Trump documents: Judges skeptical of arguments to block release of his January 6 records

All three judges on the appellate panel Tuesday that’s hearing former President Donald Trump’s case seeking to block release of his January 6 documents signaled that they had skepticism about the arguments his lawyer was making in the case.

Trump documents: Judges skeptical of arguments to block release of his January 6 records
© SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images US President Donald Trump speaks during the White House Conference on American History at the National Archives in Washington, DC, September 17, 2020.

“This all boils down to who decides. Who decides when it is in the best interest of the United States to disclose presidential records? Is it the current occupant of the White House or the former?” said Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson of the DC Circuit Court of Appeals.

She and other judges on the panel expressed doubt about Trump’s arguments for why the documents should not be disclosed to the House’s investigation into the Capitol riots. However, they also had questions for the House about scenarios where an assertion of privilege from a former president could trump a waiver of that privilege from the incumbent.

“We don’t just flip a coin or draw straws or something. What test are we supposed to use?” Judge Robert Wilkins asked a lawyer representing the House.

The arguments are likely to be an uphill battle for the former President. The Biden administration and the House are aligned against him in wanting transparency about communications in the West Wing as Trump sought to overturn the 2020 election result and his supporters raided the Capitol. Trump lost his first round in court in the case, more quickly and resoundingly than his losses when he tried to claim broad protections from investigations while he was President.

Yet by raising major, unsettled questions about the power of former presidents to control information from their time in office, the case appears to be on a path to the Supreme Court.

Trump has argued he should be able to assert executive privilege over records such as call logs and the handwritten notes of his top advisers. The Biden administration has declined to keep January 6-related White House documents confidential.

“All three branches of government have acknowledged that there’s a presidential — a right of former presidents to be able to challenge the designation in release of presidential records. The Congress did it through the adoption of the statute,” Jesse Binnall, a lawyer for Trump, argued.

The judges grilled Binnall on some of the procedural questions that have arisen in the case, before the arguments turned to the merits of Trump’s arguments, which were presented Tuesday by Trump lawyer Justin Clark.

Judge Patricia Millett, another member of the panel, questioned Clark’s focus on the Trump presidential documents that have already been released to Congress without a challenge from Trump.

Millett said that she did not see the case being about the content of the documents Trump is seeking to block, but what to do when there is a dispute between the current and former presidents over the records release.

Examining a 1977 Supreme Court opinion

In a troubling sign for Trump, at least one judge on the panel said she had a different interpretation than the Trump team of a milestone Supreme Court opinion that Trump is depending on in the case.

Jackson suggested that she did not see the 1977 decision in Nixon v. General Services Administration giving Trump the legal wiggle room to challenge in court the current president’s decision to waive privilege.

“When you have a conflict of incumbent and former, [the] incumbent gets to decide,” Jackson said.

Millett also zeroed in on that case, asking Clark how much weight courts should give a current president’s refusal to assert privilege over the documents.

“We have one President at a time under our Constitution,” is what that case said, Millett told Clark.

Judge Robert Wilkins, the appellate panel’s third member, brought up other court precedents from the Nixon era, and told Trump’s legal team “it seems your argument is inconsistent with our precedent.”

He was focused on Clark’s claim that, in these disagreements between current and former presidents, courts might have to review the disputed records document-by-document.

“That’s not the way we say we do this, at least the way I read those cases,” Wilkins said.

Millett then dug in, with an even harsher set of questions for Clark.

“Stop. Please stop!” she said, cutting him off.

Once the current president makes a call on executive privilege, “You say now the former president could say let’s look at the documents” in court to make confidentiality decisions, Millett said. “It changes the analysis not a wit for a court to say, ‘It’s executive privilege, it’s not executive privilege,'” she said.

Later in on, in her questions for Doug Letter, the lawyer representing the House’s January 6 committee, Millett asked what limits there were in an incumbent president’s ability to overrule an assertion of privilege by a former president. She asked Letter about a scenario where an incumbent was seeking the release of a former president’s documents merely to “avenge” his predecessor, and she offered another hypothetical where a former president raised concerns about the release of presidential documents putting lives of foreign agents at risk. Wilkins put forth a scenario where courts were weighing an assertion of privilege by four former presidents against the waiver of that privilege by the incumbent.

Letter acknowledged that there might be some “weird” scenario where the current president wasn’t the ultimate arbiter of executive privilege, but he stressed that those hypotheticals were very far from the case before the court.

Handover on hold

The National Archives was set to begin turning over records this month to Congress, but Trump’s lawsuit has put that on hold, potentially slowing parts of the House committee’s investigation. Trump has also warned the appeals court against giving Congress too much power.

The House said it needs the more than 700 pages of disputed Trump White House records, from close advisers including then-chief of staff Mark Meadows and press secretary Kayleigh McEnany, so it can learn enough about Trump’s efforts for Congress to make laws that could protect future elections. The Biden administration has endorsed the House learning as much as it can about Trump and the attempted coup.

Judge Tanya Chutkan of the DC District Court previously smacked down all of Trump’s arguments in the case. “Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not President,” she wrote in her opinion earlier this month.

Presidential privilege “exists for the benefit of the Republic, not any individual,” Chutkan also wrote.

Now the DC Circuit Court of Appeals could rule quickly. The panel of appellate judges — Millett, Wilkins and Jackson — are all appointed by Democrats and moved fast to schedule the case for argument, bringing it before them only three weeks after Chutkan ruled. Jackson is already known to oppose Trump’s broad executive privilege claims, having written years ago that “presidents are not kings” when Trump tried to block a congressional subpoena of his former White House counsel, Don McGahn.

So far the panel has shown an inkling of doubt. Last week, they told Trump, the House and the Biden administration to be prepared to address questions of whether the court can even decide a case like this — in addition to the arguments the parties are already prepared to make.

Wilkins also has been a strong voice on recent politically charged cases. He wrote a strong dissent against the dismissal of former Trump national security adviser Michael Flynn’s guilty plea in 2020 and authored the opinion that set the standard for the jailing of Capitol riot defendants before their trials.

Four collections of records from the Trump White House that have been reviewed by the National Archives are poised to go to the House committee if Trump ultimately loses the appeal. Witnesses subpoenaed by the House, including Meadows himself, have used the ongoing court case as a shield to skirt testifying.

Currently, the appeals court has put a temporary hold on the National Archives releasing the records Trump contests, pending its issuance of another order.

“The concern here is, we are on a timeline — in terms of a 30 day timeline — and getting a preliminary injunction so we can hash out these issues is really important on our end, and that’s where I think we are,” Clark, the Trump attorney, said.

This story has been updated with additional developments.

News Related


Tri-Service Andaman & Nicobar Command inducts Advanced Light Helicopter MK III

© Provided by The Statesman Tri-Service Andaman & Nicobar Command inducts Advanced Light Helicopter MK III In a major boost to India’s maritime security, the indigenous Advanced Light Helicopter (ALH) ... Read more »

Akhilesh Yadav says stranded in Delhi as chopper not allowed to take off for Muzaffarnagar, alleges conspiracy

© Provided by The Financial Express The SP president posted a picture with the helicopter in the background and said no reason was given for it. (Twitter/Akhilesh Yadav) Samajwadi Party ... Read more »

'Badhaai Do' trailer sheds light on lavender marriages: All you need to know about it and why it could hurt LGBTQ fight in India

© Provided by Firstpost ‘Badhaai Do’ trailer sheds light on lavender marriages: All you need to know about it and why it could hurt LGBTQ fight in India Rajkummar Rao ... Read more »

DU student among 2 arrested in robbery case in Delhi

The Delhi Police has arrested two robbers, namely Sachin and Gaurav, who are residents of Delhi. Police have recovered a stolen mobile phone along with an i-10 car used by ... Read more »

From the Editor-in-Chief

When the BJP high command anointed the mahant of the Gorakhnath Math as the chief minister of Uttar Pradesh on March 19, 2017, after the party swept an assembly election, ... Read more »

UP Polls: On Amit Shah's 'wrong home' remark to woo Jat voters, RLD's Jayant Chaudhry says 'not interested'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Rashtriya Lok Dal (RLD) chief Jayant Chaudhary on Friday (January 28) turned down BJP leader Amit Shah’s indirect invitation for an alliance with ... Read more »

Prince Andrew gives up golf club membership in another blow to embattled royal after demanding jury for sex case lawsuit

PRINCE Andrew has given up his honorary golf club membership in another blow to the embattled royal. The Duke of York, 61, will no longer keep his privileges at The ... Read more »

Man Utd transfer news LIVE: Donny van de Beek to Palace UPDATE, Ronaldo rage at £67.5m valuation, Amad Diallo to Rangers

CRISTIANO RONALDO could be heading back to Real Madrid, according to shock reports in Spain. Press in the country claim that Ronaldo has asked Jorge Mendes to speak to Florentino ... Read more »

Trial in Germany's Green Vault jewel heist opens in Dresden

© Reuters/MATTHIAS RIETSCHEL Trial starts against Dresden Green Vault robbers BERLIN (Reuters) – Six men accused of involvement in a 2019 jewel heist at a museum housing one of Europe’s ... Read more »

Christel Heydemann named as first female CEO of telecoms group Orange

© Reuters/SARAH MEYSSONNIER Logo of French telecom operator Orange in Levallois-Perret PARIS (Reuters) – Orange, France’s biggest telecoms operator, on Friday named Christel Heydemann as its new chief executive, making ... Read more »

Brutale Demütigung im Handball: Argentinien zerpflückt Bolivien auf übelste Art und Weise

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Argentinien zerpflückt Bolivien auf übelste Art und Weise Ist es ein Denkzettel? Eine Ohrfeige? Eine Klatsche oder doch ein Debakel? Die krasse 8:70-Pleite von Bolivien gegen ... Read more »

Menschenrechtler fordern diplomatischen Boykott der Winterspiele

© Keystone/AP/Ng Han Guan Ein Bündnis aus 243 Menschenrechts- und anderen Nichtregierungsorganisationen hat wenige Tage vor dem Beginn der Olympischen Winterspiele in Peking zu einem diplomatischen Boykott aufgerufen. “Die Olympischen ... Read more »

Zu tiefer Marktwert? CR7 zoffte sich online mit Fussball-Plattform «Transfermarkt»

© Dave Thompson/ Mit dem steigenden Alter sinkt der Marktwert von Cristiano Ronaldo – damit ist der Superstar nicht einverstanden. Das Online-Portal «» ist eine der wichtigsten Plattformen der heutigen ... Read more »

Verrückte Challenge League: Neun Teams im Aufstiegsrennen – Kriens auf Abschiedstour

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Neun Teams im Aufstiegsrennen – Kriens auf Abschiedstour Am Freitag ist Anpfiff zur verrücktesten Rückrunde der Challenge League seit Jahren. Zwischen dem Tabellenführer Vaduz und Xamax ... Read more »

Pariksha Pe Charcha 2022: Centre extends date of registration till February 3 - Check direct link, steps to apply

© Provided by DNA On Friday, the Union Ministry of Education announced that the registration date for the fifth edition ‘Pariksha Pe Charcha’ 2022 has been extended till February 3.  ... Read more »

UPTET Answer key 2021 released at - Know how to raise objections

© Provided by DNA The Examination Regulatory Authority of Uttar Pradesh, Prayagraj has released UPTET Answer Key 2021 on Thursday (January 27). Candidates can check UPTET answer keys through the ... Read more »

4 Tips on turning a fling into a relationship

There are numerous ways to enjoy strictly physical connections with other people, whether you’ve agreed to be friends with benefits or it’s a one-time romance with no strings attached. But, ... Read more »

FP Answers: Can I retire in 15 years even though I'm still paying off my mortgage?

© Provided by Financial Post In making a choice between paying down a mortgage that has a lower rate of interest or investing the money at a higher rate of ... Read more »

Former Karnataka CM BS Yediyurappa's granddaughter found hanging at Bengaluru apartment

© Provided by Zee News Bengaluru: The granddaughter of former Karnataka Chief Minister BS Yediyurappa was found dead at her home in Bengaluru today (January 28). Soundarya was found hanging ... Read more »

PFP's Briones declines Guanzon's dare for debate

from SFT interview Partido Federal ng Pilipinas (PFP) general counsel George Briones on Friday declined the challenge of Commission on Elections (Comelec) commissioner Rowena Guanzon to have a televised debate. ... Read more »

Biden is aiming to hit the road to reset his presidency. He starts with yet another stop in Pennsylvania.

When President Joe Biden visits Pittsburgh on Friday, it will amount to the unofficial launch of a new strategy the President devised to shore up his political fortunes by changing ... Read more »

Estate planning can be uncomfortable, but it's not just about money

© Getty Images/iStockphoto files If estate equalization is the goal, it is important to be mindful of how taxes factor into the equation. Let’s start with a fun family story. ... Read more »

Russia-Ukraine crisis: Severe sanctions could trigger crippling Moscow response

The U.S. is threatening painful sanctions against Russia if it launches an attack on Ukraine, but Moscow could hit back at the West by throttling natural gas supplies to Europe ... Read more »

London's Depave Paradise to turn more asphalt to green space this spring

© Submitted by London Environmental Network The team that converted the courtyard at Fanshawe College last year into a green space as part of the Depave Paradise program. A community ... Read more »

Krushna Abhishek Talks About 'Professional Rivalry' With Kapil Sharma But...

© Provided by News18 Krushna Abhishek is an extremely important member of The Kapil Sharma Show. The actor-comedian recently shared the trailer of Kapil Sharma’s Netflix show on his Instagram. ... Read more »

Delhi Govt Resumes Driving License Skill Test, Learning License Tests As COVID Cases Decline

New Delhi: The Delhi government on Friday issued a notification saying it is resuming the Driving License Skill Test and Learning License Test activities which were suspended due to COVID. ... Read more »

Shafee intends to delay claim, says LHDN

© Provided by New Straits Times KUALA LUMPUR: The Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) has appealed to the High Court here to set aside Tan Sri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah’s application for ... Read more »

Jubin Nautiyal's new single brims over with love and friendship

© IANS Jubin Nautiyal’s new single brims over with love and friendship Mumbai, Jan 28 (IANS) Jubin Nautiyal’s new romantic single ‘Dil Pe Zakhm’ featuring actors Gurmeet Choudhary, Arjun Bijlani ... Read more »

Red-faced estate agents forced to pull down listing for four bedroom home after viewers spot a VERY rude sign

RED-faced estate agents have been forced to pull down a £200,000 listing after eagle-eyed house hunters spotted a sign declaring “let's party bitches”. The property listing, marketed by Nicholas Humphreys ... Read more »

F1 cars could be all similar by 2023, says Ferrari

With teams putting the finishing touches to their 2022 challengers, there is some hope that the more restrictive regulations won’t make all the designs identical. For although there are far ... Read more »

UP Assembly Elections 2022: Candidates, Poll Dates of Kanpur Cantt. Vidhan Sabha Constituency

© Kritika Bansal | News Desk Kanpur Cantt Assembly Elections 2022 Kanpur Cantt Assembly Elections 2022: Kanpur Cantt is one of 403 assembly constituencies going to the polls in ... Read more »

Big rift in West Indies team involving captain Kieron Pollard ahead of India tour

© Provided by Zee News West Indies will be arriving in India in the next few days to play limited-overs series, including 3 T20Is and ODIs each.  However, even before ... Read more »

'The Gift we All Needed': Steve Waugh Clicked Eating Ice-cream at Australian Open, Clips Goes Viral

© Provided by News18 ‘The Gift we All Needed’: Steve Waugh Clicked Eating Ice-cream at Australian Open, Clips Goes Viral Australian Steve Waugh is widely regarded as one of the ... Read more »

UP polls: Congress's Badaun candidate Farah Naeem quits over 'indecent' remark by district president

Farah Naeem, the Congress candidate from Shekhupur Assembly seat in Uttar Pradesh’s Badaun district, has resigned from the party over alleged indecent remarks made by the party’s district president, Onkar ... Read more »

Want a selfie with Milind Soman? You'll need to perform 20 push-ups first - Read on

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Fitness enthusiast and actor Milind Soman recently revealed that he has a rule for taking selfies with his fans. The actor, in his ... Read more »

PHOTOS: Shweta Tiwari spotted on the sets of Bigg Boss 15 amid her controversial remark on God

Shweta Tiwari is currently treading troubled waters after her controversial remark referring to God went viral on social media. It so happened that during a press conference on Wednesday, Tiwari ... Read more »

Von Musk ins All geschossen: Teil von SpaceX-Rakete könnte im März in den Mond krachen

Ein Teil einer SpaceX-Rakete könnte nach Berechnungen von Wissenschaftlern der US-Raumfahrtbehörde Nasa Anfang März mit dem Mond zusammenstossen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Teil von SpaceX-Rakete könnte im März in den ... Read more »

Russia-Ukraine conflict: How a war between the two nations can affect India adversely

© Provided by DNA Russia has mobilised more than 100,000 troops near the Ukrainian border, raising fears of war in the region. Russia has consistently denied that it is planning ... Read more »

Chilling moment rapist carries woman through the streets to sexually assault her after grabbing her off the street

THIS is the chilling moment a serial predator carried a woman through a city centre before raping her in a horrific sex attack. Austin Osayande prowled the dark streets in ... Read more »

Love Island's Kendall Rae-Knight looks unrecognisable on the beach in new bikini shot

LOVE Island star Kendall Rae-Knight has shocked fans by looking unrecognisable in a new bikini snap on holiday. The reality TV alum – who rose to fame on the ITV2 ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic