlier Than Previously Thought, Finds Study A group of researchers at the University of Cambridge have found evidence that the warming of ... Read more »

Manipur polls: Conrad Sangma-led NPP plans to contest alone for over 40 seats

Manipur Assembly polls: Conrad Sangma-led NPP plans to contest alone for over 40 seats Meghalaya Chief Minister and National People’s Party (NPP) chief Conrad Sangma plans to contest alone for ... Read more »

Omicron variant: From urging flight ban to increasing testing. Here's how states are preparing

© Provided by Hindustan Times Some states have imposes mandatory RT PCR testing on arrival for passengers from countries where cases of the variant have been detected. (ANI | Representational ... Read more »

Maharashtra issues new COVID-19 guidelines amid 'Omicron' variant scare

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Maharashtra government on Saturday (November 27, 2021) issued fresh guidelines for COVID-19, including revised restrictions and permissions for passengers arriving in the state, amid ... Read more »

COVID-19 Omicron variant: Mumbai Mayor takes big decision as fear intensifies

© Provided by DNA Amid rising concerns over the new COVID-19 variant Omicron, Mumbai Mayor Kishori Pednekar has said that genome tests of passengers coming from South Africa will be ... Read more »

Suspected Omicron case found in Germany

Germany has confirmed that it has detected a suspected case of the Omicron Covid variant. © AP Frankfurt A minister in the German state of Hesse said on Saturday a ... Read more »

30K volunteers sign up so far for 3-day nat'l vaccination drive

© REUTERS/Eloisa Lopez Filipinos queue to get Moderna COVID-19 vaccine in a school turned vaccination site that operates 24/7 in Manila on August 9, 2021. REUTERS/Eloisa Lopez The Department of ... Read more »

David Mabuza warns of fourth wave as Covid-19 new variant Omicron hits SA's shores

© Provided by Independent Media Durban – Deputy President David Mabuza has warned against complacency in the fight against Covid-19, particularly in the face of a looming fourth wave following ... Read more »

Justice system reform is a wedge partisan issue. It doesn't have to be.

This is a column by Charlie Harper, an Atlanta-based public policy expert and a longtime contributor. Five or so years ago I attended a one-day session in Washington DC hosted ... Read more »

COVID: Omicron variant 'likely' already in Germany, says minister

© Provided by dw.com Passengers have their temperatures taken at Frankfurt International Airport A minister in the western German state of Hesse said Saturday that the potentially highly transmissible omicron ... Read more »

Pinellas domestic violence survivor helps lead other women to freedom

ST. PETERSBURG — When Zuleika Gonzalez sees the fear in her clients’ eyes, she sees her old self. When she tells them, “You will be vindicated if you stay the ... Read more »

Media experts agree action is needed, but urge caution on how streaming is regulated

OTTAWA — The Liberals have promised to quickly reintroduce legislation aimed at reforming the Broadcasting Act, which has media experts cautioning the government against bringing newer media platforms under an ... Read more »

Blinken calls for negotiations amid Ethiopia military escalation

© Provided by Al Jazeera Ethiopian soldiers parade with national flags attached to their rifles at a rally organised by local authorities in Addis Ababa [AP Photo] US Secretary of ... Read more »

Owner encouraged by sightings of missing golden pheasant near Shediac

© Facebook/Wendy Collier Winston, the missing golden pheasant, was spotted days ago, about five minutes away from his home in Shediac Cape. Winston, the golden pheasant, has flown the coop. ... Read more »

Asian Curry Awards' best curry in London revealed as surprising spot in South London

Judging by the number of Asian restaurants scattered proudly across the capital’s streets, it is safe to say that Londoners love their curry. Just this week, judges gathered in London ... Read more »

Kampf ums Covid-Gesetz: Schafft die Schweiz das Zertifikat ab?

Die Abstimmung über das Covid-Gesetz ist nicht nur eine Abstimmung über die Corona-Politik der Schweiz, sondern auch ein Stresstest für die Demokratie im Land. © imago images/Geisser Foto Manuel Geisser ... Read more »

High alert: World scurries to contain new COVID variant

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – People line up to get on an overseas flight at OR Tambo International Airport in Johannesburg, South Africa, Nov. 26, 2021. As the ... Read more »

Ex-Player Pleads IND To Tour SA For ‘Future Generation's Sake' Despite New Covid Variant

© Provided by MensXP The Indian cricket team is busy playing a home Test series against New Zealand at the moment but their eyes are already set on their next month’s ... Read more »

India vs New Zealand: Maharashtra govt allows only 25% capacity at Wankhede Stadium for second Test

© Provided by The Times of India MUMBAI: The Maharashtra government on Saturday issued an order allowing for only 25% crowd capacity at the Wankhede Stadium for the second Test ... Read more »

Amma Ariyathe, 27 November 2021, Written Update: Draupadi is worried about Aleena

© Provided by Pinkvilla As the episode starts, Draupadi is seen worried about the fight between Aleena and Ambadi. Shankaran tells her Ambadi must have started liking someone else, in ... Read more »

Kartik Aaryan's look from ‘Shehzada' leaks online, see VIRAL pic from film's set

© Provided by DNA Kartik Aaryan has a slew of films in the works, and he just visited Delhi to film ‘Shehzada’. The film stars Kriti Sanon and is directed ... Read more »

How to complete First Steps in No Man's Sky Expedition 1: Pioneers

© Provided by GamePur First Steps is the first Milestone in Phase one of No Man’s Sky Expedition 1: Pioneers. It will be the first challenge in your quest to ... Read more »

IPL 2022 Retention: Probable Players Retentions to Cost For It - What we Know so Far

© Provided by News18 IPL 2022 Retention: Probable Players Retentions to Cost For It – What we Know so Far The Indian Premier League is all set to expand from ... Read more »

7 Blockbuster Films That Actor Rajasekhar Had The Opportunity To Act in, But He Refused

© Provided by News18 Veteran Tollywood actor Dr Rajasekhar once used to be one of the busiest stars in the industry. All his films were well-received at the box office. ... Read more »

Benedict Cumberbatch reveals real reason behind Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness' 'significant' reshoots

© Provided by Hindustan Times Benedict Cumberbatch plays Doctor Stephen Strange in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Earlier this month, it was reported that Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness ... Read more »

Live Cricket Score, IND vs NZ, 1st Test Match, Day 3: Kyle Jamieson Strikes Early to Remove Shubman Gill on 1

© Provided by News18 Live Cricket Score, IND vs NZ, 1st Test Match, Day 3: Kyle Jamieson Strikes Early to Remove Shubman Gill on 1 India vs New Zealand Live ... Read more »

Kurdish woman is first Channel victim to be named - BBC

© Reuters/JOHANNA GERON FILE PHOTO: Tribute to the 27 migrants who died as they attempted to cross the English Channel LONDON (Reuters) – A Kurdish woman from northern Iraq, who ... Read more »

(KEMASKINI) 5,097 kes Covid-19, 8 kluster baharu

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Kesihatan (KKM) melaporkan 5,097 kes baharu Covid-19 dalam tempoh 24 jam lalu. Ketua Pengarah Kesihatan, Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah, berkata ini ... Read more »

Sotong goreng RM100: Pemilik restoran diberi masa hingga Isnin lengkap dokumen

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Gambar resit harga dua ekor sotong goreng RM100 yang tular di media sosial sejak Selasa lalu. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Perdagangan Dalam Negeri ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic