The two Michaels are free. Could a Canadian locked up in China for 15 years be next?

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Family/Handout Huseyin Celil is seen in this still from a family video during a citizenship ceremony in 2005.

Missing. Lost. Forgotten.

These are some of the words Kamila Telendibaeva uses to describe her husband, Huseyin Celil. Celil is a Canadian citizen who has been imprisoned in China since 2006, and who has been barely heard of ever since.

Telendibaeva had all but given hope that her husband, and the father of her four children, would ever be released. But now, with Michael Spavor and Michael Kovrig safely back in Canada, she has newfound hope there will finally be a development in her husband’s case as well.

“I was really happy when the two Michaels landed in Canada,” she told Global News. “I’m very positive for Huseyin’s case now. I’m very positive. I’m looking forward to bringing him home.”

Celil had long been an outspoken advocate for the Uyghur people.

The Uyghurs are a minority group in China who live primarily in the western province of Xinjiang and in neighbouring Central Asian countries. China accuses Celil of being a separatist and a terrorist, and sentenced him to life in prison in 2007. That sentence has since been commuted to 18 years in prison.

Video: Hostage Diplomacy: The forgotten Canadian imprisoned in China

China had even jailed him for his outspokenness in the 1990s. But his wife says his only crime was speaking out for the rights of the Uyghur people.

“He didn’t hurt anyone, any Chinese or any human being,” she told Global News. “He just had strong speech, strong speech.”

In 2006, five years after first arriving in Canada, Celil travelled back to Uzbekistan with his wife to visit family. He was detained by Uzbek authorities and then taken to China, where he has been in prison ever since. Canadian consular officials have not had any access to him, and neither has his wife, who has struggled to raise their four children by herself in Burlington, Ont.

“I was alone without family here, with no one. I raised four kids,” Telendibaeva said between sobs. “It’s been devastating, it’s been really hard.”

‘We see a real opportunity’

Chris MacLeod, the lawyer who has been representing Telendibaeva since her husband was first arrested, says the release of the Michaels, coupled with the upcoming Beijing Winter Olympics, presents a golden opportunity for Celil’s case to finally get resolved.

“Obviously, the chill with Canada-China relations has been lifted to some extent with the return, or the release, of (Huawei CFO) Meng (Wanzhou) and the return of the two Michaels,” MacLeod says. “So that provides a fresh opportunity to look at Huseyin and his release and return.”

The Olympics, MacLeod says, gives China the chance to put its best face forward to the rest of the world and to “showcase to the world the better faith of your country which all countries do when they host the games.”

And there is a bit of momentum following the Michaels’ release. MacLeod told Global News that he has had some communication with Canadian officials since the release and safe return of Spavor and Michael Kovrig.

“They said they’re on (Celil’s case) and that (the case is) of concern and interest.” But, he adds, “the proof is in the pudding.”

Until now, Ottawa has struggled to make Celil’s case much of a priority.


Video: The two Michaels are back on Canadian soil (Global News)

In February 2020, Canada’s then newly appointed ambassador to China, Dominic Barton, struggled to remember the case of Huseyin Celil when asked about it at a House of Commons committee meeting. Barton had to be corrected when he stated that Celil was not a Canadian citizen (he is).

And unlike Spavor and Kovrig, most Canadians have never heard the name Huseyin Celil.

Dual nationals

Alex Neve, the former secretary-general of Amnesty International Canada, is one of the foremost authorities on human rights abuses around the world. He says the Celil case “is absolutely one of the most egregious, if not the most egregious instance of long-term imprisonment of a Canadian citizen on completely unjust grounds, that has gone on far, far too long.”

One of the issues that has hampered action on the case, Neve says, is the fact that Celil is a dual national. China, which does not recognize dual citizenship, considers him one of its own, even though he was granted Canadian citizenship 20 years ago. His status as a dual national, Neve fears, is one of the reasons Celil’s case hasn’t risen to the top, or attracted as much attention as other Canadians who have been imprisoned in China in the past, including the two Michaels, or Kevin and Julia Garratt before them.

“Dual national Canadians often feel like they aren’t given as much high-level concern and attention as Canadians who don’t have dual nationality,” Neve said. “We just don’t see their cases rise to the top of the list, and it’s impossible to deny that to a certain degree, there’s an aspect of racism that underlies that.”

Celil is not the only Canadian, or the only one with dual citizenship, jailed in China.

There are around 115 Canadians in Chinese prisons. They include Canadian citizens like pro-democracy advocate Wang Bingzhang, whose case of arrest and detention bears some striking similarities to Celil’s. Wang, like Celil, was promoting ideas that offended the Chinese regime. He’s been in jail for two decades.

‘They are not forthcoming’

In the absence of successful efforts by Western governments to secure the release of their citizens in China, some individuals have stepped forward to nudge foreign countries toward leniency.

John Kamm is one of those people – a former chemical salesman-turned-China human rights defender who has advocated for thousands of people caught up in the Chinese legal juggernaut.

Kamm heads up a San Francisco-based not-for-profit organization called The Dui Hua Foundation. Dui Hua means “dialogue” in Chinese.

He says China’s tactic of keeping cases out of sight and out of mind is very deliberate and strategic.

“They are not forthcoming,” he told Global News.

Kamm and his organization keep meticulous records of all the various foreign detainees held in Chinese prisons. This includes Celil. Over the years, Kamm has managed to communicate with Chinese officials and to secure concessions for many of those detained.

“I never make things personal. I never attack Chinese officials by name.”

He says it is very difficult to tell to what extent releasing prisoners is a priority for China.

In Canada, new data shows that public opinion toward China is falling — fast. According to an Angus Reid survey released on Oct. 7, just 10 per cent of Canadians have a “favourable” or “very favourable” view of China, compared with 38 per cent who saw China in a positive light before the Michaels were arrested, and 58 per cent who had a similar feeling in 2005.

Moreover, the percentage of Canadians who believe that Canada should stick to its principles with respect to the rule of law and human rights has increased 14 points since 2019, according to the same survey.

But negative public perception of China by citizens of other countries has not fazed Beijing too much, according to Kamm. China, like other countries, has its reasons for doing what it does, and negative attention did not count for much in the depths of the Meng Wanzhou-two Michaels crisis. Beijing, he said, was always in it “for the long haul.”

The trouble with China, Kamm says, is that there is very little transparency, so it’s hard to tell what’s really going on.

“It’s very hard to ascertain exactly what it is that motivates the Chinese government to do what it does,” he said.

“They certainly want to keep you guessing.”

—with files from Jeff Semple 

See this and other original stories about our world on The New Reality airing Saturday nights on Global TV, and online at globalnews.ca.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Priyanka Chopra gets teased by Parineeti Chopra for her love for heels, check out her post

© Provided by Hindustan Times Parineeti Chopra and Priyanka Chopra pose together. Actor Parineeti Chopra has re-shared a picture in which a person wore heels even as she hurt her ... Read more »

Dharmendra turns 86: Sunny, Bobby and Esha Deol shower him with wishes

© Provided by DNA Veteran Bollywood actor Dharmendra, who has worked in more than 100 movies so far, on December 8 turned 86. On the special occasion, Sunny Deol, Bobby ... Read more »

Sikkim to allow entry of foreigners carrying negative RT-PCR report

© Provided by Hindustan Times The state till Tuesday has reported 405 deaths due to Covid 19 and 32,382 positive cases out of which 31,438 have recovered. (HT Photo) Sikkim has ... Read more »

CAT Answer Key 2021: IIM Ahmedabad releases CAT answer key, response sheet at iimcat.ac.in today; here's how to download

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Education Desk: Common Admission Test, CAT answer key 2021 along with response sheet has been released by the Indian Institute of Management, ... Read more »

Maid abusing employer's elderly mother caught on CCTV

© The Independent Singapore Warning: Readers may find some of the detailed descriptions in the content of this article disturbing. Singapore — A domestic helper who treated the 76-year-old mother ... Read more »

Will Katrina Kaif Be A Sabyasachi Bride Like Anushka Sharma, Priyanka Chopra And Deepika Padukone?

Everyone is waiting with bated breath for Katrina Kaif’s bridal look. Will she choose Sabyasachi over other designers like the following celebrity brides? (Image: Instagram) Priyanka Chopra looked stunning in ... Read more »

'Riverdale' and 'Sabrina' Crossover: Kiernan Shipka Explains That Bewitching and Confusing Cameo (Exclusive)

© The CW Sabrina came from Greendale to Rivervale — and not Riverdale? Looks like someone needs to adjust their broomstick’s GPS! ET is mapping out everything you need to know ... Read more »

Saudi Crown Prince arrives in Abu Dhabi on two-day state visit

© Motivate Publishing Prince Mohammed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz and Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan Prince Mohammed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz, Saudi Crown Prince, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister ... Read more »

Music streaming: The war over rights and remuneration

Musicians don’t often make a sustainable income through streaming songs on music platforms, according to a report by MPs. Should the industry change from within, or is government intervention needed? ... Read more »

DBS' suffers digital bank service glitch; MAS mulls taking supervisory action

© Provided by Singapore Business Review DBS Country Head Shee Tse Koon has apologised for the disruptions. DBS’ online banking services have faced disruptions for two days, pushing the Monetary ... Read more »

Tokyo pushes ahead with same-sex marriage plan

The Tokyo Metropolitan government will start a system that effectively allows same-sex marriage in Japan’s capital from April next year, the Kyodo news wire reported Tokyo Gov. Yuriko Koike as ... Read more »

LOL! Brooke Shields Jokes Daughter Grier, 15, Is in the 'A--hole' Stage

© Provided by US Weekly Brooke Shields And Daughter Grier Teen time! Brooke Shields’ eldest daughter, Rowan, is in her freshman year at Wake Forest University, but her 15-year-old daughter, ... Read more »

True Colours Film Festival 2021 includes award-winning works featuring people with disabilities, all free to stream

The True Colours Film Festival (TCFF) has returned with 10 features, 20 short films, and four dialogues, all available for streaming for free across Asia. Celebrating diversity and inclusion, the ... Read more »

Biden confronts Putin over Ukraine in high-stakes meeting

President Joe Biden told Russian President Vladimir Putin during a video meeting on Tuesday that the United States “would respond with strong economic and other measures in the event of ... Read more »

British PM under fire over video of staff joking about lockdown party

© Daniel LEAL British Prime Minister Boris Johnson faces questions about the reported party at Downing Street last year in breach of Covid restrictions British Prime Minister Boris Johnson was ... Read more »

Hyundai invests $530 million to bring elective vehicles to India

© Provided by Al Jazeera Hyundai will launch its first EV in India in 2022 [File: Kim Hong-Ji/Reuters] South Korea’s Hyundai Motor Co plans to invest 40 billion rupees ($530m) ... Read more »

Will Jordan opens up on competition for All Blacks fullback spot

All Blacks star Will Jordan has opened up on being denied the chance to play at No 15 for New Zealand by incumbent fullbacks Jordie Barrett and Damian McKenzie. © ... Read more »

Trotz Enttäuschungen mit gutem Gefühl nach Manchester

© KEYSTONE/THOMAS HODEL Die Young Boys beenden am Mittwoch die zweite Champions-League-Gruppenphase ihrer Vereinsgeschichte. Um den Weg in der Europa League fortzusetzen, benötigen sie einen Exploit bei Manchester United. So ... Read more »

'Panibagong Investment!' Neri Naig Adds Condo Unit To Her Business Ventures

Almost two months since welcoming her second child, celebrity mom Neri Naig shares another blessing she received this year — a new condo property. The “wais na misis” took to ... Read more »

Millennial Money: How to holiday shop at the last minute

On Location: December 7, 2021 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press Supply chain snags. Sold-out merchandise. Empty shelves. Hefty shipping fees. Inflation. There are plenty of ... Read more »

Closing arguments set in actor Jussie Smollett's trial

The Associated PressActor Jussie Smollett departs Tuesday, Dec. 7, 2021, with his mother Janet, the Leighton Criminal Courthouse after day six of his trial in Chicago. Closing arguments are scheduled ... Read more »

Scott Peterson faces new life sentence in wife's 2002 death

FILE – This Nov. 29, 2021 photo from the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, shows inmate Scott Peterson, who was convicted for the 2002 murders of his pregnant wife ... Read more »

India's SII to halve output of AstraZeneca vaccine as demand sinks - CNBC-TV18

FILE PHOTO: Adar Poonawalla, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Serum Institute of India poses for a picture at the Serum Institute of India, Pune NEW DELHI (Reuters) – Serum ... Read more »

Hempfield man's appeal in wife's murder rejected for 3rd time

Dec. 8—A Hempfield man's third appeal of his first-degree murder conviction for the 2012 killing of his wife has been rejected by a Westmoreland County judge. Common Pleas Court Judge ... Read more »

Major outage at Amazon disrupts businesses across the US

1 / 7Amazon OutageThe Amazon Spheres on the company’s corporate campus are shown near the Space Needle in downtown Seattle, Tuesday, Dec. 7, 2021. Amazon Web Services suffered a major ... Read more »

Matt Gaetz says he's talked to Trump about making the former president Speaker of the House if Republicans win a majority

In this Oct. 27, 2019, file photo President Donald Trump, right, accompanied by Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., left, arrive for Game 5 of the World Series baseball game between the ... Read more »

Bihar Panchayat Elections 2021: Voting begins for 10th phase

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Voting for the 10th and the second last phase of the Bihar Panchayat Elections 2021 has begun across the state on Wednesday (December ... Read more »

Bengaluru: At least one dead, several hurt after speeding Mercedes crashes, causes pile-up in Indiranagar

© Provided by Firstpost Bengaluru: At least one dead, several hurt after speeding Mercedes crashes, causes pile-up in Indiranagar One person was killed while at least six others were injured ... Read more »

Reliance Industries jumps 2% on JV with Abu Dhabi Chemicals

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) share price jumped as much as two percent on Wednesday after the oil-to-retail-tech conglomerate said it will partner with Abu Dhabi Chemicals ... Read more »

Gold price today: 10 grams of 24-carat gold sold at Rs 47,820; silver touches Rs 61,900 per kg

© Provided by Firstpost Gold price today: 10 grams of 24-carat gold sold at Rs 47,820; silver touches Rs 61,900 per kg The price of 10 grams of 24-carat gold ... Read more »

Stranger sexually assaults, robs woman walking home in NYC

A woman was attacked in New York City by a stranger while walking home, as the suspect crept from behind and covered her mouth before touching her. DCPI A stranger ... Read more »

PICS: Rashmika Mandanna poses with radiant smile & Vijay Deverakonda flaunts cool gym look as they get papped

Rashmika Mandanna and Vijay Deverakonda were spotted yesterday as they were stepping out of the gym. VD was papped with his face covered with a  mask while Rashmika Mandanna seemed ... Read more »

Indian Railways maps the way to bridge widening gap in capex and revenues

© Jocelyn Fernandes Indian Railways maps the way to bridge widening gap in capex and revenues The Indian Railways (IR) does not internally generate even 5 paise of every rupee ... Read more »

Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif's haldi at noon, couple gets ready for ceremony

Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif’s haldi will take place at 11.30 am today, December 8. Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif’s big wedding is just one day away. The couple’s haldi ... Read more »

Twitterati Ask Tharoor 'Which God's Devotees Are Trolling Him?' Congress MP Replies

© Surabhi Shaurya | India.com News Desk Shashi Tharoor poses with bridegroom at a wedding New Delhi: A picture of senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor standing beside bride and groom ... Read more »

Sun may set for BJP leaders who don't toe party line — Amit Shah's ‘signal' for Vasundhara Raje

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: With the Rajasthan assembly elections due in 2023, Union Home Minister Amit Shah is already doing some damage control in the state BJP, ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal wedding: From SRK to Akshay Kumar; here's a list of those who've been invited

© Provided by Firstpost Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal wedding: From SRK to Akshay Kumar; here’s a list of those who’ve been invited The who’s who will be attending Katrina ... Read more »

Happy Birthday Dharmendra and Sharmila Tagore: Duo's Iconic Movies Everyone Should Watch in Their Lifetime

© Provided by News18 Legendary superstars Dharmendra and Sharmila Tagore share their birthdays on December 8. Dharmendra and Sharmila have had remarkable careers in the film industry, individually. Moreover, they ... Read more »

Shriram Properties IPO to open today; should you subscribe?

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Shriram Properties’ IPO to raise Rs 600 crore will hit Dalal Street on Wednesday, December 8. The IPO of Shriram Properties, a Shriram Group residential realty ... Read more »

Omicron among 2021's most mispronounced words

© Getty Images Singer Billie Eilish’s surname is pronounced “EYE-lish” If you’ve been stumbling over how to say “Omicron” or the pop singer Billie Eilish’s last name, you’re not alone. ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic