The Lodger review: New Robert Holman play is enthralling and exasperating by turns

© Tristram Kenton Lodger-10-09-21-Coronet-636.jpg

A new play by Robert Holman, the most instinctive and humane of British playwrights, is something to celebrate, but The Lodger exasperates as well as enthralls. It was written, Holman says, to provide parts for two older actresses. And for the deceptively mild, gawky actor Matthew Tennyson, who won the Evening Standard’s Outstanding Newcomer Award in a revival of Holman’s Making Noise Quietly at the Donmar in 2012, and acted in his play A Breakfast of Eels at a previous incarnation of the Coronet in 2015.

The result is an unbalanced affair that requires a wildly eccentric central section and a fourth character that together undermine Holman’s reputation for emotional truth. Geraldine Alexander’s production is measured and mostly quite beautiful. She draws performances that are imperfect but distinctive, by turns assertive and skinless, from Tennyson, Penny Downie, Sylvestra Le Touzel (whose indisposition delayed last week’s planned opening) and Iniki Mariano in that impossible fourth role. I loved a lot of the play and absolutely hated 20 per cent of it.

The subject is love that is withheld, foregone, difficult or provisional. After the death of their mother at 98, Harrogate housewife Dolly (Le Touzel) detonates a lifetime of secrets and recriminations with prodigal sister Esther (Downie), a novelist and philosophy professor she’s barely seen for 30 years.

Dolly, so named because of a childhood fascination with dolls that increased exponentially in her childless married life, is nonplussed that Esther shares her London flat and Dungeness cottage with enigmatic, “paper-thin” twentysomething Jude (Tennyson). Is he a surrogate son, a disgustingly young lover, or the lodger he claims to be? Thwarted motherhood and illicit impulses run through the play like letters through rock.

© Provided by Evening Standard Matthew Tennyson (Jude) and Iniki Mariano (Anila) (©Tristram Kenton)

Things go wrong in the narrative when Jude is revealed to have secretly become a successful playwright, having had a show on at the Royal Court (one of Holman’s haunts) without Esther noticing. In my experience, things often go wrong when writers write about writing. Especially, as here, when a writer writes about two writers’ complicated feelings about each other’s writing.

Anyway, this plot twist sends the story on a wild jaunt to Norway and the suggestion that Jude has somehow written his own future, and a half-Indian soulmate, Anila, into existence. Though Iniki Mariano winningly delivers the vulnerability and frankness that’s Holman’s hallmark in this role, this character is as improbable as she is short-lived.

The other actors are in gravy. Downie and Le Touzel get a meaty, combative sister act to sink their teeth into. Tennyson displays his range as an abused boy with OCD who’s grown a looming, clever carapace. Holman’s characters usually say what they feel, then what they mean, more openly and succinctly than we ever could. That’s true here too, but for a significant chunk of the play, I simply didn’t believe them.

Coronet Theatre, to 9 Oct, thecoronettheatre.com

Register now for one of the Evening Standard’s newsletters. From a daily news briefing to Homes & Property insights, plus lifestyle, going out, offers and more. For the best stories in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Batman's Matt Reeves Shares New Look At Zoë Kravitz's Selina Kyle Ahead Of Movie's New Trailer

© Provided by CinemaBlend Zoe Kravitz as Catwoman in The Batman A new take on the Batman mythology will unfold next year, with Matt Reeves’ The Batman following Robert Pattinson’s ... Read more »

After Dropping Points in Two-Straight Matches, Roma Needs a Convincing Win Over Inter Milan

© Photo by AS Roma/AS Roma via Getty Images Back on Matchday 4, when Roma was originally slated to play Inter Milan on the road, the Giallorosse were the toast ... Read more »

Big Brother 23 Contestants Confirm Relationship, And I'm Totally Shocked

© Provided by CinemaBlend screenshot big brother 23 After much drama and loyalties questioned this summer, Big Brother 23 was able to crown the American version of the show’s first ... Read more »

Darren Criss and Wife Mia Swier Expecting Their First Baby

© Andreas Rentz/amfAR/Getty Images for amfAR Darren Criss and Mia Swier Darren Criss and Mia Swier are adding to their family. The couple revealed Friday that they are expecting their ... Read more »

Stocks extend rally as index breaches 7,200

The Philippine index extended its rally and concluded above the 7,200-point territory on Friday, buoyed by improving economic prospects onshore and Wall Street’s climb overnight. The Philippine Stock Exchange index ... Read more »

Employers seek P500 million loan for 13th month pay

© STAR / File Employers seek P500 million loan for 13th month pay MANILA, Philippines — The Employers Confederation of the Philippines (ECOP) is taking part in the crafting of ... Read more »

R&B Singer Emani 22 Dead at 22: Cause of Death Revealed

UPDATE: Emani 22‘s manager, Fred Green, has shared more details surrounding the singer’s cause of death. He tells E! News in a statement that Emani died following a “tragic accident” ... Read more »

‘Xena' stars Lucy Lawless, Renee O'Connor reunite after 20 years

Former “Xena” co-stars Renee O’Connor (left) and Lucy Lawless reunite for the season finale of Lawless’ series “My Life Is Murder.” Greenstone Pictures MLIM Ltd Xena and Gabrielle are together ... Read more »

With Monday deadline, Hollywood union prepared for 'painful' strike

IATSE President Matthew Loeb says his union representing film and TV crews is prepared for a “painful” strike shutting down Hollywood production — but he’s hoping for a deal by ... Read more »

10 Sweater Vest Outfits That'll Convince You To Get This Vintage Closet Staple

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines Since we’re already right in the middle of ber months, it’s time to relearn the art of ~layering~. Though the weather might be cooler, there’s ... Read more »

8 Easy Halloween Costume Ideas Inspired By K-Dramas

© Provided by Cosmopolitan Philippines You don’t need to spend lots on a memorable Halloween costume. You just need to be creative and nail the key elements of whoever you’re ... Read more »

Loved the Stairs in Squid Game? Check Out the Spanish Airbnb That Looks Exactly Like It

© Provided by Esquire Philippines Squid Game has taken the world by storm as the central themes of the hit Netflix show transcend cultures and languages. From the tricky challenges ... Read more »

Jennica Garcia Says Alywn Uytingco 'Expressed Desire For Family Restoration'

After announcing their separation earlier this year, Jennica Garcia and Alwyn Uytingco  are working on patching things up. Last night, Jennica revealed that she and Alwyn are talking about possibly ... Read more »

Davina McCall's touching tribute to Sarah Harding during Stand Up To Cancer

Heartbroken Davina McCall paid tribute to Sarah Harding during the Stand Up To Cancer televised special on Friday night. Sarah sadly passed away last month at the age of 39 ... Read more »

‘Succession' Recap: Catch Up on Season 2 in Under 3 Minutes (Video)

© Provided by TheWrap Succession: Season 2 Recap | HBO HBO on Friday released a nifty recap of “Succession” Season 2’s critical plot points and best barbs just days ahead ... Read more »

The 'Grey's Anatomy' elevator scene with Addison and Meredith was so emotional, even the writer cried seeing it come to life

© ABC/Eric McCandless Kate Walsh on “Hotter Than Hell.” ABC/Eric McCandless Kate Walsh returned to “Grey’s Anatomy” on Thursday night. In an emotional elevator scene, her character Addison Montgomery expresses ... Read more »

Sunrise headed for cast shakeup as Today gains in the ratings

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Sunrise will be shuffling its cast lineup as rival morning show Today gains steady traction in the TV ratings and closes the gap. ... Read more »

Steam is banning games that may deal with NFTs and cryptocurrency

Steam is cracking down on games that may issue NFTs or cryptocurrency. NFT stands for a non-fungible token; the term is often used to refer to digital assets that people ... Read more »

‘Mayor Pete,' Documentary On Pete Buttigieg's Historic Presidential Run, Opens 33rd NewFest LGBTQ+ Festival

© Amazon Studios NewFest, New York’s LGBTQ+ film festival, kicks off tonight with one of the most prominent documentaries of the fall. Mayor Pete, directed by Jesse Moss, goes behind ... Read more »

Hong Kong restaurant scene back to (almost) full glory, but owners worry over new pressures

Eighteen months ago in April 2020, during Hong Kong’s second wave of the coronavirus pandemic, I put a temporary hiatus on restaurant reviews. The food and beverage scene – normally ... Read more »

EPL GW-8 Pre-Deadline Chat

© Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images Jurgen Klopp and the Reds remain the only undefeated team in the EPL. They kick the weekend off against Watford. Saturday, ... Read more »

Dierks Bentley will rock the NASCAR nation at Phoenix Raceway. Here's how to watch

Dierks Bentley, the local country boy who made good after moving to Nashville in the ’90s, is coming home to treat the sold-out crowd at Phoenix Raceway to a pre-race concert ... Read more »

Top 5 things to do in the Lehigh Valley this weekend: Boo at the Zoo, Cider and more, Tract-or-Treat, Halloween Dance Party and Lisa Loeb

© April Gamiz/The Morning Call Trinity Shope, dressed as the cheshire cat, is ready to hand out treats to children at last year’s Boo at the Zoo. You animals! Boo ... Read more »

Artists & Makers Studios opens to the public for studio events

TUCSON, Ariz. (KOLD News 13) – Artists & Makers Studios in Oro Valley is opening to the public for several studio events this holiday season. © Randy Metcalf A new ... Read more »

Curtains rise for Cherokee musical "Nanyehi" at Hard Rock Live

TULSA – “Nanyehi — The Story of Nancy Ward,” the Cherokee musical co-written by Bartlesville native Becky Hobbs, returns to Tulsa on Oct. 29-30 for performances at Hard Rock Live at the Hard ... Read more »

Controversial Stephen Foster Statue To Move From Pittsburgh To Museum Exhibit In Los Angeles

PITTSBURGH (KDKA) — As the fate of the Christopher Columbus statue in Pittsburgh remains in limbo, another controversial statue is headed out of town. The statue of Pittsburgh-born songwriter Stephen ... Read more »

Radio station Alt 105.3 rebrands as Dave FM -- and we have questions

Audacy announced Friday that it would rebrand longtime alternative rock station Alt 105.3 KITS to something called Dave FM.  © Eric Audras/Getty Images/Onoky FILE PHOTO: Alt 105.3 in San Francisco ... Read more »

Milwaukee man uses music to connect to culture, identity

Music plays an important role in cultural connection and identity. © Provided by WISN Milwaukee One long-time musician uses it to share his culture with all of Milwaukee. Cecil Negron ... Read more »

Kentuck Festival of the Arts returns as an in-person festival Saturday

NORTHPORT, Ala. (WBRC) – A well-known West Alabama arts festival that was disrupted due to COVID-19 last year returns in 2021 to its traditional roots. © Provided by Birmingham WBRC ... Read more »

The Best Marvel Halloween Costumes for Kids Who Love Superheroes

© ShopDisney If your little one has Marvel mania, then a superhero costume is in order for Halloween. Whether they want to channel Brie Larson‘s look in Captain Marvelor Tom Holland‘s ... Read more »

Denis Villeneuve spent days flying in helicopters over the desert looking for 'Dune' filming locations because he refused to use green screens

© Provided by INSIDER Denis Villeneuve (inset) directed Timothée Chalamet and Rebecca Ferguson in “Dune.” Michael Loccisano/Getty Images; Chiabella James/Warner Bros. Pictures Denis Villeneuve insisted on filming “Dune” in real-life ... Read more »

Halle Berry's Second Sweaty Betty Collection Is Launching Soon -- Get the Details

© Stefanie Keenan/Getty Images for CDGA Halle Berry is teaming up with Sweaty Betty again! The actress, along with her health and wellness platform Respin, is collaborating with the activewear brand for the ... Read more »

Darren Criss and Wife Mia Swier Announce They're Expecting Their First Child

© P. Lehman/Barcroft Media via Getty Images Darren Criss and Mia Swier are having a baby! The Hollywood star and his wife announced that they are expecting their first child ... Read more »

Key part of Biden's climate agenda likely to be cut on Manchin's opposition - NYT

© Reuters/Joshua Roberts FILE PHOTO: Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV) speaks during hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington (Reuters) – A key part of U.S. President Joe Biden’s climate agenda – ... Read more »

Megan Fox and Brian Austin Green Finalize Their Divorce

Megan Fox and Brian Austin Green are officially, legally single. The former couple filed their divorce judgement on Friday, Oct. 15, and their divorce has been finalized after nearly a ... Read more »

How a Final Fantasy 14 player uses a Ring Fit to explore Eorzea

© Provided by GamesRadar Final Fantasy 14 Controller modder SuperLouis64 has used his talents to combine the Nintendo Switch Ring Fit attachment with Final Fantasy 14 to host a charity ... Read more »

TikTok Dad Has a Theory About the Subtle Way 'Bluey' Honors Rainbow Babies

© Provided by Mom.com Michael Vaughn/Bluey If you’ve got a kid under 5, chances are they’re obsessed with Bluey. (And honestly, chances are so are you.) The ABC Kids series ... Read more »

Ransomware hackers targeted three US water facilities in 2021, cyber officials say

© AFP via Getty Images A technician examines micro filter membranes at the West Basin Municipal Water District (WBMWD) water recycling facility in El Segundo, California. – AFP via Getty ... Read more »

Man shot by police was unlawfully killed, inquest finds

© Facebook Skelton’s family welcomed the ruling – Facebook A man who was shot dead by police while carrying an axe through the centre of Hull was unlawfully killed, an ... Read more »

wyoming refugees

© Getty Images/iStockphoto iStock-980203776.jpg Jim Shumard, the rector of St Mark’s Episcopal Church here, sent the email to his congregation with some trepidation. The plan it announced could be historic ... Read more »