Trial to determine if requiring women board members is legal

Jerry Brown
Image Icon
The Associated PressFILE – Then-California Gov. Jerry Brown talks during an interview in Sacramento, Calif., on Dec. 18, 2018. When former Gov. Brown signed the nation’s first law requiring that women sit on corporate boards of publicly traded companies, he suggested it might not survive legal challenges. Three years later, a judge will begin hearing evidence on Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021, in Los Angeles Superior Court that could undo a law that has already been credited with giving more women a seat in boardrooms. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File)

LOS ANGELES — When then-California Gov. Jerry Brown signed the nation’s first law requiring women on boards of publicly traded companies, he suggested it might not survive legal challenges.

Three years later, a judge will begin hearing evidence Wednesday in Los Angeles Superior Court that could undo the law credited with giving more women seats in boardrooms traditionally dominated by men. The California law has spurred other states to adopt or consider similar laws.

The conservative legal group Judicial Watch brought the lawsuit claiming it’s illegal to use taxpayer funds to enforce a law that violates the equal protection clause of the California Constitution by mandating a gender-based quota.

“They are creating a classification that either prefers or discriminates against one class or in preference of another,” attorney Robert Patrick Sticht said. He said the state doesn’t have a compelling government interest to create the mandate.

Another conservative legal group has filed a separate lawsuit in federal court claiming the law violates the equal protection clause of the U.S. Constitution.

Former Sen. Hannah-Beth Jackson, who authored the legislation, said the bill did not impose a quota because boards don’t need a certain percentage of women. Corporations can meet the requirement by adding women without undermining the rights of male board members.

She said the plaintiffs should be embarrassed for claiming the law is discriminatory.

“I find that to be incredibly ironic and hypocritical,” Jackson said. “Any time you try to make significant change to the status quo the powers that have been institutionalized to this kind of discrimination are likely to fight back.”

The law required publicly traded companies headquartered in California to have one member who identifies as a woman on their boards of directors by the end of 2019. By January, boards with five directors must have two women and boards with six or more members must have three women.

Penalties range from $100,000 fines for companies that fail to report board compositions to the California secretary of state’s office. Companies that do not include the required number of female board members can be fined $100,000 for first violations and $300,000 for subsequent violations.

Fewer than half the nearly 650 applicable corporations in the state reported last year that they had complied. More than half didn’t file the required disclosure statement, according to the most recent report.

No companies have been fined, though the secretary of state can do so, said spokeswoman Jenna Dresner.

The state has argued in court papers that it hasn’t used taxpayer funds to enforce the law. Dresner and the state attorney general’s office declined to comment on pending litigation.

Supporters of the law said it has already had a big impact in California and beyond. Washington state passed a similar measure this year and lawmakers in other states, including Massachusetts, New Jersey and Hawaii, have proposed similar bills. Illinois requires publicly traded companies to report the makeup of their boards.

Several European countries, including France, Germany, Norway and Spain, require corporate boards to include women.

Before the California law went into effect, women held 17% of the seats on company boards in the state, based on the Russell 3000 Index of the largest companies in the U.S., according to the advocacy group 50/50 Women on Boards. As of September, the percentage of board seats held by women climbed to more than 30% in California, compared to 26% nationally.

Still, some 40% of the largest companies in California need to add women to their boards to comply with the law, the group said.

With a deadline approaching, “there’s a lot of scrambling going on,” said Betsy Berkhemer-Credaire, CEO of 50/50 Women on Boards. She’s also heard anecdotally that other companies are waiting to see how the court rules.

Berkhemer-Credaire said she is confident it will be upheld. If it is found unconstitutional, it could slow progress, but she thinks pressure from institutional and private investors will continue to lead to more women being named to corporate boards.

“The train has left the station,” Berkhemer-Credaire said.

Adding pressure on the issue, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in August approved Nasdaq’s proposal that most of the nearly 3,000 companies listed on the exchange have at least one woman on their boards, along with one person from a racial minority or who identifies as gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender or queer.

There’s no penalty for companies that don’t meet the Nasdaq diversity criteria, but they must publicly explain why they could not comply.

The Nasdaq rule and a California law signed last year requiring publicly traded corporate boards have a member by January from an underrepresented community — including Black, Latino, Asian, Pacific Islander, Native American, or someone who self-identifies as gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender — are also facing lawsuits.

When the California law was proposed, an analysis by the state Assembly noted: “The use of a quota-like system, as proposed by this bill, to remedy past discrimination and differences in opportunity may be difficult to defend.” Brown signed it amid the budding #MeToo movement over sexual misconduct.

“I don’t minimize the potential flaws that indeed may prove fatal to its ultimate implementation,” the Democratic governor said in a letter. “Nevertheless, recent events … make it crystal clear that many are not getting the message.”

Judicial Watch sued in August 2019 and the Pacific Legal Foundation sued three months later on behalf of a shareholder who said the law would force him to discriminate on the basis of sex. The latter case was thrown out by a federal judge, but revived by a unanimous panel of the 9th U.S Circuit Court of Appeals.

Although the California Chamber of Commerce had opposed the law, it didn’t sign on to the litigation and no company has joined the legal effort being led in Los Angeles by three California residents. They sued under a provision that allows taxpayers to prevent unlawful government expenditures.

News Related


Lawyers question how publishing partygate report could prejudice police probe

© Stefan Rousseau Scotland Yard is now investigating ‘a number of events’ in Downing Street and Whitehall in relation to potential coronavirus regulation breaches (Stefan Rousseau/PA) Lawyers have questioned how ... Read more »

Suriya to collaborate with filmmakers Siva and Sudha Kongara for their next

© Provided by Pinkvilla Suriya is enjoying great heights of success after his film Jai Bhim received tremendous response for both audiences and critics. The film was even featured on ... Read more »

Jofra Archer rues missing England's Ashes campaign: Felt like I let everyone down a little bit

England fast bowler Jofra Archer said missing the T20 World Cup and the Ashes was a tough pill to swallow and that he felt like he had let the team ... Read more »

Stunning pictures of the spectacular glowing pink sky over London this morning

If you were up early enough this morning then you would have been treated to a stunning sunrise to get you in the mood for the weekend. While the weather ... Read more »

The City Libor traders are not criminals, they never were

© PA Winter weather Feb 11th 2021 You don’t have to like City traders (hardly anyone does) to think that today’s Libor verdict overturning criminal convictions is just. Until Libor, ... Read more »

Simmons rubbishes 'victimisation' claims after Powell-Smith swap

West Indies coach Phil Simmons and Cricket West Indies have both rubbished reports of Odean Smith being ‘victimised’, after the allrounder was benched in favour of Rovman Powell for the ... Read more »

Alisson sees two red cards overturned by VAR during Brazil World Cup qualifier

Liverpool goalkeeper Alisson Becker had two red cards overturned by VAR during Brazil’s dramatic 1-1 draw with Ecuador on Thursday. An eventful World Cup qualifier in Quito finished level despite ... Read more »

'Aur Kaun Hai Race Mei?' Rohit Fans Mock Shami After Pacer Says Open To Test Captaincy

© Provided by MensXP Virat Kohli stepped down as Test captain a day after India lost the three-match Test series in South Africa 1-2. Kohli’s decision shocked everyone including fans ... Read more »

Kazakhstan's President Tokayev voted in as ruling party leader following deadly crackdown

© Kazakhstan’s Presidential Press Service via AP/ File picture Kazakhstan’s president was on Friday voted chairman of the ruling party, replacing former head of state Nursultan Nazarbayev in the role, ... Read more »

German Green Party elects new leaders at volatile moment

© Provided by DW Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock and Economy Minister Robert Habeck are set to be replaced as party co-chairs It’s been a long time since Germany’s Green Party ... Read more »

Workout Diaries PHOTOS: Janhvi Kapoor, Malaika Arora, Kangana Ranaut sweat it out ahead of the weekend

The weekend certainly brings out a relaxed mood in everyone and well, even our stars are not oblivious to it. However, ahead of the weekend, many of our BTown stars ... Read more »

Sources: Oldham Athletic player set to seal Halifax move

© Provided by Football League World Carabao Cup First Round – Oldham Athletic v Derby County Zak Dearnley is set to join National League side Halifax after his contract at ... Read more »

Gal Gadot, Kenneth Branagh starrer Death on the Nile is all set to 'cruise' into the Indian cinemas on Februar

© Provided by Pinkvilla Gal Gadot and Kenneth Branagh-starrer ‘Death on the Nile’ is all set to release in India on February 11. The cast includes names such as five-time ... Read more »

Circle's CEO predicted bitcoin will hit $1 million, called gold a relic and said he's 'only just getting started' in the world of crypto in a recent interview. Here are the 10 best quotes.

© Circle Jeremy Allaire founded Circle, a leading digital payments company, in 2013. Circle Circle founder Jeremy Allaire told Insider that bitcoin’s price will eventually hit $1 million. He also ... Read more »

Daniil Medvedev screams at umpire in huge meltdown over Stefanos Tsitsipas' dad

Daniil Medvedev lost his cool with the umpire during his Australian Open semi-final with Stefanos Tsitsipas. After winning the first set, the Russian was pulled back to 1-1 by the ... Read more »

Luis Diaz forced to wait for dream Liverpool shirt number with £50m transfer imminent

Luis Diaz may have to wait to get his hands on his dream shirt number at Liverpool as he edges closer to completing a marquee transfer to Anfield. The winger, ... Read more »

US stock futures whipsaw as traders digest a mix of Fed-induced anxiety, strong GDP growth, and solid Apple earnings

© Scott Heins/Getty Images Traders have been rocked by volatility in 2022. Scott Heins/Getty Images US stocks are set for another volatile session Friday as traders weigh the US growth ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo's partner Georgina Rodriguez responds to 'ultimate birthday present'

Georgina Rodriguez has told Manchester United star Cristiano Ronaldo: “You couldn’t make me happier” in a gushing thank you message for the amazing laser show he arranged for her 28th ... Read more »

Vedanta Q3 Results | Profit grows 26.75% to Rs 5,354 crore, revenue up nearly 50%

Vedanta Limited | Representative image Vedanta Ltd on Friday reported a 26.75 percent increase in its consolidated net profit for the December quarter to Rs 5,354 crore from Rs 4,224 crore reported ... Read more »

Boleh ambil dos penggalak secara ‘walk in' di semua PPV seluruh negara

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: Vaksinasi dos penggalak untuk mereka berusia 18 tahun dan ke atas boleh diambil secara “walk-in” di semua pusat pemberian vaksin (PPV) di ... Read more »

Chandigarh hotelier duped of Rs 9.9 lakh on pretext of KYC update

Chandigarh hotelier duped of Rs 9.9 lakh on pretext of KYC update A resident of Chandigarh, a hotelier by profession, was reportedly duped of Rs 9.99 lakh by a swindler ... Read more »

Tri-Service Andaman & Nicobar Command inducts Advanced Light Helicopter MK III

© Provided by The Statesman Tri-Service Andaman & Nicobar Command inducts Advanced Light Helicopter MK III In a major boost to India’s maritime security, the indigenous Advanced Light Helicopter (ALH) ... Read more »

Akhilesh Yadav says stranded in Delhi as chopper not allowed to take off for Muzaffarnagar, alleges conspiracy

© Provided by The Financial Express The SP president posted a picture with the helicopter in the background and said no reason was given for it. (Twitter/Akhilesh Yadav) Samajwadi Party ... Read more »

'Badhaai Do' trailer sheds light on lavender marriages: All you need to know about it and why it could hurt LGBTQ fight in India

© Provided by Firstpost ‘Badhaai Do’ trailer sheds light on lavender marriages: All you need to know about it and why it could hurt LGBTQ fight in India Rajkummar Rao ... Read more »

DU student among 2 arrested in robbery case in Delhi

The Delhi Police has arrested two robbers, namely Sachin and Gaurav, who are residents of Delhi. Police have recovered a stolen mobile phone along with an i-10 car used by ... Read more »

From the Editor-in-Chief

When the BJP high command anointed the mahant of the Gorakhnath Math as the chief minister of Uttar Pradesh on March 19, 2017, after the party swept an assembly election, ... Read more »

UP Polls: On Amit Shah's 'wrong home' remark to woo Jat voters, RLD's Jayant Chaudhry says 'not interested'

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Rashtriya Lok Dal (RLD) chief Jayant Chaudhary on Friday (January 28) turned down BJP leader Amit Shah’s indirect invitation for an alliance with ... Read more »

Prince Andrew gives up golf club membership in another blow to embattled royal after demanding jury for sex case lawsuit

PRINCE Andrew has given up his honorary golf club membership in another blow to the embattled royal. The Duke of York, 61, will no longer keep his privileges at The ... Read more »

Man Utd transfer news LIVE: Donny van de Beek to Palace UPDATE, Ronaldo rage at £67.5m valuation, Amad Diallo to Rangers

CRISTIANO RONALDO could be heading back to Real Madrid, according to shock reports in Spain. Press in the country claim that Ronaldo has asked Jorge Mendes to speak to Florentino ... Read more »

Trial in Germany's Green Vault jewel heist opens in Dresden

© Reuters/MATTHIAS RIETSCHEL Trial starts against Dresden Green Vault robbers BERLIN (Reuters) – Six men accused of involvement in a 2019 jewel heist at a museum housing one of Europe’s ... Read more »

Christel Heydemann named as first female CEO of telecoms group Orange

© Reuters/SARAH MEYSSONNIER Logo of French telecom operator Orange in Levallois-Perret PARIS (Reuters) – Orange, France’s biggest telecoms operator, on Friday named Christel Heydemann as its new chief executive, making ... Read more »

Brutale Demütigung im Handball: Argentinien zerpflückt Bolivien auf übelste Art und Weise

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Argentinien zerpflückt Bolivien auf übelste Art und Weise Ist es ein Denkzettel? Eine Ohrfeige? Eine Klatsche oder doch ein Debakel? Die krasse 8:70-Pleite von Bolivien gegen ... Read more »

Menschenrechtler fordern diplomatischen Boykott der Winterspiele

© Keystone/AP/Ng Han Guan Ein Bündnis aus 243 Menschenrechts- und anderen Nichtregierungsorganisationen hat wenige Tage vor dem Beginn der Olympischen Winterspiele in Peking zu einem diplomatischen Boykott aufgerufen. “Die Olympischen ... Read more »

Zu tiefer Marktwert? CR7 zoffte sich online mit Fussball-Plattform «Transfermarkt»

© Dave Thompson/ Mit dem steigenden Alter sinkt der Marktwert von Cristiano Ronaldo – damit ist der Superstar nicht einverstanden. Das Online-Portal «» ist eine der wichtigsten Plattformen der heutigen ... Read more »

Verrückte Challenge League: Neun Teams im Aufstiegsrennen – Kriens auf Abschiedstour

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Neun Teams im Aufstiegsrennen – Kriens auf Abschiedstour Am Freitag ist Anpfiff zur verrücktesten Rückrunde der Challenge League seit Jahren. Zwischen dem Tabellenführer Vaduz und Xamax ... Read more »

Vlahović undergoing medical with Juventus for transfer

TURIN, Italy (AP) — Coveted striker Dušan Vlahović was undergoing a medical at Juventus on Friday to complete what is expected to be one of the biggest moves of the ... Read more »

Montana hosts Eastern Washington following Acliese's 22-point game

Eastern Washington Eagles (11-9, 5-4 Big Sky) at Montana Grizzlies (14-6, 7-2 Big Sky) Missoula, Montana; Saturday, 9 p.m. EST BOTTOM LINE: Eastern Washington visits the Montana Grizzlies after Linton ... Read more »

Pariksha Pe Charcha 2022: Centre extends date of registration till February 3 - Check direct link, steps to apply

© Provided by DNA On Friday, the Union Ministry of Education announced that the registration date for the fifth edition ‘Pariksha Pe Charcha’ 2022 has been extended till February 3.  ... Read more »

UPTET Answer key 2021 released at - Know how to raise objections

© Provided by DNA The Examination Regulatory Authority of Uttar Pradesh, Prayagraj has released UPTET Answer Key 2021 on Thursday (January 27). Candidates can check UPTET answer keys through the ... Read more »

4 Tips on turning a fling into a relationship

There are numerous ways to enjoy strictly physical connections with other people, whether you’ve agreed to be friends with benefits or it’s a one-time romance with no strings attached. But, ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic