Three years on, there is a new generation of lockdown sceptics – and they’re rewriting history

three years on, there is a new generation of lockdown sceptics – and they’re rewriting history

Photograph: Andy Rain/EPA

Was the pain worth it? Between March 2020 and March 2021, the UK had three national lockdowns. The goal was to control the spread of Covid-19. Essential businesses were closed, as were schools and universities, and “stay at home” orders meant families and friends were often kept apart. At the time, the government was unenthusiastic about lockdown and many Tories opposed it. Lord Sumption, for example, insisted that if it weren’t for lockdown, people could have “a perfectly normal life.”

Now a new chorus of lockdown sceptics includes people who position themselves on the left, such as the historian Toby Green and his colleague Thomas Fazi. They have joined the ranks of the Tory right in saying that the public, which strongly supported lockdown and even wanted to go further and faster than the government did, were misled by an apocalyptic campaign by medical professionals overstating the benefits and understating the costs of lockdown.

Commentators on the left and centre, wary of lockdown’s economic costs and sceptical of constant appeals to “the science” when it comes to Covid-19, have expressed sympathy for some of Green and Fazi’s argument around the necessity of lockdowns; though Green and Fazi have gone much further, in arguing that vaccine resistance was rational and that masks don’t work. As David Wallace-Wells documents in the New York Times, this is part of a general pattern of revisionism among journalists, politicians and even some health professionals about Covid-19 and lockdowns.

One problem with assessing the claims about lockdown is that it isn’t a single action,. The catch-all term “lockdown” permits a certain muddying of the waters, as when a “meta-analysis” carried out by a trio of anti-lockdown economists, led by Steve Hanke of the libertarian, Koch-funded Cato Institute, included such things as “mandated face masks” in its definition of lockdown. This study is one of the sources cited by Green, who doesn’t mention the political bias of its authors in his case against lockdowns.

Nonetheless, more serious studies find that lockdown succeeded on its own terms. For example, the early epidemiological studies of China’s lockdown found that it reduced the growth of cases and increased the doubling time of infections. An early cross-country analysis of lockdown found similar benefits. A study of lockdowns from 41 countries in the journal Science by a team of statisticians found that on average, every single non-pharmaceutical intervention (NPI) reduced infections. There were similar findings in Scandinavia. In the UK, a study found that lockdown reduced Covid-19 deaths by 86%. A recent study in England found that roughly 20,000 lives would have been saved had the first lockdown been introduced just a week earlier.

Such findings are, of course, contested. A study by a group of economists in Chile suggested that most of the decline in infections was due to voluntary behaviour. And there was a high degree of uncertainty about the extent of the benefits ascertained by the Science study. Nor would making the epidemiological case prove that lockdowns were justified, as the costs could still be greater than the gains.

After all, the costs of lockdown were enormous. The immediate economic crunch was the worst since 1709, and threatened severe industrial scarring. Although government interventions forestalled the worst of it, the cost was enormous: up to £410bn. And according to one study, depression and anxiety tripled during the peak of the first lockdown.

However, the arguments made by lockdown sceptics don’t help anyone seriously committed to working through the trade-offs, because they consistently misstate the facts in order to minimise the disease. For example, Green and Fazi’s book, The Covid Consensus, claims that the average age of death for Covid-19 was higher than average life expectancy. The implication, which is widespread among lockdown sceptics, is that most of those who died were close to death anyway. But the Office for National Statistics tells us that the average age of death from Covid-19 was much lower than for flu or pneumonia. According to the Health Foundation, ONS data shows that each of the 146,000 people who died with Covid-19 in the first year of the pandemic lost an average of 10.2 years of life: a total of 1.4m years of life.

While minimising the risks of Covid-19, lockdown sceptics also tend to indiscriminately ascribe all the economic consequences of Covid-19 to lockdown. But an early study in Scandinavian countries suggested that such restrictions were only responsible for a small share of the drop in consumer spending. The effect of voluntary social distancing was a significant contributor to the fall in growth. For example, a Cambridge University study found almost no difference between the economic effects of mandatory and voluntary social distancing.

More alarming is the apocalyptic tone of some of the claims being made. For instance, Green and Fazi claim that vaccine resisters have been discriminated against in a manner unheard of since fascism. A few years ago, this sort of boilerplate comparing Covid-19 responses to totalitarianism was the province of paranoid groupuscules like the White Rose, grotesquely named after an anti-Nazi resistance movement, and a few dull Spectator columnists. For such moral idiocy to be packaged for a leftwing audience is bizarre.

All of this is extremely odd. The costs of lockdown were severe. A case could in principle be made that they were too much. However, the value judgment that most people made was that suspending capitalism for a while, even at some cost to their income, social lives and mental health, was a good thing. That should infuriate the right, and their backlash is understandable. Why it should drive those ostensibly on the left to such gross hyperbole and travesty of the facts is something more of a mystery.

Richard Seymour is a political activist and author; his latest book is The Twittering Machine

News Related


Question Time: Tory Minister Lee Rowley forgets Rishi Sunak’s five Conservative pledges

Tory minister Lee Rowley struggled to name all five of Rishi Sunak’s pledges when he was put on the spot during a Question Time debate on Thursday night. Prompted by ... Read more »

One of the world's shortest Pride marches will take place on a housing estate

Batt Close Pride is one of the shortest pride marches in the world (Picture: PA) A housing estate is preparing for one of the world’s shortest pride marches – measuring ... Read more »

Teenager killed in horror ambulance crash following police chase named as tributes pour in

Saul Cookson Tributes have poured in for a boy who died while being followed by police yesterday. Saul Cookson, 15, was named locally early this morning after he crashed into ... Read more »

Gay man receives homophobic death threats vowing to ‘end' him after moving neighbour's bin

Joshua Val Martin received death threat A gay man has received homophobic death threats which vowed to “end” and “destroy” him after moving his neighbour’s bin. Joshua ‘Josh’ Val Martin ... Read more »

Garry Ringrose marries Ellen Beirne in big week for Irish rugby weddings

It’s been a huge week for Irish rugby as three sportsmen have tied the knot across three countries, with plenty of the team jetting from place to place to celebrate. ... Read more »

'Sunak set him up!' Woman breaks down in tears over Boris quitting during GB News video

Man speaks about Boris Johnson resignation A woman has broken down in tears in a dramatic video following Boris Johnson’s resignation as MP – claiming “Rishi Sunak set him up”. ... Read more »

Tributes paid to Cork star Teddy McCarthy at funeral – ‘a humble and kind man who never sought the limelight’

The deep admiration and respect felt for GAA and Cork legend Teddy McCarthy across the country was laid bare at his funeral mass in St Joseph’s Church in Springhill today. ... Read more »

UK to start charging Irish tourists for entry from 2024

Planning on visiting the UK? Well, prepare to get your wallet out as you’ll soon have to pay for the privilege. It’s been revealed that Britain is following the US ... Read more »

Harry Redknapp: ‘We’re in trouble’ if England does not win Soccer Aid

Former professional football manager Harry Redknapp has said “we’re in trouble” if the England team cannot win this year’s Soccer Aid match. Soccer Aid is a yearly football event with ... Read more »

Damien Duff says exciting times are ahead after Shels takeover and reveals one ‘big player’ is set for new deal

Shels manager Damien Duff Shelbourne manager Damien Duff says the takeover by Hull City owner Acun Ilicali makes the club a more exciting place to be. Following yesterday’s announcement that ... Read more »

Gentleman Thomas Clarke donated so much to the Dundalk community

Thomas (Tom) Clarke 1951-2022 The death has occurred of Thomas (Tom) Clarke, ‘Belver,’ Avenue Road, Dundalk, peacefully at his home on 12 December 2022. Thomas was a much loved, and ... Read more »

Labor unions aren’t “booming.” They’re dying.

Striking academic workers at the University of California, Los Angeles in November 2022. Every once in a while, reporters see a few successful unionization drives in the US, like at ... Read more »

‘Backpack hero’ Henri (24) praised for fending off French playground attacker

A 24-year-old Catholic pilgrim on a tour of France’s cathedrals has been hailed as a national hero after using his rucksack to take on a Syrian knifeman. The frenzied stabbing ... Read more »

One of two giant ducks in Hong Kong’s Victoria Harbour deflates

One of the two giant inflatable ducks floating in Hong Kong’s Victoria Harbour deflated on Saturday, just a day after they were unveiled to revellers. Crowds of residents and tourists ... Read more »

Ireland rugby international Jean Kleyn named in South Africa squad

Munster’s Jean Kleyn has been named in the 40 man South African preliminary squad for the Rugby Championship which kicks off in a month. Having been deemed unlucky to miss ... Read more »

Fr Clement MacMánuis of Dundalk could be described as a hibernophile

Fr Clement MacMánuis C.Ss.R. A hibernophile is a word seldom used in reference to a person, but in the case of Fr. Clement MacMánuis, C.Ss.R. who died last week at ... Read more »

Strange, life-like doll destined for the dumpster turned out to be rare antique that sold for $66,000 at auction

Kammer & Reinhardt antique doll. Vectis Auctions Ltd. A doll on the verge of being thrown away was sold for more than $60,000 at auction earlier this week. The doll ... Read more »

'I no longer work here, remember?': Employee's two-week notice rejected, asked to leave immediately but still help with transition, she claps back

Bad bosses can’t have their cake and eat it too! This is a classic example of employers making someone’s transition infinitely harder than it needed to be. This thread was ... Read more »

Trump's Former National Security Chief Says Ex-President Did 'Enormous Damage' To US, Republican Party

Trump’s Former National Security Chief Says Ex-President Did ‘Enormous Damage’ To US, Republican Party Donald Trump’s National Security Adviser, John Bolton, said the former president did ‘enormous damage’ to the country ... Read more »

Man pushes partner's head down toilet after downing three litres of wine together

A balding man with a cigarette and a striped jumper An angry boyfriend pushed his partner’s head into the toilet after she threw a dirty loo brush at him during ... Read more »

'Their relationship fizzled out' Friends of Taylor Swift and Matty Healy are not surprised it's over

It was a match that no one saw coming and a split that certainly has taken us by surprise as it is to be believed that Taylor Swift and Matty ... Read more »

Rory McIIroy reacts to Phil Mickleson’s lastest LIV comments

Rory McIlroy LIV The war between Rory Mcllroy and Phil Mickelson continues as Mickelson commented again about playing for the LIV Tour, which Mcllroy didn’t let go. Mickelson bragged that ... Read more »

Britain's Got Talent voting figures revealed as winner Viggo Venn booed at final show

Britain’s Got Talent voting figures have been revealed, which shows winner Viggo Venn bagged the title with a clear advantage despite being booed. The popular ITV show came to an ... Read more »

Shamrock Rovers cruise to victory at Sligo

Rovers stay top. Shamrock Rovers 3 Jessica Farry reports from The Showgrounds SHAMROCK ROVERS CONTINUE to lead the way at the table after a comprehensive 3-0 win over Sligo Rovers ... Read more »

Prince Andrew laughs as he gets stuck behind an 'oblivious' dog walker

andrew Prince Andrew was on a drive around when he appeared to get stuck behind a dog walker, who was clearly “oblivious” that she was blocking the Duke of York ... Read more »

Humans may only have two years before AI systems become too powerful to control, Sunak’s tech chief warns

The human race may only have two years left to tame advanced artificial intelligence systems before they become too powerful to control, Rishi Sunak’s chief adviser on the technology has ... Read more »

Apple announces iOS 17

iOS 17 is official. Apple’s iOS 17 is official, making its debut on WWDC 2023’s keynote stage. Highlights include redesigned contact cards and live voicemail. Your contact book is getting ... Read more »

Nearly 16,000 Ukrainian pupils signed up in Irish schools as Ireland has one of highest rates of enrolment

The number of Ukrainian pupils in Irish schools continues to rise, with 15,589 enrolled last month. In Europe, Ireland has one of the highest rates of enrolment for students who ... Read more »

Dannii Minogue to ‘play Cupid again’ on new BBC Three show I Kissed A Girl

Dannii Minogue will be “playing Cupid again” as host of new BBC Three dating show I Kissed A Girl. The Australian singer, sister of Kylie, announced the opening of applications ... Read more »

An internal Twitter document reportedly shows ad revenue down 59%, casting doubt on Elon Musk's statement that 'almost all advertisers have come back'

Advertising revenue is down at Twitter, according to internal documents obtained by The New York Times. Susan Walsh/AP Internal Twitter documents show the platform’s ad revenue down 59% year-over-year, The ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự