‘This should not be rushed': expansion of Hong Kong discrimination laws to cover mainland Chinese must be balanced, experts say

Asia's Tech News Daily

The government has proposed expanding anti-discrimination laws to offer protections to mainland Chinese. Photo: Bloomberg

A proposed expansion of Hong Kong’s anti-discrimination laws to give mainland Chinese people protected status – recently revived after years of lobbying – must be narrow in scope, legal experts have warned, lest the changes chip away at freedom of expression.

The government should also adhere to concrete principles laid down in past court cases in formulating any changes, they added, despite officials insisting such protections are desperately needed and in line with evolving international human rights law.

“This should not be rushed, as it is important to get the balance with freedom of speech right, adopting international standards,” said human rights lawyer Mark Daly.

“There are also concerns that in the present context, the government is already using laws to stifle freedom of expression, which is not being protected adequately in legislation or by judicial interpretation,” he added, alluding to the Beijing-imposed national security law introduced in June last year.

© Provided by South China Morning Post Erick Tsang unveiled plans to expand local anti-discrimination laws at a Legco meeting on Monday. Photo: May Tse

The calls for caution came after Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Erick Tsang Kwok-wai on Monday unveiled a time frame at the Legislative Council for implementing new protections for mainlanders, something long sought by the city’s pro-establishment camp.

Hong Kong has four anti-discrimination ordinances in place, including one that offers protection on the basis of race. However, that does not cover the kinds of discrimination and slurs sometimes directed by the city’s residents at their compatriots from across the border.

During a session on Monday, Tsang said that his bureau would come up with a legislative blueprint before the current government’s term ends in June next year. Once that was completed, he said, the next government was expected to move forward swiftly with the legislative process.

Kelley Loper, an associate professor who specialises in equality law at the University of Hong Kong, said discrimination against people from the mainland was “well documented” in the city.

“In fact, international human rights bodies have called on the Hong Kong government on several occasions to prohibit such discrimination within our existing anti-discrimination laws,” she said.

The United Nations’ Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, she noted, had recommended including “immigration status” as grounds for discrimination under the law.

The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, meanwhile, was quite explicit in a 2005 report on Hong Kong, saying: “The committee is concerned that in the proposed racial discrimination law, the protection it affords will not cover migrants from the mainland despite the widespread de jure and de facto discrimination against them on the basis of their origin.”

Despite the government’s recent emphasis on greater cross-border integration, some Hongkongers have long had an uneasy relationship with their mainland counterparts.

Entrenched political differences fed into a localist movement that sprang up in 2015 to champion Hong Kong identity and autonomy. That movement has both fuelled and been fuelled by cultural and economic resentments that have seen local residents protest against the impacts of mainland tourists and cross-border parallel traders, whom they blame for congestion and a higher cost of living.

The tensions reached new heights during the 2019 anti-government unrest, when black-clad protesters on various occasions assaulted mainlanders perceived as sympathetic to, or even spies for, Beijing. Certain businesses that supported the cause also refused to serve mainland customers.

© Provided by South China Morning Post A mainland Chinese man (centre) who was harassed and tied up by protesters at Hong Kong International Airport who suspected he was a spy. Photo: Sam Tsang

“Locusts” and “communist thieves” are among the derogatory terms hurled at mainlanders in Hong Kong, as pro-establishment lawmaker Regina Ip Lau Suk-yee noted on Monday while grilling Tsang about his progress on the legislation.

A spokesman from the Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Bureau on Tuesday said it did not have a definitive view on the scope and content of the legislative proposals yet. “Our goal is to chart the way forward in close consultation with the Equal Opportunities Commission within this term of the government,” he said.

There have been suggestions that the amendments should grant police new powers to conduct investigations, while generally banning comments directed not just at individuals, but at larger groups. Current discrimination laws in Hong Kong are largely civil in nature, allowing aggrieved individuals to sue for damages.

HKU’s Loper said that if authorities intended to turn any discriminatory act into a criminal offence, a high threshold requiring proof of serious vilification or hate speech would be needed.

“Most anti-discrimination laws protect individuals rather than groups,” she added.

Law lecturer Darcy Davison-Roberts, Loper’s colleague at HKU, noted that the Race Discrimination Ordinance already gave police the power to investigate in serious cases. The offence of “serious vilification” is punishable by up to two years in prison, though no one has ever been successfully prosecuted under law.

Davison-Roberts also pointed out that the ordinance had been criticised in the past for its limited definition of “race” – not to mention for exempting the government from its provisions. Other jurisdictions, such as New Zealand, Britain and Australia had already broadened their definitions to include nationality and residency status, for instance.

“The expansion of the definition of race to be more inclusive can only be seen as beneficial and in line with the objectives of anti-discrimination legislation more broadly,” she said.

Human rights lawyer Patricia Ho Pui-chi, meanwhile, said she hoped the expansion in scope would benefit other marginalised groups as well.

“The public have for some time been concerned about racial profiling that can be meted out by service providers, landlords, even by the press or by law enforcement. I expect that the government will not be singling out one particular racial group to protect,” she said.

However, for all the good the proposed amendments might do, Davison-Roberts also acknowledged the tightrope such legislation must walk.

“The right to free speech is fundamental and vital to a vibrant and open society. The right to be treated equally and without prejudice is also fundamental and thus, the tension,” she said.

“Where does one right end and the other begin? The answer is, we attempt to strike a fine balance and ensure that any restriction on free speech or equality rights are proportionate and justifiable. Once speech strays into hate speech or seeks to incite individuals or groups to engage in criminal activity, the societal interest in limiting it is clear.”

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (www.scmp.com), the leading news media reporting on China and Asia.

Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Bundespressekonferenz: Koalitionsvertrag unterzeichnet – Lindner lobt Scholz' Finanzplanung als „vorausschauend“

© dpa Der Koalitionsvertrag ist unterschrieben – die Ampel kann regieren. In der ersten Bundespressekonferenz der Ampel-Spitzen skizziert der FDP-Chef seine Finanzpolitik. Sie soll auf Inflation „Rücksicht nehmen“. Aber auch ... Read more »

IPL 2022: Harbhajan Singh likely to announce retirement, set to join support staff of major IPL franchise

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | PTI: Former India off-spinner Harbhajan Singh will be seen in a different avatar during next year’s Indian Premier League as a key ... Read more »

2G in allen Hockey-Stadien – ein Zuschauerrückgang ist nicht zu befürchten

© DANIEL TEUSCHER/keystone-sda.ch Die SCL Tigers spielten mit 3G meist vor gut gefüllten Rängen. Wer in den beiden höchsten Hockey-Ligen ins Stadion will, muss geimpft oder genesen sein (2G). Endlich ... Read more »

Noah Okafor, der Aufsteiger des Jahres: «Vom FCB zu Salzburg – die absolut richtige Entscheidung zum absolut richtigen Zeitpunkt»

© Bereitgestellt von Blick «Vom FCB zu Salzburg – die absolut richtige Entscheidung zum absolut richtigen Zeitpunkt» Anfang des Jahres ist noch alles anders. Noah Okafor (21) ist Ergänzungsspieler bei ... Read more »

Frist bis 10. Januar 2022: Jetzt auch Edelweiss mit Impfpflicht für die Crew

Nach der Swiss setzt auch die Schwester-Airline Edelweiss auf eine Impfpflicht bei ihrem fliegenden Personal. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Zürich, Schweiz – 4. Juni 2021: Ein Airbus A320-214 der Edelweiss ... Read more »

January sales could be ‘damp squib' due to supply crisis, experts warn

SHOPPERS could struggle to bag a bargain in the January sales as product shortages could mean retailers back out of the annual event.  The post-Christmas period has traditionally been the ... Read more »

Meghan Markle news latest – Humiliation ‘as Prince Harry snubbed by kid & mistaken for Christmas tree salesman in LA'

PRINCE Charles and son Harry have “barely spoken” in the last eight months and relations between them are “at an all-time low”, The Sun can reveal. The Prince’s personal attacks ... Read more »

Key suspect in Marengo gangland trial extradited to Netherlands

Photo: Despositphotos.com The alleged right-hand man of Ridouan Taghi, the man at the centre of one of the Netherlands’ biggest ever gangland murder trials, has been extradited from Colombia, prosecutors ... Read more »

Hope, sadness as volunteers search for victims of Indonesian volcano

1 / 2Hope, sadness as volunteers search for victims of Indonesian volcanoRescuers use a heavy vehicle during a rescue operation following the eruption of Mount Semeru volcano in Curah Kobokan ... Read more »

Carole Middleton reveals Christmas plans for George, Charlotte and Louis - plus Pippa Middleton's kids too

© Provided by Hello! carole-middleton-christmas-plans The Duchess of Cambridge‘s mother, Carole Middleton, has revealed some of her plans for Christmas this year – and Prince George, Princess Charlotte and Prince ... Read more »

Framed photo of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell kissing in paedo tycoon's Palm Beach mansion, shown to jury

A FRAMED photo of Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein kissing has been shown at her sex trafficking and abuse trial. The 59-year-old socialite is alleged to have “served up” young girls for ... Read more »

Biden and Putin talks as Ukraine tensions rise

© Reuters Vladimir Putin and Joe Biden last met in person in June US President Joe Biden is holding rare talks by video link with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin, ... Read more »

Faith Nketsi addresses cheating allegations

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Local socialite Faith Nketsi recently found her relationship in the spotlight, when rumours of her cheating on her partner surfaced. The reality star took ... Read more »

WATCH: The top Mzansi TikTok food trends for 2021

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) As we wrap up the year, TikTok South Africa has unveiled its 2021 report which takes you back to moments of 2021 that made ... Read more »

Longmont police notes: Dog bite causes serious injuries

Dec. 7—Longmont police responded to the 1900 block of Mountain View Avenue on Saturday in reference to a dog bite. A 35-year-old woman sustained serious injuries from a dog bite. ... Read more »

Michigan school shooting: Administrators had a right to search Ethan Crumbley's backpack but failed to do so

Michigan school shooting: Administrators had a right to search Ethan Crumbley’s backpack but failed to do so Oxford High School officials had the legal right to search shooting suspect Ethan ... Read more »

Gabriella Brooks Breaks Silence On 'Sacred' Relationship With Liam Hemsworth

© Getty Images Liam Hemsworth and Gabriella Brooks have gone ‘Instagram official’ after Chris Hemsworth shared a photo of the couple at a family party. Liam Hemsworth is officially in ... Read more »

Senior police officer appointed to terrorism and gangs role

A new senior officer has taken over Police Scotland’s efforts to tackle terrorism and organised crime, as an assistant chief constable is investigated over a “criminal allegation”. © PA Archive ... Read more »

Gunman kills two people after he was asked to put a mask on in Moscow

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A gunman has killed two people and wounded four after he was reportedly asked to put a face mask on in a public ... Read more »

Wife of former NFL quarterback Cade McNown arrested

Christina McNown, the wife of former UCLA and NFL quarterback Cade McNown, has been arrested for allegedly stealing luxury goods, TMZ reported on Tuesday. Cade and Christina McNown Instagram The ... Read more »

Edu Manzano, Cherry Pie Picache's children, supportive of the two stars' blossoming romance!

Edu Manzano and Cherry Pie Picache’s children have shown their support to the blossoming romance of the two senior stars. © Provided by LionhearTV On December 3, via Kapamilya Chat, ... Read more »

Millions expected to travel this holiday season

If you plan to travel for the holidays, you won’t be alone. FOX 10’s Danielle Miller has some tips to help you get through the airport crowds faster. Read more »

Top producer EQT backs U.S. natural gas exports, calls Warren's criticism "misguided'

© Reuters/BRENDAN MCDERMID Toby Rice, co-founder of Rice Energy group, speaks during an interview in New York (Reuters) – The United States should produce and export more natural gas to ... Read more »

JAKIM rujuk SKMM kes pelakon watak gay

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today JAKIM menasihatkan orang ramai bertenang dan menyerahkan kes pelakon melakonkan watak gay itu kepada pihak berkuasa untuk tindakan lanjut. PETALING JAYA: Jabatan Kemajuan Islam ... Read more »

Holiday Entertaining & Decorating

Lifestyle and parenting expert Sherri French has tips for holiday hosts wanting to throw the perfect party #PaidForContent Read more »

This Jungle Tree House Puts You in the Heart of the Brazilian Rain Forest

There’s a reason this property is a visual treat. Read more »

Air quality panel orders immediate closure of NCR industries not using cleaner fuels

In a stern action against industries, the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) on Tuesday ordered immediate closure of all those NCR industries which have not switched to cleaner fuels ... Read more »

No interim relief be granted to ED officials in local FIR, West Bengal government tells Delhi High Court

The West Bengal government Tuesday told the Delhi High Court that it cannot give an assurance that no precipitative action would be taken against the officers of the Enforcement Directorate ... Read more »

‘We can no longer afford the blackmail that Eskom is too big to fail': Stinging words at Nedlac summit

© Provided by Times Live The belief that Eskom needs to be saved no matter the cost is tantamount to blackmail and hampering the supply of sustainable electricity to the ... Read more »

Take a look inside Jeffrey Epstein's creepy Manhattan lair

Details of the bookshelf in Epstein’s home show his face on a massage figurine. SDNY A photo of Jeffrey Epstein kissing his alleged madam Ghislaine Maxwell was displayed prominently in ... Read more »

UAE: Some private firms to switch to Saturday-Sunday weekend from next year

© Provided by Khaleej Times File photo Some UAE private sector companies on Tuesday announced that they will also be switching their weekends to Saturday-Sunday from next year, in line ... Read more »

Large fire breaks out at two Dubai warehouses

© Provided by The National Firefighters contained a blaze at two warehouses in Deira on Tuesday. Dubai Civil Defence A large fire tore through two warehouses in Dubai on Tuesday ... Read more »

Robert Habeck: from translating English verse to German high office

Photograph: Andreas Gora/EPA Ted Hughes felt the soon-to-be minister for economy and climate was ‘on the same wavelength’ The man who will spend the next four years trying to bring ... Read more »

Mental health and terrorism: more people flagged to authorities have 'mixed, unstable, unclear' views than Islamist ideologies

Shutterstock It is often difficult to make sense of violence, particularly in the wake of a terrorist attack. So it’s perhaps understandable that we reach for labels such as “far-right ... Read more »

Daneri resigning as DA on Dec. 31 with two years left in term; top aide to take over

Erie County District Attorney Jack Daneri, who has held the job as the county's top prosecutor for 12 years, is resigning on Dec. 31. Daneri, 62, appointed to the office ... Read more »

Denmark sees society-wide infection with Omicron variant

Woman waits in line to get a COVID-19 test at a bar in Copenhagen COPENHAGEN (Reuters) – The new Omicron coronavirus variant has spread across Denmark, health authorities said on ... Read more »

Kirsty Gallacher looks glam in a black halterneck jumpsuit

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Kirsty Gallacher cut a glamorous figure as she arrived at the TRIC Christmas charity lunch in London on Tuesday. The TV personality, 45, cut ... Read more »

World stock markets rally as Omicron fears ease – business live

LIVE – Updated at 15:22 © Photograph: Brendan McDermid/Reuters Traders on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange Rolling coverage of the latest economic and financial news. World stock ... Read more »

The world's population is set to decline for the first time in centuries

In the next few decades, for the first time in centuries, the world’s population is forecast to decrease. © Getty Images/iStockphoto iStock-917786082.jpg Currently, the world’s population sits at around 7.8 ... Read more »

Guess who! TV presenter shares childhood photo doing physical culture

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo She’s a veteran journalist and TV presenter. At the beginning of her media career, she accepted a role at the ABC interviewing politicians ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic