Tory voters in north of England view social care reforms as ‘toxic' – research

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photograph: WPA/Getty Images

Labour polling reveals funding changes that break Conservative election pledge considered a betrayal

Conservative voters in the north of England view Boris Johnson’s changes to social care funding as toxic and say his broken pledge on not selling homes to pay for care is a betrayal, according to research seen by the Guardian.

The polling and focus group, undertaken for the Labour party, said the changes to social care funding this week found it was “the most powerful broken promise we have tested”, the report found.

Over two-thirds of the public oppose the plans and leave voters (71%) were as likely to oppose them as remain voters (74%), and it was more likely to be unpopular in the north, Midlands and among older voters, the report found.

Related: Another U-turn likely from UK government on care costs bill

The document was prepared to inform Labour’s response to changes in social care funding which would penalise poorer voters with lower house prices, meaning means-tested care would not count towards a new £86,000 cap on social care costs.

The change will mean those with £1m homes would be likely to keep more than 90% of their assets, but voters with less valuable homes, many in the north of England, are likely to be forced to sell family homes to pay for care costs once a relative has died.

Labour’s research found the change, which prompted a significant Tory rebellion in the House of Commons, “provokes genuine disgust from voters” though cautioned many did not yet understand the changes.

More worryingly for the Conservatives, it found leave voters in the north and the Midlands were some of the biggest opponents of the plan.

One Tory voter in Redcar, when played Starmer’s line at PMQs that those living in expensive homes would be able to pass them to their children versus those with a less valuable home, said it was “disgusting … they are robbing your kids really”.

Guardian graphic

Labour will hope to exploit the findings as it found visceral opposition to the plans once publicised – but little widespread understanding of them so far.

“There is real grievance about the importance of ‘people working hard all of their life to have a house to pass on to their children’, and that these plans could make that impossible,” the report says.

It quotes another female Conservative voter saying: “I class myself as working class. We’ve got a lovely four-bedroom house but it’s closer to the £100,000 mark than the £1m, that leaves your children with almost nothing, you’re working all your life to give something to your children and then you need to give it to the government.”

Related: How did your MP vote on social care funding?

At PMQs on Wednesday, Keir Starmer called the changes a “working-class dementia tax”, accusing the prime minister of breaking the Conservatives’ manifesto promise that no one would have to sell their home to pay care costs.

The line was tested across the groups in the report, with a majority calling it a fair criticism. One male Conservative voter in Redcar said: “Totally agree. People who get put in a home are penalised. It only related to the working class. People who are on handouts, it wouldn’t affect them, the rich, it won’t affect them.”

The report found there was some early evidence of the dementia tax phrase being revived, a critique that proved toxic for Theresa May in 2017, though her plan was based on a significantly different social care model.

Most concerning of all for Johnson is the regional opposition to the plans. More than 80% of voters in the north-east, the region where Johnson won a significant number of Labour heartland seats, said they opposed the plans, as did 74% in the north-west and 79% in Yorkshire and the Humber.

In contrast, those in the south of England where the changes will have a lesser effect were more sanguine, but the change was still opposed by more than half of voters in London and the south-east.

“Most working-class people, the only thing they have worth taxing is their home and if they’re going to sell that for care, they won’t have anything left,” one male Conservative voter told the report.

“I don’t think Boris should have gone back on his pledge. I know we’ve had Covid but this should be a priority. People shouldn’t have to sell their property. They want to leave something to their children,” another female Tory voter said.

Tory MPs have demanded to see an impact assessment for the change which takes in regional disparities. The bill is expected to be amended in the House of Lords, leaving Johnson vulnerable when it returns to the Commons next spring.

More than 60 MPs abstained on the social care change, with several telling the Guardian the prime minister should make changes or risk more voting against it.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Engaged Dancing On Ice star Hamish Gaman sparks fakery row as he claims he was told to ‘KISS partner Faye Brookes'

AXED Dancing On Ice star Hamish Gaman has claimed he was asked to KISS Faye Brookes on the show last year despite being engaged to fiancée Amelia Humfress. Hamish, 38, ... Read more »

Bitcoin price crash: Crypto plunges by 9% as billions wiped off market

© Getty Images Bitcoin suffered significant losses at the start of 2022 but its price has since shown signs of recovery – Getty Images The cryptocurrency market has seen a ... Read more »

Djokovic-Trainer Vajda kritisiert australische Regierung und Medien

© KEYSTONE/EPA/DEAN LEWINS Die Wegweisung aus Australien hat Novak Djokovic nach Meinung seines Trainers Marian Vajda mental heftig mitgenommen. Der Weltranglisten-Erste sei “sicher psychisch schwer getroffen worden. Das wird ihn ... Read more »

Top 10 highest scoring Championship teams ever

Kevin Keegan is clearly the second-tier cheat code for goalscoring but Fulham are chasing down the only two centurions on this list. With Fulham’s goalscoring exploits looking like breaking every ... Read more »

Blinken vows swift and severe response if Russia attacks Ukraine

© Reuters/POOL U.S. Secretary of State Blinken meets with Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov, in Geneva GENEVA (Reuters) – U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said after talks with Russia’s foreign ... Read more »

Video: Sheridan Smith battles to save her career in gripping new trailer for Channel 5 thriller The Teacher as she stars as school educator accused of drunken sexual encounter with a pupil

Read more »

EU own border chief slams bloc's rules after Macron's attack on UK over Channel crossings

The European Union needs clearer rules on balancing respect for human rights with the need for border protection, the chief of the EU’s Frontex border and coastguard agency said on ... Read more »

Government failures led to Pakistan tourist snow storm deaths, report says

© Reuters/PTV FILE PHOTO: Murree is declared calamity hit area, northeast of the capital Islamabad By Mubasher Bukhari and Asif Shahzad LAHORE, Pakistan (Reuters) – The deaths of 23 tourists ... Read more »

How André Leon Talley spent his final years in White Plains, New York

André Leon Talley, a fashion icon and driving and driving force behind Vogue’s success, spent his last days secluded at home trying to protect himself from the coronavirus that would ... Read more »

Scotland's most expensive and cheapest postcodes to buy first house ranked in new list

The most expensive and cheapest areas to buy a first home in Scotland have been named in a brand new study. Scotland’s housing market is as hot as ever as ... Read more »

Romelu Lukaku is a 'TIMEBOMB' at  Chelsea and no different to the player who left Man United in 2019 despite his success at Inter, claims Jamie Carragher... as he insists Thomas Tuchel's men are better WITHOUT him

Romelu Lukaku has struggled since returning to Chelsea back in the summerThe £97.5m striker has only scored five league goals in his second Blues stintHe also incensed Thomas Tuchel and fans with an explosive Sky Italy interviewJamie Carragher feels the alarm bells surrounding Lukaku are merely on pauseThe Liverpool icon believes Chelsea look more dangerous in attack without him Read more »

Video: Ashley Roberts flashes her legs in a grey skirt and knee-high leather boots while Amanda Holden wraps up in a stone coat as they depart Heart FM

Read more »

Bruno Guimaraes has already revealed why Arsenal have transfer advantage over Juventus

Jurgen Klopp singles out praise for Gabriel Martinelli See more videos What to watch next Conte on Tottenham's top 4 chances Antonio Conte discusses Tottenham's top 4 chances after a ... Read more »

"Might be an easier deal to do than Carlos" - Downie now drops intriguing NUFC transfer hint

Keith Downie insists that Newcastle United may find it easier to sign Jesse Lingard this month than Sevilla centre-back Diego Carlos. The club are attempting to make improvements to their ... Read more »

Ian Wright believes Cristiano Ronaldo's angry strop at Brentford is 'not a good sign for Manchester United' and shares theory that the Red Devils only signed the Portuguese striker to stop him joining arch-rivals City

Cristiano Ronaldo had a strop during Manchester United's 3-1 win at BrentfordThe Portuguese forward was annoyed he was taken off when United were 2-0 upIan Wright believes Ronaldo's sulkiness is 'not a good sign' for the Red DevilsWright says he expects that behaviour from a youngster - not a 36-year-old star  Read more »

Tom Brady, the Rams and the ultimate NFL gamble

Tom Brady and the Tampa Bay Buccaneers welcome the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday for a place in the NFC Championship. It’s a meeting between a franchise with a hubristic ... Read more »

Inspired by Just Like That? Here's where to buy your own name necklace like Carrie

HAVE you been watching Just Like Thats? The Sex And The City spin off is finally on our screens. And with the return of the hit series And Just Like ... Read more »

Video: Russia must choose between 'path of diplomacy' and path of 'conflict and condemnation' in Ukraine, US says following talks in Geneva, after Moscow accused NATO of stirring up invasion 'hysteria'

Read more »

'I think that will happen' - Phil Hay drops big Raphinha claim at Leeds

Phil Hay has been speaking about where contract talks are at between Leeds United and Raphinha. © Provided by This is Futbol Check out the latest news coming out of ... Read more »

BMW X5 M (2022) zeigt seine schlankeren Scheinwerfer

© Hersteller 2023 BMW X5 M facelift spy photo Seit fast einem Jahr haben unsere Erlkönigfotografen wir das Facelift des X5 M im Visier, doch BMW ist noch immer ... Read more »

Middlesbrough player closing in on Charlton transfer move

© Provided by Football League World FA Cup – Third Round – Brentford v Middlesbrough Charlton Athletic have agreed a deal to sign Middlesbrough attacking midfielder Marcus Browne on a ... Read more »

Google legt Einspruch gegen 2,42-Milliarden-Strafe beim EuGH ein

© KEYSTONE/AP/Alastair Grant Der Rechtsstreit um eine Wettbewerbsstrafe in Höhe von 2,42 Milliarden Euro gegen Google kommt vor das höchste Gericht der Europäischen Union. Der Tech-Gigant hat eigenen Angaben zufolge ... Read more »

No. 1 recruit Travis Hunter, Texas A&M, Notre Dame commits to show skills in Polynesian Bowl

© Provided by Sporting News Texas A&M fans will get a chance to see some of the reasons why the Aggies earned the No. 1 recruiting class in the country ... Read more »

Nicolas Pepe to regain Arsenal fans' love by playing key role in stealing Tottenham's Serie A transfer

Nicolas Pepe can win the admiration from Arsenal fans again by taking up the agent role to steal Franck Kessie from the hands of Spurs. According to the Telegraph, Tottenham ... Read more »

My tumour was in a really awkward place but they managed to save my bottom, says brave Adele Roberts amid cancer battle

ADELE Roberts has opened up about her “shock” cancer diagnosis that meant doctors almost saw her “lose her bottom”. The Radio 1 DJ told Good Morning Britain hosts Kate Garraway ... Read more »

How JJ Redick's Podcasting Career Took Off

© Provided by Sports Illustrated After officially retiring before the season, Redick opens up about his new career, the relationship between athletes and the media and more. View the original ... Read more »

Höherer Steuerabzug für extern betreute Kinder ab 2023

© KEYSTONE/DPA zb/WALTRAUD GRUBITZSCH Für externe Kinder-Betreuungskosten können Eltern ab dem Jahr 2023 bis zu 25’000 Franken pro Kind von der direkten Bundessteuer abziehen. Der Bundesrat setzt das entsprechend abgeänderte ... Read more »

Update emerges in Luton Town’s transfer pursuit of Newcastle United midfielder

© Provided by Football League World Premier League – Newcastle United v Tottenham Hotspur Luton Town’s lack of transfer activity this January is credit to the recruitment work that Nathan ... Read more »

Crystal Palace XI vs Liverpool: Predicted lineup, team news, injury and Covid latest for Premier League

© ES Composite CrystalPalacePredictedXIManagerv1.jpg Crystal Palace boss Patrick Vieira must decide whether to stick with derby hero Jack Butland or reintroduce Vicente Guaita in between the posts for Sunday’s game ... Read more »

Paratici in talks: 'Really special' Spurs talent could now leave N17 within 48 hours

© Provided by Transfer Tavern 2021-11-21T165444Z_1847217395_UP1EHBL1AZ7OI_RTRMADP_3_SOCCER-ENGLAND-TOT-LEE-REPORT Tottenham director of football Fabio Paratici will give an answer to AC Milan over a move for Japhet Tanganga ‘this weekend’. The Lowdown: Tanganga ... Read more »

Kieran Lee starts: The predicted Bolton Wanderers XI to face Shrewsbury on Saturday

Bolton haven’t been in the best form as of late but after a 2-0 victory over Ipswich in their last game, they will be desperate to extend that run of ... Read more »

Manchester United issue statement after Victor Lindelof's house broken into while he played at Brentford

Victor Lindelof’s wife, Maja, has confirmed that their house was broken into on Wednesday night as her husband played for Manchester United in London. The Sweden international was in action ... Read more »

Biden, Putin might meet to resolve standoff over Ukraine, Blinken says

On Location: January 20, 2022 See more videos What to watch next 19-year-old breaks record of youngest woman to fly solo around the world 19-year-old breaks record of youngest woman ... Read more »

Sources: Blackpool, Sunderland and Barnsley among clubs keen on Stoke City player

© Provided by Football League World Tashan Oakley-Boothe A number of clubs are keen on Stoke City youngster Tashan Oakley-Boothe this January transfer window with him potentially available for a ... Read more »

Michigan GOP co-chair said Trump campaign encouraged efforts to give him state's electoral votes

Michigan Republican Party co-chair Meshawn Maddock said at a recent event that former President Donald Trump’s campaign encouraged the effort by Republicans in Michigan to submit a document saying Michigan’s ... Read more »

Two in three drivers could be breaking the law on how far they can see number plates

Millions of drivers are unaware of the minimum eyesight requirements for driving – but it could mean points, a penalty fine and potentially prosecution if your vision is found to ... Read more »

Bitcoin billionaire Mike Novogratz says plunging crypto will have a hard time rallying until stocks find a base

© Provided by Business Insider Mike Novogratz. Bryan Bedder/Getty Images for Hudson River Park Mike Novogratz said cryptocurrencies will struggle to pull out of their sell-off if stocks keep falling. ... Read more »

Sanditon releases trailer for season two - but fans have same complaint

It feels like it’s been forever since we last visited the seaside resort of Sanditon. However, the trailer for the show’s much-anticipated second season has just been released, meaning the ... Read more »

Win an iPhone 13 Pro and stream the best shows with the Mirror Bingeworthy newsletter!

If the pandemic has given us anything, it’s a bit of a binge-watching addiction. From Tiger King back at the start of the first lockdown (remember Joe Exotic?) to Amazon ... Read more »

Could two of New Zealand's most iconic trains hit the buffers?

Fears are growing among rail travellers that two of New Zealand’s iconic long-distance train services have been permanently axed. © Great Journeys of New Zealand Final departure? Coastal Pacific train ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic