They Were Also Victims of the Holocaust. Their Fight for Recognition Is Still Ongoing.

they were also victims of the holocaust. their fight for recognition is still ongoing.

A monument to the memory of the Holocaust of the Romani in Poland. Jakub Hałun (CC BY-SA 4.0)

On July 20, 1984, a small group of protesters, many dressed in homemade costumes reminiscent of concentration camp prisoner uniforms, demonstrated against a meeting of the United States Holocaust Memorial Council in Washington. Seen from the hindsight of 2023, when both historical ignorance about the history of the Holocaust and outright Holocaust denial are on the rise in the United States, it might seem reasonable to assume that these protesters against the Holocaust Memorial Council were motivated by far-right ideologies.

But rather than advocating against Holocaust remembrance altogether, these demonstrators were there to call for a more inclusive reckoning with Nazi Germany’s legacy. Carrying signs that read “US Gypsies Demand Representation on Holocaust Memorial Council” and “Why No Gypsy Representatives—Racism Betrays Ideal of Holocaust Memorial Council,” these Romani activists had gathered in Washington to insist that the genocide of Europe’s Roma be commemorated alongside the genocide of Europe’s Jews.

The fact that approximately 6 million Jews were murdered by the Nazi regime during World War II is well-known to educated Americans. Much less well-known are the facts of Roma persecution during World War II. Historians estimate that between 250,000 and 500,000 Romani people were systematically murdered by the German regime, out of a prewar European population of perhaps 1 million.

And yet the large-scale polls designed to measure American knowledge of the Holocaust rarely ask about Roma persecution at all, an omission that points toward the broad ignorance of this major, genocidal chapter in modern history. Not until 1982 did West Germany officially acknowledge that the Roma had been victims of a genocide at all. Against the backdrop of this illiteracy, and of the continued discrimination that Roma faced in Europe during the decades after World War II, those activists converged outside the Holocaust Memorial Council’s meeting in 1984 to demand that the injustices committed against their community not be relegated to a historical footnote, known only to specialist scholars, but that they receive the public commemoration they deserve.

In his new book, Rain of Ash: Roma, Jews, and the Holocaust, historian Ari Joskowicz—a professor at Vanderbilt University and the grandson of Jewish holocaust survivors—provides the first comprehensive account of the complicated, often contradictory, relationships between Jews and Roma during and after their genocides under Nazi Germany. Drawing on exhaustive research from primary sources in several languages, Joskowicz offers a fascinating and often heartbreaking account of the Roma struggle for justice and restitution in the face of persecution. Along the way, he offers insight on vital questions whose relevance extends far beyond the legacy of World War II, as he explores how different victims of the same oppressor can act in solidarity with one another, even as the circumstances of their oppression force them into competition for finite resources and for public recognition of an idealized victimhood.

they were also victims of the holocaust. their fight for recognition is still ongoing.

Princeton University Press

The extreme postwar injustices Joskowicz presents do not make for easy reading and are often infuriating. He describes the 1956 decision by West Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (the entity that was, in that country, analogous to the Supreme Court of the United States), which ruled that Nazi deportations of Roma from Germany to foreign countries and concentration camps before 1943 were not necessarily racially motivated, because it was an established fact that “Gypsies” were “asocial.” (In 1971, delegates at the inaugural World Romani Congress voted unanimously to support a declaration that the word Gypsy is pejorative and that the terms Roma and Romani are preferable. Following Joskowicz’s approach, this review uses that standard contemporary terminology, while putting the word Gypsy in quotation marks when referring to historical usages.)

This court ruling relied on a perverse form of logic to legitimize German persecution of Romani people. Unlike the Nazi mistreatment and genocide of Jews, the West German court claimed, which were caused exclusively by bigotry, Nazi deportations of Roma were at least initially based on reasonable concern over Roma criminality, even if the Nazi response to that criminality was sometimes too extreme. The court failed to consider the obvious truth that this concern over Roma criminality was itself a symptom of bigotry and instead claimed that “Gypsies,” because of their supposed “asocial behavior,” had instigated their own oppression. In doing so, this ruling made it much harder for Roma to receive the compensation, such as financial restitution for stolen property, to which they were entitled.

This was not the only instance Joskowicz discusses of Nazi-era anti-Roma measures being legitimized by postwar European governments. In 1947, the Bavarian parliament unanimously voted to ask the American occupation authorities to build a prison at the site of the Dachau concentration camp “as a facility for the internment and reeducation of work-shy individuals,” a term often used as a euphemism for Roma. The Americans, already disturbed by Bavarian anti-Roma policy, rejected this request. And in France, the administrators of some Roma prison camps kept their inmates incarcerated after the war had ended; “until 1969,” Joskowicz writes, “the French state even maintained the same registration system for so-called nomads that was previously used by … the Vichy regime during the Second World War.” Over and over again, Rain of Ash shows the brutal ways that anti-Roma bigotry continued after the fall of Nazism.

But Rain of Ash also describes the Jews who fought for the rights of those of their fellow victims of the Nazi regime who weren’t Jewish. Kurt May, a German Jewish World War I veteran and lawyer who had survived the war in Palestine and returned to Frankfurt afterward to help victims of Nazism fight for compensation, orchestrated the attempt to overturn the 1956 court ruling that had blamed the Roma for their own victimization. He coordinated a diverse network of both Jewish and non-Jewish lawyers and scholars in order to correct the court’s egregious error, and wrote in a letter, “It relieves my conscience to know that these ‘Gypsies,’ who were hunted down by the Nazis, will finally get their right.”

The great virtue of Joskowicz’s book, alongside the comprehensiveness of its research, is its refusal to reduce any of the weighty issues it discusses to abstractions, or to stray from the complex and often contradictory human experiences at stake. Instead, Joskowicz grounds his account in the lives of the people whose suffering and whose activism animate his scholarship. That letter by May, quoted above, was written to Hans Buchheim, a German historian who used his expertise to demonstrate that Nazi persecution of Roma was motivated essentially by racial animus.

In this, Buchheim acted as an ally to the victims of Nazism. But real human experiences are more complex than simple categories of “victim,” “ally,” and “perpetrator” allow for, as Joskowicz suggests when he notes that Buchheim had served as a Nazi soldier and was close to Reinhard Gehlen, who supported an assassination attempt against Adolf Hitler while also directing the German military’s intelligence operations on its eastern front, where many of the worst massacres and abuses of Jews and Roma took place. As Joskowicz writes, these contradictions are “a living monument to the paradoxes of German attempts to rebuild a democratic society from the ruins of a racist dictatorship with mass appeal.”

Joskowicz treats his Jewish and Roma subjects with as much nuance, insisting that human lives cannot be reduced to neat categories in a hierarchy of persecution and victimhood. He describes instances of violence between Jews and Roma under Nazi occupation, as in Elie Wiesel’s description of a Romani guard at Auschwitz beating Wiesel’s father, and writes movingly of the fact that many Jewish victims at Auschwitz envied the Roma who were incarcerated alongside them, because Auschwitz’s “Gypsy camp” allowed its prisoners to remain with their families.

But the brutal liquidation of the “Gypsy camp,” on the night of Aug. 2, 1944, in which the SS murdered two-thirds of Auschwitz’s Roma inmates and dispersed the rest among other concentration camps, caused many Jews in Auschwitz to shift from seeing Roma as an abstract category of relatively privileged competitors for survival, and to view them instead as fellow victims who deserved empathy and solidarity. Few Jews saw the murder of their Roma fellow inmates on that August night, but a number vividly remembered hearing their screams. “Many Jewish witnesses,” Joskowicz summarizes, “described the night as the worst they experienced in Auschwitz, largely based on the sounds they heard.” Against a system of oppression that functioned in part by pitting Roma and Jews against each other, the tangible encounter with each other’s suffering forced these distinct groups to see each other as allies rather than as competitors.

“We should not presume,” Joskowicz writes, “that people who have experienced oppression or persecution will necessarily have a greater capacity to hear others’ stories of suffering or to feel connected to other victims.” Indeed, his book is full of anecdotes about Holocaust survivors and their descendants whose trauma makes them less receptive, not more, to empathy with other victims of oppression. The hesitancy within the Holocaust Memorial Council to include the Roma genocide fully within their narrative of the Holocaust—the target of that 1984 protest—is just one example of this. But Joskowicz provides even more counterexamples of the ways that different victims of the same oppressor can come together in mutual support.

Though the Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington still does not include Roma experiences in the ways that many survivors and their family members would prefer, it has become one of the world’s preeminent centers for academic research about Roma persecution. Without the archives that the Holocaust Memorial Council has gathered, and the research it supports, much less would be known today about the fate of Romani people under Nazi fascism.

This is the broader lesson Rain of Ash offers, beyond the particulars of its scholarship: supporting others based on abstracted categories of victimhood is much less meaningful than learning about the realities of human experience, injustice, and cruelty. As Joskowicz writes, “empathy without knowledge is fleeting.” He ends his book, after surveying much depressing material, with an inspiring discussion of the 21st-century Roma-Jewish activism and solidarity that has arisen out of a willingness for Romani and Jews to hear each other’s stories, in all their contradiction and complexity.

In 2009 and 2010, when the French government led by Nicolas Sarkozy deported thousands of non-French Romani to Romania and Bulgaria and destroyed dozens of Roma settlements, the Union of French Jewish Students (known by its French acronym, UEJF) joined forces with the umbrella organization of French Romani groups in order to protest this injustice. These joint demonstrations initiated a new era of solidarity, and in 2011 UEJF and its Roma partners organized a shared journey to Holocaust memorial sites in Poland.

Joskowicz writes that, “Unlike their predecessors thirty years ago, Romani activists today have every reason to expect their Jewish counterparts to know something about their struggles and believe in their shared interests. Roma and Jews regularly form alliances that would have made little sense before the Nazi era, and had little traction in the decades immediately after the war.” As far-right and ethnonationalist movements gain power and publicity across the world, such inter-group activism is increasingly urgent. The Roma-Jewish alliances Joskowicz describes present a model of how different groups of victims can meet one another not as competitors for restitution, or for public acknowledgement of marginalization, but rather as allies in the struggle for a more just world.

News Related


Nashville school shooting: Biden condemns 'sick' shooting as woman kills three children and three adults

The female attacker was shot dead by police after a confrontation with officers following the assault at the Covenant School. She was armed with two assault-type rifles and a pistol. Read more »

Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu delays judicial reform plan after mass protests

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday temporarily suspended his controversial judicial reform legislation that has led to mass protests and caused anger across most parts of society, including the military. The plan has ... Read more »

Who's who in the Gwyneth Paltrow ski crash trial

Gwyneth Paltrow is on trial over a 2016 ski accident in Utah involving a retired eye doctor who alleges the collision left him with life-altering injuries. Terry Sanderson, 76, says ... Read more »

2023 Chevy Malibu: Chevrolet Continues to Make the Same Mistake With Its Sedan

Chevrolet has been making the Malibu model for quite some time, and just a few years ago it was known as a good vehicle to buy, especially in the used ... Read more »

Ukraine Videos Shows Deadly ‘Excalibur’ Strike on Russian Fuel Trucks

Ukraine Attack from M777 Social Media Showed Russian Fire Trucks Destroyed in Excalibur Strike – New video footage posted on social media by Ukraine Weapons Tracker (@UAWeapons) showed the destruction ... Read more »

Emotional Dale Earnhardt Jr. Reads Letter to Ken Schrader Thanking Him for Holding the Secrets on the Dark Final Moments of His Father's Life

When Dale Earnhardt Sr. hit the outside wall in turn four on the final lap of the 2001 Daytona 500, most watching initially believed it wasn’t a serious accident. That ... Read more »

Fox News Fires Abby Grossberg, the Producer Who Accused the Network of Coercion

Abby Grossberg had worked for the Fox News host Maria Bartiromo. Fox News Media has fired a producer who last week accused the network of discrimination and of coercing her ... Read more »

Philadelphia water 'safe,' say utilities monitoring Friday night chemical spill

Water utilities along the Delaware River in Pennsylvania and New Jersey continue monitoring a Friday night chemical spill in a river tributary northeast of Philadelphia. The utilities say there’s no risk ... Read more »

Former White House Official Died When Jet Pitched Violently Upward and Downward During Flight: NTSB

The NTSB’s report details that the movement occurred after pilots responded to automated cockpit warnings and switched off the system meant to keep the private aircraft stable Mike Pont/WireImage The ... Read more »

Either the Flames or Jets Will Face the Woe of Missing the Playoffs

It’s likely either the Calgary Flames or Winnipeg Jets will have some big changes to make after missing the NHL playoffs, says Adam Proteau. Axel Jonsson-Fjallby shoots on Jacob Markstrom ... Read more »

Steven Seagal's daughter has first wrestling match as she trains with WWE legend Goldust

Steven Seagal’s daughter Arissa LeBrock is starting her wrestling career (Picture: Rhodes Wrestling Academy/Getty) Steven Seagal and Kelly LeBrock’s daughter Arissa LeBrock has made her wrestling debut after training with ... Read more »

'Our children deserve better': First lady Jill Biden responds to Nashville mass shooting

WASIHNGTON — First lady Jill Biden said “our children deserve better” as she responded to a mass shooting at a Nashville school Monday that killed seven people including three children. “I ... Read more »

Biden Acts to Restrict U.S. Government Use of Spyware

President Biden’s executive order covers only spyware developed and sold by commercial entities, not tools built by American intelligence agencies. WASHINGTON — President Biden on Monday signed an executive order ... Read more »

This English city will add a charge for visitors next month

Travelers heading to the United Kingdom may soon pay more for a stay in Manchester, England. The city will implement a City Visitor Charge on April 1, amounting to a 1 pound charge ... Read more »

Silicon Valley Bank’s Collapse Chills Start-Up Funding

Silicon Valley Bank’s Collapse Chills Start-Up Funding SAN FRANCISCO — Jonathan Nelson had lined up commitments for $2 million in new funding for his financial technology start-up, HF.Capital, from two ... Read more »

People Started Buying Crocs During the Pandemic. They Can’t Stop.

Since January 2020, Crocs’ stock price has increased 167 percent. Like Peloton, Etsy and Zoom, Crocs saw its business boom during the early days of the coronavirus pandemic. The company’s ... Read more »

Fed Vice Chair Calls Silicon Valley Bank a ‘Textbook Case of Mismanagement’

Michael Barr, the Fed’s vice chair for supervision, has acknowledged in his written testimony that bank supervision and regulation may need to change in the wake of the Silicon Valley ... Read more »

Home prices increase amid struggling housing market: CoreLogic

Mortgage rates are on the rise, making it more difficult for Americans to finance homes Read more »

The Rock's Daughter Set For In-Ring Debut At WWE NXT Stand & Deliver

Ava Backstage At A WWE NXT Show Ava, the daughter of WWE legend The Rock, will make her in-ring debut at next Saturday’s “WWE NXT” Stand & Deliver premium live ... Read more »

Harry Potter: Things That Made Dolores Umbridge Scarier Than Voldemort

Harry Potter: Things That Made Dolores Umbridge Scarier Than Voldemort Dolores Umbridge was arguably the most evil character in the Harry Potter series, sometimes more so than Lord Voldemort, mainly ... Read more »

Kaspersky releases tool for decrypting ransomware

Source code leaked last month by infighting members of the Conti gang was used to build the antidote to their attacks. Kaspersky has published a new version of a decryption ... Read more »

The 'Gilmore Girls' Costume Designer Has Just Confirmed The Father Of Rory’s Baby

The costume designer took to TikTok to end the speculation and told fans that it’s obviously Logan. If you need a reminder: Logan is Rory’s now married college boyfriend, who ... Read more »

Arkansas Gov. Signs Law Banning Transgender People From Using Bathrooms Matching Their Gender Identity In Public Schools

Topline Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders (R) signed a law on Tuesday that bans transgender people from using bathrooms that match their gender identity in public schools, the latest in ... Read more »

TikTok's Restaurant Butter Hack Makes Spreading So Much Easier

Plate of bread and butter Dining out can be a special experience on its own. After all, you get to don your finest attire, spend quality time with family and ... Read more »

Christian who escaped Chinese persecution warns US descending into 'communist-style of governance'

The leader of a watchdog group that monitors Christian persecution in China said he’s seeing echoes of the Chinese Community Party “playbook” in the U.S., and he’s worried it’ll get ... Read more »

Lollapalooza 2023: How to get tickets to the Chicago music festival

Billie Eilish and Kendrick Lamar Lollapalooza has unveiled its 2023 lineup, teasing some big acts. Headlining this year’s Chicago music festival are Billie Eilish, Kendrick Lamar, Red Hot Chili Peppers, ... Read more »

Fury vs Usyk talks break down, fight will not happen April 29

Talks for Tyson Fury vs Oleksandr Usyk have reportedly broken down Tyson Fury and Oleksandr Usyk will not be fighting, at least not on April 29, as talks have reportedly ... Read more »

Cameron Diaz's Comeback Film Halted As Cops Investigate Costar Jamie Foxx Being Targeted In Alleged Money-Grabbing Scheme

Mega Production on Cameron Diaz’s comeback film has reportedly come to a screeching halt after her costar Jamie Foxx was targeted in an alleged money-grabbing scheme, has learned. Mega ... Read more »

Why Men Fall Out Of Love (Hint: It Has Nothing To Do With Their Partners)

man and woman on date at night By Marisa Donnelly I wish love was perfect. I wish, when we fell for another person, everything just stayed the way it was ... Read more »

Insulin Price Cap Doesn't Apply to All Iowans Who Need It

Some 37.3 million Americans, or about one in 10 people, have diabetes. About one in five don’t know they have it, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự