The Schumacher Monaco conundrum that complicates F1 pole debate

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Motorsport Images Michael Schumacher, Mercedes F1 W03

With the fight for the front in qualifying being a pretty fraught affair, it’s no surprise that the driver who comes out on top wants to feel rewarded.

In Turkey, for example, Lewis Hamilton was a little bit disappointed that an engine grid penalty meant his supreme Q3 effort will never be recorded in the history books.

PLUS: F1’s missing pole winners

“Well, I still… I get recorded the pole, right?,” he asked in the press conference. “No? Ah, dammit…”

The world champion had already cheekily signed his ‘pole position’ Pirelli tyre with a special message for teammate Valtteri Bottas: “To Valtteri. Enjoy my pole trophy. Nice lap tho. 102.”

But while losing pole positions through grid penalties is nothing new in F1, and has been happening since Kimi Raikkonen lost top spot at the 2005 Italian Grand Prix with a 10-place engine drop, the implications of sprint races on the record books has been a catalyst for a growing discussion on the matter.

With F1 hosting three sprint qualifying trials this year, the shake up of the weekend format meant a two-pronged effort to set the grid for the main grand prix.

There is the traditional regular qualifying session on the Friday, and then the short 100km sprint race on Saturday.

The original plan had been for the official pole position tag in the history books to be given to the fastest driver in Friday qualifying.

However, complications caused by the FIA regulations, in that pole position is officially designated as the driver in first place on the grid, meant a change of plan and it being awarded to the sprint winner.

It’s something that Bottas does not agree with, especially as at Monza he was fastest on Friday, won the sprint – and still didn’t get pole because he took an engine change.

“I think on the sprint weekends, definitely, the fast man in qualifying should be handed the official pole award and pole position for records,” explained the Finn.

“And also in a situation like this [in Turkey], Lewis had the fastest single lap. He was technically on pole but then after he is dropped so… I don’t think it’s really fair.”

© Pole man Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes

Pole man Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

F1 chiefs are looking right now at potential tweaks to the rules to change the awarding of pole position on sprint race weekends.

But the topic of the pole record at more regular weekends is one that has ignited intense debate among fans – with many arguing that pole should simply go to the fastest driver in qualifying irrespective of penalties.

However, there are two famous examples of Michael Schumacher at Monaco that offer contrasting examples of whether that would be the right way to go.

On the positive side, handing out pole to the fastest qualifier would have put Schumacher’s brilliant lap from Monaco 2012 into the record books.

The German, who had endured a fair share of frustrations since his Mercedes comeback in 2010, finally pulled everything together that afternoon to lead the way for what would have been his last official pole.

Except Schumacher had gone into that weekend knowing that pole would never be his because he had been carrying a five-place grid penalty for a collision with Bruno Senna at the previous race in Spain.

He started sixth, with Red Bull’s Mark Webber taking the official pole after ending qualifying in second place.

Few would argue, however, that it would have been more fitting for the record books for Schumacher’s performance that day to be recognised.

© Michael Schumacher, Ferrari 248 F1

Michael Schumacher, Ferrari 248 F1

Photo by: Charles Coates / Motorsport Images

But amid the calls for poles to go automatically to the fastest man, what Schumacher did at Monaco six years before in 2006 shows the dangers of doing just that.

Back then, in the closing stages of Q3 on Saturday, Schumacher was topping the timing sheets with title rival Fernando Alonso out on track and looking on course to snatch pole.

Schumacher then famously lost control of his car at Rascasse – parking up at the barriers and, with his car wedged against the Armco, it meant Alonso could not complete the lap he needed to go top.

The session was finished and Schumacher, as the fastest man, appeared to have taken pole position.

But amid immediate accusations that Schumacher had crashed deliberately, the FIA intervened and the stewards concluded that the German had broken the rules. He was stripped of his pole position and sent to the back of the grid.

Were Schumacher to have been awarded pole position in the record books that day, even with an asterisk next to it for his grid drop, it would have always been recalled for all the wrong reasons.

What Schumacher’s Monaco examples of 2006 and 2012 show us is that there is no hard and fast rule that will satisfy everyone when it comes to awarding poles.

While most agree that the fastest on Friday of a sprint should get pole that weekend, there is not as much consensus about what happens when the sticky subject of grid penalties are included.

Should the power boost that comes from a fresh engine be cast aside and those that have swapped power units be allowed to keep their pole in the records?

Should sporting penalties be ignored – so Schumacher would have kept his poles both in Monaco 2006 and 2012?

Or should sanctions earned inside the qualifying session be taken into consideration (such as what Schumacher did or drivers ignoring yellow flags), but those handed down outside of it (engine/gearbox penalties), not count?

The latter perhaps would be a better solution, but in F1 nothing is ever completely straightforward – so don’t expect much to change very soon.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


WAC will in der Südstadt herbes 1:5 gegen WSG abschütteln

© APA Wollen bei Admira wieder jubeln: Liendl (l.) und seine Wolfsberger In der Südstadt peilt die Admira am Samstag (17.00 Uhr) am 16. Spieltag der Fußball-Bundesliga ihren vierten Saisonsieg ... Read more »

With Moscow's support, Beijing sure of success in 2022 Winter Olympics

"China is confident that it will manage to present a safe and illustrious Olympics to the world," Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokesman Zhao Lijian said Read more »

Hosts Bath ask Exeter Chiefs rugby fans NOT to wear 'disrespectful' Native American-style head dresses at tonight's match – with the visitors planning to ditch their logo as part of a re-brand

Bath have asked Exeter fans not to wear Native American-style head-dresses at the derby match this Friday night as the Chiefs review their branding. Sportsmail has seen correspondence sent to ... Read more »

Germany's new coalition promises climate revolution

© Provided by The leaders of the three parties in Germany’s new coalition government delivered an agreement on Wednesday that was heavy on climate ambition As Germany’s new coalition ... Read more »

Who can travel to Germany now that COVID restrictions are being tightened again?

© Provided by Police check arrivals at Frankfurt airport The fourth coronavirus wave is currently resulting in record infections in many European countries —including Germany. In some places, the ... Read more »

Unathi Nkayi on being fired, fallout with Sizwe Dhlomo: ‘I was silenced by Kaya'

© Unathi Nkayi. JOHANNESBURG – Broadcaster and singer Unathi Nkayi has spoken up about her verbal argument with former colleague and media personality Sizwe Dhlomo and her sudden axing ... Read more »

Ried-Heimserie ohne Zuschauer gegen Rapid auf dem Prüfstand

© APA/HERBERT PFARRHOFER Hofmann (r.) und Grüll reisen mit Zuversicht ins Innviertel Im Innviertel kommt es am Sonntag (17.00 Uhr) zum Duell zweier Tabellennachbarn der Fußball-Bundesliga. Der SK Rapid hat ... Read more »

How you can watch the 2021 Miss USA pageant from home

© Jessielyn Palumbo/Miss USA The 2020 Miss USA winner, Asya Branch, will be passing on the crown on Monday. Jessielyn Palumbo/Miss USA The 2021 Miss USA pageant will be held ... Read more »

Wales and Scotland on course to meet after World Cup play-off draw

© PA Images Aaron Ramsey and Gareth Bale celebrate a win Ukraine and Austria are standing in the way of a World Cup play-off final between Wales and Scotland after ... Read more »

Match Preview: Dortmund Face Wolfsburg After Crashing Out of the Champions League

© Photo by Bernd Thissen/picture alliance via Getty Images Borussia Dortmund return to Bundesliga play this weekend to face 6th place VfL Wolfsburg. Having failed to qualify for the knockout ... Read more »

2022 Fiat 500X gets Yacht Club Capri special edition

Fifteen years ago, Fiat released a product roadmap identifying 10 new models to appear between 2007 and 2010 that would join seven extant models across Europe and the U.S. Today, ... Read more »

Perez: "Verstappen'e yardım etmek sorun değil"

© Glenn Dunbar / Motorsport Images Sergio Perez, Red Bull Racing RB16B Red Bull, bu yıl şampiyonluk savaşında kendilerine yardımcı olabilmesi için, gridin istikrarlı ve tecrübeli isimlerinden olan Sergio Perez’le ... Read more »

Euro Paper Talk: Juventus banking on Liverpool signing star Klopp admires; Tottenham renew interest in Bundesliga striker

© PA Images German manager Jurgen Klopp celebrates Liverpool victory with fans Juventus are banking on Jurgen Klopp renewing his admiration for Aaron Ramsey and Liverpool making a bid in ... Read more »

Ooni pizza ovens are 20% off for Black Friday

© Ooni Market leading pizza oven brand Ooni is discounting its ovens and pizza accessories for Black Friday by 20% until Monday 29 November 2021. Here are our picks. While ... Read more »

Jurgen Klopp calls Ralf Rangnick 'outstanding coach'

© Provided by 90min Rangnick should be arriving in Manchester soon | Clive Brunskill/GettyImages Jurgen Klopp has lavished praise on incoming Manchester United interim manager Ralf Rangnick, describing him as ... Read more »

D-Day: Die Austria-Gremien tagen und entscheiden über die violette Zukunft

Am Freitagabend kommen Verwaltungsrat und Aufsichtsrat zusammen. Dabei geht es um die Investorenfrage und eine mögliche Insolvenz. © APA/HELMUT FOHRINGER / HELMUT FOHRINGER Um 17 Uhr beginnt die Weichenstellung in ... Read more »

F1 renews its Spanish Grand Prix contract until 2026

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Barcelona – Formula One has renewed its contract with Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya for the Spanish Grand Prix until 2026, it announced on Friday. F1 ... Read more »

Leeds United tipped to seal easy cut-price deal for international star

© PA Images Nahitan.Nandez.Cagliari.2021.TEAMtalk1 Leeds United could be given a boost in January as an update on previous transfer target Nahitan Nandez may provide them with an easy deal. Calciomercato ... Read more »

Klopp tells Man Utd fans what to expect from ‘incredible' Rangnick

© PA Images Jurgen Klopp and Ralf Rangnick during their time in the Bundesliga together Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp expects Man Utd to transform into an “organised” team under former ... Read more »

Laporta biztos a Barcelona továbbjutásában

Nyerj az Unibeten, fogadj a meccsekre kockázat nélkül! 10 000 Ft bónusz + 10 000 Ft ingyen fogadás vár Rád! Regisztrálj most!   Nehéz helyzetbe került a Barcelona a keddi, ... Read more »

‘Either you are pregnant or not' – How Man Utd interim boss Ralf Rangnick describes his exhausting Gegenpressing style

RALF RANGNICK is sure to have his Manchester United players working hard as soon as he arrives at Old Trafford. Rangnick is famed for being the brainchild behind the high ... Read more »

Kawasaki Reveals Plan To Launch 3 Electric/Hybrid Models In 2022

© Kawasaki 3 New Electric/Hybrid-Electric Models Team Green is getting ahead of the curve. Kawasaki has had a strong EICMA 2021 showing thus far, unveiling highly-revised Versys 650 and ... Read more »

Siberia mine accident: Rescuers find survivor who was presumed dead

© Provided by It was presumed that no more survivors would be found in the Listvyazhnaya coal mine in the town of Belovo Rescuers in Siberia have found a ... Read more »

No intelligence: KZN premier tells SAHRC government received no warnings from SAPS and security clusters of impending violence

Giving testimony, Sihle Zikalala said the state relied on social media and mainstream media reports in order to comprehend the scale of looting and unrest in the province. He also ... Read more »

The River Season 5 Confirmed

It is undeniable that The River is one of the most loved telenovelas across Mzansi. It is for this reason that fans will be excited to know that the telenovela ... Read more »

Nobody Baecations Like Our ZAlebs

South African celebrities who are totally smitten with each other often make public displays of affection by going on beautiful vacations together — and sharing photos with their followers. When ... Read more »

DJ Maphorisa Is Single-Handedly Carrying Amapiano Industry

There is no doubt that 2021 has been DJ Maphorisa’s year career-wise. He has been dropping hit after hit, and it is clear that he has this game on lock. He ... Read more »

WATCH: Zander Lombard loving return to form at Joburg Open

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Johannesburg — After a 2021 season he’d like to forget, in which he missed 17 cuts, South Africa’s Zander Lombard is relishing his return ... Read more »

Long-term update: Volvo XC40 is more practical than it looks

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Johannesburg – Having spent some quality time with our Volvo XC40 T4 long-term test car since it arrived in early September, we’ve come to ... Read more »

The London restaurant where you can eat an entire Christmas dinner on a pizza

When you think of Christmas, a classic Christmas dinner immediately comes to mind; cranberry sauce, stuffing, roast potatoes and a big juicy turkey in at the centre of the table. ... Read more »

Tennis: Djokovic-led Serbia down Austria in Davis Cup opener

Serbia’s Novak Djokovic in action during his match against Austria’s Dennis Novak, on Nov 26, 2021. PARIS (AFP) – Novak Djokovic sped past Austria’s Dennis Novak to give Serbia an ... Read more »

Seven best London restaurants you need to visit next year after being named the top in the UK

If you’re a foodie fan there are always going to be an array of restaurants, bars and pubs on your bucket list, but what are the top spots for London ... Read more »

These outdoor Ooni pizza ovens are 20% off & they've already got us looking forward to summer hosting

© Ooni Market leading pizza oven brand Ooni is discounting its ovens and pizza accessories for Black Friday by 20% until Monday 29 November 2021. Here are our picks. While ... Read more »

Geständnis im Fußball-Wettskandal: "Großen Blödsinn gemacht"

© Foto: APA/dpa/Boris Roessler Wien – In der Regionalliga Ost wurden mehrere Fußballspiele verschoben. Während die Untersuchungen der Staatsanwaltschaft Graz noch im Gange sind, ist einer der Beschuldigten, der suspendierte ... Read more »

Heimniederlage: Innsbruck geht gegen die Young Violets unter

In der 16. Runde der Admiral 2. Liga empfing der FC Wacker Innsbruck zum Abschluß der Herbstsaison die Young Violets Austria Wien. Nach einer ausgeglichenen ersten Hälfte zündeten die Young Violets ... Read more »

Bake Off champion Giuseppe Dell'Anno wows fans with most mouth-watering Italian recipes

This year’s Great British Bake Off winner, Giuseppe Dell’Anno, has inspired judge Prue Leith to get into Italian baking. And no wonder, if the champion’s social media pictures for his ... Read more »

Valentino Rossi Tagih Janji Honda soal NSR500

© Gold and Goose / Motorsport Images Valentino Rossi, Honda Rossi telah resmi pensiun, dengan putaran final Grand Prix Valencia menandai balapan terakhirnya di kelas MotoGP. Total sembilan gelar juara ... Read more »

Verstappen: "Şampiyonluk için savaşırken, birbirimizin işini zorlaştırmamız normal"

© Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing RB16B Bu yıl şampiyonluk savaşına giren Max Verstappen ve Lewis Hamilton, zaman zaman sert mücadelelere giriştiler. Bunlardan iki tanesi, ... Read more »

Black Friday deal! $100 off the Philips Sonicare DiamondClean toothbrush

© Provided by Live Science This Philips Sonicare DiamondClean Black Friday deal gets you 33% off. Improve your oral hygiene this holiday season with a Black Friday deal on this ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic