The story of a cabbage patch, and power-mad metro cops

© Provided by Financial Mail

That, at least, is the view of “gangsta gardener” Ron Finley.

Finley lives in Southern Los Angeles, an area of “liquor stores, fast food, vacant lots”. 

Eleven years ago, he fell foul of the law after planting a “food forest” on the strip of land between his property and the street. 

Within a mile of his house, he had all manner of fast-food outlets (a McDonald’s, Del Taco, Burger King and Popeyes) – but he had to take “a 45-minute round trip to get an apple that wasn’t impregnated with pesticides”, he says in his 2013 TED Talk, Guerrilla Gardener (4.1-million views and counting). “So what I did, I planted a food forest in front of my house.”

After the LA police received a complaint about the garden, Finley was given a citation and then threatened with a warrant of arrest if he didn’t clear the land immediately. Instead, he decided to fight – because “planting produce, especially on an open plot of land in the middle of a food desert, should not be a punishable act”, writes Vogue’s Claudia McNeilly.

Through Finley’s efforts – and driven by councillor Herb Wesson – the city council had by August 2013 unanimously voted to change the law about planting vegetable gardens on unused strips of city land. 

Three years later, LA County went a step further, implementing tax breaks for property owners who make unused land available for farming and gardening. The resolution applies to parcels of land smaller than 1.2ha (about 1½ soccer fields) and free of toxic substances. At the time, the county assessor’s office was estimated that there were 57,000 such plots in the city.

Not to put words into Finley’s delightfully foul mouth, but “that’s a lot of mother— kale”.

Cabbages: a cautionary tale

Finley’s is a fascinating story at the best of times – and it’s worth reading McNeilly’s 2017 profile of him, as well as this more recent LA Times piece. But it’s particularly apt this week, given the spotlight on SA’s own guerrilla gardener, “cabbage bandit” Djo BaNkuna.

Since 2019, BaNkuna has used the pavement of his property, in the Tshwane suburb of Theresa Park, to grow vegetables. 

His crop of pumpkins, sweet potatoes, onions, dill and the much-maligned brassica has fed the charges of his wife, a social worker in Soshanguve, as well as neighbours, recyclers and general passers-by. Given his green-fingered success, he expanded his operation to the pavement alongside the public park across the road – with the blessing of the park manager, he says.

Then, last Thursday, two metro police officers arrived at his property to investigate a complaint. They apparently informed him that his food forest was not allowed, and that he would need to either get council permission for the operation, or remove the produce and plant grass or roses instead. How very Parkhurst.

In BaNkuna’s telling, he visited the council the very next day, only to be all but laughed out of the building at the very suggestion that there was such a permit in the first place. He was simply told, he says, that he can plant what he likes – but he does so at his own risk, as the land belongs to the city, which can do with the land as it sees fit. Fair enough.

Next stop, the metro police department, to inform the authorities there that he didn’t need permission to grow produce. Only, by his account that turned into an angry confrontation.

Come Tuesday, the metro police arrived at BaNkuna’s property to hand over a fine for infringing the national Road Traffic Act and interfering with a municipal structure, and an instruction to remove the offending cabbages by the end of the day. 

He has subsequently said he will contest the fine in court.

The story is perhaps not entirely as clear-cut as it’s been presented, and there are unanswered questions. 

For one, it’s uncertain whether BaNkuna was selling his produce. The city certainly claims so, pointing to a Facebook post in March (presumably now deleted) in which he apparently refers to charging neighbours “R10 a hand” and “grabbing” the land across the road.

But the city authorities have hardly covered themselves in glory. For a start, it’s a little unseemly to immediately trawl BaNkuna’s social media to look for dirt on him. 

Quite frankly, I don’t really care if he charged his more affluent neighbours R10 a pop to offset costs if he was feeding the poor. And to focus on this one post is to ignore the many that tell a different story. Like this one, from August: “My street garden fed eight families today, free from the soil. Sharing food makes us human, sharing food builds community.”

Or this, from April: “The capitalist in me sees cash, but my wife sees help. I am forbidden to even contemplate selling my produce, even to recoup cost.”

Then there’s the apparent show of force by the metro cops. BaNkuna writes on social media – apparently backed up by pictures taken at the scene – that as many as 16 officials and five vehicles arrived at his home on Tuesday to hand over the fine. The pictures show at least two metro cop vans there.

As for the fine itself: metro police spokesperson Isaac Mahamba told TimesLIVE on Monday that BaNkuna could be liable for a fine of between R150 and R1,500, depending on the discretion of the officer. That he was given the maximum R1,500 fine, after apparently trying to do the right thing and secure a permit, reeks of malice.

A more accommodating approach

There’s little doubt that BaNkuna’s vegetable garden violated bylaws and obstructed pedestrian traffic. So in many ways this is a storm in a cabbage patch. But it speaks to broader issues of land use and whether our bylaws are fit for purpose in changing times.

Consider Stats SA’s 2017 report on food security, released in 2019. It suggests 1.7-million households, or 6.8-million people, went hungry in SA that year. A full quarter of those hungry households were in Gauteng, and two-thirds were in urban areas: the poor there either lacked sufficient money to buy food, or were unable to produce their own.

But Covid reversed a 20-year decline in hunger. 

And so the National Income Dynamics-Coronavirus Rapid Mobile Survey shows that 47% of SA households ran out of money for food in April last year; between May and June, 21% reported that someone had gone hungry in their home in the previous seven days, and 15% reported that a child had gone hungry.

Given the urban-rural breakdown in the Stats SA report, I’m assuming most of those who went hungry were in urban areas. Places, perhaps, like Tshwane, where a well-placed, well-meaning and free vegetable garden could make all the difference – particularly in the face of staggering government inaction.

I don’t know when last you walked around your neighbourhood, but I’m often struck by how intentionally hostile so many pavements in Joburg seem to pedestrians: tastefully jagged rockeries; impenetrable ivy; deserts of cacti. “Food deserts”. And impassable.

If municipalities are prepared to turn a blind eye to these monstrosities, why come down so hard on BaNkuna? 

Why wouldn’t they simply help him to establish a path through his garden so he can comply with the relevant laws? Or, here’s an idea: if it is the laws that are the problem, why not amend them, as LA did, so people can grow food on unused council land and use the ground outside their garden walls more productively, in service of society.

Gardens like BaNkuna’s are to be celebrated, not ripped down, as power-crazed metro police would presumably prefer. As Finley would succinctly say, we should all just “plant some shit”.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Ex-EastEnders actress Luisa Bradshaw-White shares bizarre new career venture after quitting soap

Ex-Eastenders star Luisa Bradshaw-White has moved on from her role as an actress to pursue hosting dance classes. The 46-year-old confirmed that she’d be taking on this new gig on ... Read more »

‘He is free to decide' – Guardiola opens exit door for Sterling

© PA Images Pep Guardiola after substituting Raheem Sterling Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola says Raheem Sterling is free to leave the club after the England star said he would ... Read more »

Ricciardo hoping Turkey troubles won't spill over to Austin

© PA Images Daniel Ricciardo in the paddock at the Turkish GP. The Turkish Grand Prix did not go to plan for Daniel Ricciardo and McLaren, but he is not ... Read more »

Political party leaders campaigning across the country 15 days before elections

© @Action4SA/Twitter. Action SA leader Herman Mashaba hangs a poster during the launch of the party’s election campaign on 9 September 2021. JOHANNESBURG – Political party leaders are campaigning across ... Read more »

France marks 1 year since the assassination of Samuel Paty

© Provided by Paty’s killing stunned France and French educators, who have long emphasized the nation’s officially secular values French leaders planned a day of commemoration in Paris on ... Read more »

South African teams in United Rugby Championship can kick doom, gloom into touch

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) CONTEXT, understanding and a bit of patience. That has to be the message to the South African rugby public when it comes to the ... Read more »

Albert Tuisue exclusive interview: Why I can forgive the racists

© Provided by The Telegraph Albert Tuisue – FRED ELLIS In the recent marketing for London Irish’s ticket subscription packages you’ll find an image of Albert Tuisue; arms crossed, biceps ... Read more »

Meet the former Merry Hill shop worker that now runs award-winning boutique in shopping centre

A former Merry Hill shopworker is now running her own award-winning business in the Brierley Hill shopping centre. Victoria Salisbury-Scott, from Shropshire, found a love for retail after shunning a ... Read more »

Ei enää valuvia sukkahousuja - muotivaikuttajan nokkela niksi pelastaa

Jokainen sukkahousuja käyttänyt tietää tunteen, kun pöksyt alkavat valua hitaasta alaspäin. © Shutterstock Ei enää valuvia sukkahousuja – muotivaikuttajan nokkela niksi pelastaa Jos olet joskus käyttänyt sukkahousuja, olet melko varmasti ... Read more »

Benitez happy to see forwards step up in DCL, Richarlison absence

© PA Images Rafael Benitez gives instructions to Andros Townsend Everton boss Rafael Benitez has praised his attacking players for stepping up in the absence of Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Richarlison. ... Read more »

Player retention is key to South Africa's success

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved The United Rugby Championship (URC) has highlighted several of South African rugby’s weaknesses and shortcomings. As experts lament a shortage of ... Read more »

Paisley's Spree festival has been a huge success with many acts still performing today

Paisley’s popular Spree festival has been a huge success after it was cancelled last year due to coronavirus. Organised by Renfrewshire Council, The Spree has helped establish Paisley as one ... Read more »

The hidden forest behind a city centre shop front - offering FREE plants

Walking through St Ann’s square, it’s easy to get lost in the the chatter of voices and the rumble of background traffic. But walk into ‘In Our Nature’ pop-up shop ... Read more »

Junge Talente in und aus Deutschland: Diese Designer:innen sollten Sie jetzt kennen

Darunter: Ein Kollektiv aus Karlsruhe, Möbel als NFT und die Renaissance des Waschebetons. © Vaust Studio 210823 VAUST WB Series_20web.jpg Fan Collective 2020 baute das Karlsruher Kollektiv zum ins Wasser ... Read more »

Robbie Henshaw a doubt for Ireland's November series

© PA Images Italy: Italy vs Ireland Ireland have been dealt a blow prior to the Autumn Nations Series with Leinster boss Leo Cullen revealing that Robbie Henshaw has picked ... Read more »

‘Attacking football' lure shoots Tottenham-linked manager up Newcastle order

© PA Images Paulo-Fonseca-Shakhtar-Donetsk-Tottenham-Zorro A manager known for his attacking brand of football who held a verbal agreement with Tottenham this summer has become a ‘serious candidate’ to become the next ... Read more »

Is Leclerc's status as Ferrari golden boy under threat?

© PA Images Charles Leclerc and Carlos Sainz laughing in Bahrain. Bahrain March 2021 Charles Leclerc has been Ferrari’s golden boy since joining the team in 2019, but for the ... Read more »

Local film ‘Sons of the Sea' kicks off Oscar qualifying run

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) South African film “Sons of the Sea” kicked off its Oscar-qualifying run on Friday at Ster Kinekor, Tygervalley. This is in line with the ... Read more »

Princess Diana's nieces Lady Amelia and Lady Eliza are taking Europe by storm and finally becoming full-fledged members of high society

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) The Venice Film Festival in Alberta Ferretti, London Fashion Week in Ralph Lauren and Chopard, the Miss Dior party in Dusseldorf and on the ... Read more »

Rezept: Spaghetti-Auflauf mit Fleischbällchen

Im Winter schmecken deftige Seelenwärmer-Gerichte besonders gut. Wie wäre es mit einem Spaghetti-Hackbällchen-Auflauf? © ISTOCKPHOTO Perfektes Gericht für kalte Wintertage: Spaghetti-Auflauf mit Hackbällchen ISTOCKPHOTO Spaghetti mit Fleischbällchen – ein einfaches ... Read more »

'I bought the same items from different supermarkets - there is a difference'

A shopper has conducted an investigation into supermarkets to find out once and for all which is the best value for money, and the results are quite surprising. Emma Gill, ... Read more »

Several witnesses expected to testify for state in Nathaniel Julies trial

© Abigail Javier/EWN Caylene Whiteboy, one of the three police officers accused of murdering Nathaniel Julies (16), appears in the Proteas Magistrates court on 22 September 2020. JOHANNESBURG – Several ... Read more »

'Vaccination' revealed as South Africa's Word Of The Year for 2021

© Provided by CapeTalk Up against “Family Meeting” and “Batlao Hurda”, the word “Vaccination” has come out on top as South Africa’s word of the year for 2021 The announcement ... Read more »

Kaizer Chiefs vs Chippa United head-to-head: Who has the upper hand?

© Provided by The South African Kaizer Chiefs welcome Chippa United to the FNB Stadium on Saturday with both teams desperate for maximum points on the day. READ | KAIZER ... Read more »

Our First Look At The 2022 Volvo C40 Recharge: Is It Worth $60K?

Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge Volvo C40 Recharge ... Read more »

2022 Ford Bronco Price Increase Officially Revealed

2022 Ford Bronco From Configurator 2022 Ford Bronco From Configurator 2022 Ford Bronco From Configurator 2022 Ford Bronco From Configurator 2022 Ford Bronco From Configurator © Copyright 2022 Ford ... Read more »

‘A special talent' – Mike Brown on ‘superstar' Adam Radwan

© PA Images Newcastle Falcons v Harlequins – Gallagher Premiership Full-back Mike Brown says that Newcastle Falcons team-mate Adam Radwan has the potential to be one of the game’s great ... Read more »

E se lhe dissermos que a Primark tem uma nova coleção para casa?

E se lhe dissermos que a Primark tem uma nova coleção para a casa? Corra para a loja mais próxima. E se lhe dissermos que a Primark tem uma nova ... Read more »

Decore a sua casa ao estilo escandinavo com estas dicas

Entre as principais características estão o minimalismo, a funcionalidade e a simplicidade. Parece-lhe o estilo ideal para adaptar no seu lar? Então, fique por aí. © Banak Importa Entre as ... Read more »

John Dobson happy as Stormers' immovable defence proves too hot to handle for Dragons

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – Stormers head coach John Dobson has lauded his team’s physicality in their maiden United Rugby Championship win on Friday night. In ... Read more »

Albert Tuisue exclusive interview: I can forgive the racists

© Provided by The Telegraph Albert Tuisue – FRED ELLIS In the recent marketing for London Irish’s ticket subscription packages you’ll find an image of Albert Tuisue; arms crossed, biceps ... Read more »

The Rolling Stones review, Los Angeles: How is it possible that they're still in their prime?

© Getty Images Ronnie Wood, Mick Jagger, Steve Jordan and Keith Richards of The Rolling Stones perform onstage at SoFi Stadium – Getty Images There’s a moment during the Rolling ... Read more »

Teufelskreis self-fulfilling prophecy

Beschreibt eine Vorhersage nur die Zukunft oder ist sie vielleicht sogar dessen Auslöser? © ZEITjUNG Wenn man Angst davor hat, dass etwas schiefgeht, wird es das warhscheinlich auch tun. Bild: ... Read more »

Form 2 Students Shown Sex Video During Virtual Exam

Subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest stories and updates. At the start of the pandemic last year when students turned to home-based learning, immoral hackers hopped on the opportunity to ... Read more »

Stroll: Whitmarsh brings ‘gold standard' experience to Aston

© PA Images Martin Whitmarsh on the McLaren pit wall. Belgium August 2013 Lawrence Stroll believes Martin Whitmarsh’s work at McLaren was “gold standard” and is sure he’ll have the ... Read more »

Sofas und Sessel: So wollen wir jetzt sitzen

Stil-Neuheiten © Anne Deppe OUT-objekte-unserer-tage-anne-deppe-2021-07-02-high-resweb.jpg Sanfte Woge Die erste Kollaboration von Six N. Five Objects und Objekte unserer Tage ist ein weiches Gipfeltreffen zwischen Barcelona und Berlin. „Ola“ spült Komfort ... Read more »

Former Amakhosi star Maselesele dies aged 41

© Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – Former Kaizer Chiefs star Lucky Maselesele has died at the age of 41. Details surrounding his death are still sketchy, but it’s believed that ... Read more »

Gerda Steyn eager to get Cape Town Marathon show on the road

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Cape Town – Gerda Steyn and Stephen Mokoka are the South African favourites for the Cape Town Marathon, but they will face serious competition ... Read more »

Fiorentina formulate swap plan to put Arsenal striker hunt against the clock

© PA Images Andrea Belotti celebrates with team-mate following Torino goal against Atalanta Arsenal must act fast if they are to secure a bargain striker deal in 2022 after Fiorentina ... Read more »

Solskjaer tells Rashford MBE to ‘prioritise his football'

© PA Images Marcus Rashford Ole Gunnar Solskjaer Man Utd F365 Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has told Marcus Rashford MBE to “prioritise his football” following his return from injury. The 24-year-old ... Read more »