The Guardian view on budget tax cuts: stealing from the public

the guardian view on budget tax cuts: stealing from the public

‘Renewed backbench calls for cuts in personal taxes in advance of Jeremy Hunt’s pre-election budget reveal a party that has learned nothing.’ Photograph: PA

Few things in British politics are more glumly predictable, whatever the economic and political circumstances, than Conservative MPs and their rightwing media echo chamber demanding budget tax cuts. Reducing the tax burden for the less well-off undoubtedly has a place in an even-handed approach to Britain’s economic challenges. The tax system also needs reform. But renewed backbench calls for cuts in personal taxes in advance of Jeremy Hunt’s pre-election budget reveal a party that has learned nothing.

It is only 18 months since Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng brought the UK economy to its knees by pursuing exactly this approach. Sterling crashed to its lowest level against the dollar in half a century after they declared their tax-cutting budget was just the start. Borrowing costs spiralled. The package also inflicted what may prove to be irreparable damage on the Tory party’s electoral standing. For the chancellor to do anything next week that smacks of that approach would be both reckless and unjust.

That some tax-cutting measure or other will nevertheless be unveiled, doubtless to the accompaniment of backbench cheers, is probably inevitable next Wednesday. The theatrical side of Conservative parliamentary politics may require such a thing. But it would shame the government. Desperate gestures of this kind seem increasingly typical of a party which, as Rishi Sunak’s ludicrous warnings of mob rule show, seems to possess a bottomless capacity for fixating on the wrong things.

The economic reality is that the scope for tax cuts is small and that they are already overshadowed, under the current fiscal rules, by the need for taxes to rise to pay for public services. The Institute for Fiscal Studies showed any likely cuts will fail to dent an ongoing overall increase in taxation anyway. A cut in inheritance tax, much touted on the right, would benefit only the already very well-off. If the fiscal deficit is meant to narrow, any reduction would portend further spending cuts after the election.

The idea that any of this would be transformative either for the economy or for the Tory party’s standing is for the birds. The 2p cut in national insurance last autumn did nothing to boost the Conservatives’ poll ratings either when it was announced or when it took effect. Tory tax cutters ignore such facts because they do not want to face the reality, illustrated in new poll findings from the Tony Blair Institute, that the public prefers long-term investment in public services to tax cuts. In short, the Tory party’s supposed panacea is both bad economics and bad politics.

Low taxes were always a feature of the Conservative party’s stance. But it is only in the past half century that the policy has been transformed into a kind of fiscal fetish. Much of this is due to a rewriting of Conservative history under Margaret Thatcher, in which tax cuts have come to be treated as the litmus test of true Toryism and as a surefire guarantee of electoral success. In fact, they are neither. Tax cuts may boost a party when they are seen as a reward for successful handling of the economy. But if they look like a giveaway at the expense of the rebuilding of the NHS and the public realm in difficult times, they deserve to be seen for what they are – an act of stealing from the public.

OTHER NEWS

21 minutes ago

Peter Dutton reveals intent to cut migration and support first-home buyers

21 minutes ago

How relevance deprivation syndrome has liberated me in my retirement

21 minutes ago

'Let Them Be Kids': New youth campaign tackles dangers of social media

21 minutes ago

Video: Candid Aussie reveals surprise job that pays $50 an hour - and only requires one week of training and no degree

22 minutes ago

Boxing-Usyk beats Fury to become undisputed heavyweight champ

22 minutes ago

Simbine registers fastest 100m of season, Lyles superb in 150m

22 minutes ago

Irish business tycoon and rugby record breaker Tony O'Reilly dies at 88

25 minutes ago

Golden girl! Cate Blanchett stuns in a puffy metallic gown as she attends Cannes Film Festival - before getting a four-minute standing ovation for new film Rumours

25 minutes ago

Sam Kerr wins fifth straight WSL title with Chelsea - as Mary Fowler endures public heartbreak

26 minutes ago

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott pledges to keep bussing migrants to NYC: ‘Mayor Adams needs something to do’

26 minutes ago

Actress Lucy Punch will reunite with Dame Joanna Lumley for Motherland spin-off

26 minutes ago

Shane Lowry ties major-championship scoring record with 62 and makes biggest move on Moving Day at 2024 PGA Championship

26 minutes ago

‘Emilia Pérez' Review: Leading Lady Karla Sofía Gascón Electrifies in Jacques Audiard's Mexican Redemption Musical

26 minutes ago

Six of the best: Manchester City’s mainstays who have gone distance

26 minutes ago

Dublin’s hopes broken by Eoin Cody’s saving grace as Kilkenny get back on track

27 minutes ago

Streep, Gerwig shine on Cannes red carpet

28 minutes ago

Tyson Fury accuses judges of helping Oleksandr Usyk win because Ukraine is ‘at war’

29 minutes ago

Police arrest suspect in 1989 cold case killing of 78-year-old Pennsylvania woman

30 minutes ago

Revered Chicago candy shop makes People magazine's summer travel bucket list

32 minutes ago

Video: Inside Cristiano Ronaldo's arrival for Oleksandr Usyk's historic victory over Tyson Fury... as the football star is welcomed by Saudi Arabia officials before taking his ringside seat

34 minutes ago

'Whether they're from Donegal or Senegal, it makes no difference': A night at the Lighthouse café

34 minutes ago

RA_17MAY24_FLV_WILLIAMS_IS_CLEAR_FAVOURITE_FOR_GOALKEEPER_OF_THE_SEASON_16-9.mp4

34 minutes ago

Hepatitis A case reported at Beverly Hills Whole Foods

35 minutes ago

Chelsea vs. AFC Bournemouth, Premier League: Preview, team news, how to watch

35 minutes ago

The Look Ahead: May 17, 2024

35 minutes ago

Should Your Engine Be Hot Or Cold When You Check Oil Levels?

36 minutes ago

HISD, Cy Fair ISD and Spring Branch ISD give updates on status of their schools

39 minutes ago

MCoBeauty founder Shelley Sullivan 'abruptly' splits from husband Anthony seven years after lavish wedding

40 minutes ago

Lok Sabha polls: Kharge accuses PM Modi of ‘provoking’ people, calls on ED to take action

40 minutes ago

World-first live remote muster by drone at Beef Australia 2024 a sign of thing to come for cattle industry

41 minutes ago

Depleted Bristol beat Harlequins in thriller as both teams miss semi-finals spots

41 minutes ago

Best beach cover ups: sarongs, kaftans and more

41 minutes ago

Does servicing outside your dealership void your warranty?

41 minutes ago

Rep. Ritchie Torres talks lithium-ion battery safety legislation

41 minutes ago

After five years, three bridges and two floods, a permanent Mersey River crossing is now open

41 minutes ago

Shane Lowry ties major championship record, shoots 9-under 62 at the PGA

41 minutes ago

Donald Trump attends youngest son's graduation

41 minutes ago

Pittsburgh Penguins' Mike Sullivan to coach U.S. Olympic men's hockey team in 2026

43 minutes ago

‘The Balconettes’ Review: A Very Bloody, Somewhat Didactic, Game – Cannes Film Festival

43 minutes ago

Will Quebec’s forest fire season be as bad as it was last year?

Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch