The myth of generations, debunked

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Sai deSilva/Unsplash Generational divides and conflicts between Gen Z, millennials, and boomers only hold society back.

This story originally appeared in the Youth issue of Popular Science. Current subscribers can access the whole digital edition here, or click here to subscribe.

If one were to make a Generation Z mood board, it might include, in no particular order: TikTok, climate activism, autonomous sensory meridian response (ASMR), Olivia Rodrigo, Minecraft, and calling older folks out of date or “cheugy.” A unifying theme, beyond the phone-bound youth associated with these things, is the internet. Climate TikTok galvanizes the young and eco-conscious. Regular TikTok unleashes Gen Z barbs like cheugy unto the group’s predecessors, millennials (ouch). Whispered Minecraft commentary does double duty as ASMR. “Drivers License” sped through a global pandemic into the streaming-music hall of fame.

As Gen Z creates and inhabits entire digital worlds of its own, older groups may feel left out—or pushed out, if the tone set by some cultural commentators is to be taken seriously. Many of them contend that we are in the midst of a generational war, in which Gen Z dismisses Hogwarts-loving millennials as too self-obsessed to take action against the ice-cap-melting wrongs of their capitalist elders, who respond by scoffing at the snowflakery of modern youth. To which the kids say: OK, boomer.

But take an honest look at the mood board, and any credible basis for war dissipates. Generational labels are so fuzzily defined that it can be hard to tell who belongs in which camp, let alone who’s fighting with whom. (How does one categorize a 34-year-old climate justice advocate who’s definitely a Gryffindor and knows every word to Olivia Rodrigo’s Sour? Asking for a friend.) Even where there is tension—take Gen Z’s derision for cheugs—it’s no different from the contempt youth have always directed at older people. And while Gen Zers seem to prefer their phones and friends over everything else, it doesn’t mean they reject their elders and whatever wisdom they may have.

Viewing society through the lens of generational conflict is humorous at best, but it can cause real harm. “These stereotypes are not just a bit of fun,” says Bobby Duffy, a professor of public policy at King’s College London and author of the forthcoming book The Generation Myth. “They are a problem because they affect how we see and therefore deal with big issues” like climate change and social injustice. If we keep raising arms along the fabricated battle lines between generations, then divided we may all fall.

Generations are, by and large, ill defined. The simplest explanation comes from demographers and marketers: People born between roughly 1981 and 1996 are millennials, while Gen Z falls between 1997 and 2012.

But birth year isn’t the only factor, and, many would argue, it’s hardly the most important one. The term generation originally referred to levels of kinfolk in ancestry (the grandmother, her daughter, her grandchild, and so on). In immigrant studies, it pertains to steps in a family’s lineage after it moves to a new country. It wasn’t until the 19th century that Western philosophers proposed it as a metric to track a society’s progress. German sociologist Karl Mannheim cemented this idea in 1928, positing that generations composed of “youth experiencing the same concrete historical problems” drove social change.

“We have to understand that there is diversity within generations, but there are some generational factors that are relatively consistent.”Corey Seemiller, professor of leadership studies at Wright State University

In a 1991 book titled Generations, American authors William Strauss and Neil Howe proposed that new groupings appear roughly every two decades according to a cycle of four personality types (idealist, reactive, civic, and adaptive) that repeats every 80 years or so. Academic experts panned this theory for lacking empirical evidence, but its emphasis on birth year remained, to the chagrin of some scholars. St. Louis University professor Cort Rudolph, who studies aging in the workforce, contends that generations are “not really a ‘thing’ outside of the language that we use variously to describe relatively older/younger people at a given point in history.”

Most academics who study generations acknowledge that doing so is imprecise. “It’s very tricky when you’re talking about generational research because you are in fact generalizing,” says Stanford University anthropologist Roberta Katz, a co-leader of the iGen Project, an in-depth study of British and American kids growing up in a hyperconnected world.

Still, rigorous research on generations exists and can be useful. Thinking about them helps investigators determine how societies change. “We have to understand that there is diversity within generations, but there are some generational factors that are relatively consistent,” says Corey Seemiller, a professor of leadership studies at Wright State University who specializes in Gen Z.

For example, information and misinformation have spread faster during Gen Z’s lifetime than at any other point in history. As a result, they “self-inform in a way that prior generations of young people could not,” says Katz, who is co-authoring a forthcoming book titled Gen Z, Explained. (Millennials are referred to as “digital natives,” but she points out that this term refers to fluency with electronic devices, not the unique circumstances of growing up with a vast communication network at your fingertips.) Ultimately, adds Seemiller, “the fact is that all of Gen Z were born into a world in which the commercial internet exists”—a characteristic no other generation can claim. This makes them different, but it doesn’t make them uniquely adversarial.

Tension between youth and adults is nothing new. King’s College’s Duffy points out that after World War I “there was this very clear sense of young people being betrayed by older generations,” who had sacrificed mere teenagers in battle. Thus a sense of united consciousness emerged: They did this to us.

History repeats. Bruce Gibney’s A Generation of Sociopaths, published in 2017, blames boomers for squandering the country’s post–World War II wealth. Aggrieved environmental activist Greta Thunberg told world leaders at a United Nations climate summit in 2019 that young people “are starting to understand your betrayal.” No matter the unique challenges of the present day, feeling screwed over by one’s elders is a time-honored tradition.

So is not wanting to hang out with them. In the past, putting up a “No grown-ups” sign on a treehouse would have effectively kept adults out, creating a place where kids could be kids. Not so in the internet era, where most digital spaces are accessible to people of any age. The “creepy treehouse effect” occurs when adults use a social media platform claimed by youth, making it, well, creepy: Turned off by olds on Instagram, Gen Z migrated to Snapchat. When millennials discovered snaps, kids danced over to TikTok. The cycle will likely continue as long as the internet is free and adults can keep up.

Though youth have always wanted separation from their elders, the dynamic may feel more fraught now because “technology makes it easier for adults to show up in their treehouse,” explains Seemiller.

That’s not to say Gen Z wants to cut ties with its elders altogether, even though its immersion in devices—and frustration with hopelessly tech-inept parents—can make it seem that way. Seemiller, who has co-led three large national surveys of Gen Z students and published the results in four books, has found that today’s youth are actually more likely to look to their parents for advice than previous generations, a trend corroborated by multiple other studies.

Though youth have always wanted separation from their elders, the dynamic may feel even more fraught now.

Gen Z kids I spoke to seem to agree. Seventeen-year-old Kiera Menor, from Oklahoma City, turns to the internet for schoolwork but to her parents for personal insights. “They’re a reliable source,” she says. “They’ve lived more than I have.” Chelsea Fuller, a 21-year-old college grad from Lancaster, California, says, “Anything about my body, I would go to my mom.” Andrew Heller, 17, from Petaluma, California, wants college guidance from his parents, not from strangers on the internet. “I don’t know how much I can trust them,” he says.

Parents, understandably, get nervous when they don’t know what Gen Z is up to online. Seemiller assures them that kids and teens use tech for the same reasons older folks do: entertainment, finding information, and showing people how to do things (mainly via YouTube). A big goal is connecting with others, which they do differently from older people, who tend to use social media to stay in touch with those they already know. Gen Z also uses it to form new relationships. While millennials met on campus and messaged on Facebook, for Gen Z, TikTok is the college quad. But the impulse to be social is the same. “The technology provides them with an opportunity to learn and connect in ways that none of us had when we were younger,” says Seemiller.

It’s easy, and sometimes funny, and sometimes funny, to play along with the notion of generational stereotypes as they’re presented in think pieces and survey results online. They can give a sweeping view of the ways society is changing, offering older people some context for resituating themselves within it. (I accept that millennials are outdated because, honestly, it is cringe-worthy to ascribe one’s entire personality to a Hogwarts house.) But these are reductive tropes, and they carry a dangerous suggestion of conflict.

Duffy contends that there is no evidence of a looming generational war. “We don’t really want to go to battle with our grandparents on things,” he says. “We want them to be looked after because we love them. And they want a better future for their kids and grandkids because they love them.” But he cautions that there is a real risk of drifting apart.

Keeping sight of the connections that exist between generations is important because doing so helps maintain optimism and faith in society and thus the willingness to keep working together to improve it.

Indeed, members of Gen Z, at the very least, seem interested in keeping their elders around—as long as they cool it with the digital creepiness. And if we stand by them, maybe there’s a thing or two we can learn from them too. As Kiera Menor put it, referring to her Minecraft expertise: “I’m a beacon of knowledge.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Netflix Scoops Up ‘Three Songs for Benazir' for Doc Shorts Slate (EXCLUSIVE)

Netflix has bolstered its slate of Oscar short hopefuls with the acquisition of “Three Songs for Benazir.” Directed by Gulistan and Elizabeth Mirzaei, the 22-minute docu tells the story of ... Read more »

Omicron variant may increase risk of COVID reinfection, study finds

Johannesburg — As data on real-world infections in South Africa, where the Omicron variant of the coronavirus was first identified, suggest the mutated virus has an increased ability to reinfect ... Read more »

Government has Rs 100 crore budget for chip design related activities this fiscal: Vaishnaw

The government on Friday said it is cognizant of the importance of semiconductor design and has a budgetary allocation of Rs 100 crore for chip design related programmes the ongoing ... Read more »

Hackers steal $120 million in crypto from DeFi platform

Hackers have stolen crypto tokens worth $120 million from Blockchain-based decentralised finance (DeFi) platform BadgerDAO. Several crypto wallets were drained before the platform could stop the cyber attack.In a tweet, ... Read more »

Government must back UK train travel or risk long-term retreat to cars

Jon Fitton/Shutterstock There’s no doubt that the UK’s railways have been hit hard by the pandemic. Recent figures from the Office of Rail and Road show a huge drop in ... Read more »

Businesses set to face an onslaught of ransomware attacks over holiday season

In each of the past three years, the number of ransomware attacks increased by almost a third over the holiday season as compared to the monthly average, new data from ... Read more »

Finland battles 'exceptional' malware attack spread by phones

The messages started beeping Finns’ mobiles late last week, prompting the National Cyber Security Centre to issue a “severe alert”. HELSINKI (BLOOMBERG) – Finland is working to stop a flood ... Read more »

7 new movies and TV shows on Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO Max and more this weekend

We’ve been warning you all for the past few weeks, but Christmas has well and truly arrived on streamers in 2021. This weekend will see several new festive movies and ... Read more »

Everyone's been talking about AWS, and Google Cloud is jealous

Just as the curtain falls on Amazon Web Services’ re:Invent 2021 event, Google Cloud has announced a series of new cloud regions, not just in the US, but around the ... Read more »

Microsoft to stop forcing Edge on Windows 11 users

Microsoft has changed the way Windows 11 handles switching default web browsers, thankfully, reversing an unpopular decision it made when the OS was still in pre-release testing (back in August). ... Read more »

Robots doing brain surgery: CEO describes the latest in medical AI

The development of the Moderna (MRNA) coronavirus vaccine relied on it. The early discovery and modeling of COVID-19 outbreaks depended on it. And new drugs for the disease benefited from ... Read more »

Video: £100k Robot displays life-like facial expressions and 'could go to meetings'

Ameca is billed as the "world's most advanced human shaped robot". CEO of Engineered Arts Will Jackson says the machine could take someone's place in a meeting, and costs more than £100,000. Read more »

Omicron covid variant three times more likely to cause reinfection than delta, South Africa study says

Omicron covid variant three times more likely to cause reinfection than delta, South Africa study says Scientists in South Africa say omicron is at least three times more likely to ... Read more »

Tesla recalls one in every four Model Ys it has made in the first 1o months of the year to fix faulty steering

Tesla will recall more than 20,000 of its bestselling made-in-China Model Y sport-utility vehicles (SUVs) to fix a steering issue. The US electric vehicle (EV) giant will recall 21,599 Model ... Read more »

COVID-19: First encounter with virus shapes body's future immune response to new infections, research shows

Instead of having a one-size-fits-all approach, developers could, researchers suggest, tailor make vaccines according to a person's infection history. Read more »

China wants to turn Macau from a casino den into a tech base for the Greater Bay Area

China is forging a new identity for Macau, the world’s largest casino den, as a regional technology hub, according to Chinese technology industry executives and officials. As the former Portuguese ... Read more »

Hey Google, here's a blueprint for a Pixel smartwatch to rival the Apple Watch

The cat’s out of the bag, once more. After a few years of silence, we are again seeing reports about Google working on its own Pixel-branded smartwatch. We just know ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell's 58-page rule book for staff at Jeffrey Epstein's mansion revealed

Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell wrote a household manual for staff at Jeffrey Epstein’s Florida home, instructing employees to “see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing”, a former housekeeper revealed in testimony ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial – live: Defence to quiz former Epstein employee after graphic sex toy testimony

Day five of the trial of British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell starts in New York City, as the 59-year-old answers to charges related to her alleged involvement in financier Jeffrey Epstein’s ... Read more »

Need a doctor? Google can now help you find places that accept your health insurance

Looking for a new doctor who takes your health insurance? An update to Google search might make that easier. Google announced updates to search results providing more information on doctors, ... Read more »

Alcohol, anorexia and chronic colloidal silver ingestion revealed as cause of death in mummified Love Has Won cult leader

The autopsy report of Colorado cult leader Amy Carlson aka “Mother God” has revealed that the leader of religious group Love Has Won died due to a history of alcohol ... Read more »

Want to trade in your smartphone? Take these steps first: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

Little Mix speak out on 'terribly emotional' hiatus decision

Watch: Little Mix 'taking break' after Confetti tour next year Little Mix have opened up on the “terribly emotional” decision to take a hiatus from the performing. This week saw ... Read more »

Trove of new dinosaur fossils in Italy helps rewrite prehistory of the Mediterranean region

An adult and two juvenile individuals of the dinosaur ‘Tethyshadros insularis’ showing the different appearances exhibited by immature and mature specimens (Davide Bonadonna) A trove of new dinosaur skeletons unearthed ... Read more »

Omicron: Britain plans to vaccinate 25 million in two months – but can it be done?

What impact the new omicron variant will have is still unknown. But with early data suggesting it could be the most transmissible form of the virus yet – and that ... Read more »

Oppo Inno Day 2021 date announced, may include new flagship launch

Chinese smartphone giant Oppo has announced the schedule of its annual ’Oppo Inno Day’ through a press release, which will be held on December 14 and 15 this year in ... Read more »

A single VPN drop-out exposed breach scandal that cost Ubiquiti $4bn

A brief VPN outage has led to the arrest of a former Ubiquiti developer, who has reportedly been charged with stealing data and trying to extort his employer while pretending ... Read more »

Cheap AMD GPUs could finally arrive from January 2022

AMD is rumored to have a pair of wallet-friendly graphics cards in the pipeline, and the latest speculation has floated release dates for the RX 6500 XT and RX 6400 ... Read more »

How to add a widget to your Mac in macOS Monterey

The release of macOS Monterey has brought an impressive list of new features for users to enjoy. In this guide, we’ll be focusing on widgets, a feature that’s seen a ... Read more »

The Samsung Galaxy S21 FE is rumored to cost the same as the S20 FE

The Samsung Galaxy S21 FE is expected to finally make its debut next month, and according to the latest rumor, it’s going to go on sale at the same price ... Read more »

Having severe COVID-19 doubled the chance of dying within a year for people in a Florida study — the risk was even higher for young people

A COVID-19 patient recovering at home in Brooklyn, New York, on November 21, 2020.Andrew Lichtenstein/Corbis/Getty Images A new study tracked nearly 180 hospitalized COVID-19 patients in Florida for up to ... Read more »

Huawei could launch HarmonyOS for global customers next year: Report

Chinese technology company Huawei has seen its share of trouble globally but in the native market, the company is still a big player. The company’s own HarmonyOS, which has been ... Read more »

California has 50 times more monarch butterflies than last year — a puzzling blip in their path to extinction

Butterflies land on branches at Monarch Grove Sanctuary in Pacific Grove, California, on November 10, 2021.Nic Coury/AP Photo Monarch butterflies migrating to California made a promising rebound from the edge ... Read more »

Scientists Have Found The Two Most Effective Covid Booster Jabs

(Photo: Yui Mok – PA Images via Getty Images) The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines are the most effective Covid booster jabs. a new study has found, but all boosters could ... Read more »

This is what Reliance chairman Mukesh Ambani has to say on data privacy and cryptocurrency bills

Billionaire Mukesh Ambani on Friday backed the proposed data privacy and cryptocurrency bills, saying India is putting in place the most forward-looking policies and regulations.Ambani, who has been a votary ... Read more »

New Data Shows Startups Prefer Keyword-Based Descriptive Domain Names

For the past few decades, it was assumed that rising startups would opt for exact brand match domain names ending in the legacy top-level domain (TLD) .com as soon as ... Read more »

Indian doctor with no travel history tests positive for omicron: ‘This may be everywhere already'

Indian doctor with no travel history tests positive for omicron: ‘This may be everywhere already’ A 46-year-old Indian doctor with no travel history is among the two people who have ... Read more »

Meta pushes high-profile Facebook account holders to enable Facebook Protect features

Photo credit: Timothy Hales Bennett on Unsplash Meta appears to be making more effort to push Facebook users handling high-profile pages to enable Facebook Protect features. Those who fail to turn on the ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S21 FE price leaks, and it's reportedly just $100 cheaper than Galaxy S21

Samsung Galaxy S20 | Photo credit: Daniel Romero on Unsplash With the possibility of the Samsung Galaxy S21 FE launching in a month, more details about the anticipated mid-range phone have leaked once ... Read more »

Polar Grit X Pro review

Two-minute review The Grit X Pro showcases the best that Polar has to offer in terms of sports tracking and rich data analysis – and adding more navigation features means ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic