Trump-era tariffs: Caught between a rock and scorching inflation, Joe Biden mulls handing China a big, unexpected ‘win’

Trump-era tariffs: Caught between a rock and scorching inflation, Joe Biden mulls handing China a big, unexpected ‘win’

US President Joe Biden. AP

Joe Biden is reportedly planning to roll back tariffs on a range of Chinese imports imposed by his predecessor. A final decision may only be taken after next week’s G7 meeting, with multiple reports indicating that Biden’s team is deeply conflicted over the issue.

Nevertheless, the very fact that the move is being considered and even favoured is indicative of the confusing priorities and self-contradictory impulses of an administration that at times has seemed to be lacking in ideas, resembling a headless chicken in its attempts to teach Russia a lesson and adopt a viable policy to tackle China, its biggest strategic rival.

The Section 301 tariffs on more than $350 billion worth of consumer goods from China, spanning textiles, meat, laptops, clothing, etc., were imposed by the Donald Trump administration in several tranches since 2018 to address the trade deficit, pressurise China into changing its predatory trade practices and impose costs on Beijing’s theft of US intellectual properties.

Trump-era tariffs: Caught between a rock and scorching inflation, Joe Biden mulls handing China a big, unexpected ‘win’

Former President Donald Trump speaks at the Road to Majority conference in Nashville, Tenn. AP

The deficit has widened, but Biden has so far not tampered with the tariffs. He had indicated in January this year that these levies won’t be rescinded since China has failed to abide by the commitments of the Trump-era Phase One trade deal signed two years ago. So, why is Biden mulling over scrapping these tariffs now? Has China started acting on its promises? Has it given any major concessions?

Quite the contrary. Recent data indicates that far from purchasing additional American goods and services to the tune of $200 billion by the end of 2021, that would have meant China buying a total of $502.4 billion worth of American soybean, sorghum and other agricultural products, aeroplanes, energy and services over the designated two-year period, China has ended up buying only $288.8 billion, or 57 per cent of the total it had promised — a volume that is lower than even the baseline 2017 levels under the agreement, reports New York Times, citing Chad Bown from Peterson Institute for International Economics.

If that is the case, why is Biden talking about reviewing these tariffs at all? The answer lies in the runaway inflation in the US that has already accelerated to a 40-year high in May and threatens to further scorch the Democrats’ already perilous political fortunes in the upcoming midterm elections.

As consumer confidence ebbs and bourses enter a bear grip, consumer prices are up 8.6 per cent from a year earlier and has recorded an estimate-breaking 1 per cent jump since April. The spectre of a recession is looming large with “record gasoline prices, paired with unrelenting food and shelter costs (that) are adding strain to Americans’ cost of living.”

With prices reaching for the sky and the dollar travelling less than it used to, Americans are getting angrier, and Biden is feeling hot under the collar. The latest poll figures show only 29 per cent of Americans approve of Biden’s handling of the economy and only 23 per cent feel that he is doing a good job at containing inflation, with a massive 71 per cent of Americans disapproving of his tactics. Little wonder that the Republicans at this stage enjoy a 19-point lead in the poll on better handling of inflation and skyrocketing prices with the survey indicating a 55-36 per cent advantage over Democrats hinting at a red wave in November.

Trump-era tariffs: Caught between a rock and scorching inflation, Joe Biden mulls handing China a big, unexpected ‘win’

Representational image. News18

A Pew Research survey conducted between 25 April and 1 May found that seven in 10 Americans view inflation as a “very big problem for the country” and “no other concern comes close.”

Faced with such a predicament, and the possibility of becoming a lame-duck president after the midterm, Biden and his team are desperate to tame the inflation monster. The interesting thing to note here is that the inflation, that is causing such a big political headache for Biden, has been fed to a large degree by US-led western energy sanctions on Russia. It is mostly a self-inflicted wound.

To punish Putin, Biden and his allies imposed some of the toughest economic sanctions on Moscow. That in turn triggered an unprecedented rise in global oil and natural gas prices, driving up housing, food, and electricity prices and fuelling four-decade high inflation in the US and the UK.

The collateral damage of Western sanctions has been so severe that the Biden administration is now “quietly encouraging some US businesses in the agricultural and shipping spheres to buy and carry more Russian fertilizers”, reports Bloomberg.

On the inflation front, Biden’s problem is that he has very few tools at his disposal to fight the raging fire. But he must be seen to be doing something, so he may end up reversing the Trump-era tariffs as a desperate, stopgap measure. That doesn’t address the core problem, won’t alleviate the pain, makes no economic sense, even less political sense, and is a strategically short-sighted and counterproductive move that may handsomely reward China for its duplicitous trade policies.

Biden, of course, didn’t want to be pushed to such a dilemma. He was happy to let the status quo prevail on the sanctions, fully aware of the onerous choices at hand. But the coincidence of politically noxious high energy prices and the looming, statutory four-year review of the Section 310 tariffs that must be completed this summer has forced him to act. Latest reports say he is going to request Congress for a three-month suspension of the federal gas tax, a frantic manoeuvre that Barack Obama had once called a “gimmick”.

Trump-era tariffs: Caught between a rock and scorching inflation, Joe Biden mulls handing China a big, unexpected ‘win’

Former US president Barack Obama. AP

This conundrum reflects the policy indecisiveness and ad-hocism in an administration that seems confused both in its rhetoric (consider the White House’s rolling back thrice of Biden’s comments on Taiwan) and actions. It is muddling through on China — that Washington considers to be its “most serious competitor” — in a mix of uncertain lunges and walkbacks, and on Russia, Biden is all fire and brimstone, taking actions without thinking through the consequences.

The US president had boasted in March that his sanctions had turned the Russian ruble into a “rubble”. He had predicted that the Russian economy will soon be halved. Yet months after the US and its allies moved to impoverish Russia, the ruble is now the strongest against the dollar in seven years, it is the strongest currency in the world this year, and Russia is selling more oil than ever, earning even more than it did before the war and even European nations are quietly creeping up their share of Russian crude while the US is battling crippling inflation at home.

If Biden’s Russia policy seems to be backfiring, it would be nothing in comparison to the long-term pain he may invite if the US president does decide to lift the Trump-era tariffs on Chinese goods. The US president is under increasing internal, competing pressure from within his own administration. While national security officials and the Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR) — the agency that implements the tariffs — loathe to give away the negotiating leverage over China, the treasury and commerce departments that represent the business communities and lobby groups, are advocating rolling back the tariffs claiming that it would let some inflationary steam off the economy.

Biden has so far been coy, unwilling to commit one way or another, but Democrats are panicking at falling ratings even among core voters and senior administration officials are willing to grasp at anything if only to manage the optics around a president seemingly doing nothing to curb high food and fuel prices affecting ordinary Americans.

However, the move to tweak the tariffs would carry significant political and strategic costs, without bringing any substantial economic benefits.

Politically, it would expose Biden to renewed attacks from the Republicans that he is “soft on China”, especially if the lifting does not involve any quid pro quo. Wall Street and business lobbyists apart, China’s adversarial position is among the rare issues that enjoy consensus in a bitterly polarised American polity, and if the president is seen to be easing the pain on China without any tangible gains, that would outweigh any political benefits Biden may derive by easing off the inflationary pressure.

Additionally, it would complicate Biden’s pitch for a midterm or even presidential polls going ahead if, after promising to create and bring back “well-paying, middle-class jobs”, the US president takes a step that encourages American companies to maintain their supply chains in China and undermines whatever is left of the American manufacturing base. That would hurt the chances of creating more jobs. Biden has been tom-tomming the fact that the US has recorded a healthy job growth under his watch, but it is worth remembering that the growth comes off a low base point. In April 2020, battered by a rampant Covid crisis, US unemployment had hit its highest level since the Great Depression of the 1930s.

Biden’s economic record, therefore, at best has been patchy. After months of denial on inflation, calling it a temporary phenomenon, trying to deflect the blame, Biden finally admitted that there’s not much he can do to tame the soaring prices. He is now fending off fears of recession.

On top of this, if Biden removes the tariffs, ahead of what is likely to be a difficult election he will end up angering Democrats’ core constituency — the domestic trade groups and labour unions — who want the Trump-era tariffs on Chinese imports to stay and have officially filed an appeal with the USTR demanding an extension. Biden has so far been careful not to irk the backbone of his party, but with reports trickling in that he is considering a removal, the labour unions are feeling restive and has warned the White House against such a move.

Kim Glas, the chief of the National Council of Textile Organizations, a major American textile group, released a statement last month pointing out that “tariffs are a reasonable and necessary mechanism to support US jobs, offset unacceptable practices, and strengthen the national economy. They help partially level the playing field for American manufacturers and workers trying to compete against unfair and illegal trade practices – ranging from intellectual property theft, forced labor, to state-sponsored subsidies – that have been perpetuated by the Chinese government… It’s critical we maintain key negotiating leverage to address these predatory trade behaviors.”

It would have been understandable if the political cost returned long-term, economic benefits. The tariffs did not cause inflation, and they are expected to have a marginal and transitory effect on price rise, shaving off at best a few percentage points from overall inflation.

Washington Post cites a study by economists Gary Hufbauer, Megan Hogan and Yilin Wang of the Peterson Institute for International Economics that says tariff removal would reduce the inflation measure by 0.3 percentage points, and even then the full benefit “could take nine to 15 months to materialize.”

Other studies paint an even bleaker picture, contesting that benefits are illusory, and effects would be harmful to US economy. Robert E Scott and Adam S Hersh of Economic Policy Institute write that “rolling tariffs back would return efforts to reshore key elements of global manufacturing supply chains to the United States back to square one. Given how damaging fragile global supply chains have proven to be—and how important it is to reshore production back to the US —claims that tariff rollbacks are an answer to inflation are dangerous.”

Besides, there’s no guarantee that retailers and importers would pass on the benefits to the consumers instead of profit-taking, and there’s even the possibility that China may stop the deep discounts that were placed to counterbalance the tariffs and will now absorb the differential by hiking prices at their end.

The only constituency that is lobbying for tariff removal are the big retailers and businesses that have large operations in China. Washington Post quotes Derek Scissors of the American Enterprise Institute as saying that the “the financial community wants to get rid of the tariffs because they will get treated better by the Chinese government regarding access to the Chinese market.”

It is not surprising to see that China has been very vocal about removal of the tariffs, and is now helpfully suggesting that Biden should rescind these to curb inflation. Beijing senses that Biden is in a tight spot and has been making the case that the import duties are “harming Americans more than the Chinese.”

Therefore, whether or not Trump succeeded in forcing China to change its behaviour, the tariffs do present the Biden administration with a negotiating leverage that should not be abandoned for nothing. Not only will that take away a key cushion for US manufacturing base, it would embolden China to carry on with its subversive and illegal trade practices and, as Bob Bilbruck of consulting firm Captjur tells New York Post, “the amount of negative impact this will have will last decades if not forever turn the tide of competition with China in favor of China.”

The Biden administration so far has appeared clueless when it comes to China strategy, failing to match rhetoric with action. It has talked a game bigger than it is capable of walking, and as the power balance shifts in Asia in favour of China, the US domestic debate over the withdrawal of the China tariff is a further example of the Biden administration’s muddled thinking that ends up weakening its own hand and strengthening that of its chief adversary.

News Related


25-hour countdown for Indian rocket mission to begin at 5 pm today

Representative image The 25-hour countdown for the Thursday evening launch of Indian rocket Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) carrying three Singapore satellites will begin at 5 p.m. on Wednesday. The ... Read more »

Zara Aleena: Man charged with murder of 35-year-old

Jordan McSweeney will appear in custody at Thames Magistrates’ Court on Wednesday Read more »

What to do if your home is down valued, from negotiating a new price to increasing your deposit

According to online broker Mojo Mortgages, down valuations affected 12.8 per cent of all house purchase mortgages in April 2022 Read more »

Finding a new house rental is more stressful than ever with landlords charging top rates

It is three years since Grace Gausden had to move and the cost has been a massive shock Read more »

From Pet Shop Boys Glastonbury wall to U2’s giant lemon: What happens when the hi-tech stage show goes wrong

Chris Lowe of the Pet Shop Boys became stuck behind a wall during the band’s Glastonbury headline set but he isn’t the first artist to suffer as a result of stage malfunctions Read more »

Six experts on the parts of the home you should clean before inviting guests over

Do you do these six commonly overlooked things before guests come to visit? (Credit: Getty) Making sure your home is clean and tidy ahead of guests coming over is a ... Read more »

Serena Williams refuses to confirm she will return to Wimbledon after shock first round defeat

Serena Williams suffered a shock first round defeat at Wimbledon against Harmony Tan (Picture: Getty) Serena Williams left her future open to question after her return to Wimbledon ended in ... Read more »

Man charged with murder and attempted rape of aspiring lawyer killed while walking home

Jordan McSweeney, 29, has been charged with the murder of 35-year-old Zara Aleena in Ilford (Picture: PA/SWNS) A 29-year-old man has been charged with the murder of Zara Aleena, 35, ... Read more »

Brexit: UK should rejoin single market as quitting EU ‘biggest piece of self-inflicted harm,’ says Sadiq Khan

© PA Wire London Mayor Sadiq Khan Britain should push to rejoin the single market because Brexit is the “biggest piece of self-inflicted harm ever done to a country,” says ... Read more »

Australian of the Year Dylan Alcott's urges young people with disabilities to 'be proud'

Five months into his tenure as 2022 Australian of the Year, Dylan Alcott says he is still “incredibly humbled” by the appointment, but also cannot wait to hand over the ... Read more »

Daily IOL News Bulletin - June 29

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) IOL NEWS · Daily IOL News Bulletin – June 29 Durban – In our top story, The National Department of Health has confirmed the ... Read more »

Domestic tourism spending for 2021 drops 54.5% to RM18.4 billion

The number of domestic visitor arrivals in 2021 fell 49.9% to 66 million compared to 131.7 million the year before. Read more »

DS 7 facelift debuts as sophisticated French SUV centred around luxury

Image: DS Automobiles Image: DS Automobiles Image: DS Automobiles Image: DS Automobiles Image: DS Automobiles The DS 7 facelift retains all of the sophistication and luxury from before although the ... Read more »

I took the train to Graz, Austria – here’s my guide to the city

Photograph: Oleh_Slobodeniuk/Getty Images Graz truly is a tale of two cities. The old town lies on the east bank of the River Mur under the lee of the tree-covered Schlossberg. ... Read more »

When we arrived at 9pm at our hotel in Tenerife it was closed

Photograph: Robbin Lee/Alamy In February, we responded to a promotion by travel firm Holiday Gems for an all-inclusive package to the Bluesea Callao Garden hotel in Tenerife. We paid £850 ... Read more »

Transfer news LIVE: Chelsea 'close' to Raphinha signing as Gabriel Jesus has Arsenal medical, Man Utd double deal

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Bison charges at family of tourists, gores man in Yellowstone National Park

A bison gorged a Colorado man at Yellowstone National Park on Monday. Getty Images A 34-year-old Colorado man was gored by a charging bison in recently-reopened Yellowstone National Park Monday ... Read more »

analysis: Netball is facing an identity crisis as it tries to recover financially

Netball Australia's financial trouble has seen it dominate headlines during the past month. The peak governing body sold its Super Netball grand final to the highest state government bidder, revealing the serious economic ... Read more »

Orient Bell zooms 18% on upward revision in credit ratings by Crisil

Shares of Orient Bell (OBL) zoomed 18 per cent to Rs 684 on the BSE in Wednesday’s trade in an otherwise weak market after Crisil ratings upgraded its ratings on ... Read more »

Why a motorhome holiday is excellent value despite rising costs – and how to make the most of a UK road trip

Motorhome ownership rose sharply during the pandemic and, despite rising petrol costs, a road trip still offers excellent value this summer. Martin Dorey explains how Read more »

Coronation Street spoilers: Debbie has Toyah sent to prison after big discovery?

Toyah’s getting herself into more trouble (Picture: ITV) Currently on bail under suspicion of the murder of Imran in Coronation Street, Toyah (Georgia Taylor) would really be wise to keep ... Read more »

Coronation Street spoilers: Fiz wedding showdown, Audrey death decision, new Toyah crime

Wedding drama on the cobbles (Picture:ITV) Wedding fever hits Coronation Street but, as with their entire relationship, there is going to be huge turbulence for Fiz Stape (Jennie McAlpine) and ... Read more »

Abuse at all ranks in the services, Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide hears

A damaging cycle of abuse within the Australian Defence Force is likely to continue without a “circuit breaker”, the Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide has been told. Key ... Read more »

New additions at center of Yankees’ stark defensive improvement

Almost every move the Yankees made this past offseason came with an eye on their defense. So perhaps it shouldn’t be a total surprise that the club’s fielding has been ... Read more »

Digi-Celcom merger gets MCMC green light

The commission says it is satisfied with companies' commitment to significantly reduce any competition issues that might arise due to the merger. Read more »

MCMC luluskan penggabungan Celcom-Digi

Penggabungan ini akan menghasilkan pengendali perkhidmatan mudah alih yang terbesar di Malaysia. Read more »

SC agrees to hear Shiv Sena's plea challenging Maharashtra Governor's floor test decision today at 5 pm

The Supreme Court of India. ANI The Supreme Court has agreed to hear Shiv Sena chief whip Sunil Prabhu’s plea challenging Maharashtra Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari’s direction to Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray ... Read more »

Who is Ghislaine Maxwell? The British socialite who lured and groomed girls for her former boyfriend Jeffrey Epstein

How the mighty have fallen! Once considered the toast of high society, now Ghislaine Maxwell has been sentenced to 20 years in jail for grooming and trafficking underage girls. AFP ... Read more »

PSHS to start accepting lateral admission for Grades 8, 9 on July 1

PHILIPPINE Science High School (PSHS) will start accepting applications for lateral admission for incoming grades 8 and 9 for school year 2022-2023 on July 1. Interested students must be a ... Read more »

SSS partners with private bank for pay cards roll out

THE Social Security System (SSS) said its members can acquire Unified Multi-Purpose Identification (UMID) Pay Cards through Union Bank of the Philippines by the fourth quarter of the year. The ... Read more »

Chris Pratt slams 'f***ed up' criticism of his message to his wife after she gave birth

Chris Pratt as hit out at those who criticised his choice of words after wife Katherine Schwarzenegger gave birth. The Guardians of the Galaxy star, 43, admitted he was “really ... Read more »

Man, 29, charged with murder and attempted rape of 'kind soul' Zara Aleena

A homeless man has been charged with the murder and attempted rape and robbery of a law student in northeast London. Zara Aleena, 35, was just minutes from her home ... Read more »

More than 60,000 bees euthanised in NSW with more to come as additional varroa mite red zones identified

More beekeepers are preparing to have their hives destroyed after new detections of varroa mite were found at multiple sites across New South Wales, as authorities also consider a plan to ... Read more »

Shares, property, bonds, cryptocurrencies face major falls, Australian Office of Financial Management CEO warns

A senior public servant has warned of the potential for significant falls on asset markets in the months ahead. Key points: Rob Nicholl says low interest rates and money-printing programs ... Read more »

Good News: South Africans rally together to raise funds to send Lavender Hill pool players to nationals

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – As a journalist, I am often inundated with messages through all social media platforms on a daily basis. But the ... Read more »

Rupee weakens to a new low; traders see currency breaching 79/$ soon

ALSO READ Rupee closes at all-time low of 77.74 against USD amid elevated oil prices BS Number Wise: RBI needs to strike the right balance as rupee falls RBI steps ... Read more »

MVA will have to move SC against Guv's letter for floor test: Prithviraj

Prithviraj Chavan Senior Congress leader Prithviraj Chavan on Wednesday said Maharashtra's ruling Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) will have to move the Supreme Court against Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari's letter mandating ... Read more »

Govt probe panel finds safety flaws behind electric two-wheelers fires

As fires in electric vehicles (EVs) continue unabated in the country, an expert committee set up by the Union Road Transport and Highways Ministry has found safety system flaws in ... Read more »

These Are the Most Expensive Places to Work Abroad in 2022

Hong Kong has be named the most expensive city in which to live and work overseas this year, according to a new report which highlights the impact of rising living ... Read more »

Incoming Philippines Finance Secretary Wants to Put His Country Back on a Growth Track

The Philippines’ incoming finance minister wants to get his county back on a growth path and tackle pressing economic issues such as its huge debt pile. “As finance secretary I’ll have a ... Read more »