‘Thinking of Him’: Looking into universality of Tagore’s friendship with Victoria Ocampo through an Indo-Argentine film​

‘thinking of him’: looking into universality of tagore’s friendship with victoria ocampo through an indo-argentine film​
© Provided by Firstpost ‘Thinking of Him’: Looking into universality of Tagore’s friendship with Victoria Ocampo through an Indo-Argentine film​

Rarely one comes across a biographical cinematic production which explores both the personal life story and explores the meaning and power of ‘ideas’ of the ‘subject’ or the ‘individual. Case of the recent movie, Thinking of Him, an Indo-Argentine production, seamlessly slides between the foreground of a contemporary setting about the search for Rabindranath Tagore’s ideas about education by an Argentine school teacher and the historical background of an episode from his personal life of an encounter with Victoria Ocampo. According to film director Pablo Cesar, this alternating parallel tracks method was to emphasise the universality and timelessness of Tagore and his relationship with Victoria Ocampo.

Thinking of Him is based on the encounter and deep spiritual, platonic friendship between Tagore and Argentine high-society lady Victoria Ocampo. Tagore was the first Asian Nobel laureate, India’s most famous poet, music composer, thinker and philosopher and one of the most revered figures of his time. On the other hand, Ocampo, born in the highest strata of Argentine society, was a dashing, glamorous, intelligent, sensitive, strong-willed Socialite who strode tall amongst the crème de la crème of the Argentine bourgeoisie society. Victoria was known for ruffling feathers of the conservative elites of Buenos Aires with her unconventional, unfeminine and daring mannerisms and was widely scorned and ridiculed at large. There are scenes in the movie where passers-by in the streets of Buenos Aires are admonishing her while she is driving in her vehicle and the personal chambermaid warning her of the consequences in her family life of her conduct.

At a certain stage while living this ‘high’ life, Ocampo discovers Tagore’s poetry and is inexorably drawn toward the magic and mystique of both the person and his poems. This attraction to Tagore’s poetry leads her to yearn for a meeting with the colossus ‘sage philosopher’ himself.

Victor Banerjee plays the role of Tagore in the film and Ocampo is played by Argentine actress Eleonara Wexler. The film is directed by the Argentine film director Pablo Cesar with Suraj Kumar as the co-director/producer from the Indian side with the script being written by Jeronimo Toubes.

The hallowed encounter, as I would call it, finally happened in 1924 in Buenos Aires while Tagore was visiting Latin America and was fatigued from his extensive travels accompanied by his secretary, Elmhurst. At that point in time, Tagore was 63 years old and Ocampo just 34 years, which lent an interesting esoteric dimension to her fascination with the poet. Tagore had christened Victoria as his ‘Bijoya’ since he met her in the twilight era of his life and would address her by this name in his letters and verbal communication. Ocampo very generously arranged for a small retreat in a magnificent splendid villa located on the banks of River Plate in San Isidro with the enchanting view of the river and in a verdant landscape with lots of trees. This is a perfect setting for Tagore who is a lover and worshipper of nature and there is a wonderful scene where he starts admiring the flowers and trees on his arrival at the villa.

The background part of the movie is shot in black-and-white with a genteel, unrushed pace along with a wonderful blend of music composed by Tagore (known as Rabindrasangeet) and a few other soulful melodious tracks. The most poignant of the interplay of music and setting being the scene where the tragic news of Tagore’s demise is announced over the car radio while Ocampo is driving along the bayfront. She has her eyes moist with sorrow, stops her car and lights up a cigarette and contemplates her memories of friendship with Tagore against the backdrop of the vast ocean with the rapturous tunes of a ‘Rabindrasangeet’ being played in the background titled ‘Amar Hrid Majhare…’, which roughly meant: ‘Shall keep you in my heart forever, I shall leave you never…’ — and indeed she kept Tagore in her heart.

In the end, their relationship was mystical and spiritual and as Tagore himself defined in a letter to Ocampo, “this love between you and me is as simple as a song”. I am, however, of the opinion that the music of the film could have been much more eclectic and appealing given the wide repertoire of Tagore’s songs. For instance, there were dramatic scenes like the first highly anticipated meeting between Ocampo and Tagore where the heart-throbbing anxiety could have been better captured through a soul-stirring ‘Rabindrasangeet’.

Victor Banerjee in his role captures the very raison d’etre of the aging, sagacious poet very beautifully and strikingly. The personality of Tagore comes alive through his acting and his role really evokes the charisma of the poet-philosopher of India. Victor is the quintessential Bengali bhadralok (gentleman) actor with his charm, chivalry and elegance along with a deep tenor voice which lends a certain soothing gravitas. He speaks in this movie with his trademark crisp, clear and genteel English accent. Elenora Wexler played a very measured role with understated elegance and sophistication since there was the possibility of exuberance being a glamorous Socialite but her dialogues and expressions remain rather scripted. In my opinion, this lent a certain dignity to her role as a high society patron of arts and culture in Buenos Aires. Her dealing with emotional moments in life with regard to her bond with Tagore was nuanced like hearing the death of her hero.

The film derives its name from a letter Ocampo sent to Tagore’s son after his death where she just wrote, “I am thinking of him”, which again reinforces this moderate style of communication.

While the audience is indulged with all the romantic richness of the Tagore-Ocampo friendship, the foreground is a more prosaic tale of an Argentine teacher, Felix, played by actor Hector Bordoni, travelling to Shantiniketan in India in his quest for answers to a dysfunctional educational system. Shantiniketan was the abode of Tagore and his experimental educational institution which attempted to forge a new sensitive and moral human being deeply rooted in the nature and traditions of India.

Felix is disoriented by the suicide of one of his school students and decides to embark on a personalised journey to find meaning and understanding of education and life. His interest in Tagore is triggered by reading a book on Tagore and his sojourn in San Isidro during his meeting with Ocampo. On his arrival at Shantiniketan, Felix encounters two very competent and smart individuals — Kamali and Prakash — both residents of Shantiniketan and active practitioners of Tagorean ideals and philosophy. In the movie, Felix learns a lot about Tagore’s metaphysics and philosophy through his interactions with both of them.

The roles of Kamali are played by Raima Sen and that of Prakash by Bratin Bandhopadhyay. With Kamali, Felix strikes up a friendship which assists him in his personal journey and in absorbing Tagore’s ideals of life and education. Kamali cajoles Felix to abandon fear and live life ‘full size’ dropping his old inhibitions and fear. There are scenes in the movie where Felix is healed through rituals facilitated by both Kamali and Prakash.

The contemporary part has a certain subtlety and sophistication of emotions at play by Raima Sen, who really strikes out in this section. In her part, she brings forth her sophisticated yet assertive Bengali style while speaking her dialogues. Having watched several of her films, I find this blend interesting. Finally, the movie is a worthwhile watch and an enriching rendition of a glorious episode in the lives of two passionate and aesthetic individuals.

The author is an entrepreneur and independent researcher based in Bengaluru and holds a PhD in Management Studies from Cass Business School, London. He is an Anglosphere enthusiast and celebrates Indian cosmopolitanism. Views expressed are personal.

News Related


Incredible photos show competitors chewing and grimacing at World Nettle Eating Championships

Ouch (Picture: Graham Hunt/BNPS) One of the world’s most bizarre competitions returned this weekend, after a three-year hiatus. Men and women lined up to chew and grimace as they took ... Read more »

Sketchy TikTok ads push high-interest payday loans

A group of secretive TikTok advertisers are using sketchy tactics to push massive loans that experts say could run afoul of deceptive advertising laws, The Post has learned. Some of ... Read more »

At least 20 found dead in South African night club, cause yet unknown

South African police are investigating the deaths of at least 20 people at a nightclub in the coastal town of East London early Sunday morning. It is unclear what led ... Read more »

Where next for Douglas Luiz? AC Milan favourites but English clubs also interested

Douglas Luiz was signed by Dean Smith in 2019 following promotion back to the Premier League. Read more »

Chicago Forecast: Clearing Skies, Breezy Conditions Expected Sunday

Link video: http://nbclim-download.edgesuite.net/Prod/NBCU_LM_VMS_-_WMAQ/142/827/WMAQ_100000021684329__815664.mp4 Sunday will start out on the cloudy and muggy side, but breezy, sunny conditions are expected to develop as the day goes on, making for a great ... Read more »

Newcastle Utd transfer news: Joaquin Correa deal on as Eddie Howe is given green light and bargain fee emerges

© PA Images Joaquin Correa, Inter Milan Eddie Howe’s quest to bring more attacking options to Newcastle reportedly looks set to end with a deal to bring Joaquin Correa to ... Read more »

Clever phishing method bypasses MFA using Microsoft WebView2 apps

A clever, new phishing technique uses Microsoft Edge WebView2 applications to steal victim’s authentication cookies, allowing threat actors to bypass multi-factor authentication when logging into stolen accounts. With the large ... Read more »

Inside the wild parts of Glastonbury you don’t see on TV - 'naughty corner' to secret club

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

Bruised US stock investors brace for more pain in second half of 2022

With US stocks on track to mark their worst first half of the year in more than 50 years, investors are studying a range of metrics to determine whether the ... Read more »

Edinburgh crime news: Here is a round up of all crime and breaking news stories from last week in the Capital and the Lothians

© Edinburgh crime news: Here is a round up of all crime and breaking news stories from last week in th… Monday Police are continuing to investigate an assault with ... Read more »

Iraqi PM Mustafa al-Kadhimi in Iran after MBS visit

© Provided by Al Jazeera Al-Kadhimi (right) met with Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi (left) after travelling to Saudi Arabia and being personally received by Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu excited to embrace 'special' opportunity to play on Wimbledon's Centre Court

Emma Raducanu joins defending champion Novak Djokovic and Andy Murray on Centre Court during the opening day of Wimbledon on Monday. Read more »

Itching for more Sex Education? We've got 7 spiky shows to help you make it through…

Some shows like Sex Education Read more »

You’ve decided it’s time to get a gun safe. What are 3 things to know before you buy?

There’s a difference between gun safes and gun cabinets Read more »

Scorched earth: The climate impact of conflict

Burning wells during the 1991 Gulf War generated over 2% of CO2 emissions that year War exacerbates climate impacts in many ways — even after troops are long gone The ... Read more »

Bundesliga: Hertha Berlin chooses former ultra as president

Former ultra fan Kay Bernstein has been chosen as the club’s new president The Bundesliga club Hertha Berlin elected a former member of the team’s ultra supporters, Kay Bernstein, as ... Read more »

Autobusom za Beograd kreće 77 putnika iz Rima, putnica za Euronews Srbija: Imali smo dve opcije

Ambasador Srbije u Italiji Goran Aleksić izjavio je da će 77 putnika iz Srbije koji u Rimu čekaju zbog otkazivanja jučerašnjeg leta Viz era za Beograd danas u 16.30 sati ... Read more »

Researchers created gene-edited hamsters full of rage in an experiment gone wrong

A group of researchers made gene-edited hamsters that were meant to be less aggressive. The researchers used CRISPR, a gene-editing platform, to remove a gene they believed was responsible for ... Read more »

Man, 20, with mystery illness plans assisted death after heartbreaking 'goodbye' BBQ

A 20-year-old man is pursuing medically assisted dying after years of struggling with chronic pain. Canadian Eric Coulam, from Fort St John, British Columbia, has a medical condition that has ... Read more »

Woman, 21, rushed for lifesaving surgery after Specsavers warn she may have tumour

A young woman who thought she needed glasses was shocked when an optician suspected a brain tumour and doctors sent her for emergency surgery – saying if it had been ... Read more »

Man slams restaurant boss who says workers are 'too comfortable' thanks to his chairs

A man who allows restaurant workers to sit on chairs in his garden during their lunch breaks has criticised the employees' boss for trying to force him to remove the ... Read more »

Pregnant Billie Faiers cradles baby bump as she models swimsuits and bikinis

Mummy Diaries star Billie Faiers has showed off her blossoming baby bump as she modelled her own swimwear brand for InTheStyle. The mum-of-two, 32, who last week shared she is ... Read more »

Emergency a 'black spot' on India's vibrant democracy: PM Modi in Germany

PM Modi (Photo: ANI) Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday said that the emergency imposed 47 years ago is a “black spot” on India's vibrant democracy as he praised the ... Read more »

As rebels bide time in Guwahati, Shiv Sena gears up for legal battle

Maharashtra CM Uddhav Thackeray With dissident Shiv Sena MLAs led by Eknath Shinde staying put in Guwahati for the last five days, the party is preparing for a legal battle ... Read more »

Logan Paul makes "jealous" claim over brother Jake's boxing clash with Tommy Fury

jQuery(function(){ if (typeof jwplayer_load == typeof indefined) { var jwplayer_load = 1; jQuery(window).load(function(){ jQuery(".sc_video_shortcode_jwplayer").each(function(){ var _this = $(this); jQuery.get(jQuery(this).attr("url"), function(data, status){ if (typeof data.split("\n") !== typeof undefined) { var src ... Read more »

I was told to wear a black bra to cure my breast cancer – these kinds of suggestions are dangerous

It turns out, when you get diagnosed with breast cancer, you basically have to do a PhD overnight (Picture: Iyna) In January 2015, I had just finished a workout at ... Read more »

At least 22 young people found dead inside popular South African tavern after school exams

South African authorities are investigating the deaths of at least 22 young people found inside a popular tavern in the coastal town of East London, provincial health officials say. Key ... Read more »

Huge plumes of smoke darken London skyline after Norbury wildfire

A school playing field was swallowed up by a wildfire that charred six hectares of grassland in south London. Plumes of smoke darkened the London skyline for miles around after ... Read more »

¿Dónde están las playas más sucias de California? Esta lista podría sorprenderte

© Proporcionado por LA Times El muelle de Santa Mónica se encuentra entre las playas más sucias de California este año, tras un sorprendente aumento de la contaminación. (Al Seib ... Read more »

UK health services failing south Asian people with dementia, says report

Photograph: Paula Solloway/Alamy Thousands of south Asian people with dementia are being failed by outdated health and care services designed for white British patients, according to an alarming review that ... Read more »

Learn ASL with this highly rated online course, now under $20

Getty Images Learn to speak without saying a word and connect with a brand new community by mastering American Sign Language. The success of the film, “Coda” earlier this year ... Read more »

SNP MP Patrick Grady will sit as independent as Met Police investigate sexual harassment allegations

The Metropolitan Police is investigating an incident which took place at a London pub in 2016 Read more »

Meghan Markle news – Duchess’ image is ‘PLUMMETING’ in the US as ‘bewildered’ fans question why she keeps royal title

MEGHAN Markle's image is 'plummeting' in the US as 'bewildered' fans question why the Duchess keeps her royal title despite 'speaking out so much against the monarchy'. Following a new ... Read more »

IAF receives 56,960 applications under Agnipath scheme

Photo for representation New Delhi: The Indian Air Force (IAF) has received 56,960 applications under the Agnipath recruitment scheme till Sunday, within three days of the registration process getting under ... Read more »

Most popular baby names in Houston and Texas: See the top 10 lists

HOUSTON – “What’s in a name?” Shakespeare once wrote. Apparently a lot. And there are a select few names that have the stuff of magic in them for parents-to-be. Here ... Read more »

These beautiful, heat-loving plants won’t die -- unless you really try -- in your Houston garden

They’re also butterfly magnets that experts recommend Read more »

How John Cornyn and the U.S. Senate defied 26 years of inaction to tackle gun violence

Four senators, including Cornyn, used a distinctive combination of policy expertise, legislative experience and political courage to push past obstacles that had repeatedly stymied previous attempts at compromise. Read more »

LAPD officer killed during training was beaten to death during mob simulation: lawsuit

A Los Angeles police officer was beaten to death by his fellow officers who were simulating a mob attack during a training exercise, his mother claims in a wrongful death ... Read more »

Gujarat Police arrests activist Teesta Setalvad, seeks 14-day custody

Crime branch officials produce social activist Teesta Setalvad at Metropolitan Magistrate Court, in Ahmedabad (Photo: PTI) The Gujarat Police Crime Branch on Sunday arrested Teesta Setalvad in connection with a ... Read more »

Teens risk privacy breach by sharing personal information on social media

Representative image. Photo: Bloomberg Data privacy company Tsaaro, in its latest report on the state of teenager data security in the internet world, highlights that teens are increasingly sharing personal ... Read more »