The 'sustainable' investing fad is based on a Wall Street-created myth

Asia's Tech News Daily

The 'sustainable' investing fad is based on a Wall Street-created myth
© Provided by Business Insider There is no empirical evidence that investing in ESG funds helps mitigate climate change. Samantha Lee/Insider

  • The latest investing fad is environmental, social, and governance funds that invest in “responsible” companies.
  • But there is no evidence that ESG funds help mitigate climate change.
  • Investors and the SEC should be wary of thinking these funds help the environment.
  • Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School.
  • This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.

Investing fads are nothing new. For example, in the 1990s the stock market was caught up in the dot-com bubble – a massive speculation spree where investors flocked to any and all stocks related to the internet. Eventually the fad faded, the bubble burst, and investors lost approximately $5 trillion.

The latest fad in investing is environmental, social, and governance (ESG) funds. The purpose of these funds is to invest in “responsible” companies as a way to push for social change – particularly for the purpose of mitigating climate change – while at the same time earning market returns. But the problem with this fad when it comes to climate change is that there is no empirical evidence backing up the idea at their core. In fact it seems fairly clear that an investment strategy of overweighting portfolios with securities of companies that produce a relatively low level of carbon emissions has no impact on mitigating climate change. The world just keeps spewing out emissions in spite of the rapid growth and level of investment in ESG funds.

ESG investing doesn’t mitigate climate change

People that understand the data on ESG acknowledge the lack of a connection between the popularity of the products and attaining their supposed goals when it comes to climate change. In a recent LinkedIn post by noted finance professor Alex Edmans of the London Business School, he agreed with my comment “that ESG investing doesn’t mitigate climate change.”

In another comment, Ashley Hamilton Claxton, the head of Responsible Investment at Royal London Asset Management, wrote, “ESG data is not data, it’s opinion. We can’t and shouldn’t claim direct impact in secondary markets. Investors are one cog in the wheel that turns the global economy. You can’t change the world or fix climate change by buying and selling shares and bonds.”

This understanding is also shared by Bill Gates, Boston College professor Alicia Munnell, and former BlackRock chief investment officer for sustainability Tariq Fancy, among others.

The idea behind ESG’s impact on climate change is that by moving money away from companies that spew fossil fuels, the funds can effectively make it cheaper for “clean” companies to raise money either through debt or equity offerings and more expensive for “dirty” companies. This sounds good in theory, but does not hold up in reality because the major effects of ESG funds are on the secondary market, where securities are traded but no new money is being raised. As explained by Fancy, investing in ESG funds does not provide new funding for those companies that would help mitigate climate change. “Instead, the money goes to the seller of the shares in the public market.” Basically, ESG products are buying stock in companies from other asset managers, not the underlying businesses, so they aren’t directly funding these firms at all.

Moreover, there are still plenty of investors out there who are willing to invest in the securities of high carbon emissions companies, allowing those companies to raise new funds at less-than-onerous rates. For example, if ExxonMobil, a company under attack for its policy of refusing to move into low carbon energy production and lobbying against legislation to mitigate climate change, were to make a $2 billion debt offering with a maturity of 30 years, it would probably only have to pay an interest rate of around 3% per year.

So, what’s with the ESG fad?

If ESG funds do not mitigate climate change, what is the motivation for marketing these funds to investors? The simple answer is that the investment industry, which includes large investment advisers, rating agencies, index providers, and consultants, makes a lot more money when investors purchase shares in ESG funds versus plain vanilla index funds where the management fees sometimes approach zero.

Of course, investors have a right to invest in anything they want, including the latest investment fad. However, in doing so, it is important for them to understand that investing in ESG funds will not result in the mitigation of climate change. What they are getting for their money are investment funds with higher management fees and potentially higher levels of unsystematic risk – due to a lack of diversification – relative to comparable non-ESG funds.

Finally, the SEC is moving forward on a proposed rule that will require a broad range of mandatory climate change disclosures, facilitating the providing of ESG ratings and the creation of ESG funds. For this to take place, the SEC must not only determine that it has legal authority to do so under the applicable legal statutes, which I discuss in my recent comment letter to the SEC, but also whether it wants to use its discretionary rule-making power in this regard.

In coming to a decision on the use of its discretion, I suspect that at least some of the SEC commissioners will be influenced by the presumption that by requiring mandatory climate change disclosures they are going to somehow help mitigate climate change. The incorporation of this presumption may encourage those commissioners to test the limits of their legal authority.

However, before doing so, I urge each commissioner to take a critical look at the empirical evidence – not just the marketing hype that is coming out of the investment industry. If they can find good empirical evidence demonstrating that investment in ESG funds provides a significant benefit in mitigating climate change, then it may be appropriate, depending on what the law allows, for the SEC to take a broad based approach to its new disclosure rules.

However, I doubt such empirical evidence actually exists, requiring the SEC to take a more restrictive approach in promulgating a new rule on climate change disclosures. In sum, before investors dive into ESG investing and regulators approve new rules that support such investing, I hope all parties take into consideration that such investing will not mitigate climate change.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Tiga lelaki termasuk anak dan bapa didakwa membunuh

© Provided by Sinar Harian IPOH – Tiga lelaki termasuk dua beranak didakwa di Mahkamah Majistret Ipoh pada Rabu atas pertuduhan membunuh seorang lelaki berusia 29 tahun, minggu lalu. Bagaimanapun ... Read more »

Industri penerbangan dijangka pulih 2025

© Provided by Sinar Harian SHAH ALAM – Industri penerbangan awam yang merosot ekoran penularan Covid-19 dijangka kembali pulih menjelang 2025. Selain itu, Perdana Menteri Ismail Sabri Yaakob berkata, projek ... Read more »

UAE beat Syria in FIFA Arab Cup opener

DOHA, 30th November, 2021 (WAM) — The United Arab Emirates beat Syria 1-0 in their FIFA Arab Cup in Ras Abu Aboud Stadium here tonight. Caio Canedo opened the game ... Read more »

We will be testing attendees for COVID-19 everyday - Rage Festival organiser

© Provided by CapeTalk Organisers of the Matric Rage festival which kicked off in Balito in KwaZulu-Natal on Tuesday said they are closely monitoring the developments around the new COVID-19 ... Read more »

'Afrocensus' results: What is it like to be Black in Germany?

© Provided by dw.com Last Friday in Berlin’s Fennpfuhl district, Adegbayi B. was out with his one-year-old daughter when a woman suddenly spat at him and began shouting racist insults. ... Read more »

Gauteng epicentre of COVID infections as SA records 4,373 new cases

© AFP Patients are seen lying on hospital beds inside a temporary ward dedicated to the treatment of possible COVID-19 coronavirus patients at Steve Biko Academic Hospital in Pretoria on ... Read more »

Camilo Opens Up About Becoming a Father for the First Time (Exclusive)

© Arturo Holmes/Getty Images Camilo couldn’t be more excited to become a father. The 27-year-old Colombian singer, who is expecting his first child with wife Evaluna, might feel “clueless” about ... Read more »

Follow these renovation dos and don'ts to get more bang for your buck if or when you decide to sell your home

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) *This article first appeared in our latest Home Improver digital magazine If you’re thinking of doing renovations without spending an absolute fortune, what is ... Read more »

Aspen licensing deal secures supply of J&J vaccines to Africa

© Provided by SowetanLive Aspen Pharmacare has signed a deal to license Johnson & Johnson’s (J&J) Covid-19 vaccine in SA, opening the way for increased supply of vaccines to Africa. ... Read more »

PBA begins EASL tie-up by sending teams to $1M HK tournament

© Provided by SPIN.ph EMBRACING the growing concept of global basketball, the PBA formally joined the East Asia Super League (EASL) where its teams will compete  against squads representing the top leagues ... Read more »

India asks states to step up COVID testing over Omicron

India’s Ministry of Health says the states should ramp up COVID-19 testing as the world battles the new coronavirus variant Omicron, while some cities have delayed the reopening of schools ... Read more »

Lakers overcome 'unexpected' LeBron absence to get back at Kings

© Provided by SPIN.ph SACRAMENTO, California — Anthony Davis scored 25 points, Russell Westbrook added 23 and the Los Angeles Lakers overcame the absence of LeBron James to beat the ... Read more »

Prickly present: dancing cactus toy that raps in Polish about cocaine goes viral

A word of warning before you go toy shopping this Christmas: beware the rapping cactus. The toy, marketed as educational, may teach your children more than you want them to ... Read more »

PBA formalizes multi-year partnership with East Asia Super League

SBP President Al S. Panlilio, EASL co-founders and top officials Henry Kerins and Matt Beyer, PBA Chairman Ricky Vargas, and PBA Commissioner Willie Marcial The Philippine Basketball Association (PBA) has ... Read more »

Analysis-History says expect strong December for U.S. stocks, despite Omicron and Fed worries

By Lewis Krauskopf © Reuters/Lucas Jackson FILE PHOTO: A man wears a protective mask as he walks on Wall Street during the coronavirus outbreak in New York (Reuters) – A ... Read more »

Pediatric, medical experts tackle COVID-19 vaccine questions, concerns during town hall

© John Woods/The Canadian Press Dr. Joss Reimer, medical officer of health and medical lead for the Manitoba vaccine implementation task force, says least 11,212 vaccine doses have been administered ... Read more »

Maruti Suzuki jumps 4% after ramping up prices of Eeco van

NEW DELHI: Shares of Maruti Suzuki gained almost 4 per cent Wednesday as the country’s largest carmaker announced an increase in prices of all non-cargo variants of its Eeco van ... Read more »

Renewable energy has ‘another record year of growth' says IEA

Photograph: Phil Noble/Reuters Renewables will account for about 95% of growth in global power-generation capacity up to the end of 2026, finds energy agency It has been another record year ... Read more »

‘Tiada apa perlu disorok', kata Dr Mahathir berhubung pajakan tanah di Langkawi

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Dr Mahathir Mohamad berkata beliau tidak mempunyai apa-apa yang perlu disorok berhubung tanah di Langkawi yang diterimanya semasa Kedah di bawah Mukhriz Mahathir sebagai respons kepada ... Read more »

Congress forges tie-up with Goa Forward, takes Tribal MLA who joined TMC in October

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Goa Forward Party entered into a formal alliance with the Congress on Tuesday following a meeting of party president Vijay Sardesai ... Read more »

Mamata Banerjee coins 'Jai Maratha, Jai Bangla' slogan in Mumbai, meets Shiv Sena leaders Aaditya Thackeray, Sanjay Raut

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee began her two-day visit to Mumbai on Tuesday (November 30) in a seeming attempt at pan-national expansion ... Read more »

A look at Sushmita Sen's inspiring fitness journey

© Provided by The Indian Express Former Miss Universe and actor Sushmita Sen has always been impressive, be it with her commanding presence onscreen or her evergreen beauty. The Aarya star ... Read more »

Delhi Girl Unable to Ride Scooty with 'SEX' on Number Plate as Neighbours Bully Her

© Provided by News18 Delhi Girl Unable to Ride Scooty with ‘SEX’ on Number Plate as Neighbours Bully Her Society is weird. People bid for number plates that make interesting ... Read more »

Shehnaaz Gill steps out in public months after Sidharth Shukla's death, visits an orphanage

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Actress Shehnaaz Gill was spotted in public months after rumoured boyfriend Sidharth Shukla’s shocking death. The former Bigg Boss 13 contestant visited an ... Read more »

Head-on | Mamata Banerjee is on the march, but electoral math of 2024 may stop her in her tracks

© Provided by Firstpost Head-on | Mamata Banerjee is on the march, but electoral math of 2024 may stop her in her tracks Is West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee ... Read more »

Historic colonial-era pistol bought at UK auction makes it way back to Indian Army

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: An antique pistol from the 1850s, which was used by the 17 Poona Horse Armoured Regiment of the then British Indian Army, has ... Read more »

Market Wednesday, Dec 1 Updates: Sensex rises by 500 pts in opening trade; HDFC twins, Tata Steel, Reliance among top gainers

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran Business Desk: Equity benchmark Sensex jumped over 500 points in early trade on Wednesday tracking gains in index majors HDFC twins, Tata ... Read more »

Numerological Predictions For December 2021

According to Numerology, December 2021 is an 8 Universal Month. A lot of new manifestations will happen during this month that will take you by surprise. The readings below are ... Read more »

As Omicron Threat Looms, Prioritise Vaccination Coverage and Boosters for Vulnerable

© Provided by News18 As Omicron Threat Looms, Prioritise Vaccination Coverage and Boosters for Vulnerable Every time someone in India (politician, media anchor or scientist) declares emphatically that we have ... Read more »

Happy Anniversary Priyanka Chopra & Nick Jonas: 6 Times the couple set the red carpet on fire with their style

Shushing all the divorce rumours, the global star Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas celebrate their second wedding anniversary today. The couple’s wedding was a grand affair that combined both Christian ... Read more »

Star Health IPO Opens Today: Price, Valuation, GMP, Key Risks, Should you Invest?

© Provided by News18 Star Health IPO Opens Today: Price, Valuation, GMP, Key Risks, Should you Invest? Star Health IPO: The initial public offering, or IPO, of Star Health and ... Read more »

Xiaomi 11i Hypercharge colour and storage options leaked, likely to launch this year

There have been rumours going around for a while about the launch of Xiaomi 11i HyperCharge in India. The smartphone is said to be a rebadged version of the Redmi ... Read more »

North Central Railway Recruitment 2021: Apply for 21 posts against sports quota

North Central Railway, RRC has invited applications from candidates to apply for posts against sports quota. Candidates who want to apply for the posts can apply online through the official ... Read more »

Pulwama encounter: Top JeM commander, IED expert among two terrorists killed by security forces

© Provided by Firstpost Pulwama encounter: Top JeM commander, IED expert among two terrorists killed by security forces A top commander of proscribed outfit Jaish-e-Mohammed Yasir Parray and an Improvised ... Read more »

People who survive severe COVID at increased risk of dying for a year

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Long Covid may lead to an increased risk of death in the year after a patient’s diagnosis, a new study finds. Researchers at ... Read more »

Mike Pence calls for abortion decision to be overturned by Supreme Court

© Manuel Balce Ceneta Former Vice President Mike Pence speaks about abortion at the National Press Club in Washington (Manuel Balce Ceneta/AP) Former US vice president Mike Pence has called ... Read more »

Covid news live: US to tighten testing requirements for all arriving travellers amid Omicron concerns

© Photograph: Remko de Waal/ANP/AFP/Getty Images Travellers seen at Schiphol Airport, the Netherlands, on 30 November as the WHO issues a Covid-19 travel warning ahead of the holiday season in ... Read more »

New Zealand joins regional effort to calm restive Solomon Islands

WELLINGTON (Reuters) – New Zealand said on Wednesday that it will deploy military and police personnel in the Solomon Islands, joining efforts by Australia, Fiji and Papua New Guinea to ... Read more »

Tak perlu bayar untuk guna MySejahtera, PAC beritahu kerajaan

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Aplikasi MySejahtera pada asalnya dibangunkan sebagai usaha CSR. PETALING JAYA: Kerajaan tidak sepatutnya membuat bayaran bagi penggunaan aplikasi MySejahtera, kata Jawatankuasa Kira-kira Wang Negara ... Read more »

Robert Irwin Turns 18: Sister Bindi, Mom Terri & More Send Him Heartfelt Birthday Wishes

© Jamie McCarthy/WireImage Robert Irwin is feeling the love! The famous animal conservationist celebrated his 18th birthday on Wednesday, in Australia, and received and outpouring of sweet messages from his ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic