The Guardian view on human rights and the borders bill: the wrong path

Asia's Tech News Daily

The government belief that national sovereignty trumps humanitarian principle leads to bad policy and moral aberration

When government policy collides with human rights legislation, the Conservative party instinctively finds fault with the law. For that reason, Priti Patel, the home secretary, is unlikely to be moved by a parliamentary report published on Wednesday calling for humanitarian amendments to the nationalities and borders bill.

The joint committee on human rights has various concerns about the bill, of which the most pressing are the intent to criminalise the very act of “irregular” arrival in the UK and the plan to “push back” migrants attempting to cross the Channel. In the former case, the committee identifies a breach of a UN convention, which states that refugees must not be penalised for the fact of entering a safe country illegally.

As for driving boats back towards France, the core principle at stake is the fundamental right to life as enshrined in the European convention on human rights (ECHR) and incorporated in UK law via the Human Rights Act. As the recent drowning of 27 people tragically demonstrated, the water is treacherous enough without the increased hazard of aggressive intervention by border guards.

The very idea mandates cruelty to those on the vessels being repelled. It is also unfair on enforcement officers, who might be ordered to imperil the lives of vulnerable people. The deterrent effect is likely to be negligible. The criminals who run the trafficking networks stay safe on dry land.

Ms Patel is aware that her policy risks putting border guards on the wrong side of the law. One remedy reported to be under consideration is to declare them immune from prosecution. To assert such impunity in a matter of life and death would be an egregious challenge to one of the most fundamental principles on which legitimate state power rests.

Bad laws are often born of political frustration, and this is no exception. Sovereign control over the nation’s frontiers was the central to the promise of Brexit. Anything that makes the border look porous is thus intolerable to Boris Johnson. When driven by fear of losing the support of his core vote, the prime minister is unpersuaded that human rights law, or moral obligation to desperate people, makes a compelling case for a different approach. In that respect, he is going with the grain of Conservative policy for decades. The party has long discussed repealing the Human Rights Act and withdrawing from the European convention. Some hoped Brexit would make that happen, but it does not. The ECHR is not an EU institution, but it does set standards that are embedded in EU treaties – including the trade and cooperation agreement that Mr Johnson signed last year.

It takes a combination of arrogance and nationalism to presume that assertions of British sovereignty take precedence over international principles that were established as mitigation against humanitarian disaster and insurance against political atrocity. There is an authoritarian thread woven through the parts of the bill that pertain to Channel crossings. There is also a more banal calculation at work when the government subordinates ethical considerations to the politics of talking tough on immigration. That approach takes Britain further down the path of treating human rights as a disposable impediment to effective government. It is a road that leads, sooner or later, to acts of official cruelty that bring shame on the politicians who permit them.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Glenn Youngkin is right — mask mandates harm kids

Critics believe Youngkin doesn’t have the authority to issue his order because Virginia passed a statute that schools should follow the CDC guidelines. AP Glenn Youngkin promised to be on ... Read more »

Drivers get stuck along major Toronto-area highways as winter storm blasts southern Ontario

Thousands of drivers out along Toronto-area highways got stuck in snow Monday morning as a historic winter storm blasted southern Ontario. OPP Sgt. Kerry Schmidt said drivers got stuck in ... Read more »

"Gipfel der Quizgiganten": Elfriede Awadalla gewann vor 17 Jahren WWM – heute ist die Million weg

© picture alliance / dpa | Christian Bruna Elfriede Awadalla In der RTL-Sendung “Gipfel der Quizgiganten” ist der Name Programm. Der Sender vereint drei der beliebtesten Moderatoren Deutschlands mit klugen ... Read more »

Goalie duo keeping Islanders in games despite ugly offense

The Islanders’ offense has been ugly this season. Through 30 games, they’re 30th in the league in goals per game, 20th in expected goals percentage and 23rd in high danger ... Read more »

15 Bilder und Videos, die das gewaltige Ausmass des Vulkanausbruchs in Tonga zeigen

© EUROPEAN UNION, COPERNICUS SENTI/keystone-sda.ch epa09690859 (COMPOSITE) – A handout composite satellite image made available by Copernicus, the European Union’s Earth Observation Programme, shows imagery produced using data from the ... Read more »

Winter storms pummeling Ontario and Quebec

Ontario and Quebec residents are dealing with severe winter weather Monday as two storms continue to dump snow on the provinces. © THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck A woman shovels snow ... Read more »

Cummings wirft Johnson Lüge zu Partys vor – Foto von Carrie Johnson sorgt für Ärger

© Alastair Grant/keystone-sda.ch Dominic Cummings erhebt schwere Vorwürfe gegen Boris Johnson. Der britische Premierminister Boris Johnson hat im Skandal um Lockdown-Partys im Regierungssitz auch zu Beginn der neuen Woche keine ... Read more »

N.S. government seeks delay in housing rights hearing for people with disabilities

HALIFAX — Nova Scotia’s government is asking to delay a human rights case involving access to housing for people with disabilities until the country’s top court rules on the matter. ... Read more »

Why Our Team Is Obsessed With These Cozy Thermals

The weather outside is frightful, so all the more reason to up your layering game. Thermal leggings and/or undershirts worn under your regular clothing are a great way to make ... Read more »

‘Betty White: A Celebration' released on what would have been her 100th birthday today

A new documentary featuring the last interview with beloved comedian and actress Betty White is being released today, on what would have been her 100th birthday. © Provided by National ... Read more »

Winter storm brings traffic to a standstill in Ontario, Quebec (PHOTOS)

A wide-reaching winter storm blanketed parts of Ontario and Quebec Sunday evening into Monday with more than 35 cm of snow accumulating in some places, leading to dangerous roadways, delays, ... Read more »

Ontarians should wait out dangerous blizzard at home, major highways close

Drivers are being urged to avoid any non-essential travel on Monday, as heavy snow and powerful winds make for treacherous road conditions across Ontario. Although the blizzard warnings dropped across ... Read more »

Vaccine mandates increased uptake of COVID shots by almost 70%, Canadian study finds

When Quebec recently ordered that anyone wanting to buy liquor or cannabis from government stores had to be vaccinated against COVID-19, the results were striking. © Provided by National Post ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian 'is upset about Kanye West's accusations'

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Kim Kardashian has been frustrated by Kanye West’s recent comments. The 41-year-old star – who has North, eight, Saint, six, Chicago, four, and Psalm, ... Read more »

Ontario buried under epic snow totals as lake-effect setup takes over

Parts of southern Ontario are digging out after one of the most impactful winter storms in recent years powered through the region Sunday night and Monday. The storm shut down ... Read more »

RCMP's new harassment process hampered by lack of independent investigators: union head

© Provided by National Post Members of the RCMP stand at attention during a Remembrance Day ceremony in Iqaluit, Nunavut, on November 11, 2021. OTTAWA – The head of the ... Read more »

Who betrayed Anne Frank? A cold case team has named a new surprising suspect

© Provided by WPTZ Plattsburgh-Burlington A cold case team that combed through evidence for five years in a bid to unravel one of World War II’s enduring mysteries has reached ... Read more »

Barcelona fans make Manchester United point after Philippe Coutinho debut for Aston Villa

Philippe Coutinho made a goalscoring start to life as an Aston Villa player against Manchester United at the weekend. The Brazil international made his debut after he was introduced as ... Read more »

3 Undervalued Stocks to Buy Cheap in 2022

Canada’s primary stock market index hasn’t advanced substantially from year-end 2021 (+0.63%), and only four of the 11 primary sectors are in positive territory as of January 14, 2022. The ... Read more »

Gatwick and Heathrow: Last day to book flights to Spain, Greece, France, Italy and more for as little as £22 in British Airways flash sale

Blue Monday is a tough day for many of us, and you’d be forgiven for getting through it by daydreaming of better days ahead. One thing that doesn’t need to ... Read more »

Bez feels 'gutted' after testing positive for COVID-19

© Bang Showbiz Bez has tested positive for COVID Happy Mondays star Bez has tested positive for COVID-19. The 57-year-old musician has revealed he tested positive for the virus shortly ... Read more »

Iga Świątek sheds light on the harsh reality of being a Grand Slam champion

Iga Świątek is one of many tennis stars who have achieved Grand Slam champion status at a young age. At just 19, the Polish international stormed to victory at the ... Read more »

Sadiq Khan plots to hit drivers in London with 'pay per mile' charges

Sadiq Khan was accused last night of clobbering hard-up motorists with his plans to charge them by the mile in London. The capital’s Labour mayor wants road pricing to force ... Read more »

Robert Downey Jr. Shares Sweet Response After Netflix's Sweet Tooth Starts Nabbing Awards

© Provided by CinemaBlend Christian Convery and Nonso Anozie on Sweet Tooth With all the amazing shows streaming right now, it’s easy to forget some serious gems that came out ... Read more »

Armed teenager who stormed college is facing jail as he pleads guilty

A teenager who took a gun into a college and began shooting at students and staff causing them to flee in terror is facing jail. Sandijs Dreimanis, 18, walked into ... Read more »

The Rasmus share their Eurovision entry song bid for Finland

The Rasmus have released their ‘Eurovision Song Contest’ entry bid, ‘Jezebel’. © Bang Showbiz The Rasmus release Eurovision entry song After it was announced that the ‘In the Shadows’ rockers ... Read more »

‘I fought dinosaurs': Chinese boy, born with no fingers on 1 hand, tells people he lost them protecting his mum, becomes dumpling-making celebrity

The boy was born with no fingers on his left hand but has learnt to live with the disability His parents said they have worked hard to help the boy ... Read more »

OPINION - UK economy: We're doing better than Germany – but there may be trouble ahead

It may be a little premature to bring out the bunting but, nevertheless, the UK economy is finally bigger than it was before the onset of the Covid crisis. The ... Read more »

The biggest points deductions in sporting history

Premiership giants Saracens have just a few days to prove that they are under the league’s salary cap for this season and if they can’t, they face possible relegation from England’s ... Read more »

Man Utd make permanent manager decision as midfield shortlist is drawn up

Manchester United‘s search for a new centre-midfielder continues, and the club has now reportedly drawn up a three-man shortlist of players they hope can fill the problem position. It comes ... Read more »

Trump is briefing insiders that DeSantis is too dull to be President

Donald Trump has privately revealed that he believes Florida Governor Ron DeSantis is too boring to become US President, according to reports. According to Axios sources close to Trump, the ... Read more »

Unfazed woman takes selfie from her car sinking through the ice in Rideau River

© Provided by National Post The woman, seemingly unconcerned about the dangers she could have put others to, has been charged with dangerous driving. Residents along the banks of the ... Read more »

Drag Race UK vs The World cast finally Ru-vealed and it's the gag of the century

Drag Race UK vs The World has finally revealed the queens vying for global drag dominance, and it’s going to be the showdown to end all showdowns. The new All ... Read more »

‘Bachelor' Star Matt James on Finding Love With Rachael Kirkconnell Amid Controversy, New Book & Boston Marathon Mission

They rode a roller-coaster through one of the most controversial seasons of “The Bachelor”; now, 15 months on from their first meeting, Matt James says he and Rachael Kirkconnell are ... Read more »

‘90210' Star Shenae Grimes Enjoys ‘First Snow Day' As She Shares Adorable Family Winter Pics

Shenae Grimes-Beech is glad to be back in the snow after returning home – and she’s sharing it with the world. The “90210” actress is enjoying the winter weather with ... Read more »

Prince Harry And Meghan Markle Help To Feed Volunteers On Martin Luther King Jr. Day

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle honoured Martin Luther King Jr. Day in the U.S. by showing their support for his daughter, Dr. Bernice A. King, and The King Center. The Duke ... Read more »

Some students protest return to class amid rising COVID-19 numbers in Manitoba

WINNIPEG — Some Manitoba students walked out of class today to protest the return to school as COVID-19 numbers continue to rise. © Provided by The Canadian Press Fifteen-year-old Amelie ... Read more »

Roughly half of Canadians financially insecure as debt confidence hits record low: report

Canadians’ confidence in their personal finances and ability to repay their debt has hit a record low, a new report suggests, with roughly half the country worried about how they ... Read more »

FIRST READING: Probably not the best time for Canada to pick a fight with truckers

First Reading is a daily newsletter keeping you posted on the travails of Canadian politicos, all curated by the National Post’s own Tristin Hopper. To get an early version sent ... Read more »

Laura Coates Reveals She Was Rejected As New ‘Jeopardy!' Host

“Jeopardy!” fans will not be seeing Laura Coates on the show anytime soon. The late Alex Trebek once shared the CNN Senior Legal Analyst as someone he would like to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic