The really scary news in the Social Security Trustees Report

The Social Security Trustees just released their annual report on the system’s finances. The news is awful. Most people know that the system’s future benefit promises are greater than its future payroll tax (FICA) revenues. But how big is the difference – its fiscal gap, also called its unfunded liability?

© iStock The really scary news in the Social Security Trustees Report

The answer – a terrifying $59.8 trillion – is buried deep in Appendix table VIF1. That’s over 2.5 times the size of the U.S. economy. Even more disturbing is the change since last year’s report. The system’s debt grew by $6.8 trillion. In other words, Social Security ran a deficit equal to 30 percent of GDP. This is more than twice last year’s $3.1 trillion official deficit. But unlike the change in official debt, Social Security’s deficits are carefully kept off the books – for political, not economic reasons. Consequently, not a single media outlet we know of has reported these numbers.

The cause of Social Security’s massive increase in red ink? It’s not policy. Nothing’s changed there. Instead, it’s less favorable long-run economic and demographic projections. But the source of Social Security’s deficit doesn’t make it any easier to handle. The current Social Security payroll tax is 12.4 percent, levied up to the maximum taxable earnings (now $142,800). Find-it-if-you-can table VIF1 says we need a 4.6 percentage point permanent increase in this rate, raising the Social Security FICA payroll tax to 17 percent, to pay Social Security benefits on an ongoing basis.

Go back to the 2011 Social Security Trustees Report and you’ll find in table IVB6 that the system needed a 3.6 permanent percentage point tax hike to keep paying benefits through time. Hence, by this measure, Social Security’s highly troubled finances have deteriorated by an additional 28 percent in just 10 years.

Unfortunately, Social Security’s fiscal shortfall is just part of our nation’s long-term insolvency. Official debt is now 100 percent of GDP. In 2007 it was 35 percent. Then there’s our out-of-control federal health care spending. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that Medicare, the Affordable Care Act and other federal health care outlays will rise from 5.7 percent of GDP to 9.4 percent of GDP over the next 30 years. Paying for just the Medicare part of this problem requires raising our current combined Social Security and Medicare 15.3 percent FICA tax to 22.4 percent today.

Yes, half of the FICA is the employer’s share. But our bosses are lowering our net pay to cover what they need to send Uncle Sam on our behalf. Except for the politically driven bookkeeping, workers pay the entire FICA tax.

One can look at our fiscal debacle program by program. But what really matters is the overall picture. Fortunately, CBO’s long-term fiscal projections can be used to assess Uncle Sam’s overall fiscal gap – the present value of all projected federal outlays, including interest payments on official debt, less the present value of projected federal receipts. Hold your breath: The U.S. fiscal gap exceeds 10 years of GDP.

This figure is based on the government’s preferred, but quite low interest rate for forming present values. With a higher and, arguably, more appropriate rate, the U.S. fiscal gap is dramatically smaller. But so is the present value of the future tax base needed to cover the gap. No matter what interest rate you use, the U.S. needs to immediately and permanently raise every federal tax by at least one third to pay, through time, for what our government plans to spend.

The alternative? Massive spending cuts. And, no, the Federal Reserve can’t make this problem go away by printing the money needed by the Treasury. This would end where it always does – in hyperinflation.

The size of the overall U.S. fiscal gap is unknown to Americans because neither political party wants to officially calculate it. But other countries routinely measure their fiscal gaps. Indeed, the European Union does so every three years in an extensive study of long-term fiscal sustainability. None of the major EU countries has anything close to the sustainability problem we face.

Herb Stein, President Nixon’s chair of the Council of Economic Advisers, famously said, “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.” When it comes to America’s fiscal affairs, what can’t go on forever will stop too late, leaving our kids paying dramatically more in taxes and receiving dramatically less in benefits. This is fiscal child abuse, pure and simple.

Most people think our country is divided left and right. But that conflict is being hyped by politicians to hide the real war – the fiscal war they, with our adult consent, are waging and winning against our children.

John Goodman is president of the Goodman Institute. He is the author of “New Way to Care: Social Protections That Put Families First.” Laurence Kotlikoff is a professor of economics at Boston University.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Lakhimpur Kheri Violence Accused Ashish Misra Hospitalised with Dengue Symptoms, Sample Sent to Lab

Union minister Ajay Kumar Misra’s son Ashish Misra, who is currently in jail in connection with the Lakhimpur Kheri violence, has been shifted to a government hospital on suspicion of ... Read more »

‘We planted a seed': the Afghan artists who painted for freedom

Negina Azimi felt shock and fear like never before when she heard that Taliban fighters had entered Kabul on 15 August. As an outspoken female artist in Afghanistan, she knew ... Read more »

Wall Street Week Ahead: Tech giants' earnings may be another test for markets at new highs

NEW YORK: Investors are homing in on a flood of earnings reports from Wall Street‘s tech and Internet giants, as the high-growth stocks that have led markets higher for years ... Read more »

Amit Shah to inaugurate development projects in J K today, meet Kashmiri Pandits' delegation

Amit Shah to inaugurate development projects, lay foundation stone for others today in J&K Union Home Minister Amit Shah, who arrived in Jammu and Kashmir on Saturday for a three-day ... Read more »

Women in burqa, Men in salwar kameez, and artistes in hiding in 2 months of Taliban 'rule'

Mansoor Haidry, a doctor from Kabul, has been living in India for six years and runs a general store in Bhogal in the national capital. Most members of his joint ... Read more »

Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in UP: CM Yogi Adityanath

© Provided by News18 Tablets, Smartphones Distribution to Begin November End in UP: CM Yogi Adityanath Months ahead of the 2022 Assembly elections, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath on ... Read more »

COVID-19: Centre asks states to ensure upcoming festivals celebrated with 'utmost precautions'

The Centre has asked states and union territories to ensure that upcoming festivals are celebrated in a safe and cautious manner with “utmost precautions” in view of the COVID-19 pandemic. ... Read more »

Here's what I've learnt on family holidays with my three children

Georgina Fuller and family in France If you were to believe those picture perfect posts you see on Instagram of Boden-clad, peachy-cheeked cherubs in Breton tops on windswept beaches, you ... Read more »

Delhiites to take part in Kejriwal Government's anti-dengue ‘10 Hafte, 10 Baje, 10 Minute' campaign today

© Provided by The Statesman Delhiites to take part in Kejriwal Government’s anti-dengue ‘10 Hafte, 10 Baje, 10 Minute’ campaign today Once again calling Delhiites for Sunday’s weekly in the ... Read more »

Amazon's best-selling portable heater is small but mighty (and currently on sale)

Stay cosy this winter with this portable heater. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life's editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a share ... Read more »

Stock investors remain unfazed by supply-chain snarls

This was the week when supply-chain angst finally landed on media stocks while inflation sirens blared in commodities even as the pace of economic growth showed signs of cooling. But ... Read more »

The Offing review – soft-pedalled adaptation of Benjamin Myers novel

After Benjamin Myers published The Offing in 2019, one shrewd critic said if the novel were a play it would be “a classic two-hander”. On the one hand, you have ... Read more »

Smartwatches are CM Khattar's Latest Idea to Track Attendance, Movement of Govt Officials in Haryana

© Provided by News18 Smartwatches are CM Khattar’s Latest Idea to Track Attendance, Movement of Govt Officials in Haryana Haryana chief minister Manohar Lal Khattar on Saturday said smartwatches will ... Read more »

Why China and Taiwan relations are in such dire straits as Beijing flexes military muscle

© Provided by Firstpost Why China and Taiwan relations are in such dire straits as Beijing flexes military muscle Taiwan is finding it difficult to keep itself out of international ... Read more »

Dalal Street Week Ahead: PSUs, banks, auto and select financials may put up a resilient show

After testing a fresh lifetime high at 18604, the Indian equity markets slipped into some corrective consolidation within a broad range. The bulk of the previous week was spent in ... Read more »

Dhaka ties deeper than any other strategic partnership: Harsh V Shringla

Foreign secretary Harsh V Shringla said on Saturday that India remains a committed partner in Bangladesh’s socio-economic growth and development, and described the bilateral ties as “deeper than any other ... Read more »

India-Pakistan T20 world cup match against national interest: Ramdev

Yoga guru Ramdev on Saturday said the India-Pakistan T20 World Cup match scheduled for Sunday is against the national interest and “Rashtradharma” as the “game of cricket and the game ... Read more »

Power ministry comes out with rules to ensure sustainability of sector

The Ministry of Power on Saturday announced new rules to sustain economic viability of the sector, ease financial stress of various stakeholders and ensure timely recovery of costs involved in ... Read more »

How to spend 48 hours in Qatar

How to spend 48 hours in Qatar Once a pearl-diving settlement, Qatar is transforming into a country of the future with its state-of-the-art architecture and ambitious new real estate projects. ... Read more »

5 budget-friendly knife sets on Amazon, all for the home chef

Join In The Know Cooking Editor Ellie Conley as she dives into the newest recipes and food trends each week. Read more »

Indigenous Australia, holograms and the Beano – the week in art

Exhibition of the week Songlines: Tracking the Seven SistersAn epic gathering of Indigenous Australian art, on tour from the National Museum of Australia, that gives a platform to the world’s ... Read more »

10 nutritionist-approved foods that can help you feel less stressed

Certain foods can help relieve stress. (Getty Images) Stress is a somewhat inevitable part of life. At one point or another everyone will feel stressed-out, whether it’s due to work, ... Read more »

‘I used to breakdance outside Snappy Snaps in legwarmers' – Stephen Gill's exhausted farewell to photography

At the age of nine, Stephen Gill was already experimenting with double exposures and, by the time he was 12, he had created several photographic collages. In one surrealist-style self-portrait, ... Read more »

Drag racer slams into spectators in Texas; 2 children killed

KERRVILLE, Texas (AP) — A driver lost control during a Texas drag racing event on an airport runway and slammed into a crowd of spectators, killing two children and injuring ... Read more »

When is Black Friday 2021 and where are the best UK deals?

Everything you need to know about Black Friday 2021. (Getty Images) Yahoo Life’s editors are committed to independently selecting wonderful products at great prices for you. We may receive a ... Read more »

Belanjawan 2022: Tentera mungkin tak dapat lebih dana, kata pakar

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Salah sebuah kapal tempur yang ditempah Tentera Laut dalam projek bernilai RM9 bilion. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: Seorang pakar berkata, Kementerian Pertahanan mungkin tidak ... Read more »

Selling Sunset's Heather Rae Young ties the knot with Tarek El Moussa in a romantic ceremony

© Provided by Pinkvilla Selling Sunset star Heather Rae Young is officially married to Tarek El Moussa. The couple tied the knot in a romantic ceremony on October 23, Saturday ... Read more »

Chancellor unveils multi-billion pound spending pledges ahead of budget

The chancellor has announced a series of spending pledges ahead of the autumn budget this week, which include £5bn for health research and innovation and £3bn for education. © Imagebridge ... Read more »

Luzern auf dem Weg zu Servettes Negativrekord

© KEYSTONE/THOMAS HODEL In der Kolonne der Siege steht nach 10 Runden der Super League nur beim FC Luzern noch eine Null. Für die Luzerner wird es ungemütlich, wenn sie ... Read more »

2 children dead as drag racer plows into spectators

Two children were killed and several other people were seriously injured after a drag racer lost control and plowed into spectators at an event in Texas. © KSAT The accident ... Read more »

Meghan McCain stops short of ruling out run for office

Weeks after departing “The View” where she made a point of being the firebrand conservative debating anyone who stood in her way, Meghan McCain is now not ruling out a ... Read more »

They Said It: Rod Brind'Amour, Jordan Staal, and Vincent Trocheck on 5-1 win in Columbus

With their convincing 5-1 win over the Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday night, the Carolina Hurricanes improved to 4-0 on the 2021-22 season. The win was fueled by dominant special ... Read more »

U.S. envoy urges N.Korea to end 'provocations', accept offer of talks

© Reuters/POOL U.S. envoy for North Korea Sung Kim meets South Korean counterpart Noh Kyu-duk, in Seoul By Josh Smith SEOUL (Reuters) – North Korea’s recent ballistic missile tests ... Read more »

A fire broke out on a cargo ship after about 40 shipping containers fell overboard due to rough seas off the coast of Vancouver Island

© US Coast Guard Imagery captured of located containers from U.S. Coast Guard Air Station Port Angeles helicopter. US Coast Guard Around 40 shipping containers went overboard when a cargo ... Read more »

PM Narendra Modi to address the nation on 82nd edition of Mann Ki Baat today

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi is set to address the nation on the 82nd edition of his monthly radio programme “Mann Ki Baat” on ... Read more »

Afghanistan situation overflow can happen in Jammu and Kashmir: CDS Bipin Rawat

© Provided by Zee News Guwahati: Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) General Bipin Rawat said on Saturday that “overflow” of the situation in Afghanistan can happen in Jammu and Kashmir ... Read more »

COVID-19 third wave in India? Centre issues fresh guidelines

© Provided by DNA The festival season in India sees a lot of footfall of people in markets and public places, often congregating in large crowds and celebrating together. As ... Read more »

Sanders on Medicare expansion in spending package: 'Its not coming out'

Senate Budget Committee Chairman Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said Saturday that the expansion of Medicare to include dental, hearing and vision coverage is staying in the human infrastructure bill despite doubts ... Read more »

£74 million plan to replace Border Force boats to tackle illegal migration

© Gareth Fuller Money will be spent improving the fleet of boats at the Border Force (Gareth Fuller/PA) Ageing Border Force vessels will be replaced by new cutters as part ... Read more »

TV Tonights: our highlights for Sunday, Oct. 24

© Provided by WhatToWatch Will Mariette’s hopes for romance be scuppered? On TV tonight, Ma and Pop Larkin take a mini break to Margate in The Larkins on ITV, the comedian ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic