‘Turned away': how strict government rules denied young pilot with brain cancer the disability pension

Asia's Tech News Daily

George Upjohn is constantly tired, his muscles ache, and he will start chemotherapy in two weeks. A pilot by trade, he’ll never work in the field again.

At 29, he’s at the start of a fight for his life.

Yet despite his doctors saying Upjohn cannot work and should minimise all stress, Centrelink has denied his application for the disability support pension, saying his condition does not meet the stringent requirements.

“When the claim was denied, I was just amazed,” says Upjohn, who was diagnosed with a grade three brain tumour in June. His condition carries a 50% survivability rate over five years, he said.

“People in this situation with serious illness and long-term illness must be getting turned away left, right and centre,” Upjohn says.

    Upjohn’s case is the latest to show how strict government rules – including the requirement a condition is “fully diagnosed, treated and stabilised” – can force some of the sickest people in Australia on to the sub-poverty line jobseeker payment.

    About a third of the one million people on jobseeker payments are classified as having a “partial capacity to work”, usually due to chronic illness or disability, a figure that has grown dramatically since changes to the disability pension rules beginning in 2011.

    Guardian Australia revealed this month that more than 7,000 of those people have cancer.

    The government’s own guidelines determining access to the disability pension state that “non-terminal cancer that is still being treated by chemotherapy and for which prognosis is uncertain, would not normally be regarded as fully treated”.

    This bars many cancer patients from accessing the payment unless they are terminally ill and are likely to die in two years or less.

    Upjohn had been working as a commercial pilot and living with his girlfriend in their rental property in Sydney’s southern suburbs when she woke early in the morning to find him having a seizure.

    He had been “jerking both arms, frothing at the mouth”, his face had gone pale and his lips were blue, according to hospital records.

    Doctors discovered a growth on the left side of his head. They operated, and managed to remove what turned out to be a grade three astrocytoma. Upjohn says he was so unwell he could hardly stand post-surgery.

    “We called Centrelink and said, ‘What would you advise us to do,’” Upjohn says. “They said, apply for disability payment. It should be an easy process.”

    Related: Jobseeker rights at risk under ‘sham’ mutual obligation rule change, welfare groups warn

    The rejection letter, seen by Guardian Australia, came in late July. Instead, he was placed on to the $45-a-day jobseeker payment, which is $338-a-fortnight less than the disability pension.

    It’s not been enough to cover his rent or bills, and he’s sold aviation gear and borrowed money from family to stay afloat.

    “I’ve just finished up radiotherapy,” he says. “Half my head is bald. We’re in a transition period … Next week it’s seeing the surgeon, the oncologist, my chemotherapy oncologist, my GP and also a psychologist as well as part of the cancer care umbrella. That’s my life.

    “For two or three weeks after radiotherapy, you still have a huge amount of inflammation and residual radiation,” Upjohn adds. “It’s a bit like feeling run down with the flu but you just don’t get better.

    “You wake up and you can barely move. [There is] this muscle wastage feeling. Every muscle you have aches, and if you try to get in some exercise to rebuild it, you wipe yourself out for two days.”

    In a fortnight, he will commence chemotherapy. It may last more than a year, with breaks, depending on his progress.

    Though the tumour has been removed, doctors need to tackle the “microscopic cells left behind, and the deep roots of the growth itself”, Upjohn says.

    Email: sign up for our daily morning briefing newsletter

    App: download the free app and never miss the biggest stories, or get our weekend edition for a curated selection of the week's best stories

    Social: follow us on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter or TikTok

    Podcast: listen to our daily episodes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or search “Full Story” in your favourite app

    Upjohn hopes to get back into the workforce eventually, but he has been told he will never work as a commercial pilot again. He’s also been prohibited from driving for six months.

    “The aviation medical team said we can give you a medical and your commercial licence back, but no employer will ever hire you again now you’ve had a seizure,” he says. “It’s not worth the risk for them.”

    To make matters worse, Upjohn says he was not even receiving a full jobseeker payment, with Centrelink applying the partner income test due to his girlfriend’s modest income from part-time work.

    His last three fortnightly payments were for $430, $409 and $432, according to payment statements seen by Guardian Australia.

    Upjohn says when he complained that the money was not enough to live on, a Centrelink staff member told him his girlfriend should be helping to cover those costs.

    “At some point, I must have just snapped,” Upjohn says. “I said, ‘What are you talking about? She’s not responsible for paying my medical bills, my phone bill, my rent, my food.’”

    “[They said], ‘Realistically you might be better off looking at a personal loan if things get tricky,’” Upjohn adds.

    Victoria Legal Aid and 26 disability groups are among the organisations calling for reforms to the disability support pension’s “fully diagnosed, treated and stabilised” rule, along with other changes.

    Some advocates have called for a specific payment to support people with temporary medical conditions such as cancer, while others say the jobseeker payment should simply be lifted to the poverty line.

    Janet Rice, the Greens community affairs spokesperson and chair of a Senate inquiry into the payment, says Upjohn should unquestionably be receiving the disability support pension.

    “It’s clear the measure of ‘fully diagnosed, treated and stabilised’ is deeply flawed and prohibits thousands of Australians from rightfully accessing the [disability support pension],” she says.

    Related: Disability pension rules leave thousands with cancer on $44 a day

    Cassandra Goldie, the chief executive of the Australian Council of Social Service, says there is a “long-term deliberate government policy to deprive people with disability or chronic illness, including cancer, the disability support pension”.

    A spokesperson for the social services minister, Anne Ruston, who is responsible for disability support pension policy, referred questions to Services Australia, which assesses applications.

    Services Australia’s spokesperson, Hank Jongen, says the agency understands “Mr Upjohn is going through an extremely difficult time”.

    “While we can’t go into the details of his case, we’d like the opportunity to get in touch with him to make sure he’s receiving all available help,” he says.

    “We also have a large national network of social workers available to help people like Mr Upjohn and connect them with support services.”

    Upjohn says the experience had dented his faith in the country. “It’s the first time I realised that people in a country that I was proud to be part of, would suffer needlessly, would have stress pressed on to them during the darkest days of their lives,” he says.

    Do you have a story? luke.henriques-gomes@theguardian.com

    Internet Explorer Channel Network
    Asia's Tech News Daily
    News Related


    'All our margins are gone': Supply chain challenges squeeze small businesses

    TORONTO — Before the COVID-19 pandemic, Helmi Ansari could get espresso makers and stainless steel water bottles manufactured within three months and delivered to Canada by boat for about US$4,500 ... Read more »

    Leavenworth man accused in 2019 of attempting to rape woman pleads no contest

    A Leavenworth man charged in a 2019 attempted rape has entered a plea, court records show. Thomas Henkle, 43, pleaded no contest to the charge, according to a news release ... Read more »

    'Wrong' for Christmas party in Number 10 last year, says Dominic Raab - but he dismisses 'unsubstantiated claims'

    Deputy PM Dominic Raab acknowledges that "if anyone held a party contrary to the rules, of course that's the wrong thing to do". But he dismisses "unsubstantiated claims" of a festive bash in Number 10 last year when indoor mixing was banned in London. Read more »

    Schweizerinnen gewinnen an der Unihockey-WM die Bronzemedaille

    An der Unihockey-WM in Schweden siegen die Schweizerinnen im Spiel um Platz 3 gegen Tschechien 5:2. Damit sichert sich die Nati zum fünften Mal WM-Bronze. Traumtor von Shaqiri an der ... Read more »

    Revanche geglückt – Schweizer Unihockey-Frauen schlagen Tschechien und holen WM-Bronze

    © keystone Teaserbild © keystone Corin Rüttimann jubelt nach ihrem Treffer zum 1:0. Das Schweizer Unihockey-Nationalteam der Frauen gewinnt an der 13. WM zum zehnten Mal eine Medaille. Die Mannschaft ... Read more »

    All Aether currents locations in Garlemald in Final Fantasy XIV Endwalker

    © Provided by Dot Esports The exciting time of new land discoveries has returned on Final Fantasy XIV with the early-access release of the game’s latest expansion Endwalker on Dec. ... Read more »

    Covid: UK records 127 deaths and 42,848 daily cases

    People queuing to receive their Covid-19 vaccinations at a site in Liberty shopping centre, Romford, east London (Yui Mok/PA) (PA Wire) The UK has recorded 42,848 cases and 127 deaths ... Read more »

    Calum Butcher challenge on Celtic star David Turnbull slammed by Kris Boyd as it's branded a 'disgrace'

    Kris Boyd insisted Calum Butcher should have seen red for his studs-up lunge on David Turnbull as the challenge was also branded a “disgrace” by Tam McManus. And the Sky ... Read more »

    Public Displays of Resignation: Saying 'I Quit' Loud and Proud

    Tiffany Knighten at her home in Ridgewood, New York, Dec. 2, 2021. (Amy Lombard/The New York Times) For Gabby Ianniello, it was the blisters from putting on stilettos every morning ... Read more »

    Ten passengers are diagnosed with COVID on Norwegian Cruise ship returning to New Orleans

    A Norwegian Cruise ship returning to New Orleans has detected ten cases of COVID-19 among its crews and guestsThe ship, which held over 3,200 passengers, had departed New Orleans for a week long cruise on November 28 with stops in Belize, Honduras and Mexico The members and passengers onboard will be tested for COVID before leaving and will be provided with post-exposure and quarantine public health guidanceThose who tested positive will either go home or self-isolate  Read more »

    'Lennon ruined this man last year', 'Wow' - Many Celtic fans hail star who's 'sheer perfection'

    © Provided by This is Futbol Tom Rogic Celtic brushed aside Dundee United at Tannadice Park three goals to nil thanks to goals from Tom Rogic, David Turnbull and Liam ... Read more »

    A Southwest Airlines passenger opened a galley door and jumped out of a plane while it was taxiing, authorities say

    © KAMIL KRZACZYNSKI/AFP via Getty Images A Southwest Airlines Boeing 737-7H4 jet taxis to the gate. KAMIL KRZACZYNSKI/AFP via Getty Images As a flight from Colorado Springs to Phoenix was ... Read more »

    UK Omicron cases climb to 246 as 86 more Covid variant cases found

    © PA Wire People wearing face masks walking along Oxford Street, London – PA Wire Omicron Covid cases soared to 246 after a further 86 Covid variant cases were identified ... Read more »

    Rohit Sharma to be Test vice-captain? Selectors to take call in meeting later this week

    © Provided by Zee News Mumbai: Virat Kohli’s position as India’s ODI captain, his Test deputy Ajinkya Rahane’s future as vice-captain in the longest format along with 100-Test man Ishant Sharma’s ... Read more »

    Breaking: Omicron enters Rajasthan, 9 cases reported in Jaipur so far

    © Provided by Zee News New Delhi: In a surge in Omicron variant cases in India, Rajasthan on Sunday (December 5) reported its first nine infections.  The state health department ... Read more »

    Omicron variant proof that Covid pandemic is just starting, warns UK scientist

    © Provided by WION A British scientist has warned the world that the emergence and spread of the Omicron variant of coronavirus shows that the world is closer to the ... Read more »

    India women thrash Thailand in Asian Champions Trophy opener

    The Indian women’s hockey team returned to action for the first time since the fourth place finish at the Tokyo Olympics by hammering Thailand 13-0 in their opening game of ... Read more »

    Six die as car catches fire in Andhra's Chittoor, infant among victims: Report

    © Provided by Hindustan Times The accident happened near Chandragiri zone near Chittoor, (ANI Twitter) At least six persons died in a road accident on the Puthalapattu-Naidupeta road near Chandragiri ... Read more »

    Tamil Nadu: Newborn girl found dead inside toilet flush tank at Thanjavur hospital

    A newborn girl’s body was found inside the flush tank of a toilet at Thanjavur Medical College Hospital (TMCH) in Tamil Nadu. The body was discovered when a sanitary worker ... Read more »

    Ind vs NZ 2nd Test, Day 3: India on cusp of victory as New Zealand lose five wickets in second innings

    © Provided by Jagran English Mumbai | Jagran Sports Desk: The half of New Zealand team was sent to dressing room at Wankhede stadium by quick succession of wickets by ... Read more »

    Germany's Free Democrats back coalition agreement

    © Reuters/ANNEGRET HILSE Germany’s FDP party convention in Berlin BERLIN (Reuters) – Members of Germany’s pro-business Free Democrats (FDP) voted on Sunday by a large majority to back a coalition ... Read more »

    Covid live: NHS will be in ‘very difficult position' if Omicron leads to more hospital admissions; protests in Belgium

    LIVE – Updated at 15:08 © Photograph: Hollie Adams/Getty Images A pop-up Christmas market at Trafalgar Square in London. Hospitals already struggling to cope as they enter winter, says president ... Read more »

    One winner and one loser following Derby's 1-0 defeat v Bristol City

    © Provided by Football League World Wayne Rooney n Derby suffered back-to-back defeats as they were beaten by 1-0 Bristol City at Ashton Gate on Saturday.  The Rams had come ... Read more »

    Promising teenage motocross star Rene Hofer among three skiers killed in Austrian avalanche

    Red Bull KTM paid tribute to Rene Hofer, 19, after he died in the incident. Authorities said the three dead were part of a group of 11 who were on a ski tour in the Salzburg province. Read more »

    7 students charged in Wayne County for making threats or bringing a weapon to school

    Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy has charged seven juveniles in recent days for making threats against schools or having a weapon in school. “There is a stranglehold on Southeastern Michigan ... Read more »

    Search for missing UNH student Vincenzo Lirosi in Durham goes into second day

    DURHAM — Police are continuing their search Sunday for a missing University of New Hampshire student. Vincenzo Lirosi, 22, of 9 Woodman Road, was reported missing at 3 a.m. Saturday. ... Read more »

    Tesco workers to strike days before Christmas over pay rises as shoppers could miss delivery slots

    TESCO workers are due to strike just days before Christmas, and during crucial home delivery periods too. The warehouse workers have already been warned they could lose their annual bonus ... Read more »

    I live in the UK. Here's what the 'American' section of the grocery store is actually like.

    © Sophia Mitrokostas for Insider The “American” section is really tiny. Sophia Mitrokostas for Insider I’m an American and Scotland’s version of American food in grocery stores puzzles me.  There ... Read more »

    From Gulmarg to Auli, 10 places to visit in India to enjoy the winter season at its best

    © Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Lifestyle Desk: Winters are here and as the year is coming to an end to give a proper see off to ... Read more »

    BTS and Drake among Spotify's 2021 most-streamed artists in the UAE

    © JEON HEON-KYUN BTS are the most streamed artists in the UAE for the second year in a row, according to Spotify Wrapped. EPA Spotify’s 2021 Wrapped results reiterate the ... Read more »

    GT Sprint Race: Debes é campeão na AM e Torres vence corrida 1; Costa triunfa na PROAM

    E a GT Sprint Race tem novo campeão no torneio Brasil 2021! Após Julio Campos/Léo Torres garantirem o título PRO depois da classificação de sábado, Luis Debes foi o vencedor ... Read more »

    Explorer's Diary: Here are 4 reasons why you should travel solo frequently

    We all want to go on trips with our friends and family and a year without that seems to go waste. However, the idea of solo travelling is not everyone’s ... Read more »

    How Pinterest's new Creator Fund is helping users monetize their content and expand their reach

    © Getty/Ivan Pantic How Pinterest’s new Creator Fund is helping users monetize their content and expand their reach Like Instagram and TikTok, Pinterest is creating ways for its users to ... Read more »

    Black man to get new trial after all-white jury deliberated in a Tennessee court room decorated with a Confederate flag and a portrait of Jefferson Davis

    Tim Gilbert, 56, was convicted by an all-white jury in June 2020 on assault and weapons charges charges stemming from a December 2018 altercationHis attorney, Evan Baddour, appealed the decision arguing that having the jury meet in a room adorned with a Confederate flag may have swayed its decisionThe room also had a gold-framed photos of Confederate President Jefferson Davis and was maintained by the United Daughters of the ConfederacyOn Friday, the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals agreed that having the jury deliberate in the room 'exposed it' to 'extraneous prejudicial information'The three-judge court also ruled that the prosecution did not sufficiently prove that having the jury deliberate in the room did not sway its decisionThe court granted Gilbert the right to a new trial in the case  Read more »

    Video: Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin admits China is 'on pace to become a peer competitor' to US military and warns Xi Jinping wants to build a thousand nuclear warheads by 2030 

    Read more »

    Video: 'She always felt sorry for herself': Stepmother who tortured and killed Arthur Labinjo-Hughes NEVER mentioned him and claimed she was in jail because her boyfriend 'neglected' his son, her cellmate says

    Read more »

    Newcastle co-owner Mehrdad Ghodoussi DENIES report claiming former Chelsea and Monaco sporting director Michael Emenalo turned down the chance to become their new director of football

    Mehrdad Ghodoussi said Michael Emenalo did not reject the club's approachThe Telegraph had claimed Emenalo had discussed sporting director postThe Nigerian enjoyed a decade of success in a similar role at Chelsea  Emenalo had a less successful stint at Monaco between 2017 and 2019 Read more »

    Top experts warn that the standing of the US as the 'partner of choice' for global allies has waned after the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan

    Sen. Joni Ernst and former Bush advisor Karl Rove say US credibility is fallingErnst says allies and partners pulled her aside with questions after the deadly August withdrawal from AfghanistanRove says the US should have explained the US' presence in the country betterHe was part of the team that promoted the invasion of Iraq and the War on Terror  Read more »

    Even MORE aides to Kamala Harris are 'eyeing the exits' after four staffers left in just two weeks

    Even more staffers are considering leaving Vice President Kamala Harris' office, people familiar with the conversations revealed Four top aides to Harris will exit in the span of about a monthHarris ' staff are leaving because they're burned out and they don't want to be permanently branded a 'Harris person,' Axios reportedAmong those leaving are her chief spokesperson Symone SandersPeter Velz, director of press operations, and Vince Evans, deputy director of the Office of Public Engagement are also expected to leave Ashley Etienne, Harris' former communications director, left last month Read more »

    I'm A Celebrity's Naughty Boy moans throughout latest trial after being accused of game playing by campmates

    NAUGHTY Boy moaned and groaned throughout his latest trial – after being voted for the seventh time. In scenes set to air tonight, the music producer takes on Gross Vegas ... Read more »
    On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic