The Government is misleading us about the true cost of public sector pensions

Asia's Tech News Daily

A few weeks ago, I wrote about the deceit at the heart of national insurance – a tax dressed up as a savings product, in which the capital is simply spent rather than invested.

The Treasury may be unwise, but it is not stupid – and certainly not so much as to squander a clever wheeze by only using it once. This tactic is also deployed on public sector pensions, and if anything, the accounting is even more cynical.

Public sector pensions are more generous than those in the private sector. Once upon a time this practice was justified on the basis that public sector pay was lower, but it magically persists despite the fact that these workers now earn more, and enjoy better job security, as seen in the pandemic.

In recent decades most companies have phased out “defined benefit” pensions – where retirement funds are related to how much you earned, not how much you paid in – because they were unaffordable, but much of the public sector has clung onto the model regardless.

While public employees contribute a portion of their salaries, the expectation is that taxpayers will make up the balance. A pension model that guarantees higher payouts means bigger contributions for public employers – the Civil Service Pension Scheme, for example, collects between 26.6 per cent and 30.3 per cent of the total cost of salaries in employer pension contributions.

The cost of that policy is striking, but it’s only one of several concerning notes in this story. In a normal pension scheme, that money – and the employee’s contributions – goes into a fund, to be invested in order to grow during the saver’s working life, then provide for them in retirement. A company can’t touch the pension pots of its workforce for obvious reasons.

Not so for the public sector. Just like with national insurance, the Treasury grants itself the right to spend the money contributed by other public sector employers.

The Government is misleading us about the true cost of public sector pensions
© Provided by The i Read More – Featured Image

That’s red flag No. 2. But there’s worse to come. A new report published by the Institute of Economic Affairs reveals that behind the hollow façade of public sector pensions lies an additional deceit. Those generous employer contribution figures aren’t plucked out of thin air. Rather, they’re calculated to estimate how much the pension in question will eventually cost to fund. The money is still spent, but at least everyone gets a figure from the official accounts on how much it costs to hire and employ people. This feeds into the public finances, and the debates we hear at Budgets and elections.

Except, the report reveals, this calculation is skewed. If the Treasury used the same interest rates private companies are required by law to use in their reporting, then the numbers would look vastly worse. For example, the NHS Pension Fund is reported publicly to cost 30.4 per cent of salaries. The true figure seems to be double that. In sum, the report’s author estimates the total value of this under-reporting in the last financial year alone to be £57bn.

These costs aren’t negotiable, or theoretical – they’re real. Failing to tell voters and taxpayers about them is a betrayal of huge proportions.

Mark Wallace is the chief executive of Conservative Home, a political blog that is independent of the Conservative Party

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘Expiry' date labels needed to guide Australians shopping for white goods and electronics, report finds

Photograph: MBI/Alamy Productivity Commission’s ‘right to repair’ report recommends a pilot scheme be adopted to advise consumers of durability of devices Download the free Guardian app; get our morning email ... Read more »

Sensex surges 600 points: Key factors at play

NEW DELHI: Following the international trend, domestic benchmark equity indices bounced back on Wednesday after the previous day’s selloff but uncertainty over the impact of Omicron coronavirus variant kept investors ... Read more »

U.S. tightens COVID-19 travel rules as countries race to quell Omicron threat

FILE PHOTO: Passengers travelling at Newark Liberty International Airport in Newark SYDNEY/TOKYO (Reuters) – Air travellers to the United States will face tougher COVID-19 testing rules as several countries moved ... Read more »

Knockout City Season 4 will bring alien invasion theme, new map, and more

© Provided by GamePur Knockout City Season 4, titled Alien Invaders, will be crash landing on December 7. Velan Studios released a new teaser trailer that fleshed out some lore, ... Read more »

All the Festive Starbucks Tumblers to Add to Your Cart This Holiday Season

© Provided by Spot.ph PHOTO BY Starbucks Philippines © Provided by Spot.ph PHOTO BY Starbucks Philippines (SPOT.ph) On November 2, Starbucks Philippines officially unveiled their 2022 Planners and Organizers, marking ... Read more »

Barca ‘moderately optimistic' Ansu Fati will be fit to face Bayern - report

© Photo by Juan Manuel Serrano Arce/Getty Images Barcelona are reportedly moderately optimistic that Ansu Fati will be fit enough to play some part in the team’s crucial Champions League ... Read more »

FLCT acquires property in new UK business park for S$51.5m

© Provided by Singapore Business Review Frasers Logistics & Commercial Trust (FLCT), through its wholly-owned subsidiary, Worcester Property Co Limited, has acquired a property in West Midlands, United Kingdom for ... Read more »

Langgar SOP PKPB: Neelofa, suami lepas tanpa bebas

© Provided by Sinar Harian SEREMBAN – Mahkamah Majistret Seremban pada Rabu melepas tanpa membebaskan selebriti, Noor Neelofa Mohd Noor dan suaminya, Muhammad Haris Mohd Ismail terhadap pertuduhan melanggar prosedur ... Read more »

How to get Iron Shards in Len's Island

© Provided by GamePur One of the roadblocks in Len’s Island is Iron Shards. Alongside Gold, Iron Shards are a very difficult resource to obtain naturally — they are only ... Read more »

Can an Unhealthy Lifestyle Lead to Cancer? Adopt These 5 Health Mantras

© Anjali Thakur | India.com Lifestyle Staff Can an Unhealthy Lifestyle Lead to Cancer? Adopt These 5 Health Mantras (Picture credit: Pixabay) Certain healthy lifestyle choices can help you to ... Read more »

FICCI requests Assam govt to consider bringing in cost-based floor pricing for tea

Industry body FICCI has requested Assam government to consider bringing in cost-based floor pricing for tea. FICCI has made a host of recommendations for rejuvenation of the Tea Industry in ... Read more »

Arunachal Pradesh govt ropes in Bollywood actor Sanjay Dutt as brand ambassador for 50th year celebrations

Arunachal Pradesh government has roped in bolloywood actor Sanjay Dutt as the brand ambassador for ‘50 Years of Arunachal Pradesh’ celebration. “Apun ko bahut bahut khusi hoyele hai k apun ... Read more »

Boyfriend will stand trial over girlfriend's murder after young mum's body was found in landfill

Joon Seong Tan, 35, has been charged with murdering his girlfriendBody of  Ju 'Kelly' Zhang, a mother, was found in a Melbourne landfill in JuneTan set to face Victorian Supreme Court on December 16  Read more »

Kathie Lee Gifford Returns to 'Today' Show & Opens Up About 'Very Sweet' Man in Her Life

© Nathan Congleton/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images Kathie Lee Gifford is feeling the love. The TV personality reunited with her former colleagues as she sat down with a chat ... Read more »

Israel to host Miss Universe contest despite Omicron

© Provided by Interaksyon JERUSALEM — Israel will host the Miss Universe beauty pageant in the Red Sea resort of Eilat on Dec. 12 despite imposing travel restrictions to try ... Read more »

Omicron fears: Commonwealth Wrestling Championships in South Africa called off

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Covid-19’s latest variant Omicron has disrupted the sporting world, and also the Indian athletes’ training and competition programme. After the postponement ... Read more »

Welcher grüne Flitzer gewinnt?

© Cyril Minder Alfa Romeo Giulia GTAm gegen den BMW M3 – wer macht das Rennen? Bei grünen Autos denken die meisten zuerst an Elektro- oder Hybridautos. Es geht aber ... Read more »

IPL 2022 Retention: ‘With my heart and soul': Kohli shares a heartfelt message with fans after RCB retain former captain

Former Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB) captain Virat Kohli shared a heartfelt message with the fans following his retention by the club ahead of the mega Indian Premier League (IPL 2022) ... Read more »

Senior Taiwan lawmaker thanks countries for help with submarine programme

1 / 5Senior Taiwan lawmaker thanks countries for help with submarine programmeTo match Special Report TAIWAN-CHINA/SUBMARINES TAIPEI (Reuters) – A senior lawmaker of Taiwan's ruling party thanked major submarine producing ... Read more »

What the papers say – December 1

The papers are led by the Prime Minister pledging a date for the completion of the Government’s expanded booster rollout. The Times, Metro and i report Boris Johnson has vowed ... Read more »

Fauci says COVID diverted resources from fighting AIDS

UNITED NATIONS — Dr. Anthony Fauci, the top U.S. infectious disease expert, said Tuesday the COVID-19 pandemic has diverted scientific and financial resources from the fight against AIDS, seriously impeding ... Read more »

Baby boy from Aboriginal community is latest case of Covid in the Northern Territory as he tests positive at the same quarantine facility where three teens escaped from

An Aboriginal baby boy tested positive to Covid and is being tested for Omicron  Baby is from Binjari and was in the same facility three teenagers escaped fromTown is now 81 per cent double vaccinated as wastewater points to more cases  Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Kerri-Anne Kennerley reignites her feud with Yumi Stynes on the red carpet at a Sydney event as she goes on a rant about the radio star who called her 'racist' two years ago - before the pair are seen having a VERY intense conversation

Kerri-Anne Kennerley reignited her long-running feud with Yumi Stynes at the Women of the Future Awards in Sydney on Wednesday. The 68-year-old former Studio 10 host – who was called ... Read more »

Bethesda Teases Big Moments In Sci-fi RPG Starfield With New Video Featurette

© Provided by Geek Culture Bethesda Teases Big Moments In Starfield With New Video Featurette Now that the exclusivity furore is out of the way, Bethesda has given us a ... Read more »

South Korea reports daily record of over 5,000 new COVID-19 infections

© Reuters/HEO RAN Women wearing masks walk in a shopping district amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic in Seoul By Sangmi Cha SEOUL (Reuters) -South Korea reported a new daily ... Read more »

Fake sugar daddy agent De Beers Wong: Jail term more than doubled after appeal dismissed

SINGAPORE — A man who posed as a social escort agent to cheat women into having sex with him had his jail term more than doubled after his appeal for ... Read more »

WHO warns against Omicron travel bans as nations shut borders

© Yann Schreiber In Germany, the next chancellor Olaf Scholz indicated his support for compulsory Covid vaccines The World Health Organization has warned blanket travel bans will not prevent the ... Read more »

'Check your ticket': Hunt for Dublin winner of unclaimed Lotto prize of over €825,000

© Alamy Stock Photo THE NATIONAL LOTTERY is appealing to players in Dublin to check their tickets as the hunt is on for the winner of an €826,392 prize from ... Read more »

Storm Arwen: Dramatic video shows RNLI Dunbar battle severe conditions to get to safety

On Friday, a Met Office rare red weather warning was issued across the east coast of Scotland which predicted high winds and potential loss of life from flying debris. © ... Read more »

Ständerat debattiert über Verlängerung von Corona-Artikeln

© KEYSTONE/ANTHONY ANEX Der Ständerat debattiert am Mittwoch über die Verlängerung von gewissen Artikeln im Covid-19-Gesetz. So soll sich der Bund beispielsweise auch im nächsten Jahr auf Gesuch an überkantonalen ... Read more »

Luganesi mit berechtigter Zuversicht im Wankdorf

© KEYSTONE/MICHAEL BUHOLZER Die Spieler des FC Lugano können sich dem Nachtragsspiel vom Mittwochabend in Bern gegen die Young Boys voller Selbstvertrauen stellen. Die Tessiner sind die Mannschaft der Stunde. ... Read more »

BMW releases striking Concept XM

BMW has unveiled a new model that previews an upcoming performance SUV from its M brand – the Concept XM. The production model – badged XM – will be built ... Read more »

China's property woes worsen as home prices slip in November-survey

People ride scooters past residential buildings in Beijing BEIJING (Reuters) – China's property market woes worsened in November, with prices for both new and resale homes falling amid weaker demand ... Read more »

India's Serum Institute delivers first Novavax shot through COVAX

A vial and a syringe are seen in front of a displayed Novavax logo, in this illustration taken NEW DELHI (Reuters) – Serum Institute of India has sent doses of ... Read more »

Two men injured in shooting Tuesday night in Lansing

LANSING – Police were investigating a shooting that injured two men Tuesday night. Officers responded to a shots-fired call in the 600 block of West Willow Street about 8:10 p.m. ... Read more »

‘Unbecoming': Family angered over Kansas City chief's remark at fatal police shooting scene

Family members of Cameron Lamb are outraged with Kansas City Police Chief Rick Smith’s description of him as a “bad guy” minutes after he was fatally shot by a police ... Read more »

Yahoo's top 10 most-searched male Singapore celebrities of 2021

From talented singers to troubled stars, this year’s most-searched Singapore male celebrities made us sit up and take notice. Here are Yahoo Singapore readers’ top ten most-searched male celebrities of ... Read more »

World AIDS Day: 57% Indians don't use contraception, Ahmedabad ranks lowest, survey finds

© Provided by The Print Delhi: A survey released Tuesday, on the eve of World AIDS Day — on 1 December — shows Ahmedabad to be the Indian city with ... Read more »

Creating an impact with her powerful anchoring skills Jyotsna Bedi

© Provided by DNA The job of an anchor doesn’t quite provide fixed hours or a regular routine; it’ll change by the day. The type of work will change daily, ... Read more »

Two intense systems likely to bring widespread rain and thunderstorms

© Provided by Hindustan Times A low pressure area is likely to form over east central Arabian sea off Maharashtra coast on Wednesday. (Pratik Chorge/HT PHOTO) Two intense weather systems ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic