The problem with online learning? It doesn't teach people to think

to produce new knowledge, teaching to knowledge dissemination, John Dewey, How We Think, Democracy and Education, Donald Schon’s work, reflective practice, You’re Not Listening, collaborating with diverse others

Instead of asking how universities might benefit from shifting courses online permanently, we ought to ask how students might suffer from fewer opportunities for lived experience and practice. (Shutterstock)

The modern research university was designed to produce new knowledge and to pass that knowledge on to students. North American universities over the last 100 years have been exceptionally good at that task.

But this is not all that universities can do or should do. The COVID-19 pandemic has made it even easier to reduce teaching to knowledge dissemination and to obscure other, equally important, forms of education that help students be better citizens, thinkers, writers and collaborators.

These other forms of education are the cornerstone of human flourishing and democratic participation.

This is a problem.

Practical wisdom

The Ancient Greeks relied on a distinction between “knowing-that” (episteme) and “knowing-how” (techne). This was the difference between an abstract body of theoretical knowledge about an area of interest and the practical wisdom necessary to carry out a specific task.

In music, for instance, we might call this the difference between knowing what pitch means, what notes are or the other aspects of music theory that help explain how to play — and knowing how to play an instrument like the piano really well.

For American philosopher John Dewey, this amounts to the difference between an education that focuses on information and an education that focuses on habits of thinking and deliberation.

In How We Think and Democracy and Education, Dewey prioritized teaching how to solve problems over bodies of knowledge because he knew that improved thinking skills would produce better outcomes for students and for public life.

Dewey believed that acquiring knowing-how habits, like critical thinking, problem-solving and close reading, required interaction and imitation. The practices of reading, speaking and thinking were all intertwined for Dewey, and all required practice and reflection. Practising these related skills would improve our decision-making, as individuals and as communities.

The kind of imitation he had in mind — people imitating each other — is impossible in a remote setting.

Dewey also thought curiosity, along with a recognition of, and confrontation with, real problems set people in the direction of improved thinking. These were modelled by teachers through engagement and interaction with students.

How We Think also argues that teaching students habits of using language for the purposes of persuasion is a central part of education. This drew Dewey’s work quite close to classical conceptions of rhetoric, or the teaching of how to speak and write effectively (including the emphasis on imitation as central to mastering the techne of communication).

These commitments were necessarily embodied in live practice in the classroom.

Know-how compromised online

The modern research university, since the late 19th century, has tended to prioritize “knowing-that” over “knowing-how” in a wide range of different disciplines (despite Dewey’s attempt to articulate an alternative).

Urban studies and planning professor Donald Schon’s work at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology on reflective practice was an attempt to correct this over-emphasis and apply Dewey’s approach to contemporary curricula. But the emphasis on “knowing-that” persists.

Remote learning is well suited to the kinds of education that focus on abstract theoretical knowledge and not “know-how.” And this is exactly the problem with those forms of learning — and why we ought to resist being seduced by them.

Some researchers argue that the adequacy of online learning is demonstrated by the fact that a cohort of students might achieve the same grades in an online setting as in an in-person setting. This justifies the assumption that there is no significant difference in academic performance between the two settings.

But my analysis of how people learn, grounded in rhetorical studies and Dewey’s emphasis on embodied and practical forms of democratic education, and also in my own experience administering a first-year seminar program in a faculty of arts, points to the fact that it is much harder to teach (and to assess) the “knowing-how” skills that will matter more to students’ future success.

These include learning outcomes like knowing how to analyze data, collaboration with peers, self-reflection and reading and writing.

Drowning in specialized knowledge

Specialized bodies of knowledge are everywhere now, not just in lecture halls or within the ivy-covered walls of elite institutions. If you want knowledge about advanced python programming or mycology, you can find it online through a range of different media for free. This is why silicon valley gurus can question the value of a degree from an expensive university.

The threat to the university is this: boundless “knowing-that” is readily and easily available to any student because of the very same media that have made the transition to remote teaching easy. But the same is not true for the lived experience required for developing “knowing-how” habits and practices.

As we drown in ever-increasing amounts of available knowledge, our “knowing-how” forms of wisdom continue to suffer. This is true for elementary school students that need school to learn how to navigate social relationships and for university students trying to learn how to use the scientific method or perform a critical, close reading of a poem.

Careful and close readings

To teach a student how to carefully read a text, for example, is a responsibility of the university. But this feels unlikely in remote learning environments. Dewey’s focus on the importance of the interaction between student and teacher, the modelling and imitation of habits of thinking and the necessity of creative and collaborative problem solving in the classroom are all made more difficult in a remote setting.

An isolated 18-year-old, staring at a computer, can learn what a text is supposed to mean but will have a much harder time learning how to perform a careful interpretation.

It is also one of the many “knowing-how” skills that seem so broadly absent in our public culture. Close reading is akin to close listening, which is a requirement of collaboration and a precursor to self-reflection. Journalist Kate Murphy’s You’re Not Listening shows just how complex the embodied task of reading someone else can be and how important listening and reading are for success in all fields.

What we ought to ask

Instead of asking how universities might benefit from shifting courses and curricula online permanently, we ought to be asking how students might suffer from fewer opportunities to focus on “knowing-how” and ever-greater commitments to “knowing-that.”

The pandemic has shown that we need finer, more well-honed and well-practised “knowing-how” skills. Skills like: asking thoughtful questions, finding new evidence, testing hypotheses, collaborating with diverse others, critically evaluating data or evidence, performing analysis of source material and designing new methods of evaluation.

These forms of wrestling and questioning are largely lost online. They get easily replaced with rote information processing. We should worry about the outcomes associated with that shift.

to produce new knowledge, teaching to knowledge dissemination, John Dewey, How We Think, Democracy and Education, Donald Schon’s work, reflective practice, You’re Not Listening, collaborating with diverse others

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Amazon to launch 'Lord of the Rings' series in September 2022

Uruk-Hai warriors from the Lord of The Rings during the parade through the Wellington streets prior to the worldwide premier of the third and final Rings movie “Return of The ... Read more »

Nearly 5m fewer girls to be born worldwide over next 10 years

Researchers are concerned that a rise in sex-selective methods could skew demographics and hold development back. PARIS: An estimated 4.7 million fewer girls are expected to be born globally in ... Read more »

Otop Fest takes its products online

The Community Development Department is offering 20% discounts on some Otop products. photos courtesy of The Community Development Department The One Tambon One Product (Otop) Midyear Fest 2021 has returned. ... Read more »

Little Prince exhibition moves online

The online exhibition will get viewers to learn more about the classic book. museum.socanth.tu.ac.th “The Little Prince: Books, Collections And Cross-Cultural Dialogues”, which impressed readers and viewers at Thammasat Museum ... Read more »

Staying mentally strong Even psychiatrists experience Covid anxiety

Amid the coronavirus pandemic, Dr Supara Chaopricha — a psychiatrist who manages her own practice — feels that psychiatrists are not exempt from feeling stressed or anxious, which leads to ... Read more »

Place a bid on rare antiques

Some of the pieces up for auction. RCB Auctions RCB Auctions presents a timed auction for Asian antiques and decorative items on its own platform, rcbauctions.com, and also invaluable.com, an ... Read more »

Pamper mum with a Chiva-Som retreat

Photo: Kiattipong Panchee Health is the greatest gift and Chiva-Som International Health Resort has launched a retreat package to pamper mums on the occasion of National Mother's Day, which is ... Read more »

The passing of a great Jacob Desvarieux recorded more than 50 albums and helped invent zouk

Guitarist, singer and Kassav founding member Jacob Desvarieux died last month in Guadeloupe at the age of 65. Kassav, which was founded after he met with brothers George and Pierre ... Read more »

Ultimate hair-styler Dyson Airwrap makes 70s curls and 90s wavy looks an easy task

As part of a campaign for National Mother’s Day, the Dyson Airwrap styler comes in a travel pouch and is available at Dyson.co.th. Photos © Dyson Due to lockdowns and ... Read more »

Best Laptop Brands: find the best laptop brand for your specific need

The best laptop brand for your specific need is likely going to be less important than any given machine’s specific hardware, but when it comes to finding the best laptop ... Read more »

How to become a UX hero

Let’s face it, life isn’t always easy. We’d all appreciate it if things were just a bit simpler and we didn’t have to battle our way through poor experiences. In ... Read more »

A hammerhead shark baby boom near Florida hints at a historic nursery

It seems like an unlikely place for a nursery of endangered hammerhead sharks, but a recreational hot spot just off the coast of Miami may host a school of these ... Read more »

Singer JJ Lin issues legal statement refuting allegations against him over Kris Wu saga

SHANGHAI – Singapore singer JJ Lin has issued a swift rebuttal to nasty talk about him in the wake of the scandal over Canadian-Chinese singer Kris Wu, who was recently ... Read more »

McDonald's launches new Hainanese Chicken burger for National Day

SINGAPORE – McDonald’s Singapore is launching a new locally-inspired burger just in time for National Day on Monday (Aug 9). Inspired by the classic local dish, Hainanese chicken rice, the ... Read more »

Actor Joel Choo posts photo of himself with grey hair in support of #GoSilverSG campaign

Joel Choo posted a photo of himself sporting grey hair in support of #GoSilverSG. SINGAPORE – Local actor Joel Choo may be only 27, but has peeked into the future ... Read more »

Cantopop singer Anthony Wong charged with corruption for singing at 2018 opposition rally

HONG KONG – Popular Cantopop singer Anthony Wong has been charged with corruption for singing two songs at a 2018 rally held by the opposition. Anti-graft watchdog Independent Commission Against ... Read more »

Jacob Desvarieux, pioneer of Caribbean zouk music, dies at 65

Jacob Desvarieux has died of Covid-19. PARIS (AFP) – Jacob Desvarieux, the Guadeloupean co-founder of Caribbean band Kassav’ which shot to global fame in the 1980s by creating the fast-beat ... Read more »

US music fest Lollapalooza drops DaBaby over Aids comments

DaBaby sparked widespread backlash during his performance at the Rolling Loud Festival in Miami on July 25, 2021, when he was accused of spreading misinformation about HIV and Aids. WASHINGTON: ... Read more »

Celebrate the King's birthday through online art exhibition

Some of the paintings to mark the King’s birthday. photos courtesy of Office of Traditional Arts The Office of Traditional Arts at the Fine Arts Department is holding an online ... Read more »

Predators on the loose With online sexual abuse rising amid a pandemic, parents and society have a role to play in improving internet literacy in young children who are most at-risk

Going online to connect with over 1,000 Facebook friends through posts of daily activities was the lifeline Nan* craved after each school lesson. In the hopes of raking in likes ... Read more »

Somtow's Symphony Of Terror to premiere at German Sundance

A scene from The Maestro: A Symphony Of Terror. photo courtesy of Somtow Sucharitkul The Maestro: A Symphony Of Terror, a new Thai film, is scheduled to make its gala ... Read more »

Finding joy in helping others

Two years ago, Banjerd Nualiem opened his first khao kaeng (curry and rice) shop in Nakhon Pathom's Kamphaeng Saen district to offer self-service meals. The price was very minimal, almost ... Read more »

Waste not, want not Environmental groups are urging the Thai government to stop importing other countries' toxic garbage

Thailand has enough of its own e-waste to handle that it doesn’t need to import waste from other countries, environmental groups say. Photo: Ecological Alert and Recovery Thailand To generate ... Read more »

Stay-home guide for Monday: Listen to stars read poems, make your own book nooks and more

1. Listen: The Love Book App The celebrity readings are the hook, but the app offers other textual inspirations. PHOTO: THE LOVE BOOK APP Sometimes, all one needs is Tom Hiddleston ... Read more »

Tar Pau Nation: Easy, healthy meals with herbal chicken from Pokpok Keh

The Original Pink Salt Chicken Bento. Herbal chicken is one dish that can be chilled or frozen with little loss in quality when reheated. So I knew I wouldn’t go ... Read more »

Shelf Care: Sorcerer To The Crown is a Regency romp with pontianaks

Regency romance gets a post-colonial spin in this delightful historical fantasy of dragons and pontianaks. Sorcerer to the Crown By Zen Cho Fantasy/Pan Macmillan/2015/Paperback/384 pages/$18.95/Available here Regency romance gets a ... Read more »

After a chaotic pandemic school year, help kids get back on track this fall

The 2020-2021 school year was unlike any other. Millions of students spent part — or most — of the year learning remotely. After months physically away from teachers, classmates and ... Read more »

Netflix releases first look at The Crown's new queen played by Imelda Staunton

Netflix has given a first look at actress Imelda Staunton as Queen Elizabeth II in The Crown. LONDON – The fifth season of hit Netflix series The Crown started filming ... Read more »

Songwriter Roy Loi closed music school due to pandemic, now focused on his Thai eatery

SINGAPORE – Singer-songwriter Roy Loi had to close his music school Imagine Music last June due to the pandemic. Better known as Li Feihui, the 56-year-old self-professed semi-retired musician had ... Read more »

Actor Nicholas Tse says HK entertainment scene has the same old faces, including his

Actor Nicholas Tse has criticised the Hong Kong entertainment world, saying it has the same old faces and does not nurture fresh talent. HONG KONG – Actor Nicholas Tse is ... Read more »

Chinese pop star Kris Wu detained on suspicion of rape

Kris Wu originally shot to fame as a member of the K-pop boyband EXO, before leaving in 2014 to launch a successful solo career BEIJING: Chinese-Canadian pop megastar Kris Wu ... Read more »

Aardvarks and rabbits: Acclaimed American kids' show Arthur says goodbye

The show is based on the series of Arthur Adventure children’s books by Marc Brown. NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – These wonderful kind of days in a neighbourhood where aardvarks, rabbits ... Read more »

Headman steals wife, shooter on run, uncle pays for sin

Village head Samreng with his health volunteer lover, Hong. Local leader lets down the team A village headman in Buri Ram is facing calls to resign after he took off ... Read more »

Dennis Chew reveals Aunty Lucy was killed off as some could not accept the drag role

Aunty Lucy, a middle-aged woman with curly hair who loves free gifts, was known for saying “so embarrassing”. SINGAPORE – Actor-DJ Dennis Chew has opened up on why his popular ... Read more »

Teachers are feeling burned out. Artificial intelligence can help.

Educators are at the ends of their ropes. So suggests a fall 2020 survey by RAND Corp., which found that a quarter of all teachers were thinking about leaving education. ... Read more »

Vaxxers privilege: Best perks and discounts for the vaccinated

Growing array of freebies and discounts extended to those jabbed. SINGAPORE – Joining the vaccination club has many privileges. Moves to encourage people to get the Covid-19 vaccine have expanded ... Read more »

Celebrities who had secret Covid-19 babies

Actress Emmy Rossum kept her pregnancy under wraps until she gave birth in May. SINGAPORE – There appears to be a baby boom among celebrities during the pandemic. And with ... Read more »

Restaurant chefs turn to running hawker stalls in S'pore amid Covid-19 pandemic

Mr Kek Wan Fong (right) and Mr Gui Jin Keng at their stall, Qing Feng Yuan, in the Tiong Bahru Market food centre. SINGAPORE – It is not uncommon for ... Read more »

Book review: Ambitious heroines take flight in a magnificent Great Circle

Great Circle, American author Maggie Shipstead’s third novel, was longlisted for the Booker Prize earlier this week. Great Circle By Maggie Shipstead Fiction/Doubleday/Paperback/591 pages/$29.96/Available here 4 out of 5 “I ... Read more »

Heartbreak season: More couples are calling it quits amid challenges wrought by the pandemic

Travel restrictions due to closed borders brought about by Covid-19 also led to the demise of some long-distance relationships. SINGAPORE – The course of true love never did run smooth. ... Read more »