The Wellness Industry Has A Cultural Appropriation Problem — & It's Not Alone

© Provided by Refinery29

Almost 30 years ago, in 1995, two researchers from the University of Mississippi were granted a patent for “the use of turmeric for wound healing.” At that time, turmeric was not known in the U.S. for being a wellness “super-ingredient”; the age of golden oat milk lattes had not yet risen. But, of course, turmeric had been a staple in South Asian countries for centuries, as both a cooking spice and a healing agent. And so India’s Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) challenged the patent, on the grounds that the researchers were attempting to personally capitalise off  traditional cultural knowledge, and therefore didn’t fulfil the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office’s requirement for novelty or inventiveness. The year-long legal battle cost the CSIR $15,000 (£10,870), but they won, and the patent was revoked in 1997.

This isn’t just about turmeric, though, nor is this type of cultural property theft limited to international appropriation. Thirteen years after becoming a state, New Mexico adopted a new state flag; a simple, impactful design, the flag features a crimson red sun symbol centred on a golden-yellow background. The symbol, though, belonged to the Zia, an Indigenous tribe of the region. Long used by a small sect within the Zia as part of their religious healing practices, the sun symbol was never intended to be distributed widely, even within the Zia’s own community. In fact, it only became more widely known after a piece of pottery featuring the sun symbol was stolen from the Zia and later displayed at a museum, where it inspired the state flag’s design. 

The Zia’s continued fight to protect this sacred symbol has been long and complex; since it has been treated as part of the public domain for so long, the legal options have been limited. In the late-1990s, after decades of New Mexico’s desecration of its sign, the Zia Pueblo asked the state to pay it around $74 million in reimbursement for using the symbol without permission. New Mexico didn’t pay, but The New York Times reported in 2000 that the Pueblo hadn’t expected the state to. The Zia had hoped that their request for reimbursement would put pressure on the state and raise awareness around the issue of Indigenous intellectual property protections — and it has, but the solutions put in place have been imperfect. 

The Times notes that not long after the Zia asked New Mexico for reimbursement, the federal Patent and Trademark Office released a statement acknowledging the issues around protecting Native American insignia. It also created an insignia database to help protect these cultural expressions. But Frank Ettawageshik, the executive director of the United Tribes of Michigan, says databases like this aren’t a viable solution for many Indigenous communities when it comes to protecting their heritage. “Most of that knowledge we can’t put in that database, because it’s secret and sacred,” Ettawageshik says. In fact, it’s possible that the Zia Pueblo would have been unable to put the sun symbol into the USPTO database, but it still deserved to be protected. 

This highlights the fundamental tension between how many native or Indigenous cultures view their own traditional knowledge, genetic resources, and cultural expressions, and how non-Indigenous legal systems treat such resources. “Under the conventional intellectual property system, traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions are generally regarded as being in the public domain, and thus free for anyone to use. Indigenous peoples, local communities, and many countries reject this so-called ‘public domain’ status, arguing that being considered as such opens the door to unwanted misappropriation or misuse,” explains Anna Sinkevich, an Indigenous Fellow at the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). 

“The largely oral nature of transmission of these traditional forms of creativity and innovation from one generation to the next adds an additional layer of complexity,” Sinkevich adds. The lack of a written record can make communities that benefit from traditional knowledge more vulnerable to theft or exploitation.

The way the U.S. and many other legal systems view ownership is another point of friction. “In non-Indigenous thought, intellectual knowledge is considered an invention of the human mind. If the human mind gets this beautiful, wonderful idea and makes a widget of some sort, the maker of that widget can get a patent for it and then will be the sole person to profit from any money that’s made from it for a period of time,” Ettawageshik says. 

But, as Sinkevich points out, that way of thinking doesn’t correspond with Indigenous concepts of ownership, which, she explains, reflect the idea that “traditional knowledge is generally regarded as being collectively held, meaning that any rights and interests in it belong to the community rather than an individual member, including in cases where an individual member of a community has developed traditional knowledge.” If a community were to try to apply for a copyright, patent, or other intellectual property protection, “it may be difficult to identify the ‘owner’ of the intellectual property rights,” Sinkevich says. “In addition, it could be the case that more than one community shares the same or similar traditional knowledge or traditional cultural expressions. So even if they were to individually qualify for the protection of their rights, how would you, for example, offer fair and equitable protection to each of these communities separated by modern international borders?”

Another reason communities may not want to seek existing intellectual property protections like a patent is that these eventually expire, and once they do, the property becomes public domain, Ettawageshik says. And again, the knowledge that’s being protected may not have been intended to be part of the public domain or even necessarily profited from in the first place.  

But, even though the current legal system isn’t set up to protect traditional knowledge, traditional cultural expression, and genetic resources, it’s still essential to find a way to properly safeguard these resources. “When traditional knowledge is put in the wrong context by a third party, in particular without the community’s consent, it can be not only offensive to the community but also runs the risk of misrepresenting or distorting the perception of the community and their traditional knowledge,” Sinkevich points out. “From a financial perspective, the lack of protection for traditional knowledge as such can have a negative economic impact on its holders, possibly even preventing them from benefiting from their own traditional knowledge or traditional cultural expressions,” she adds.

Unfortunately, getting the legal system and large corporations to recognise communities’ rights to protect their own traditional knowledge, cultural expressions, and genetic resources has been a struggle for community leaders. Sinkevich says that developing countries are responsible for much of the negotiations done in this area, although many developed countries — especially those with Indigenous populations — have taken part as well, and many countries do have some legal protections or guidelines in place. Organisations such as the Native American Rights Fund are set up to push for legal recognition and protection for Indigenous communities in the U.S., and similar organisations exist internationally. Sinkevich says that the WIPO Secretariat’s Traditional Knowledge Division “facilitates a normative process among Member States, which aims to develop an international legal instrument for the protection of traditional knowledge,” one that addresses “the intersection between the intellectual property system and the concerns of practitioners and custodians of traditional knowledge, traditional cultural expressions, and genetic resources.” 

Ettawageshik has been heavily involved in negotiations with governing bodies, including the U.N., regarding the rights of Indigenous peoples to protect their intellectual property, and the need for international intellectual property law to adequately accommodate the unique collective and temporal nature of Indigenous intellectual property. The work of Indigenous communities and the people intent on protecting the sanctity of traditional knowledge has led to changes that have allowed for actual accountability. In 2016, for example, Urban Outfitters settled with Navajo Nation after the clothing company illegally used the tribe’s name in a collection. 

Ettawageshik says that protecting cultures’ traditional knowledge, and specifically protecting Indigenous intellectual property, is not about making sure no one outside of Indigenous communities can use it: “When you’re talking about protecting indigenous knowledge… it’s also what we’re willing to share.” But not all Indigenous or traditional knowledge is meant to be disseminated in that way, and in an ideal world, Ettawageshik says that “people would respect Indigenous knowledge and not abuse that relationship.” The world is far from ideal, but this is a baseline everyone is capable of practicing — as is being more conscious about why a golden latte isn’t just another wellness trend.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


What You Need to Know About Billie Eilish's Boyfriend, Matthew Tyler Vorce

Looks like Billie Eilish is in a full blown relationship! Photos were snapped of the Grammy winner cozying up to Matthew Tyler Vorce in Santa Barbara back in April. And ... Read more »

Brittany Matthews Shares Adorable Video To Celebrate 8 Months With Her Daughter

© Provided by Brittany Matthews, Sterling Mahomes It seems like only yesterday that Brittany Matthews and her NFL fiancé, Patrick Mahomes, welcomed their first child together. But according to ... Read more »

Molly-Mae Hague stuns as she shows off dazzling £180,000 worth of jewellery

Molly-Mae Hague stepped out in London on Thursday evening for the launch of her Christmas collection with Beauty Works. The 22 year old stunned just as she usually does in ... Read more »

How are alligators and crocodiles different?

© Provided by Live Science null All alligators and crocodiles belong to a taxonomic order called Crocodylia. Crocodylia is then split up into three major families; Alligatoridae (alligators), Crocodylidea (crocodile) ... Read more »

Strictly's Motsi Mabuse makes candid confession about judging sister Oti

© Provided by Hello! motsi-mabuse Motsi Mabuse has made a candid confession about how she judges her sister Oti on Strictly Come Dancing. Appearing on this week’s Graham Norton Show ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin: Rust shooting ‘43rd fatal incident on US film set since 1990'

© Getty Images for National Geogra Alec Baldwin – Getty Alec Baldwin fired a prop gun on the set of his new western movie on Thursday, killing cinematographer Halyna Hutchins ... Read more »

John Travolta 'is so proud of his daughter's maturity' after Kelly Preston's death

© Bang Showbiz John Travolta John Travolta is “so proud” of his daughter’s “kindness and strength”. The ‘Grease’ star lost his wife Kelly Preston in July 2020 when she lost ... Read more »

Leytonstone McDonald's is shut down after MICE overrun kitchen

© Google thumbnail_image.png A McDonald’s branch where mice overran its kitchen has been shut down due to “an imminent risk to public health”, environmental health inspectors said. Customers sitting down ... Read more »

'Housewives' Star Kandi Burruss Says It Hurt When People Questioned Her Surrogacy Choice

© Provided by Kandi Burruss When Real Housewives star Kandi Burruss chose to welcome her third child via surrogate, not everyone had positive feedback ready for her. During a ... Read more »

Gemma Collins feels 'vulnerable' after Steve Allen's cruel comments as she speaks out

Gemma Collins has jumped at the chance to support Tilly Ramsay after an old tweet from LBC host Steve Allen was dug up and reported on. Headlines this week have ... Read more »

Skin Proud's £16.95 gel-to-ice cryotherapy moisturiser is TikTok famous - here's why

© Provided by Hello! skin-proud TikTok fans have been going wild for Skin Proud’s cool new cryotherapy product – and we can see why. The brand’s affordable £16.95 ‘Frozen Over’ ... Read more »

What to wear for every type of half-term scenario

© Provided by The Telegraph The gallery-hopping day out to a staycation, it’s crucial to get your look just right Parents will no doubt be keen to keep children busy ... Read more »

The six products that Wendy Lowe can't live without

© Image courtesy of Wendy Make-up artist Wendy Lowe has worked with celebrities including Sienna Miller, Suki Waterhouse and Cara Delevingne – Image courtesy of Wendy When it comes to ... Read more »

Les 5 Airbnb les plus insolites pour un week-end en novembre

© Courtesy of Airbnb Le chalet finlandais Le chalet finlandais Ce chalet en immersion totale dans la nature est situé… en Normandie. Il offre un cadre exceptionnel sur un étang ... Read more »

Delta Air Lines is restoring 13 routes out of New York this fall that were suspended during the pandemic - see the full list

© Philip Pilosian/ A Delta Air Lines Airbus A320. Philip Pilosian/ Delta is restarting 13 routes out of New York this fall, including nine domestic and four international. The added ... Read more »

Halyna Hutchins and Joel Souza: What we know about the victims of the Alec Baldwin Rust shooting

© Getty, Shutterstock pjimage – 2021-10-22T081106.247.jpg Cinematographer Halyna Hutchins died on Thursday after actor Alec Baldwin fired a prop gun on a film set in New Mexico. Hutchins was transported ... Read more »

“Boys can be Emma”: Em Rusciano says everyone can adore Emma Wiggle!

If you’ve ever tried telling a toddler what they can and can’t wear you’ll know that resistance is futile. And if that toddler happens to be a little boy wanting ... Read more »

So schützen Sie Ihr Haus vor Stürmen im Herbst

© Bereitgestellt von Das Haus Schon Windstärken um die 40 km/h reichen aus, um leichte Gartenmöbel oder Sonnensegel herumfliegen zu lassen, sagen Experten. Am besten vorher einsammeln und sicher im ... Read more »

India seizes $2.7bn of heroin from Afghanistan at port

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Ghulamullah Habibi/EPA Nearly three tonnes of heroin with a street value of $2.7bn (£2bn) from Afghanistan have been seized from a western Indian port ... Read more »

Greaves remembered affectionately at funeral

© PA Family, friends and former team-mates paid a fond farewell to football great Jimmy Greaves at his funeral on Friday. Greaves, who died last month aged 81, was celebrated ... Read more »

Harry makes surprise call to veterans on walking expedition

© James Manning Walkers taking part in the Grenadier Walk of Oman during a break at Horse Guards Parade, Whitehall, central London (PA) The Duke of Sussex made a surprise ... Read more »

How it feels to go into space: ‘More beautiful and dazzling and frightening than I ever imagined'

It was a balmy morning in the west Texas desert when Chris Boshuizen stepped into Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin rocket capsule for a journey most of us will never experience. ... Read more »

Kenya runner's death highlights pressures faced by female athletes

© Jonathan NACKSTRAND Agnes Tirop’s death shone a light on the lives of elite Kenyan women athletes The death of Kenyan running star Agnes Tirop has thrown a spotlight on ... Read more »

Two arrests in Nottingham amid nightclub spikings ‘epidemic' probes

© @mjtrimble/Pixabay nightclub221021v1a.jpg Two men have been arrested in connection with a spate of reported drink-spiking incidents involving needles in Nottingham. Nottinghamshire Police said the men, aged 18 and 19, ... Read more »

UK Government ‘should have followed Israel's lead to fight third Covid wave by ramping up booster jabs'

© Provided by The i The UK Government should have followed Israel’s lead to fight the third Covid wave by ramping up its booster jab programme much earlier, an expert ... Read more »

Eyeliner von Adele: Ihre Make-up-Artistin verrät, wie du den ikonischen Lidstrich der Sängerin nachmachen kannst

© ddp images Make-up-Artistin verrät: So kannst du den ikonischen Lidstrich von Sängerin Adele nachmachen & Der schwarze Lidstrich ist der Signature-Look von Adele. Seit Beginn ihrer Karriere setzt die ... Read more »

More than five million booster doses delivered in UK

© Joe Giddens People receive Covid-19 booster vaccinations at Midland House, Derby (Joe Giddens/PA) An estimated 5.3 million booster doses of Covid-19 vaccine have been delivered in the UK, new ... Read more »

Donnelly: Free contraception scheme for women aged 17-25 will begin in August 2022

© Alamy Stock Photo THE DEPARTMENT OF Health has confirmed that free contraception for young women will be made available in August, 2022.  Minister Stephen Donnelly said that it is ... Read more »

Who is Halyna Hutchins? Tributes paid to cinematographer shot by prop gun discharged by Alec Baldwin

© Getty Images 2018 Sundance Film Festival Official Kickoff Party Hosted By SundanceTV Tributes were today paid to director of photography Halyna Hutchins, who died after she was shot by ... Read more »

New York millionaire Robert Durst charged with 1982 murder of wife

© Myung J. Chun Robert Durst was recently sentenced to life in prison for murdering a confidante who prosecutors said helped him cover up Kathie Durst’s killing (Myung J Chung/Los ... Read more »

Club entry searches unlikely to be enough to protect women from injection spikings, says ex-detective

Cases of spiking by injection are difficult to police because of the “subterfuge and modus operandi of the attacker”, a former senior police officer has said. More thorough door searches ... Read more »

Raizen, E2MAX, Ch4knu propel Omega to next playoff round

© Provided by THE SECOND match of the first day of the MPL PH Season 8 playoffs featured SEA powerhouse Omega Esports against their rivals, ECHO PH, a team led by veteran and ... Read more »

Husband who stabbed his wife to death in their Dublin home is jailed for life

A 39-year-old man who was found guilty of murdering his wife Anne Colomines in their Dublin home four years ago has been sentenced to life in prison. Renato Gehlen, a ... Read more »

This new dating and friendship app wants to help Asians and Pacific Islanders 'find community and belonging'

© Courtesy of Alike Courtesy of Alike Alike is a new dating and friendship app for the Asian and Pacific Islander communities. The app was created by Hanmin Yang, a ... Read more »

7 Times Kangana Ranaut showed how to hit festivities on a glam note with kurta suits

This festive season we hope you’re not just bundling up in sarees. Although, these flatter easily, don’t revert to these soon. There’s more to mood boards like kurta suits which ... Read more »

‘I've trained with Prince Harry, lost my legs in Helmand – now I'm on course to be a bobsleigh world champion'

© Andrew Crowley for The Telegraph Corie Mapp – Andrew Crowley for The Telegraph When Corie Mapp woke up in a hospital bed, two weeks after driving over a homemade ... Read more »

Dune REVIEW: Ambitious new adaptation

© Warner Bros Dune still The title on the screen for Denis Villeneuve’s ambitious new adaptation of Herbert’s dense (and some say unfilmable) sci-fi novel, reads Dune: Part One. Whether ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic