The week in classical: Fidelio; Gabriela Montero – review

Asia's Tech News Daily

Poor Beethoven. A brief history of recent productions of his only opera, Fidelio, originally set in an 18th-century prison, has to include the following: a spaceship hurtling towards doom (director Gary Hill, Opéra de Lyon/Edinburgh); a fluorescent, Kafka-esque maze (Calixto Bieito, ENO); a white room denoting Freud’s “salon of the unconscious” (Claus Guth, Salzburg); and a real horse (Tobias Kratzer, Royal Opera House). Glyndebourne’s last staging, by Deborah Warner, more modestly, relevantly and arguably most powerfully, featured an ironing board and washing line.

Now Glyndebourne Tour has a new production, directed by Frederic Wake-Walker and conducted by Ben Glassberg. It, too, has ideas, though none like the above. Originally planned for the main festival, it is being presented under the umbrella of Glyndebourne Tour though is not, confusingly, going on the road – all part of the backlog and compromise caused by the pandemic.

The opera is perceived (not by all of us) as an oddball: too symphonic, not dramatic, lopsided and, for non-German speaking audiences, hampered by awkward dialogue. It also celebrates married love, which isn’t to all tastes. Few directors are brave enough to trust this work of genius on its own terms. They fiddle, cut, add, reinvent. Glyndebourne’s new staging has the great benefit of being set, in Anna Jones’s designs, with lighting by Peter Mumford, in a prison. It looks striking, if relentlessly dark until the very end, when sheets of crinkly gold fabric symbolise the triumphant forces of light.

A braced panopticon, like an empty gas holder, dominates. The white-gowned prisoners’ chorus (excellently sung) stands on its different tiers as if suspended like angels. All this is promising, but there are problems. Everyone is seen, but does not see. To drive the point home, large, immersive video images play out on the bare fretwork structure. The visuals spin and lurch and confuse. It’s hard to follow this essentially straightforward story. Anyone new to it might have welcomed more clarity, less interference; with some rethinking, this could be achieved.

Not for the first time, the dialogue has been cut. The greatest intrusion is an invented character, Estella (Gertrude Thoma), who narrates a fictional scenario which I couldn’t entirely follow. When Estella talks over the music, our patience is tested. Beethoven is so inventive with the orchestration – on second night, well played by Glyndebourne Tour musicians, with plenty of beauty and vitality – that you don’t want to miss a note.

The singing was accomplished, and in the case of Dorothea Herbert, the German soprano playing Leonore, outstanding, passionate, soaring. Adam Smith as Florestan struggled with the merciless top notes, but gave an affecting performance. Gavan Ring’s unusually thoughtful Jaquino, Carrie-Ann Williams’s bright-voiced Marzelline and Callum Thorpe’s nuanced Rocco, too often made oafish, led an accomplished cast and chorus.

Glyndebourne Tour, between now and December, will travel to four venues with two operas (Stravinsky’s The Rake’s Progress and Donizetti’s Don Pasquale) and Handel’s Messiah. You can also see, at base camp only, Charlie Chaplin’s comedy City Lights (1931) accompanied live by Glyndebourne Touring Orchestra.

Whereas Beethoven, in his singular way, gives you all you need, Chaplin’s silent films are actually incomplete without music to provide emphasis and shading. Kings Place screened his The Immigrant (1917) as part of its London piano festival last weekend. Gabriela Montero’s programme centred around the theme of exile, with music by Prokofiev, Rachmaninov and Stravinsky. Above all, it gave the Venezuelan pianist a platform to make her own, brilliant live accompaniment to the Chaplin, compressing every possible sound and style, witty and communicative, into a breathtaking improvisation.

She may have played to this slapstick comedy before (in which, as my meticulous American companion pointed out, the Statue of Liberty is on the wrong side, so these “arrivals” are actually leaving New York harbour), but each time is new. As she told us in advance, she had no idea where the music would go, or even which note she would start on. Not all musicians can improvise, and few can do it with this degree of control and invention. Montero included echoes of the Prokofiev (Sarcasms, leading straight into Piano Sonata No 2) and Rachmaninov (Piano Sonata No 2) she had played earlier in the recital. In those works she dazzled but was at times unyielding. In her own music she touched the heart – and the funny bone.

Star ratings (out of five)
Fidelio
★★★
Gabriela Montero
★★★★★

  • Fidelio is at Glyndebourne until 31 October

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Biden says putting together comprehensive plan in Russia-Ukraine crisis

© Reuters/VALENTYN OGIRENKO The national flag of Ukraine flies over the town of Kramatorsk WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. President Joe Biden said on Friday he is putting together a set ... Read more »

'Worrying' number of children and pregnant women in hospital as omicron surges in South Africa

© Phill Magakoe/Pool via REUTERS Scientists say that omicron is behind the explosion of infections in the country’s Gauteng Province, which is home to both the sprawling metropolis Johannesburg and ... Read more »

ISL 2021-22 Highlights: Chennaiyin FC Held to Goalless Draw by SC East Bengal

© Provided by News18 ISL 2021-22 Highlights, Chennaiyin FC vs SC East Bengal: Chennaiyin FC have had four shots on target but have not been able to convert those chances. East ... Read more »

There's A Tiger King Spin-Off Coming And It Looks Ridiculous

Netflix/YouTube In March 2020, there was only one thing people could talk about. It dominated social media and had millions wondering about what the state of humanity would look like ... Read more »

Karnataka: All events in educational institution postponed

Events in all the educational institutions of the state have been postponed till January 15 next year. (Photo Courtesy: PTI) State Revenue Minister for Karnataka, R Ashoka, informed that the ... Read more »

Goa Archbishop nudges govt to preserve Old Goa heritage precinct

© Provided by Hindustan Times Goa Archbishop Filipe Neri Ferrão warned the state authorities to preserve the Old Goa heritage precinct lest it loses its world heritage status granted by ... Read more »

Ghaziabad's Nehru World School becomes UP's becomes first PASCH certified school

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Ghaziabad’s Nehru World School (NWS) has become the first school in Uttar Pradesh to be integrated into the PASCH network, a cooperative organization of ... Read more »

Kodiyeri Balakrishnan Returns as Kerala CPI(M) State Secretary After a Year-Long Hiatus

© Provided by News18 Kodiyeri Balakrishnan Returns as Kerala CPI(M) State Secretary After a Year-Long Hiatus CPM politburo member Kodiyeri Balakrishnan on Friday returned to the post of Kerala CPI(M) ... Read more »

Previous SP regime looted Bundelkhand: BJP reply to Akshilesh's 'befooling people' barb

© Provided by The Times of India LUCKNOW: On a day Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav completed his last leg of Vijay Rath Yatra in Bundelkhand region of Uttar ... Read more »

NCP attacks Centre over NCB asking states to take help in inter-state, int'l drug cases

National Congress Party spokesperson Nawab Malik criticised Centre on Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) chief’s letter asking states to seek NCB’s help with cases having inter-state and international ramifications. Malik said ... Read more »

Court discharges Chhota Rajan in 2002 extortion case involving his henchman

Court discharges Chhota Rajan in 2002 extortion case involving his henchman A special court dealing with criminal cases related to Rajendra Nikalje, alias gangster Chhota Rajan, has discharged him in ... Read more »

Omicron scare: Karnataka CM Basavaraj Bommai chairs meeting with experts, senior health officials

© Provided by DNA Just a day after the government confirmed two cases of the Omicron variant of COVID-19 in Karnataka, state Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai on Friday chaired a ... Read more »

Canadian grocery retailer Loblaw wins offshore tax case in top court

© Reuters/CHRIS WATTIE FILE PHOTO: A Loblaw logo is seen outside a grocery store in Ottawa OTTAWA (Reuters) – Canadian grocery retailer Loblaw Companies Ltd does not have to pay ... Read more »

Rishi Sunak tax warning: Hike to heat your home could QUADRUPLE

© Getty Rishi Sunak Announcing a new report on steps post COP25, Chair of the CCC Lord Deben said the UK needed to “walk the talk” and deliver urgent actions. ... Read more »

Motorists ‘overcharged 12p a litre' for petrol as fuel costs rise despite wholesale price fall

Supermarkets and petrol retailers have been been accused of overcharging motorists by as much as 12p a litre for fuel by increasing prices despite falling wholesale costs. The cost of ... Read more »

Architecture and design tutors join UK university walkouts over pay and pensions

Architecture and design tutors and academics are participating in strikes across the UK this week over pension cuts, falling pay and poor working conditions at their universities. © Provided by ... Read more »

Who is the referee for Rangers v Dundee, Celtic's game on Sunday and each weekend match in the cinch Premiership and SPFL Championship?

It’s been a busy week to be a football match official in Scotland – almost as busy as it has been to be a fan and keep up with a ... Read more »

Biden, 79, insists his alarming low and hoarse voice is just a COLD

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo President Biden raised concerns Friday morning sounding particularly hoarse as he delivered remarks on November’s jobs report, which was less robust than expected.    ... Read more »

UK records 50,584 Covid infections and 143 deaths amid Omicron spread

The UK faced a further 50,584 new Covid cases and 143 deaths on Friday. © PA Wire People wearing face masks walking along Oxford Street, London – PA Wire The ... Read more »

Britons can get paid £148,000 to move to a dreamy country next year - full list

New research by packaging retailer RAJA revealed the countries that will pay travellers to move there. There are many countries around the world with schemes that encourage people to move ... Read more »

The London hospitals that could be thrown into chaos as 40,000 NHS staff face sack over vaccine

London hospitals could be hit hard by staff shortages next year with tens of thousands still not double-jabbed. Health Secretary Sajid Javid announced in November that all frontline workers would ... Read more »

Ron DeSantis calls for Florida state military guard he would control

Florida Gov Ron DeSantis announced he would recommend $3.5 million in his state’s budget to re-establish a military guard that would answer to him. © Getty Images GettyImages-1333405306.jpg Mr DeSantis ... Read more »

Golf-Bekker takes three shot lead in South African Open

SUN CITY, South Africa (Reuters) – Oliver Bekker moved from joint overnight leader into a three shot lead at the midway point of the South African Open after carding a ... Read more »

Ange kicked while he's down after learning 'special' Celtic beast could miss next six games

Celtic forward Giorgos Giakoumakis could be out for three more weeks, Ange Postecoglou has revealed. © Provided by Transfer Tavern Georgios Giakoumakis in action for Greece The Lowdown: Giakoumakis’ struggles ... Read more »

Italian govt moves to crack down on violence against women

© Reuters/REMO CASILLI New Italian government led by PM Conte, is sworn in at the presidential palace in Rome ROME (Reuters) – Italy’s government approved a bill on Friday to ... Read more »

Lin-Manuel Miranda says directorial debut ‘Tick, Tick Boom!' is about 'failure'

“It’s not the story of the genius who made rent writing ‘Rent.’ It’s the genius who made ‘Rent’ spending 10 years writing the show that no one wanted to see," Miranda said about the late Jonathan Larson. Read more »

Venezuela denies visa extension for electoral observers-source

© Reuters/Ueslei Marcelino A woman holds a Venezuelan flag while participating in a candlelight vigil held for victims of recent violence in Caracas By Vivian Sequera CARACAS (Reuters) – Venezuela ... Read more »

Men's Junior Hockey World Cup 2021: India's title defence comes to end as Germans clinch dominant 4-2 win

© Provided by Firstpost Men’s Junior Hockey World Cup 2021: India’s title defence comes to end as Germans clinch dominant 4-2 win Bhubaneswar: Defending champions India’s dream of a second ... Read more »

Sri Lankan factory manager lynched and set on fire in Pakistan

© Provided by Al Jazeera Police officers stand guard at the site where a Sri Lankan citizen was lynched by a Muslim mob outside a factory in Sialkot, Pakistan [Shahid ... Read more »

ISL 2021-22: Night of Missed Chances for Chennaiyin FC in 0-0 Draw vs SC East Bengal

© Provided by News18 It was a night of missed chances but Chennaiyin FC would have felt hard done by as they featured in a goalless draw with SC East ... Read more »

IND vs NZ: Mayank Agarwal says THIS Sunil Gavaskar advice helped him score century on Day 1 of 2nd Test

© Provided by Zee News Mumbai: Indian opener Mayank Agarwal on Friday explained how he acted on the advice of former skipper Sunil Gavaskar to improve his side-on stance during ... Read more »

Line closed and 100m cordon in place after World War Two bomb found near rail track

An unexploded Second World War bomb has been found near railway tracks, leading to the delay of some train services. © Other Images of the unexploded World War Two bomb ... Read more »

Sara Sheridan to give talk on Edinburgh-set historical novel at the Botanics

Set in 1822, the novel features the Botanics’ move from its location at Leith Walk to Inverleith. © Meet author Sara Sheridan at the Botanics when she will be talking ... Read more »

Google maps sleuths spot ‘Nazi' house in the middle of a runway at Berlin airport

© Google Maps/Reddit House on airport runway Google Maps provides some extraordinary sights – and now, people are convinced they’ve spotted an old “Nazi house” at a major Berlin airport. ... Read more »

Glasgow city guide: Where to stay, eat, drink and shop in Scotland's cool capital of culture

While often overlooked by tourists seeking Harry Potter thrills in neighbouring Edinburgh, Glasgow is undeniably Scotland’s cultural heart, with the finest homegrown music scene in the country. It’s Scotland’s largest ... Read more »

Parents and teachers: what impact has the pandemic had on five-year-olds?

Photograph: lovethephoto/Alamy We would like to hear from parents and teachers about how this age group is coping We would like to hear about the impact the pandemic has had ... Read more »

Haiti cops caught soldier in stolen car. His fast release raises questions of unequal justice

The two armed men were on a mission. It was either to steal Widlore Mérancourt’s gray Suzuki Vitara, to kidnap him or to do both. As they drove him around ... Read more »

Biden announces ‘free' at-home Covid tests – but there's a catch

Biden announces ‘free’ at-home Covid tests – but there’s a catch Americans with private medical insurance will be able to have the costs of at-home Covid-19 testing kits reimbursed by ... Read more »

U.S. to not reimburse private health insurers for covering at-home COVID test costs

U.S. FDA authorizes first COVID-19 test for self-testing at home WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. government will not reimburse private health insurance companies for covering the cost of at-home COVID-19 ... Read more »

Ex-State Dept. employee sentenced for embezzling $150k in travel funds for SOUTHCOM events

A former State Department employee was sentenced to more than a year’s imprisonment Dec. 1 for his role in defrauding the department and the Defense Department of $150,000 through his ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic