The problem is bigger than Keir Starmer – Labour's centrists have run out of ideas

These ought to be good times for the British centre left. A divisive Tory government is running into trouble. The Labour left has been marginalised. The Liberal Democrats are still recovering from their disastrous decisions in office. Across the western world, from France and Spain to Canada and the United States, politicians of the centre and centre left are in power.

Meanwhile rightwing populist regimes have performed particularly badly during the pandemic. After an exhausting, polarised few years, it is possible to believe that politics is entering a quieter, more centrist phase.

But not in Britain. Even in mid-term, and with mounting problems, the Conservatives lead Labour in the polls. Even worse, Labour has few memorable policies, an indistinct political identity and little sense of momentum. With its annual conference starting this weekend, outside interest in the party is mostly confined to the question of whether it can mount a fightback. Such a scenario – welcome though it would be – is a long way from preparing for power.

Labour’s critics inside and outside the party like to blame Keir Starmer, and it’s easy to see why. The leader’s limited political experience and stiff public persona, his narrow circle of advisers and messy party management, his disproportionate emphasis on voters in the so-called red wall, and his failure to say clearly what he stands for: all these are convincing explanations for Labour’s underperformance. Starmer’s publication of a long essay this week, to try to set out his vision for the party and the country is an acknowledgement that his leadership needs yet another relaunch.

Related: Keir Starmer’s words – and what they mean for Labour

But the focus on his mistakes and flaws misses a much bigger problem. Over the past 20 years, ever since Tony Blair’s government peaked – around the time of his final landslide victory, in 2001 – the British centre left has failed to renew itself.

The failure is especially stark because New Labour regarded the ability to change as one of the most important political skills, and prioritised “reconnecting the party to the modern world”, as Blair put it in his memoirs. However dated and discredited his project may look now, New Labour and its intellectual allies did engage seriously with how Britain and the world were changing during the 1990s. Yet since then, despite dominating Labour’s parliamentary party and bureaucracy, and receiving much more media support than the party’s other factions, New Labour’s descendants have failed to update their politics – to “modernise”, in Blairite language.

Instead of coming up with new and compelling ideas to address big contemporary issues, such as the accelerating problems of capitalism, the rise of identity politics and the sharply diverging economic interests of the young and old, Labour centrists have turned inward. Rather than also seeking to understand and shape society, they have become increasingly fixated on shaping their party.

This week Starmer announced surprise plans to change how Labour elects its leaders, makes policy and reselects its MPs – all of which would reduce the influence of party members. The plans seem an unsubtle attempt to weaken the left – which is still strong in the membership – but equally striking is their introspectiveness. While the worst Tory government for decades runs amok, Labour is fiddling with its rulebook, creating a controversy that threatens to become the main story of the party conference.

There is something perfectionist and self-defeating about this centrist desire for control. Since Blair stood down in 2007, three of Labour’s four leaders have come from the centre left – Starmer, Ed Miliband and Gordon Brown. Yet all three have been criticised by New Labour purists, including Blair himself, for not being centrist enough. As it was with Thatcher and her remaining disciples after her ejection from office in 1990, no one who heads the party after the great leader is ever seen as quite good enough.

Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership was also treated by the centrists as a time for in-fighting – rather than for reflecting on the fact that his rise was a symptom of centrism’s problems, such as its inability to speak for the young. On the rare occasions the centre-left did present an alternative vision – the leadership challenge to Corbyn by Owen Smith in 2016, the breakaway from Labour by the Independent Group in 2019 – the absence of fresh policies was telling.

This contrasted with the profusion of plans for government produced by Corbyn’s advisers and shadow cabinet. This policy glut proved too much for many voters at the 2019 election. But even then, Corbyn’s vote was still bigger than Blair, Brown and Miliband had won between 2005 and 2015. The collapse of Corbynism hid the continuing decline of Labour centrism.

Starmer’s essay does show some awareness that the centre left needs to change. Compared with the clever but euphemistic manifestos produced by New Labour, his language is blunter and his critique of the status quo harsher. He writes about “completely rethinking where power lies in our country”. There is also a new emphasis on rebalancing the relationship between workers and employers. Starmer seems to appreciate that Britain is much more unequal and troubled than during the Blair era, and that the kind of modest economic reforms New Labour promised and enacted will no longer be enough – even if he doesn’t often specify what a Starmer government would do instead.

There are a few similar, equally belated concessions to radicalism in another ambitious centre-left document published this week: Rebuilding Labour and the Nation, from the thinktank Progressive Britain (a new incarnation of the old Blairite organisation Progress). Behind its standard centrist claim that Labour can win only by appealing to “soft Tory” voters, the report also recommends that the party make “a bold offer on the environment”, to appeal to “voters on Labour’s left, who have been flirting with the Green party”. Until now, Labour centrists have complacently assumed such voters had nowhere else to go.

But anyone hoping that the centre left is finally modernising shouldn’t get too excited. Much of Starmer’s essay and Rebuilding Labour is devoted to wearily familiar centrist themes: the need for the party to be patriotic and pro-family,; to value community and “people who work hard”, and to be tougher on crime. Labour leaders have been saying these things, to diminishing electoral effect, for a quarter of a century. The Conservatives say them better.

The essay’s one big idea is “the contribution society”: a clunky phrase for the Britain that Starmer wants to create, where every adult is both a contributor to, and a beneficiary of, a partnership between socially responsible business, a protective state and vibrant local democracy. It’s quite an appealing vision – until you think for a moment about how far removed it is from reality. Britain is full of competing interests. To say it can be otherwise is either naive or a deliberate evasion in order to appeal to as broad a range of voters as possible.

Under Blair, this sort of centrist talk was a sign of confidence. Under Starmer, it feels increasingly like desperation.

  • Andy Beckett is a Guardian columnist

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


What 1,000 Pushups in a Single Day Did to This Guy's Body

Fresh off a recent video in which he performed 100 pushups and 50 pullups every day for week, YouTuber Lucas (known to his subscribers as Pigmie) upped the ante for ... Read more »

NFL DFS, Week 7: Optimal DraftKings, FanDuel daily Fantasy football picks, stacks, lineup advice

The Week 7 NFL schedule features several lopsided NFL spreads, with the Cardinals, Rams and Buccaneers all favored by double-digits. That means that game flow could be an issue for ... Read more »

Peminat AMD perlu dapatkan nombor plat Perak ini

Peminat dunia komputer pasti mengenali nama AMD, pengeluar CPU Ryzen dan GPU Radeon yang terkemuka di dunia. Jika anda kipas susah mati AMD, maka anda perlu mendapatkan nombor pendaftaran kenderaan ... Read more »

Live Score Updates, England vs West Indies, T20 World Cup 2021: Morgan opts to field, Tymal Mills returns

© Provided by Firstpost Live Score Updates, England vs West Indies, T20 World Cup 2021: Morgan opts to field, Tymal Mills returns 19:17 (IST) West Indies playing XI: Kieron Pollard (Captain),Evin ... Read more »

Australia vs South Africa, T20 World Cup Highlights: Wade, Stoinis guide AUS to 5-wicket win

© Provided by Firstpost Australia vs South Africa, T20 World Cup Highlights: Wade, Stoinis guide AUS to 5-wicket win 19:10 (IST) That’s it for this match folks! Australia won the ... Read more »

Government pledges £65m to help vulnerable renters in arrears

© PA New fund announced to help vulnerable households to pay rent during winter – PA The government has announced £65m to support vulnerable renters who have fallen into arrears ... Read more »

Trees planted in Tower Hamlets green space ahead of Queen's Platinum Jubilee

© Kirsty O’Connor Volunteers help plant a tree at Furze Green in Tower Hamlets (Kirsty O’Connor/PA) A green space in Tower Hamlets has been transformed with trees and bulbs ahead ... Read more »

'Oh my God', 'Sickens me', 'What is the point' - Lots of Leeds fans react to big Bielsa news

Many Leeds fans have taken to Twitter to Marcelo Bielsa’s decision to leave out England midfielder Kalvin Phillips against Wolves in the Premier League. © Provided by This is Futbol ... Read more »

Kate and William spotted with children at airport after Queen's hospitalisation

Kate and William have been spotted at Heathrow airport with their children after the Queen’s hospitalisation. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge were seen with Prince George, eight, Princess Charlotte, ... Read more »

Carla Abellana, Tom Rodriguez finally married

CELEBRITY couple Carla Abellana and Tom Rodriguez finally tied the knot on Saturday at the Madre de Dios Chapel, Tagaytay Midlands. Bishop Teodoro Bacani officiated the wedding, which was attended ... Read more »

West Ham predicted lineup vs Tottenham - Premier League

© Provided by 90min Things are going well for David Moyes and his West Ham staff | Chloe Knott – Danehouse/GettyImages A gruelling run of fixtures for West Ham continues ... Read more »

Bigg Boss OTT fame Urfi Javed shares her horrific and shocking experience of working in a web-series; says, 'Producer made that guy touch my legs, lift my saree'

© Provided by Her dress had a high slit and an opening around the waist area. TV actress Urfi Javed, who recently garnered popularity for her stint in Karan ... Read more »

Did Ishaan Khatter visit rumoured girlfriend Ananya Panday after he was papped buying flowers in the city?

© Provided by Pinkvilla Ananya Panday made the headlines recently after her name emerged in Aryan Khan’s ongoing drugs case. It was reported that she was summoned by the Narcotics ... Read more »

The Big Picture: Sara Ali Khan & Janhvi Kapoor engage in fun activities with host Ranveer Singh

© Provided by Pinkvilla Bollywood stars Janhvi Kapoor and Sara Ali Khan will be appearing together on ‘The Big Picture’ hosted by Ranveer Singh. Going by the promos, the trio ... Read more »

After African mediation, Eswatini king calls for calm

Africa’s last absolute monarch on Saturday called for calm and dialogue in the kingdom of Eswatini following a visit by regional mediators to try resolve the national crisis and deadly ... Read more »

Biden remarks on Taiwan leave administration scrambling

President Biden’s public remarks Thursday that the United States would come to Taiwan’s defense if it were attacked by China left White House officials scrambling to explain it did not ... Read more »

Colorado daycare owner gets six years in prison after dozens of toddlers found hidden behind fake wall in basement

The owner of a Colorado daycare was sentenced to six years behind bars, two years authorities discovered 26 toddlers stashed behind a fake wall put up in the basement of ... Read more »

Australia vs South Africa, T20 World Cup Live Updates: Wade, Stoinis guide AUS to 5-wicket win

© Provided by Firstpost Australia vs South Africa, T20 World Cup Live Updates: Wade, Stoinis guide AUS to 5-wicket win 19:10 (IST) That’s it for this match folks! Australia won ... Read more »

Grosser Aufmarsch der Massnahmengegner in Bern

© KEYSTONE/PETER SCHNEIDER Tausende Gegnerinnen und Gegner der bundesrätlichen Coronapolitik haben sich in Bern zu einer nationalen Grosskundgebung versammelt. Auf dem vollen Bundesplatz begann die offizielle Kundgebung. Redner auf dem ... Read more »

2022 Honda Civic Si revealed, Volvo C40 Recharge and more: Roadshow's week in review

Welcome to the weekend once again, Roadshow readers. It’s time for the week in review, so you can catch up on everything you may have missed that our editors worked ... Read more »

Few Watches Are More Fun or More Affordable Than Kid Cudi's G-Shock

© Photograph  courtesy Getty Images; Collage by Gabe Conte Welcome to Watches of the Week, where we’ll track the rarest, wildest, and most covetable watches spotted on celebrities. Staring at ... Read more »

West Brom team news v Bristol City as Valerien Ismael makes two changes

West Bromwich Albion boss Valerien Ismael has made two changes to the side that were defeated at Swansea in midweek in this afternoon’s clash against Bristol City. Jordan Hugill has ... Read more »

Arsenal's win over Aston Villa suggests Mikel Arteta finally finding the right balance

Arsenal jumped up to ninth in the Premier League on Friday night with a 3-1 victory against Aston Villa in the Premier League. The Gunners are blessed with superb attacking ... Read more »

‘Oh well', ‘Speechless' – Many Hull City fans react as Grant McCann names starting XI to face Luton Town

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Hull City v Swansea City Hull City travel to Luton Town this afternoon, in search of their first three points away from ... Read more »

‘Mowbray didn't really have the choice' – These Blackburn fans react to confirmed team news for Reading match

© Provided by Football League World Tony Mowbray Blackburn Rovers will be targeting a return to winning ways on Saturday afternoon, as they host Reading at Ewood Park. Tony Mowbray’s ... Read more »

Digital-driven recovery to dominate Global Aerospace Summit next year in Abu Dhabi

© Courtesy IATA The Iata Travel Pass. The International Air Transport Association says the successful trial demonstrates that technology can help travellers and governments manage health credentials. Photo: Iata A recovery ... Read more »

Climate change must not be an economic burden for developing nations, UAE minister says

© FAYEZ NURELDINE Dr Sultan Al Jaber said during a panel discussion at the Saudi Green Initiative forum on Saturday, October 23, that “the world has sleepwalked into a supply ... Read more »

Halloween is back: People are shelling out for candy, costumes, and decor after a quieter 2020

© Provided by Business Insider Drew Angerer/Getty Images Consumers are expected to spend a record $10.14 billion on Halloween this year. Spending on Halloween candy has already surged: sales jumped ... Read more »

First-time buyers will borrow a record £10billion from Mum and Dad

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo First-time buyers will borrow a record £10 billion from the Bank of Mum and Dad this year to get on the property ladder. ... Read more »

JEE Advanced AAT 2021: Results announced at; check steps and direct link here

© Provided by Firstpost JEE Advanced AAT 2021: Results announced at; check steps and direct link here The results of the JEE Advanced Architecture Aptitude Test (AAT) 2021 have ... Read more »

Delhi 'very close to winning' the battle against dengue, says Arvind Kejriwal

© Provided by Hindustan Times “We all have to work together to stop mosquito-breeding. We all have to do this for 10 weeks, and defeat dengue,” chief minister Arvind Kejriwal ... Read more »

Maharashtra CM failed to address problems faced by artists during lockdown, says BJP MLA Ashish Shelar

© Provided by The Indian Express A delegation of painters and sculptors led by BJP leader Ashish Shelar called on state Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari at the Raj Bhawan on ... Read more »

UP Government To Build Houses For Poor On Land Recovered From Mafia

© Provided by News18 UP Government To Build Houses For Poor On Land Recovered From Mafia Just a few months ahead of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections Chief Minister Yogi ... Read more »

Chelsea 7-0 Norwich: 5 talking points as the Blues maul the Canaries

Chelsea opened up a four-point lead at the top of the Premier League after thrashing Norwich City 7-0 at Stamford Bridge on Saturday afternoon following a hat-trick from Mason Mount. ... Read more »

Harrison Ford reunited with lost credit card in Sicily

MILAN (AP) — Harrison Ford lost his credit card during a stay in a beach town near Palermo, Sicily, but got it back thanks to a German tourist, police in ... Read more »

Rivaldo tells Leeds star to make Liverpool move to ‘benefit' career

Brazilian legend Rivaldo believes that his fellow countryman, Raphinha, should make the move to Liverpool to progress his career. © PA Images Rivaldo-F365 Raphinha impressed for Brazil in the most ... Read more »

Watch: Mason Mount puts Chelsea ahead with superb one-touch finish

Chelsea’s Mason Mount wowed fans with a superb first-touch finish from the edge of the box to put his side ahead against Norwich. © PA Images mason-mount-chelsea Mount, who was ... Read more »

When India and Pakistan play, it's always exciting – Suresh Raina

Speaking from his experience of the fixture Suresh Raina says that whenever India and Pakistan meet it is an exciting affair. © PA Images India-vs-Pakistan-1 Raina played in T20 World ... Read more »

'What is this', 'Jesus', 'Bring back Bruce' - Many Newcastle fans in meltdown over big news

A score of Newcastle United fans have taken to Twitter to react to the team’s line-up to face Crystal Palace at 3pm away in south London. © Provided by This ... Read more »

Cheapest autumn Europe city breaks ranked - surprising winner with just £5 for a meal

The most affordable city break spot this autumn was Belgrade, the capital of Serbia, according to new research. The Eastern European city was great value for money and offered warm ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic