TikTok-ers Helped Find Gabby Petito. If She Had Been a BIPOC, Would She Still Be Missing?

© Octavio Jones

“Not to sound disrespectful, but I can’t wait for the Netflix series,” a commenter wrote on a TikTok video that analyzed Gabby Petito’s Instagram for clues about her disappearance. Petito’s story has captivated America: Attractive 22-year-old travel blogger goes missing, her fiancé refuses to talk, he goes missing too, investigators find what they believe is her body in a national park.

It’s a nightmare. And while most of us have been following along from a respectable distance, a subset of women on TikTok have decided to treat it like an interactive whodunit. “This is like watching true crime on Netflix, but in real time,” a commenter wrote on a video discussing Instagram posts by Brian Laundrie, Petito’s fiancé.

On TikTok, #GabbyPetito has more than 500 million views. Countless people have flocked to Petito’s and her fiancé Brian Laundrie’s Instagrams to search for clues and leave long, ardent comments. Accounts that have turned themselves into Petito content mills have exponentially grown in followers. These at-home investigations bring together the aesthetics of Nancy Drew, memes, and pastel educational infographics. “Not to go all Elle Woods but Gabby Petito doesn’t have her roots done on ig pics of the parks but her has fresh blonde in the most recent pic aka it’s an old picture,” a woman tweeted, garnering tens of thousands of reactions.

It’s tempting to pronounce this insensitive, or say that it undermines the serious investigation of Petito’s and Laundrie’s disappearances. But social media’s penetration into our lives can rarely be so neatly simplified. Some of these content creators are monetizing a tragedy, but the reality is that some of them were instrumental in finding the body and narrowing the search for Laundrie.

The New York Times reports that a YouTuber couple, Kyle and Jenn Bethune, realized they had been traveling and making content in Bridger-Teton National Forest around the same time as Petito and Laundrie. Jenn found shots of Petito’s van in their YouTube footage and reported it to the FBI. The couple also uploaded the video about finding the van to YouTube. And through that video’s popularity, Bethune connected with Petito’s mother—the Bethunes had also lost a child, and the two cried together, Kyle Bethune told the Times. On Sunday investigators found what they believe is Petito’s body near the place where the Bethune’s video had located the van.

Another crack in the case: A woman named Miranda Baker saw Laundrie’s image on TikTok and realized that she and her boyfriend had picked him up hitchhiking after Petito’s disappearance. She contacted the authorities, and shared her own story on TikTok. The line between entertainment and evidence has never been less clear. Giving the morass of social media content about Petito a quick scan, most of it seems to come from a place of compassion, not just morbid curiosity. “Anyone else cry even tho they didn’t know her? I’m so sad,” one popular comment reads, on a TikTok announcing the news that Petito’s body had been found. Many of the responses are just prayers.

But what is it about Gabby Petito that’s captured the public imagination in a way that hasn’t been matched by interest in, say, Dulce Maria Alavez, a five-year-old who went missing this time two years ago while playing in a park in New Jersey? Or Mary Johnson, a 31-year-old woman who was reported missing last December on the Tulalip Reservation in Washington State? It’s what journalist Gwen Ifill called “missing white woman syndrome.” That’s the phrase she coined to describe the crazed public attention on cases like those of Natalee Holloway or Elizabeth Smart, and utter indifference to nonwhite girls and women who disappear.

It’s not that crazy that we’re invested in a tragic, highly visible news story. But the frenzied focus on Petito—when hundreds of thousands of missing person reports are filed in the United States every year, and around 17,000 remain unresolved—is startling. It reveals a horrifying paradigm when it comes to the way the public processes violence against women. When white women die under mysterious circumstances—think JonBenét Ramsey, Kitty Genovese, Sharon Tate—they are turned, gruesomely, into entertainment. But when women of color, especially Black, trans, and indigenous women die or are killed, their stories are largely ignored.

Activists and journalists have gently pointed out that at least 710 Indigenous people went missing in Wyoming in the last decade, the same state where Petito’s body was apparently found. Eighty-five percent were children. The vast majority were girls. They deserve our tears, anger, and clicks too. If you’re a white woman who gets defensive over the phrase “white feminism,” consider the response to Petito. It’s never a mistake to feel compassion for a stranger, or to pay attention to the overwhelming violence that women face from men. But the way people reacted to Petito’s story—the way they put aside their regular lives to help search for her, the way they felt pain for her and her family—it feels like a kind of white woman sisterhood.

Our grief is real. I felt a stab of shared heartbreak when I searched Petito’s name on YouTube and saw that one of the top recommended search terms is “Gabby Petito found alive.” We wanted so badly to see her safe. We have enough reservoirs of empathy to share with others too.

Jenny Singer is a staff writer for Glamour. You can follow her on Twitter. 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Kim Seon Ho's ex-girlfriend issues apology; to take legal action against death threats

© Provided by PEP.ph Nag-issue rin ng apology ang ex-girlfriend ni Kim Seon Ho ilang oras maglabas ng kanyang official statement ang Hometown Cha Cha actor kaugnay ng kontrobersiyang kinasasangkutan ... Read more »

Hulu Just Dropped 'The Great' Season 2 Trailer and It's Epic

Huzzah! The Great is returning for season 2. After the satirical comedy drama packed a punch with its season 1 debut in May 2020, Hulu green lit the series for ... Read more »

How To Watch the 2021 Gotham Awards Nominations

© Courtesy of the Gotham Awards The Gotham Film & Media Institute will announce nominations for the Gotham Awards on Thursday at 7:00 a.m. PT. The award show will take ... Read more »

K-Pop's TOMORROW X TOGETHER 'Add Their Own Flair' to The Kid Laroi and Justin Bieber's 'Stay'

“Stay” has become one of the biggest songs worldwide — and TOMORROW X TOGETHER wanted a part of it! On Tuesday, the K-Pop group’s Yeonjun and Taehyun debuted a cover ... Read more »

Dupont's New Clubstaurant Serves Gold-Garnished Steaks Under a Crystal Chandelier

© Sau/Courtesy of The Mayflower Club A gold leaf-encrusted strip steak at The Mayflower Club arrives atop a bed of potato puree. A revived nightlife scene in Dupont Circle will ... Read more »

Weihnachtsgeschenk für den Freund gesucht? Das sind die 44 besten Geschenkideen für die bessere Hälfte!

© Getty Images Weihnachtsgeschenk für den Freund: 44 coole Geschenkideen für Männer & Männer können, was Geschenke angeht, ein bisschen kompliziert sein – entweder haben sie schon alles oder sie ... Read more »

I was left ‘screaming in pain from pus-filled spider bite' – then a maggot crawled out

The TikTok user was horrified to see the “worm” emerging from her back. Getty Images/iStockphoto A woman was left “screaming in pain” from a pus-filled pimple doctors initially dismissed as ... Read more »

Fact check: Are smokers at less risk for contracting the coronavirus?

The claim: Nicotine substitutes could have a positive effect in fighting COVID-19 Amid coronavirus news, claims have surfaced that nicotine could contribute to preventing people from contracting COVID-19. This followed ... Read more »

Destiny 2 players will have to pay extra for Witch Queen's new dungeons

© Image: Bungie The new dungeons coming as part of Destiny 2’s upcoming The Witch Queen expansion won’t be included in the Standard Edition or Season Pass. They will only ... Read more »

Brew Your Own Spooky Vibes With This Boiling Witch's Cauldron DIY

<figure role="img" aria-label="SLIDE 2 of 6, You can approach this DIY two different ways. The first method involves a diffuser, which will give off a steam effect when you place ... Read more »

Fox News host Neil Cavuto has Covid, but network still hasn't told viewers why he's not on air

© Getty Neil Cavuto is an anchor on Fox News and Fox Business – Getty Fox News host Neil Cavuto has contracted the coronavirus, he says, and credits his Covid ... Read more »

New ‘Darna' Iza Calzado joins other sheroes in championing Financial Literacy for Women

Actress Iza Calzado recently joined other InLife Sheroes in encouraging Filipino women to be financially empowered. Set to reprise the role of the mature Darna in the latest adaptation of ... Read more »

Sen. Bato dela Rosa will support the ABS-CBN franchise if the network's issues are addressed properly

Presidential candidate Bato dela Rosa admitted that he is willing to support ABS-CBN’s bid for a franchise if issues thrown at the network are appropriately addressed. © Provided by LionhearTV ... Read more »

Charlie Dizon, Dimples Romana, Jake Cuenca, and Joshua Garcia headline new show on controversial videos ‘Viral Scandal'

Four of the country’s sought-after actors of their generation Charlie Dizon, Dimples Romana, Jake Cuenca, and Joshua Garcia star in ABS-CBN Entertainment’s latest series exploring the spread of controversial videos, ... Read more »

WATCH: Jamie Dornan and Caitriona Balfe Are 'Living in a Civil War' in Haunting Belfast Trailer

One family is caught in the conflict of 1960s Ireland in the latest trailer for Belfast, a new drama from director Kenneth Branagh. In a new trailer for the upcoming ... Read more »

Diptyque's Holiday Candles Are A Festive Dream

© Provided by Refinery29 The only thing better than a warm, spicy fall candle? A crisp, woody holiday candle. Whether you’re into a freshly baked gingerbread or vanilla vibe or ... Read more »

Mãe de cadete da Escola Naval relata abusos físicos e psicológicos

A mãe de um dos cadetes do primeiro ano da Escola Naval relatou hoje à Lusa que o seu filho sofreu abusos físicos, “mas sobretudo psicológicos”, enquanto frequentou esta instituição, ... Read more »

O truque 'secreto' para retocar a maquilhagem na perfeição

Para um look intacto e imaculado durante mais tempo! © Shutterstock Para um look intacto e imaculado durante mais tempo! Maquilha-se de manhã e a meio da tarde o seu ... Read more »

Benfica vs Bayern Munich: Bayern struggling to break Benfica down

© Photo by Tom Weller/DeFodi Images via Getty Images 30’ — We’re half an hour in and no goals yet. Bayern are really struggling to break down this defense. Kickoff: ... Read more »

Noli de Castro: Is He moving to a TV5's ‘Frontline Pilipinas'?

After leaving the ABS-CBN network and backing out from his senatorial bid, a rumor surfaced that Noli de Castro is transferring to TV5’s newscast, Frontline Pilipinas. © Provided by LionhearTV ... Read more »

These are the 7 tricks I swear by to help my baby sleep 12 hours a night

@caitsjayne4 definitely blessed! #BurberryTB #babyboy #pregnancy #babysleep #sleep #dreamfeed #baby #mumsoftiktok #mum #parents #viral #fypシ #family #teenmom #mom ♬ I GUESS I’M IN LOVE – Clinton Kane Many parents find ... Read more »

Meghan Markle is urging Democratic leaders in Congress to support for paid family and medical leave

© WPA Pool/Getty Images WPA Pool/Getty Images Meghan Markle urged Democratic leaders in a letter Wednesday to support paid family and medical leave. The letter comes as Biden’s paid leave ... Read more »

3 Chinese cousins were adopted by different families in the US. They found each other decades later with 23andMe.

© Netflix Netflix Three cousins were adopted in China separately and moved to the US with their new families. Thanks to 23andMe, the girls were able to reconnect and find ... Read more »

Inaugural Indy Autonomous Challenge Brings 'Shock and Awe' to the Brickyard

© Indy Autonomous Challenge No drivers, no problem for driverless cars on the famed Indianapolis Motor Speedway, with the winner taking home $1 million. On October 23, for the first ... Read more »

TikTok star Tefi Pessoa went viral after saying she accidentally wore her dress incorrectly on the 'Dune' red carpet

© Provided by INSIDER Tefi Pessoa had a wardrobe malfunction at the UK “Dune” premiere. Eamonn M. McCormack/Getty Images Influencer Tefi Pessoa interviewed stars of “Dune” at the film’s UK ... Read more »

Have you read them yet? Nominations NS Audience Award announced

The books Bonus child by Saskia Noort, Derksen by Michel van Egmond and Antoinette Scheulderman, I’m going to live by Lale Gul, Martien by Jan Dijkgraaf, Excited to the finish ... Read more »

Veja como substituir o leite de vaca com 7 opções vegetais

O leite de vaca é consumido por muitas pessoas por conta do seu sabor e por ser uma grande fonte de nutrientes importantes, como o cálcio, por exemplo. Mas algumas ... Read more »

Baby Grace Warrior Poses With a Water Dragon In Cute New Selfie

© MEGA Babies and animals go together like peas in a pod, right? When we see pictures like the one Chandler Powell recently posted on Instagram we tend to agree. ... Read more »

Como consumir pães sem comprometer os resultados da dieta

© Freepik Freepik No café da manhã, em lanches da tarde ou em outras refeições, o pão costuma ser a escolha de muitas pessoas. No entanto, apesar de saboroso, esse ... Read more »

What is the max amount of Power Bombs you can have in Metroid Dread? Answered

© Provided by GamePur The Power Bomb has been one of Samus Aran’s best weapons since it was introduced in Super Metroid, and it’s back for Dread. The Power Bomb ... Read more »

Everton's Calvert-Lewin still sidelined by thigh injury

© Lindsey Parnaby Injury setback: Everton striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin Everton striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin faces an extended spell on the sidelines after the club said Wednesday his recovery from a thigh ... Read more »

Benfica vs Bayern Munich: Kickoff! We're underway!

© Photo by Tom Weller/DeFodi Images via Getty Images Kickoff: We’re underway in Lisbon! One hour until kickoff: We have lineups! Kingsley Coman returns to the XI, while Sabitzer gets ... Read more »

Christian Martinoli y Perro Bermúdez: Narrador imita a cronistas en Tik Tok

© RÉCORD Christian Martinoli en sesión de fotos con RÉCORD TikTok se ha convertido en una ventana muy popular para dar de qué hablar, sin embargo, también una alternativa para ... Read more »

Boots No7 beauty advent calendar returns and is on sale soon

Boots‘ popular No7 advent calendar is making its much anticipated return – and it goes on sale soon. The rise of beauty advent calendars has been steep, with many brands ... Read more »

3 signs you're about to get a bad haircut, according to the longtime hairstylist of Paramore's Hayley Williams

© Lani Parrilla Hayley Williams and Brian O’Connor are the co-founders of hair brand Good Dye Young. Lani Parrilla Hayley Williams and Brian O’Connor are hosting a virtual hair class ... Read more »

Carvajal: “I hope to be in the squad list for El Clasico”

© Photo by Pedro Castillo/Real Madrid via Getty Images Real Madrid right-back Dani Carvajal is edging closer towards making his return from the muscle injury he picked up last month. ... Read more »

13 Only Murders in the Building Gifts Every Arconiac Needs

© Provided by E! News Craig Blankenhorn/Hulu/E! Illustration We independently selected these products because we love them, and we hope you do too. Shop with E! has affiliate relationships, so ... Read more »

Le chili con carne maison, la recette qui met toute la famille d'accord

Quand il s’agit de préparer un repas savoureux et convivial, le chili con carne se classe parmi nos recettes favorites. Petite histoire et recette de cette emblématique spécialité tex-mex. © ... Read more »

Why royal experts say the Queen's forced rest on doctor's orders is 'nothing to be worried about'

Buckingham Palace did their best not to cause any alarm when they announced Queen Elizabeth was taking a few days of forced rest on doctor’s orders. The statement, issued on ... Read more »

Don't Freak Out: Velvet Nap Dresses From Hill House Home Have Dropped

Just when you thought the nap dress craze was over, Hill House Home has pulled a few holiday-themed tricks from up its puff sleeves. Everyone’s favorite pandemic era smocked frock ... Read more »