There's a chance China might finally put taxes on property

Asia's Tech News Daily

Vehicles drive by unfinished residential buildings from the Evergrande Oasis, a housing complex developed by Evergrande Group, in Luoyang, China September 16, 2021.Carlos Garcia Rawlins | Reuters

BEIJING — China is closer than ever to taxing property owners, analysts say, nearly two decades after authorities began floating the idea.

What's changed is that Chinese President Xi Jinping now has the political momentum to get the ball rolling on property tax, analysts said. This summer, Xi has emphasized authorities' commitment to delivering “common prosperity,” or moderate wealth for all, rather than just a few.

And in an essay earlier this month detailing what common prosperity means, Xi called for regulating excessively high incomes, with measures such as tests of a property tax.

It is something which they will have to do because it is coming from the top, and therefore, it will happen.
David Roche
Independent Strategy, president and global strategist

On Saturday, the top executive body, the State Council, was authorized to conduct such a test for five years in unspecified regions. These developments follow years of trying to limit speculation in China's property market, which accounts for the bulk of household wealth.

“I think the central government has chosen [the] right time because of the political reshuffling happening before and after the 20th party congress next year, so to really resist a central government policy will be [a risk] to local government officials' own career,” said Yue Su, principal economist at The Economist Intelligence Unit.

She was referring to the National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party, held every five years to determine top leadership positions.

Property tax talk since 2003

Unlike the U.S., China does not have a blanket tax on property. Real estate ownership in China can also differ. For example, state-owned enterprises have distributed apartments to their employees.

Chinese leaders began discussing a property tax in 2003, but so far only the municipalities of Shanghai and Chongqing have implemented a limited version, analysts said.

The experiences of those two cities in the last decade haven't created a compelling argument for other local governments to roll out a property tax, Larry Hu, chief China economist at Macquarie, said in a note over the weekend.

In 2020, property taxes in Shanghai and Chongqing accounted for 5% or less of local tax revenue, and contributed far less than what land sales did, Hu said.

More than 20% of regional and local government revenue comes from sales of land to real estate developers, according to Moody's. But if the property market is successfully tapped through tax channels, it could ultimately bring in significant revenue for local authorities.

Real estate and related sectors like construction account for at least 25% of China's GDP, according to Moody's.

Those figures partly reveal just what a force real estate is in China.

China's privatization of the housing market in 1998 allowed an older generation to buy apartments at a low cost, giving them a disproportionately larger share of the property market than younger generations, Hu said in a note over the weekend. He added that home prices vary significantly by city.

“Property tax in China is much more than a wealth redistribution from rich to poor, but from older generations and high-tier [more developed] city residents to the rest,” Hu said. “As the result, the resistance to property tax is not only broad but also powerful.”

A tax on wealth

Property accounts for about 70% to 80% of household wealth in China, and drives about 10% of household income, Moody's said.

A nationwide property tax would likely require disclosures of business and government leaders' real estate holdings, which means such a policy could meet resistance even as the country has been cracking down on corruption.

But the latest political developments could tip the scale. Tycoons once built fortunes through developers like Evergrande by relying on debt for growth. That use of debt has become a target of government scrutiny in the last 18 months.

In addition, Xi said in August that pursuing “common prosperity” in China would require curbing “excessive” income and encouraging the wealthy to give back to society. Later that month, the State Taxation Administration said it was investigating individuals who concealed their high income and evaded taxes.

“The big idea is of course to recreate a lot of new, happy, middle class people who have affordable housing and affordable health care and affordable education, and therefore happy citizens,” David Roche, Independent Strategy, president and global strategist, said Monday on CNBC's “Squawk Box Asia.”

“And in order to do this you need to make sure that housing is for living — that is, not speculation, or for investment,” Roche said. “So, [property tax] is not something which is going to be left to local authorities to put into practice or local governments. It is something which they will have to do because it is coming from the top, and therefore, it will happen.”

Read more about China from CNBC Pro

Even with the latest political momentum, analysts don't expect a nationwide tax on real estate immediately.

“We believe Beijing is determined to quicken the rollout of property tax, but will still proceed in a cautious way and only phase in the tax gradually,” Ting Lu, chief China economist at Nomura, said in a note Monday.

“Still,” he said, “the expectation of ever-rising home prices will likely be significantly reined in among Chinese households, new home sales across China could slow down, Beijing might see mounting challenges on the road to a nationwide property tax, and near-term pains are inevitable.”

Ultimately, authorities will need to weigh the economic consequences of any moves on China's massive real estate market.

If there are simultaneous property dumps, that might slow the introduction of property tax and increase the ability of individuals to apply for exemptions, the EIU's Su said.

— CNBC's Weizhen Tan contributed to this report.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

IDFC First Bank Debuts India's First Metal Debit Card

IDFC First Bank announced the launch of FIRST Private Infinite, the country’s first-ever standalone metal debit card, in partnership with Visa, the global leader in digital payments. IDFC First Bank ... Read more »

S&P 500 Downside Hedged ETF (PHDG) Hits a 52-Week High

For investors looking for momentum, Invesco S&P 500 Downside Hedged ETF PHDG is probably a suitable pick. The fund just hit a 52-week high by gaining 17.7% from its 52-week low price ... Read more »

Snowflake Shares Pop More Than 15% After Blowing Past Q3 Estimates

Cloud-based data warehousing specialist Snowflake (NYSE: SNOW) rebounded sharply Thursday following better-than-expected third-quarter results.  Depositphotos.com contributor/Depositphotos.com – MarketBeat Shares were trading at $354.88 late in Thursday’s session, up more than ... Read more »

City comment: Campaigners will celebrate Shell abandoning Cambo — but it's not black and white

Campaigners from Greenpeace outside Downing Street, London, during a protest in October against the Cambo oil field off the west coast of Shetland (Victoria Jones/PA) (PA Wire) Shell has pulled ... Read more »

Pink's not dead: City shirt-maker comes back from brink of lockdown collapse

(PA) Thomas Pink is gearing up for a return to the High Street, 12 months after the City’s go-to shirt-maker suddenly shut up shop amid a wipe-out in demand for ... Read more »

Sleaze row Covid testing firm improves terms for customers

A Covid-19 testing firm at the centre of a Government sleaze row has improved its terms and conditions to avoid falling foul of competition laws. Randox has made changes to ... Read more »

Spanish bank Unicaja to cut up to 1,513 jobs, union says

FILE PHOTO: The logo of Unicaja bank on the facade of a Unicaja bank branch in Ronda MADRID (Reuters) – Spain's Unicaja has reached a pre-agreement with unions to cut ... Read more »

‘The fruit bowl is emptier and petrol is shocking': one family's experience of soaring cost of living

From running a car, to food bills and pet products, UK household expenditure is stacking up Jon Daly has noticed it in the family’s fruit bowl, which isn’t as well-stocked ... Read more »

Nationwide appoints Debbie Crosbie as first female chief executive

Photograph: TSB/PA Nationwide has appointed Debbie Crosbie as the first female chief executive in the building society’s 175-year history. The 51-year-old, who has led the turnaround of the troubled bank ... Read more »

France says UAE arms deal secures supply chain, jobs

FILE PHOTO: A model of the Rafale plane seen at a defence expo in Cairo, Egypt PARIS (Reuters) – A 17-billion-euro ($19.23 billion) French arms deal with the United Arab ... Read more »

Selfridges to be sold to Thai retail giant for £4bn

The luxury department store has been owned by the Weston family, one of Canada’s richest families, for the last 18 years. It has agreed sale terms with the group. Photo: ... Read more »

Set your table with these brilliant Christmas centrepiece ideas

Photo credit: Stars for Europe/Bjarni B. Jacobsen Fotografi Apart from the turkey, of course, a stunning Christmas centrepiece should be the focus of your festive table on Christmas Day – ... Read more »

Macy's reliance on stores for e-commerce weighs on mulled split

FILE PHOTO: Black Friday sales in the Manhattan borough of New York City By Svea Herbst-Bayliss and Anirban Sen (Reuters) – Macy's Inc is grappling with how to make its ... Read more »

NAV director fears increased unemployment benefits make it less attractive for laid-off people to look for jobs

Increased unemployment benefit rates during the pandemic have led to laid-off people not working hard enough to get a new job, Innlandet NAV director Bjørn Lien fears. The authorities increased ... Read more »

TVS Emerald announces new finance scheme to home-buyers

Emerald Haven Realty Ltd (TVS Emerald), the real estate division of TVS Group, on Friday announced the rolling out of new finance scheme for its project TVS Emerald Atrium to ... Read more »

Virgin Media TV services restored after power outage

Virgin Media has confirmed its TV services have returned to normal after a power outage took some channels offline for many customers. The company said in an update on Friday ... Read more »

Shell to go ahead with seismic tests in whale breeding grounds after court win

Photograph: Kim Ludbrook/EPA Judgment rules company can blast sound waves in search for oil along South Africa’s eastern coastline Royal Dutch Shell will move ahead with seismic tests to explore ... Read more »

Global tax deal leaves billion-dollar loopholes, Reuters analysis finds

1 / 5Global tax deal leaves billion-dollar loopholes, Reuters analysis findsLogo of Adobe Inc. is pictured at the company’s office in Citywest Business Campus, Saggart By Tom Bergin DUBLIN (Reuters) ... Read more »

Nationwide poaches first female boss from TSB

One of the UK’s biggest mortgage lenders will be led by a woman for the first time in its nearly 140-year history after Nationwide stole TSB’s boss for its top ... Read more »

British Airways will be first airline to use UK-produced sustainable fuel

British Airways will become the first airline to use sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) produced on a commercial scale in the UK. The carrier announced it will fly planes using the ... Read more »

Black Friday sales fail to perk up shopping malls and high streets

Total UK footfall decreased by 15.7% in November compared to 2019, according to the British Retail Consortium. Photo: PA Brick-and-mortar retailers hoping to attract customers with Black Friday sales this ... Read more »

UK service sector boosted by export sales and new business growth

Prices charged by service sector firms rose at a record pace during the period thanks to soaring inflation, higher fuel prices and wage increases. Photo: Stu Forster/Getty The UK saw ... Read more »

Shell wins court case to start seismic surveys offshore South Africa

FILE PHOTO: A logo for Shell is seen on a garage forecourt in central London CAPE TOWN (Reuters) – A South African high court on Friday struck down an urgent ... Read more »

Swiss chocolate makers focus on incomes to end child labour

1 / 3Swiss chocolate makers focus on incomes to end child labourFILE PHOTO: Logo of Swiss chocolatier Lindt & Spruengli is seen in Kilchberg By Silke Koltrowitz ZURICH (Reuters) – ... Read more »

China's ride-hailing firm Didi to switch listing from New York to Hong Kong

Stock exchange decision comes as Beijing cracks down on technology firms listing overseas The Chinese ride-hailing firm Didi is to move its listing from the New York stock exchange to ... Read more »

European stock markets push higher as Omicron strain concerns ease

Investors have been trying to weigh up the effects of the new variant this week. Photo: Toby Melville/Reuters European stock markets pushed higher on Friday, in what has been a ... Read more »

Petrol prices: UK supermarkets and fuel retailers ‘ripping off drivers', RAC says

Wholesale petrol prices fell 10p in November to their lowest levels since September, while the cost of wholesale diesel fell by 7p. Photo: PA Even as wholesale costs of both ... Read more »

German services firms post modest growth, Omicron clouds outlook - PMI

FILE PHOTO: VW’s plant in Wolfsburg, Germany, Europe’s largest car factory BERLIN (Reuters) – German services firms saw their business activity improve slightly in November, but a strong fourth wave ... Read more »

OPEC+ output increase adds to Goldman's bullish oil market view

FILE PHOTO: A sticker reads crude oil on the side of a storage tank in the Permian Basin (Reuters) – Goldman Sachs said current oil price levels offer 'compelling' opportunities ... Read more »

David Beckham-backed cannabis company Cellular Goods sees losses jump

(PA) Cellular Goods, the cannabis skincare product company backed by David Beckham, has seen its losses soar over the last year as it invested in setting up production and going ... Read more »

Major CEE currencies set to strengthen over next 12 months: Reuters poll

FILE PHOTO: People visit closed Christmas market in Prague By Miroslava Krufova and Jason Hovet PRAGUE (Reuters) – Most central European currencies are set to strengthen in the next year, ... Read more »

Britain's Wickes raises profit guidance on resilient trading

LONDON (Reuters) -British home improvement retailer Wickes raised its full-year profit guidance on Friday, saying it had continued to trade well in its fourth quarter so far. The group, which ... Read more »

Covid loans worth £28bn ‘paid out before basic anti-fraud measures started'

The Government only put in some basic anti-fraud checks on the small Covid loans it was providing to businesses once more than £28 billion had already been paid out, a ... Read more »

FTSE 100 Live: See-saw week for stock markets ends on high, oil prices climb

(ESI) Stock markets are ending a difficult week on the front foot after weekly jobless claims figures last night pointed to continued resilience in the US economy. The Dow Jones ... Read more »

Advent, Aurora withdraws $8 billion bid for Swedish drugmaker Sobi

FILE PHOTO: The logo for Singapore sovereign wealth fund GIC Pte Ltd, is seen on a building in Singapore STOCKHOLM (Reuters) – U.S. private equity firm Advent International and Singapore's ... Read more »

Sales cool at Wickes but profits set to beat expectations

DIY and home improvement business Wickes has said customers are continuing to flock to stores although not at the same levels as at the height of the pandemic a year ... Read more »

Statistics Norway: Adults in low-income families with children in Norway rarely have a job

Adults in low-income families with children in Norway rarely have jobs, and when they do, they are often short-term jobs with low wages and short working hours. Immigrants are overrepresented ... Read more »

Allianz aims for 5-7% annual EPS growth for 2022-24

The logo of Allianz is seen in Paris BERLIN (Reuters) – Allianz raised its targets for shareholder returns for 2022-24 on Friday, aiming for 5-7% annual growth in earnings per ... Read more »

Arcab Raises Undisclosed Amount In Seed Round

Arcab, a technology-enabled bus aggregator, has raised an undisclosed amount in its Seed round led by We Founder Circle. Pexels The Dubai-based startup Arcab allows fleet owners to make more ... Read more »

Stocks stumble as bond traders turn to jobs data

Passersby wearing protective face masks walk past an electronic board displaying world stock indexes in Tokyo By Tom Westbrook SYDNEY (Reuters) – Asian stocks wobbled and risk-sensitive currencies in the ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic